Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Racism

98 replies

Bloominggoodvibes · 21/06/2022 21:47

AIBU.

Incident in school last week resulting in my child (12) being disciplined by the school.

My child asked another pupil questions during one conversation last week. At the time of the conversation the other pupil didn’t become upset and my child was unaware they had caused any distress until Monday morning when a teacher pulled my child for a chat.

The teacher questioned my child and
they admitted what they had asked and explained they hadn’t meant to cause any upset or embarrassment and requested to apologise to the pupil. The questions were of a curious nature in their eyes but on reflection they can see why the other person is upset over
it.

The teacher
called me to explain what had happened and the subsequent punishment, of suspension, due to the school’s zero tolerance policy regarding racism.

The teacher also explained that the pupil was called racist names by another pupil on the same day but not at the same time and in a separate
incident.
My child was not a part of or aware of the name calling incident.

I have had a chat with my child about their behaviour and understand that the school have to follow there discipline policies so have no issue with this.

HOWEVER today my child has now received lots of messages from friends in school saying there was a year group assembly about racism were the teacher holding the assembly has named my child and the other child who used the racist names and explained that these pupils had been suspended for being racist.

AIBU for thinking that the teacher and school are wrong to have done this ?

My child , who was already mortified and apologetic that they had offended another person is now beside themselves with upset thinking they have been labelled racist to their whole year group.

OP posts:
Meraas · 23/06/2022 09:54

Asking who cooks the curry is not an innocent question, especially from a 12yo. Some of us were being told 'you smell of curry' at a much younger than 12. From experience, I doubt the questions are as innocent as some are making them out to be.

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 12:56

The question was not asked to cause upset or embarrassment but my child
does know that they should exercise caution when speaking to people , especially those who are different from them , to not be offensive and cause offence.

My child is VERY curious and friendly and has the ability to strike up a conversation with anyone. This time they have made an assumption (based on believing flats info given) and have upset another child.

To those posters who have said there has been no regard for the child at the receiving end then I disagree. I do feel for this child - that does not mean I can not also disagree with school naming and shaming my child.

I am going to raise this with the head and governors and ensure that the report held on my child’s behaviour record is an accurate reflection of what has been said.

I do wonder if the SEPARATE incident of name calling had not of happened then would my child have been punished as they were ? I do feel like they have been lumped together for the punishment , although the name calling child has received a much longer suspension.

I do not think racism should be tolerated however I don’t think the answer to stamping it out lies with ‘jumping on’ borderline , in my opinion due to context and childs age, racist conversation.

The school held this assembly in racism while my child was off - wouldn’t it have been more beneficial to deliver this whilst they were present. Of course we have these conversations at home but a discussion with other people will help and broaden understanding of the issues.

Additionally wouldn’t it be great if as well as teaching children to be kind of people taught there children to be resilient. When my child questions hurt the other child wouldn't it have been been better for that child to say , ‘ hey that’s rude because of XYZ. Don’t you realise your question towards me feels racist to me ?’

IF , as many if you have posted , a 12 year old ‘OUGHT TO KNOW BETTER‘ then surely the other child (12) is quiet capable of using there experience to educate , peer to peer , during conversation.

OP posts:
Hornbostel · 23/06/2022 13:03

IF , as many if you have posted , a 12 year old ‘OUGHT TO KNOW BETTER‘ then surely the other child (12) is quiet capable of using there experience to educate , peer to peer , during conversation.

A child should not have to educate their peers on racism.

Do you believe everything your child says?

PAFMO · 23/06/2022 13:06

Meraas · 23/06/2022 09:54

Asking who cooks the curry is not an innocent question, especially from a 12yo. Some of us were being told 'you smell of curry' at a much younger than 12. From experience, I doubt the questions are as innocent as some are making them out to be.

Oh, I'm not making them out to be innocent. Not by a long shot.

Especially given the latest post from the OP.

Looks like the apple hasn't fallen far from the tree. Funny that.

Glitternails1 · 23/06/2022 13:09

@Bloominggoodvibes your update suggests that your Ds will continue to think it’s okay to be racist because you say he didn’t do anything wrong. He probably said that in a mocking tone to make other people laugh, and the victim feel intimidated (that’s why he didn’t say anything back - he was humiliated). You don’t even know if this other boy lives in a takeaway so why would your ds feel the need to ask if his mum made curry? That is not an innocent question. It’s fine if a curious 4 year old asks, but not someone in secondary school.

I highly doubt the school named and shamed him in the assembly. The students were probably told: “Racism is not acceptable and we have excluded a student for making a racist remark.” The students put two and two together and worked out who it was.

Sirzy · 23/06/2022 13:12

So basically it’s the fault of the other student did not educating your son?

EarthquakesinEastActon · 23/06/2022 13:35

IF , as many if you have posted , a 12 year old ‘OUGHT TO KNOW BETTER‘ then surely the other child (12) is quiet capable of using there experience to educate , peer to peer , during conversation.

Wow. So a child being intimidated by racist comments from other children should try to be brave enough to tell those making racist comments in a calm and reasoned fashion why the comments they are making are racist? Wonderful.

“Sorry you were called a despicable name, darling. Did you explain about the history of white British colonialism and the oppression of native people? Did you get all the dates right? Did they properly understand the concept of unconscious bias? No? Well, it’s clearly your own fault then. You’ll just have to try harder next time.”

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 13:40

Why do you all want to be outraged by this ?

picking parts of my message to make it sound like I am not telling the truth or saying my child has done nothing wrong.

Re-read my posts and at least try and look at it objectively. I think some of you may have personal experiences that you cannot emotionally detached from to take a balanced view to this situation and this is EXACTLY why I have an issue with my child being names and shamed.

The events I have told you about MATCH what the school and upset child described! Nothing else happened - this has come from the SCHOOL !

The SCHOOL have ADMITTED that they NAMED my child in assembly. You can’t come on a thread and say ‘that didn’t happen’ because you can’t bring yourself to agree a ‘dirty little racist’ child has themselves been wronged.

Someone can be IN the WRONG and WRONGED.

@Sirzy I think you know I'm
not saying that. I think the majority of people know that racism is ingrained in the Uk , through a lot more then CHILDREN causing offence by making/ believing assumptions and asking inappropriate queuing which have upset someone based on these assumptions. Yes it may start here and YES stopping children and punishing them for allowing racial stereotyping to lead in there language will challenge their thinking and help combat the bigger issue at play BUT that does still not mean the school have acted wholly appropriately.

And I do actually think that some people including posters on this thread to harm to the cause of ending racism by being so overly outraged by some incidents and happily labelling / accusing / making CHILDREN out to be racist villains instead of conceding that some situations haven’t been dealt with in the best way.

OP posts:
Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 13:50

@EarthquakesinEastActon actually the example of the conversation I gave is a lot more realistic example of the conversation they possibly could of had.

I was making the suggestion that peer to peer conversations in school would be a better way if combatting the wider issue to AVOID it happening in the future. You know as well as people teaching there children to be broad-minded that we also teach our children to resilient and stand up for themselves.

To have come backs ready when they feel
personally attacked for whatever reason - not just race. In general - not victim blaming in this incidence. Just musing about how attitudes on the whole could improve the situation….but it seems this falls on deaf ears and people would rather just be outraged instead.

OP posts:
Sapphirensteel · 23/06/2022 13:52

I feel very sorry for your child if they were only asking questions, tho perhaps the child was uncomfortable with them and your dc didn’t pick up on this ( only 12, they’re still learning. ) Teacher, IMO, was wrong to name names.

DH and I ( and dds) spent some time in the Middle East and DH and I did a short stint in W. Africa. Particularly in Africa we found the local people he worked with, and we lived among ( no posh hotels or housing for us) wanted to tell us about their culture, traditions, festivals, their families etc.. I even had women starting discussions on the differences between our skin and dressing me up in local clothes ( dresses fine, headdress didn’t work on me, much laughter all round) Was any of this racist? I saw it as chatting and learning from each other.

RedWingBoots · 23/06/2022 14:03

Why do you all want to be outraged by this ?

The apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

@Sapphirensteel if you don't understand why there is a difference asking the same question in a Middle Eastern or West African country and in the UK, then you are as intelligent as the OP.

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:08

@RedWingBoots are you outraged ? If so why ? Because you believe that my child being named and shamed is acceptable? This was my AIBU.

Now you are suggestion I and other posted lack intelligence because we don’t agree with how this situation has been dealt with. Cant you disagree with someone’s view without digging at there level of intelligence?

OP posts:
Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:10

Sapphirensteel · 23/06/2022 13:52

I feel very sorry for your child if they were only asking questions, tho perhaps the child was uncomfortable with them and your dc didn’t pick up on this ( only 12, they’re still learning. ) Teacher, IMO, was wrong to name names.

DH and I ( and dds) spent some time in the Middle East and DH and I did a short stint in W. Africa. Particularly in Africa we found the local people he worked with, and we lived among ( no posh hotels or housing for us) wanted to tell us about their culture, traditions, festivals, their families etc.. I even had women starting discussions on the differences between our skin and dressing me up in local clothes ( dresses fine, headdress didn’t work on me, much laughter all round) Was any of this racist? I saw it as chatting and learning from each other.

Exactly this ! It doesn’t always have to be racist. Yes a lot of the time in the UK it may be but doesn’t make everything racist and a one size fits all punishment isn’t the answer imo.

OP posts:
LabiaMinoraPissusFlapus · 23/06/2022 14:18

I am shocked that the school has named your son. I don't believe this is standard practice in schools. You are right that he might potentially face a backlash when he returns to school.

EarthquakesinEastActon · 23/06/2022 14:20

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 13:50

@EarthquakesinEastActon actually the example of the conversation I gave is a lot more realistic example of the conversation they possibly could of had.

I was making the suggestion that peer to peer conversations in school would be a better way if combatting the wider issue to AVOID it happening in the future. You know as well as people teaching there children to be broad-minded that we also teach our children to resilient and stand up for themselves.

To have come backs ready when they feel
personally attacked for whatever reason - not just race. In general - not victim blaming in this incidence. Just musing about how attitudes on the whole could improve the situation….but it seems this falls on deaf ears and people would rather just be outraged instead.

Outrage at racism - which is defined as such by the person receiving it, by the way, regardless of what you understand the intention of the person making the racist comments or perpetrating the racist act to be - is a response which should be natural to everyone.

No child, no person, should have to have ready come backs against racist comments. Racism should not be tolerated in any setting. There is no gradation, it is just wrong. It was your job to teach that to your child, explicitly and implicitly by example.

voldr · 23/06/2022 14:31

You seem to think that because your son is "only" twelve it must have been a completely innocent question and must have happened exactly the way he told you it did. You are either extremely naïve or are willfully turning a blind eye to your little angel's racism.

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:36

Phew ….Oh ok @EarthquakesinEastActon Lets all walk around outraged - do you think that will fix the problem ?

So no one has any comebacks, no peer to peer conversations, we are all outraged ! Who’s learning anything then ?

My child has been taught , but I cannot control how they put what they’ve learned into practice and they have made a mistake which they regret. They are a child - they are learning !

But that’s ok we are outraged , they’ve been named a racist and there’s nothing wrong with the situation.

I believe your attitude actually hinders progress being made on this matter. in my opinion it people with views as strong and inflexible as yours that muddy the message and make people think that sometimes, some people just want to be offended.

no person should have to send end themselves against anything , in an ideal world but that’s not the world we live in so we have to give people the tools to navigate these situations and the policy’s supporting that need to be in place.

for example the schools policy regarding suspension which I don’t have an issue with !!!!!! It’s the naming and shaming which is my issue but it seems you just want to disagree with ‘unintelligent’ me because how I’ve raised my dirty little racist child, who you think hasn’t fallen far from the tree.

OP posts:
Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:38

voldr · 23/06/2022 14:31

You seem to think that because your son is "only" twelve it must have been a completely innocent question and must have happened exactly the way he told you it did. You are either extremely naïve or are willfully turning a blind eye to your little angel's racism.

Exactly the way the SCHOOL told me it did , as told by them by the child who was asked the questions and as confirmed by my child.

Neither naive nor turning a bling eye. I have an issue with the naming and shaming.

Did you bother reading the thread ?

OP posts:
Danzig · 23/06/2022 14:40

Why bother starting the thread if your just going to attack anyone who dares disagree with you?

EarthquakesinEastActon · 23/06/2022 14:41

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:36

Phew ….Oh ok @EarthquakesinEastActon Lets all walk around outraged - do you think that will fix the problem ?

So no one has any comebacks, no peer to peer conversations, we are all outraged ! Who’s learning anything then ?

My child has been taught , but I cannot control how they put what they’ve learned into practice and they have made a mistake which they regret. They are a child - they are learning !

But that’s ok we are outraged , they’ve been named a racist and there’s nothing wrong with the situation.

I believe your attitude actually hinders progress being made on this matter. in my opinion it people with views as strong and inflexible as yours that muddy the message and make people think that sometimes, some people just want to be offended.

no person should have to send end themselves against anything , in an ideal world but that’s not the world we live in so we have to give people the tools to navigate these situations and the policy’s supporting that need to be in place.

for example the schools policy regarding suspension which I don’t have an issue with !!!!!! It’s the naming and shaming which is my issue but it seems you just want to disagree with ‘unintelligent’ me because how I’ve raised my dirty little racist child, who you think hasn’t fallen far from the tree.

None of the comments you raise in your final paragraph were made by me.

Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:44

@Danzig I don’t feel I have.

Its frustrating that people reply on the thread saying it’s not true that my child has been named and shamed and that I can’t admit my child wrong doing.

People also posting saying what my child has told me is not a true reflection of what’s said when this was the story from the school aswell.

I have said more than once that my child was in the wrong.

My AIBU was asking if the school was BU in naming and shaming my child.

OP posts:
Bloominggoodvibes · 23/06/2022 14:46

EarthquakesinEastActon · 23/06/2022 14:41

None of the comments you raise in your final paragraph were made by me.

Apologies I had mixed your comments up with another posters.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 23/06/2022 14:46

Danzig · 23/06/2022 14:40

Why bother starting the thread if your just going to attack anyone who dares disagree with you?

When posters start threads in AIBU they expect every to tell them they are reasonable.

Most then go on the attack when the majority of posters don't agree with them.

They ignore the fact that this forum is anonymous so no-one knows who they are in real-life - that is if the situation they are describing is real.

RedWingBoots · 23/06/2022 14:51

OP this isn't the place to put a thread about them naming and shaming your child at secondary school if you want to deal with it. You should put your thread here - www.mumsnet.com/talk/secondary

Comefromaway · 23/06/2022 14:55

I absolutely cannot see that this was racist. It's just asking about their parents jobs.

My mum ran a corner shop, the kids at school used to ask me if I got to eat all the sweets.

My auntie ran a newsagents, a girl who lived nearby asked if I could get her Smash Hits magazine.

It would be different if the child called the other a racist name, or said the child smelt of curry or was laughing at them for living above a takeaway.