Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How I became a TERF

16 replies

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 19:31

Venice Allan thought that Labour would listen to her concerns about women’s rights. Then she tried to organise a debate.

https://www.academyofideas.uk/p/how-i-became-a-terf

How I became a TERF

Venice Allan thought that Labour would listen to her concerns about women’s rights. Then she tried to organise a debate.

https://www.academyofideas.uk/p/how-i-became-a-terf

OP posts:
Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:38

I'm not sure. I had been reading about gender ideology and had thought that indeed sex was a spectrum, with diagrams! And then something, I'm not sure, but I found an article by Alex Byrne. I read it and realised that it had blown away ideas about sex as a spectrum and the idea that one could have a gender that was different from one's sex. It can't just have been the article, I must already have been suspicious and been looking for explanations of inconsistencies in gender ideology. I may also have seen the furore over Kathleen Stock (a very mild GC woman) and also seen some of the attacks on women who just wanted to discuss e.g. VAWG or single sex spaces. I woke up one morning and was gender critical and knew I was bloody right, too and on the right side of history.

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 23:11

Grammarnut · Yesterday 22:38

I'm not sure. I had been reading about gender ideology and had thought that indeed sex was a spectrum, with diagrams! And then something, I'm not sure, but I found an article by Alex Byrne. I read it and realised that it had blown away ideas about sex as a spectrum and the idea that one could have a gender that was different from one's sex. It can't just have been the article, I must already have been suspicious and been looking for explanations of inconsistencies in gender ideology. I may also have seen the furore over Kathleen Stock (a very mild GC woman) and also seen some of the attacks on women who just wanted to discuss e.g. VAWG or single sex spaces. I woke up one morning and was gender critical and knew I was bloody right, too and on the right side of history.

Interesting. I dont think I ever thought that, but also although only dimly understood, was influenced by "gender bender" politics.

The whole point of which was acknowledging your sex as being fixed, but that as gender is a social construct, constraint you could break the straight jacket of gender.

ie a far more radical politics than trans, which in effect agrees that you sex (even if artificially constructed) should conform to society's rules about gendered behaviour.

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · Yesterday 23:13

Just to add in a way that was a problem for me, as it seemed so obvious and generally accepted, that it never occured to me that such a reactionary, anti progressive concept would take hold!

OP posts:
OverpricedCupcake · Yesterday 23:18

I always was one.
I honestly thought TIMs were just some weird blokes on the Internet that no one took any notice of, kinda like flat earthers, as soon as I realised that they were being taken seriously I was horrified and looked at what I could do to protest against it.

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 23:20

This forum. With its intelligent, articulate, passionate women painstakingly explaining the negative impact on women and children. Thank you.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:35

Great article, thank you.

I can't remember the exact trigger for this thought, but do I remember very clearly suddenly realising that my Feminist belief that men and women's minds aren't fundamentally different and my it's-just-like-being-gay belief that trans people really were people just born as mentally the opposite sex simply couldn't both be true.

And when I realised that starkly it was one or the other, Feminism immediately won, because I simply find it harder to believe there are male and female minds independent of the body than to believe male and female minds are the same other than the differences that arise due to our bodies.

murasaki · Yesterday 23:46

I never believed they were the opposite sex. But I thought we could be nice. Until I realised they weren't being nice at all, and were trying to skin walk us, put us at risk and were actually claiming to have changed sex. And sports, which I am very interested in. So I stopped being nice.

And all the wonderful erudite posters on here, of course, and even our drive by loons who merely reinforce my views.

murasaki · Yesterday 23:49

Actually I forgot one thing from years and years ago. Gina Rippon was our external examiner on a BSc programme I was administering, and we went to lunch. I did say I was planning on reading her book and had bought it, and we had a bit of a chat. Pink brain my arse. So maybe that started it. Over pasta in Bloomsbury....

Lovelyview · Yesterday 23:57

I never paid much attention until 'Isla Bryson'. I instantly became an implacable Terf. The statistic that 99% of sex offenders are male also made me realise that women's single sex spaces had to be ferociously defended.

unwashedanddazed · Today 00:15

My niece 's child declared they were the opposite sex at the age of about three. This was 11 or 12 years ago I think. Until then I'd not given much thought to transsexualism but I became interested in why a child might make such a statement. I began to read wide and deep. The more I learned the terfier I got, as do most who truly educate themselves.

The child has presented as the opposite sex since then. Now on illegal hormones and puberty blockers thanks to Anne health and their whole family are TRAs.

IwantToRetire · Today 01:21

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 23:13

Just to add in a way that was a problem for me, as it seemed so obvious and generally accepted, that it never occured to me that such a reactionary, anti progressive concept would take hold!

Sorry to repost myself but feel my usual typos and spelling have made that post meaningless. So will try again:

Just to add in a way that was a problem for me knowing that gender was a social construct), as it seemed so obvious and generally accepted (that sex was a biological fact), that it never occurred to me that such a reactionary, anti progressive concept would take hold!

ie that instead of challenging the sexist stereotypes of gender conforming, people would accept that gender stereotypes (a construct of patriarchy) would be so believed by some, that they felt that they would need to claim to be the sex of the reactionary gender stereotypes to claim them.

OP posts:
Transperson · Today 01:23

unwashedanddazed · Today 00:15

My niece 's child declared they were the opposite sex at the age of about three. This was 11 or 12 years ago I think. Until then I'd not given much thought to transsexualism but I became interested in why a child might make such a statement. I began to read wide and deep. The more I learned the terfier I got, as do most who truly educate themselves.

The child has presented as the opposite sex since then. Now on illegal hormones and puberty blockers thanks to Anne health and their whole family are TRAs.

A kid being allowed to openly explore themselves and a medical team and parents supporting them made you a TERF?

I don't understand.

nocoolnamesleft · Today 01:47

Transperson · Today 01:23

A kid being allowed to openly explore themselves and a medical team and parents supporting them made you a TERF?

I don't understand.

Seeing a vulnerable child sterilise themselves would give most rational adults concern.

MyAmpleSheep · Today 02:04

Transperson · Today 01:23

A kid being allowed to openly explore themselves and a medical team and parents supporting them made you a TERF?

I don't understand.

Medical team my arse.

Manyanamanyana · Today 02:05

I remember reading Germaine Greer's book, maybe it was "The Whole Woman", which is newer than "The Female Eunich", so i think it was that one, and I'd not given it much thought then but she argued that there is no way that Men can understand us, our culture, our shared experiences of growing up and being socialised into femininity and the conditions we navigate as female people. I can't remember exactly any words but I do remember realising that yes, men have no claim to womanhood, like, we've earned it, and they can't, won't and shouldn't try. That was a long time before this all started, and around that time I had a very close male friend, young gay and pretty, who had a "sex change" operation. I remember asking him if he was going to become a feminist now (so naive) and he said "no, I'm going to be a whore", and laughed. I laughed along, called him "her", this was in the early 2000's. We fell out eventually and yes, he was working as a prostitute last I heard. He became very dark and moody after his operation, shut everyone out who knew him before. I was really sad to lose him, he was my best friend for a while.
Jump forward, and I was working in a large University as the ideology began to take hold. I was very "live and let live", but remember a conversation I was having with a colleague about school toilets (there was a girl in my sons grade at primary school who suddenly declared she was a boy - shes grown out of it now, in fact had by high school) and I said "I think safety might be an issue if toilets just become mixed sex", and we both looked at each other in a shared realisation and said "yeah, hmmm".
A couple of years later, I found these boards, and it wasn't until then that I realised the actual threats to womens rights. As it dawned on me that our spaces were being handed over to men. This I couldn't get past, and I educated myself, (ha-ha), and now am a TERF, and am gradually getting braver, and more active in that space. Once the truth is revealed, it's impossible to accept the lies inherent in trans ideology. It's impossible not to act on behalf of women and children.

paraphrasequeen · Today 03:15

I didn't realise how bad things were getting until a few choice posts by Munroe Bergdorf on X. That's when I started to pay more attention.

And then I discovered Magdalen Burns on YouTube.

Of course the single biggest 'awakening' I experienced on this journey was finding out I was a fascist. After over 40 years of being a staunch leftist. Quite the revelation and no mistake.

🙄

New posts on this thread. Refresh page