Please or to access all these features

Work

Chat with other users about all things related to working life on our Work forum.

Thread gallery
7
Namechangedatheist · 22/10/2026 21:03

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 20:41

How are people talking about this issue to family, friends, colleagues, employers etc?
Do other people get it? Either in the context of everyone or most people losing their jobs, with no plan on how to keep those people alive, or in the context of the threat that AI will exterminate humanity?

At the recent cyber conference I spoke to a senior civil servant who said the view is that the future is either Star Trek or Terminator with a roughly 50/50 split of opinion.
Yes we discuss this at work and at home, must people I know are concerned.
Both my sons are classical musicians so probably slightly more inured to AI than sone others. I'm sure an AI Opera could be performed but not sure how many people would want to go to one.

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 21:05

I haven't met anyone who isn't concerned about AI. This thread is typical. There is literally nobody putting their head above the parapet and making the case that it will all be fine.

Basically around June my job essentially changed forever. I'm still there getting paid but with AI my productivity has increases 30 times. There will be a period 2 years? 5 years? where I do the backlog of work there has never been time to do before.... Then what?

I'm just enjoying the "happy time" where I'm in work, getting the credit for my hyper productivity as though it was me doing the work. I'm making the most of that because I have no way to predict what comes next.

We've never, ever had a new technology that could exponentially make itself better. This is unknown.

I feel for my kids. They don't even know what jobs will still be in demand when they graduate. It's utterly unpredictable.

A good point in this thread was about robotics. Once you have AI combined with good robotics there's literally nothing left for humans except roles that involve "responsibility". At some point you need people for accountability, you need people who can be sued, fired or prosecuted. But we don't need many of them.

Bleak times.

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 21:08

disgracefullyyours · 22/10/2026 17:22

That’s a huge if. Where would the money come from?

No, what will I believe happen is that you will be expected to sell your assets, utilise your pensions and savings etc, just like now. Boomers and their possible beneficiaries are going to be in for a hell of a collective shock, really anybody with significant assets who isn’t rich. It’s not like it would be a logistical admin nightmare to deal with, for obvious reasons.

Sell our assets to who?

disgracefullyyours · 22/10/2026 21:13

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 21:08

Sell our assets to who?

To anyone who wants and afford them, similarly to now. Of course there will be much fewer buyers in the near future than there are now.

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 21:13

But people are still talking about having babies, fgs. I've talked to some perfectly bright people about it, and they had no idea how advanced AI now is, and what it's been getting up to (Hugging Face etc).

Shocking that @Namechangedatheist has been told that half those dealing with this in the civil service think we're heading for human extermination.

AndyouWILLATONE · 22/10/2026 21:23

FancyKitten · 22/10/2026 00:27

I was talking to a couple of friends in tech / computer science & even they were saying the that they can’t keep up with AI changes to their work. What hope have the rest of us?

Gulp. 😳

Catarinabella · 22/10/2026 21:23

I work in HE, online student support, my job will be overtaken by AI within the next few months

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 21:26

Isn't this going to effect the middle classes more? People earning 50k plus. What happens when AI takes their jobs and all they can get is NMW work? How do they pay their 300k mortgages? What happens to their 30k plus cars? Or there 1.5k mobile phones or 3k laptops. And nobody can afford a 10k family holiday.

All well and good getting rid of all your well-paid staff, but if every company does that they won't have any customers to buy their products.

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 21:42

Catarinabella · 22/10/2026 21:23

I work in HE, online student support, my job will be overtaken by AI within the next few months

Don't students need a human touch?

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 21:43

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 21:26

Isn't this going to effect the middle classes more? People earning 50k plus. What happens when AI takes their jobs and all they can get is NMW work? How do they pay their 300k mortgages? What happens to their 30k plus cars? Or there 1.5k mobile phones or 3k laptops. And nobody can afford a 10k family holiday.

All well and good getting rid of all your well-paid staff, but if every company does that they won't have any customers to buy their products.

I don't know why you think those people are going to get NMW work. People are already struggling to get that kind of work, and employers tend not to want to offer basic low paid jobs to people who are over-qualified.

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 21:48

I've just thought of a positive. There will be no contracting out technical work to Eastern Europe or Vietnam or other cheap places. There may be less jobs, but those jobs will remain in high value economies. When everyone is 10 times more productive there will be no need to penny pinch on staff.

When there's a jobs cull, the contractors abroad will go first.

And perhaps that's another mitigation... Technical jobs have been outsourced for decades. We've all been undercut for years. That's needless now, and the entity we're being undercut by will be owned by us.

In my own company they can halve our head count without losing a single UK role.

disgracefullyyours · 22/10/2026 21:58

When everyone is 10 times more productive there will be no need to penny pinch on staff.

But those humans cost much more than what AI and automation cost. Pay, NI, liability insurance, benefits, equipment, insurance, training, pension. And every employer’s top priority is making money.

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 21:59

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 21:42

Don't students need a human touch?

AI is the ultimate patient teacher. It never gets frustrated, it can explain things clearly in many different ways.

