Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU - Racism

98 replies

Bloominggoodvibes · 21/06/2022 21:47

AIBU.

Incident in school last week resulting in my child (12) being disciplined by the school.

My child asked another pupil questions during one conversation last week. At the time of the conversation the other pupil didn’t become upset and my child was unaware they had caused any distress until Monday morning when a teacher pulled my child for a chat.

The teacher questioned my child and
they admitted what they had asked and explained they hadn’t meant to cause any upset or embarrassment and requested to apologise to the pupil. The questions were of a curious nature in their eyes but on reflection they can see why the other person is upset over
it.

The teacher
called me to explain what had happened and the subsequent punishment, of suspension, due to the school’s zero tolerance policy regarding racism.

The teacher also explained that the pupil was called racist names by another pupil on the same day but not at the same time and in a separate
incident.
My child was not a part of or aware of the name calling incident.

I have had a chat with my child about their behaviour and understand that the school have to follow there discipline policies so have no issue with this.

HOWEVER today my child has now received lots of messages from friends in school saying there was a year group assembly about racism were the teacher holding the assembly has named my child and the other child who used the racist names and explained that these pupils had been suspended for being racist.

AIBU for thinking that the teacher and school are wrong to have done this ?

My child , who was already mortified and apologetic that they had offended another person is now beside themselves with upset thinking they have been labelled racist to their whole year group.

OP posts:
Bednobsbroomsticks · 22/06/2022 07:22

Tbh I'd be focusing more on if my child had been innocently asking these questions or mocking the other kid. If the former it's a shame for your son as its easy to be lumped as ignorant rather than curious. Kids don't always see the negative connotations in what they say. If the latter hopefully he's learnt a very valuable lesson

redbigbananafeet · 22/06/2022 07:29

XelaM · 21/06/2022 22:25

Don't think the questions sound racist if it was in the context of cooking food. 🤷‍♀️ My 12-year-old was once reported by boys on her class for being homophobic because they were discussing being married and one of the boys asked my daughter: "Who would you marry" and she replied "Your mum" (as a joke obviously). The boy made a huge deal of telling the teacher that my daughter implied his mum was gay. She wasn't suspended, but did get into trouble.

Absolutely shocking if kids were named and shamed in an assembly. You should definitely complain.

A 12 year old knows what they were doing regarding those questions. Why curry?

redbigbananafeet · 22/06/2022 07:29

SusieSimpleman · 21/06/2022 22:30

The child lives in a takeaway and your child asked them, straight after food tech, whether their mum or dad did the cooking?

And that was not only viewed as being racist by the school but also accepted by you as him being racist?

I feel there must be quite a bit more to the story somehow.

💯

redbigbananafeet · 22/06/2022 07:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SandyWedges · 22/06/2022 07:41

I think name and shame is a bit much. People will know they've been suspended if they aren't there and a general reminder of the schools rules on racism should be enough, people will put two and two together. But tbh if you go round saying racist shit then you can't then be surprised when you are called out for racist shit, that is part of the consequences.

AquaticSewingMachine · 22/06/2022 07:51

Yep, as always, zero concern for the child faced with racism (again) at school and max concern for the poor, poor petals who perpetrated it.

Nb12 · 22/06/2022 08:19

But what was the tone that your child used to ask those questions?

The same question can be asked in an innocent and curious way or in a mocking way that made everyone around them laugh.

Soontobe60 · 22/06/2022 13:00

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

From what the OP has told us, we cannot assume it was a racist incident. That doesn’t mean she hasn’t got hold of the full facts or that she is withholding them from us. But calling a 12 year old a ‘dirty little racist’ when you've not got the full information is beyond despicable.

Soontobe60 · 22/06/2022 13:02

redbigbananafeet · 22/06/2022 07:29

A 12 year old knows what they were doing regarding those questions. Why curry?

Because he had been told that the family had a takeaway. If hed been told they had a garage, he may have asked if his dad fixed all the cars.

Sirzy · 22/06/2022 13:04

My guess is that the others in the year knew they had been suspended and so it didn’t take much to put two and two together.

it says a lot your assuming they other child’s comments where wrong but yours where on so innocent!

Sirzy · 22/06/2022 13:06

also it seems it not a fact that they live in a takeaway simply an assumption/rumour from other children? Quite possibly one being use to perpetuate racist stereotypes.

Hornbostel · 22/06/2022 13:09

Bloominggoodvibes · 21/06/2022 22:34

I don’t know the child or the family but I think that the comments were seen as racist because the assumption that they lived in a takeaway/restaurant which is why I accepted it.

So the victim might not actually live in a takeaway, it's just a racist stereotype?

IRunbecauseILikeCake · 22/06/2022 13:14

I do agree that I think there's more to this story.
Maybe your son has stretched the truth a little about what he said.
I also agree that seeing your son as the victim here isn't right. Think about the child who's been at the receiving end of racism and use this as a teachable moment for him.

Sandinmyknickers · 22/06/2022 13:17

Nb12 · 22/06/2022 08:19

But what was the tone that your child used to ask those questions?

The same question can be asked in an innocent and curious way or in a mocking way that made everyone around them laugh.

This.
And I'm sure they will have asked other students present what they heard before suspending him based on these 'questions'

NippyWoowoo · 22/06/2022 13:24

Funny to see this thread post about a week after the apparently 'not racist' thread about a week ago re a receptionist asking a teenager if she was the girl from the takeaway.

Goady.

10HailMarys · 22/06/2022 13:34

I strongly suspect that a) there is a lot more to what your son said, or the tone he said it in, than he is letting on and b) that the headteacher actually said that 'two pupils have been suspended' rather than naming them, and that their friends just put two and two together because they were off school.

Hallyup89 · 22/06/2022 13:35

Nobody named and shamed your child. Other pupils just can't keep their mouths shut.

There was nothing wrong with what your child said if they're telling the truth. I suspect not if they've been suspended.

Hobele · 22/06/2022 13:55

Bloody hell, this world is bonkers. Why would it be racist to ask these questions? Child is 12, probably confused by the fact that his friend lives in a take-away. assumed they own it etc. Ffs, I'd have probably asked further, is was a conversation.

C8H10N4O2 · 22/06/2022 14:59

Bloominggoodvibes · 21/06/2022 22:34

I don’t know the child or the family but I think that the comments were seen as racist because the assumption that they lived in a takeaway/restaurant which is why I accepted it.

"seen as"?

So when some random person tells you "X lives in a takeaway" your normal reaction is to accept that and ask them "who cooks the curry" knowing that "X lives in a takeaway" is a common racist jibe?

Really?

Would either hypothetical child have even raised the subject if the child was white?

If any of this is true it sounds like that assembly was overdue.

As @downtonupton says - this wide eyed faux ignorance gets a bit tedious after you have heard it for the millionth time.

Soontobe60 · 22/06/2022 16:00

C8H10N4O2 · 22/06/2022 14:59

"seen as"?

So when some random person tells you "X lives in a takeaway" your normal reaction is to accept that and ask them "who cooks the curry" knowing that "X lives in a takeaway" is a common racist jibe?

Really?

Would either hypothetical child have even raised the subject if the child was white?

If any of this is true it sounds like that assembly was overdue.

As @downtonupton says - this wide eyed faux ignorance gets a bit tedious after you have heard it for the millionth time.

I’ve never heard that phrase being used as a ‘common racist jibe’ and believe me, I’ve heard a fair few different ones over the years.
What if this child does actually live at a take away? In my class over 50% of the fathers are taxi drivers, 5 children have parents who run curry restaurants and take aways, 3 are single parent families, 2 are landlords with several properties. Several are asylum seekers who can’t work. There are only 2 White British families. Having a conversation with a child about who cooks the curries in their restaurant would not be seen as being racist.
the racism is in the assumption that a Pakistani family lives in a take away and cooks curry.

comealongponds · 22/06/2022 16:05

Your DC was BU to ask racist questions/assumptions/stereotypes.

but if it’s true, the school were BU to publicly name and shame

C8H10N4O2 · 22/06/2022 17:13

I’ve never heard that phrase being used as a ‘common racist jibe’ and believe me, I’ve heard a fair few different ones over the years

Are you speaking as the target of racist comments or an observer of racism?

Bloominggoodvibes · 22/06/2022 19:47

the story I have given is the same story that the school gave to me - so there is no stretching of the truth for me to make my ‘dirty little racist’ child seem like the victim here.

They have been disciplined by the school and by us at home as they should have know better than asking intrusive questions where assumptions have been made to a child who looks different to them.

the reason I have an issue with the naming and shaming is due to the highly emotive backlash they may face off the likes of the people who have commented on this post adamant that there must be more to the story etc.

I have spoken to the school today who confirmed that they did name my child in the assembly. They did not think there was a problem with this as they are a fairly small school and they used the conversation as an example of my child’s to drive home the message how those questions, based on assumptions , can be racist. I am not happy about this but cannot change what’s already been said so Im just hoping that’s there is no on-going fall out from this.

OP posts:
TeddybearBaby · 22/06/2022 20:21

Your poor son! How inappropriate of the school. I’d seriously think about changing schools. They’ve actually put him in danger!

PAFMO · 23/06/2022 06:10

The school's reasoning for the naming of the two students involved in the racist incident (that it's a small school) is very strange.

This is the kind of story that the redtops would have a field day with. Innocent question about food causes innocent child to be suspended from school and named in assembly.

You can almost see the headline.

What are you going to do now, OP? Headteacher? Governors?

All schools (mine certainly does) have rigid protocols in place regarding serious things like racism. And quite rightly, it's zero tolerance and a one strike leads to suspension one.

The naming of the students who have been suspended for the racist incident however is very "private school in the 1950s". I suppose it could be (as it's a small school) to quash the gossip mill when the others see the students involved are absent and to reinforce the zero tolerance on racism policy.