I had a 120 page book on a maths based topic. In an afternoon it had cemented the whole concept in my head. I must have asked it questions that were too stupid to dare ask a lecturer. It taught me a complicated topic in a few hours. I don't think.I'd ever have got there with a lecturer/teacher or the book alone. It's very hard to admit to a real teacher that they need to explain something a 4th time.

And it's 1-1 tuition. So no wasted time listening to other people's questions.

Plus it set me tests so I could be confident I'd picked it up.

I can see AI replacing teachers in much the same way that physical face to face courses were replaced by online courses over covid and never came back.

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 22:01

disgracefullyyours · 22/10/2026 21:58

When everyone is 10 times more productive there will be no need to penny pinch on staff.

But those humans cost much more than what AI and automation cost. Pay, NI, liability insurance, benefits, equipment, insurance, training, pension. And every employer’s top priority is making money.

Yeah, we'll be replaced by AI instead of being replaced by clever people in Romania.

The 4 people who still have jobs will be in the UK. 🎉

It's not that much of a silver lining, but it was the best I can do!

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 22:03

I am retired and just trying to learn stuff. I was doing this OU type course about the Tudors, and we were supposed to write a 200-word essay on why Elizabeth I never married. I just asked AI and it wrote me one. I am learning French. I ask AI when I should use the subjunctive.

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 22:05

But can it explain the NE expletive?

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 22:10

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 22:05

But can it explain the NE expletive?

Can you explain the NE expletive?

lawlessfrench
+1
If by "NE expletive" you mean the French ne explétif, it's a grammatical "ne" that does not create a negation. It appears mainly in formal written French after certain expressions of fear, prevention, comparison, and a few conjunctions. [citation]
lalanguefrancaise
+1
lawlessfrench
+2
lawlessfrench
+2
lalanguefrancaise
+1
lawlessfrench
+1
lawlessfrench
+1
For example:
•Je crains qu'il ne vienne. = I fear that he may come. (Not: "I fear that he may not come.") [citation]
lalanguefrancaise
+1
The key point is that the ne explétif does not change the meaning of the sentence. It's traditionally used for stylistic or grammatical reasons and is often optional. [citation]
lawlessfrench
+2
Common triggers include:
•craindre que ("to fear that")
•avoir peur que ("to be afraid that")
•avant que ("before")
•à moins que ("unless")
•comparative expressions such as plus... que and moins... que in some formal contexts. [citation]
lawlessfrench
+2
Compare:
•Je crains qu'il ne vienne. = I'm afraid he'll come. [citation]
lalanguefrancaise
+1
•Je crains qu'il ne vienne pas. = I'm afraid he won't come. [citation]
lawlessfrench
+1
That second sentence contains a real negation because of pas.
If you meant a different "NE expletive" (for example in linguistics outside French), let me know the context and I'll explain that version instead.

Timemouse · 22/10/2026 22:12

If you’re a middle class office worker your job will be obliterated. People will either be incredibly rich AI overlords or very poor. Not sure what will happen when everyone loses their job and home…:will it cause another financial crash? Another Great Depression looming.

ShhhYouDontKnowMe · 22/10/2026 22:13

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 22:03

I am retired and just trying to learn stuff. I was doing this OU type course about the Tudors, and we were supposed to write a 200-word essay on why Elizabeth I never married. I just asked AI and it wrote me one. I am learning French. I ask AI when I should use the subjunctive.

Why bother doing the course in that case?

Namechangedatheist · 22/10/2026 22:21

ShhhYouDontKnowMe · 22/10/2026 22:13

Why bother doing the course in that case?

I wondered that...

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 22:25

RaggedRocks · 22/10/2026 22:03

I am retired and just trying to learn stuff. I was doing this OU type course about the Tudors, and we were supposed to write a 200-word essay on why Elizabeth I never married. I just asked AI and it wrote me one. I am learning French. I ask AI when I should use the subjunctive.

That's truly depressing reading. Try 1) doing your own research, thinking your own thoughts, writing your own sentences - you might learn something and even enjoy it, 2) using a grammar book?
And you do know that getting AI to write your essay is cheating, don't you?

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 22:27

Timemouse · 22/10/2026 22:12

If you’re a middle class office worker your job will be obliterated. People will either be incredibly rich AI overlords or very poor. Not sure what will happen when everyone loses their job and home…:will it cause another financial crash? Another Great Depression looming.

"will it cause another financial crash" LOL. We're in for a much bumpier ride than that.

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 22:30

@ThinkOfABetterUsername Do you think that schools will soon be replaced by something like individual kiosks for pupils, with computers and headphones, where they receive individual tuition from AI? Do you think that teachers will be made redundant soon?

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 22:33

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 22:30

@ThinkOfABetterUsername Do you think that schools will soon be replaced by something like individual kiosks for pupils, with computers and headphones, where they receive individual tuition from AI? Do you think that teachers will be made redundant soon?

No, not at all.

IMHO kids need a physical human there to make them pay attention and focus.

Toutafait · 22/10/2026 22:38

ThinkOfABetterUsername · 22/10/2026 22:33

No, not at all.

IMHO kids need a physical human there to make them pay attention and focus.

I think you could have the individual kiosks, with one person, who wouldn't need to be a teacher, in the room to provide basic supervision. In fact there are already schools that do this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread