Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

massive TRAs who subsequently have a child who is trans?

398 replies

cfri · 19/11/2026 22:14

I’ve seen this in my extended and closer social circle: there’s a connect between very noisy TRA types (often from an academic background) subsequently, years down the line, declaring that their son is now their daughter and their daughter is now their son. It feels as though the ridiculous idea of changing sex is normalised in these homes which ultimately leads to children believing the impossible and embarking on a life of irreversible treatment, described as expressing themselves . Of the ones I know, autism and trauma are underlying but unexplored because all difficulties are associated with “trans”. Has anyone else seen this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:00

Differentforgirls · 20/11/2026 15:51

Thank you for clarifying a thing that everyone on the planet knows.

I had no idea that “males” meant boys and men.

I blame my parents.

But thankfully having two brothers and three BiLs and my husband and me having two boys and having 6 nephews I have managed to clarify the difference between men and women.

Strange but true,

So you do know that you don’t actually become a woman just by saying that you are?

spannasaurus · 20/11/2026 16:01

In Scotland you need to look to Section 13(2) of the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act 2009 for the circumstances where there is no consent due to deception

Consent and reasonable belief
Consent
13Circumstances in which conduct takes place without free agreement

(1)For the purposes of section 12, but without prejudice to the generality of that section, free agreement to conduct is absent in the circumstances set out in subsection (2).

(2)Those circumstances are—

(a)where the conduct occurs at a time when B is incapable because of the effect of alcohol or any other substance of consenting to it,

(b)where B agrees or submits to the conduct because of violence used against B or any other person, or because of threats of violence made against B or any other person,

(c)where B agrees or submits to the conduct because B is unlawfully detained by A,

(d)where B agrees or submits to the conduct because B is mistaken, as a result of deception by A, as to the nature or purpose of the conduct,

(e)where B agrees or submits to the conduct because A induces B to agree or submit to the conduct by impersonating a person known personally to B, or

(f)where the only expression or indication of agreement to the conduct is from a person other than B.

(3)References in this section to A and to B are to be construed in accordance with sections 1 to 9

Transperson · 20/11/2026 16:01

CohensDiamondTeeth · 20/11/2026 15:59

And as it was pointed out in the other thread, it is still illegal in Scotland and people have already been prosecuted for what is essentially sex by deception, even though we don't call it that here.

I think even if Scotland had missed criminalising sex by deception in actual fact, most people would still view it as abhorrent and immoral. I'd love for you to start a poll in AIBU and clearly set out your position on this, and ask if people think that's it's ok behaviour.

I think you might be surprised at the negative response you'd get.

What sex you are is not your medical history. When it comes to sexual contact with sexual partners, they need to know that you are actually male, and not be given the incorrect impression that you are female, in order to give their informed consent to any sexual contact with you.

Fraud was the charge in Scotland, the people actively created fake identies and used them for sexual gain.

My name and GRC based gender aligns with my identity.

I can't commit fraud for things I have legal papers that show case that I am not lying.

cryupmykingdom · 20/11/2026 16:05

>What sex you are is not your medical history.

They come up with this a lot. And it's always the type who's fond of deceptions of one form or another, from trying to sneak into DMs,all the way to procuring sex on the basis of false premises, who'll assert that his sex is his 'private medical history.'

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:07

cryupmykingdom · 20/11/2026 16:05

>What sex you are is not your medical history.

They come up with this a lot. And it's always the type who's fond of deceptions of one form or another, from trying to sneak into DMs,all the way to procuring sex on the basis of false premises, who'll assert that his sex is his 'private medical history.'

Edited

They come out with it because it’s a useful gotcha for them. It was one of the main lines of argument in the Roz Adams v ERCC tribunal, for instance. Though obviously not particularly convincing.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:08

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 15:07

It's a total myth that being a trans man insulates you from SA, and all trans guy's know this

'Female people remain at risk of SA even if they say they aren't female, shocker'

I'm aware. A lot of people.aren't, and claim that trans men transition in order to escape sexual violence.

Anyone not cis male is at risk of gender-based sexual violence. And a fair few gnc cis guys too.

Transperson · 20/11/2026 16:10

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:07

They come out with it because it’s a useful gotcha for them. It was one of the main lines of argument in the Roz Adams v ERCC tribunal, for instance. Though obviously not particularly convincing.

Are you really comparing employment law to criminal law? Wildly different areas

Rockyroadminibites · 20/11/2026 16:15

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/11/2026 15:30

And right wing ...

😁

Someone rather missing the point.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:15

Transperson · 20/11/2026 16:10

Are you really comparing employment law to criminal law? Wildly different areas

I’m just making a point. It’s the same shaky principle, no?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:16

And yes I do know the GRA has super special privacy protection built in for GRC holders - it’s one of the main reasons I want the GRA to be repealed.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:18

cfri · 20/11/2026 15:25

born not made? Nope. Social contagion has forever been at the heart of this trend.
Have you read The Cass review? I think you might have denounced it as transphobic? Most children with gender disphoria will desist. The permanence of gender identity was debunked in the Cass review.

Social affirmation and transactivist parents pollute the air. A child needs the opportunity to backpedal from decisions which aren’t neutral, like being gay: permanent irreversible changes are made in trans affirmative care , which cause lifelong harms. It’s a massive safeguarding fail and parents who go along with it to play nice or be progressive are utterly failing their children.

Afraid that's all just transphobia. None of it's factual.

The transphobic anger, ignorance and misinformation which enable real-life violence against trans people (especially trans children in schools) is sadly why it's important we mark today's Transgender Day Of Remembrance.

273 killed because of who they were. I'm such a small popukation, that is a really significant number.

Many more have been attacked, terrorised and raped because they were trans.

Transphobic myths are not people, and spreading them endangers real human beings, individuals who are all different. None of whom chose to be trans, or were created trans by anyone else.

Being trans is a a really small element of who someone is, same as being cis. Trans people are not defined by who they are - they simply are.

Creating origin stories for them is really odd.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:19

I think it will be interesting to see what happened if a GRC holder was convicted of sex by deception. As discussed in the FWS SC hearing, the certificate makes zero practical or material difference to the other person. People don’t think about the possession or non possession of certificates in their personal lives.

DialSquare · 20/11/2026 16:20

Differentforgirls · 20/11/2026 15:26

Going to bow out of this thread now, not that anyone will be bothered 🤣.

BUT, I am a “trans women are women” because who would actually want to be one? It’s not as if we are respected.

The shit I read on here about female politicians is abysmal. “Rachel from accounts” etc.

I would be here all day listing them.

The complete shite that is posted about Nicola Sturgeon is dreadful from people who claim to be women.

You’re not feminists.

BUT, I am a “trans women are women” because who would actually want to be one? It’s not as if we are respected.

Fuck me, that is stupidly naive.

murasaki · 20/11/2026 16:20

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:18

Afraid that's all just transphobia. None of it's factual.

The transphobic anger, ignorance and misinformation which enable real-life violence against trans people (especially trans children in schools) is sadly why it's important we mark today's Transgender Day Of Remembrance.

273 killed because of who they were. I'm such a small popukation, that is a really significant number.

Many more have been attacked, terrorised and raped because they were trans.

Transphobic myths are not people, and spreading them endangers real human beings, individuals who are all different. None of whom chose to be trans, or were created trans by anyone else.

Being trans is a a really small element of who someone is, same as being cis. Trans people are not defined by who they are - they simply are.

Creating origin stories for them is really odd.

Well it seems to define you a lot.

murasaki · 20/11/2026 16:21

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:19

I think it will be interesting to see what happened if a GRC holder was convicted of sex by deception. As discussed in the FWS SC hearing, the certificate makes zero practical or material difference to the other person. People don’t think about the possession or non possession of certificates in their personal lives.

Particularly a certificate you're not allowed to ask about.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:22

I think this is the main reason the SC came down in favour of Team Reality.

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:23

Social.contagion is a ridiculous myth.

My son was the only trans boy in his entire school..He knew he was trans aged 4.

He has a few nb friends after being at school, college and now uni, but knows no other trans men except his cousin, who came out separately to him. (They live at considerable distance and weren't in touch.)

I know. It's easier to believe the myths, because then you can pretend to be able to control a difference you don't understand. Unfortunately, difference is baked into every population - and suppression of the visibility of difference will never eliminate it.

murasaki · 20/11/2026 16:25

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:23

Social.contagion is a ridiculous myth.

My son was the only trans boy in his entire school..He knew he was trans aged 4.

He has a few nb friends after being at school, college and now uni, but knows no other trans men except his cousin, who came out separately to him. (They live at considerable distance and weren't in touch.)

I know. It's easier to believe the myths, because then you can pretend to be able to control a difference you don't understand. Unfortunately, difference is baked into every population - and suppression of the visibility of difference will never eliminate it.

So your decision to call yourself non binary post your daughter's transition was completely unrelated...

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 20/11/2026 16:27

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 15:38

‘Transwomen are women because who would want to be one’ is possibly the most ridiculous reasoning I’ve encountered. In a very crowded field.

I read that as "why would you want to be one and put yourself through all the abuse" if you didn't have to.
Which I think is a fair point.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 20/11/2026 16:29

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 15:04

That trans kids are more likely to.come out in a supportive environment? Yeah, I've seen that. Hardly a surprise. Plus, being trans tends to run in families. Both my cousin and I have trans kids, but weren't in contact when they came out.

That some people are really ignorant and ableist about autism, and how autistic people experience gender? Yes.

That trauma creates trans boys? Nope. Conservative estimates are that 1 in 4 girls have suffered sexual abuse, yet trans boys remain a tiny minority. Trans boys and men are at very high risk of sexual assault because their gender-nonconformity and use of male facilities angers violent cis men.

Trans people in general are at very high risk of sexual assault. It's a total myth that being a trans man insulates you from SA, and all trans guy's know this.

People who to you are "massive TRAs" are just sticking up for their trans friends, relatives and colleagues. Or are trans themselves. Responding to the extreme and violently consequential anti-trans activism of recent years, when you are or.love someone who is trans, should not be a surprise.

Same way a lot of women are 'massive feminists" - it's not an insult to want respect and safety for persecuted, at-risk social groups.

Trans people are born, not made. They are more visible now.but have always existed.

I can accept that you think some trans people are born trans, though I've seen nothing to convince me of that. It is definitely not true of all trans people.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:32

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 20/11/2026 16:27

I read that as "why would you want to be one and put yourself through all the abuse" if you didn't have to.
Which I think is a fair point.

In what sense?

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 20/11/2026 16:35

TransParentlyAnnoyed · 20/11/2026 16:18

Afraid that's all just transphobia. None of it's factual.

The transphobic anger, ignorance and misinformation which enable real-life violence against trans people (especially trans children in schools) is sadly why it's important we mark today's Transgender Day Of Remembrance.

273 killed because of who they were. I'm such a small popukation, that is a really significant number.

Many more have been attacked, terrorised and raped because they were trans.

Transphobic myths are not people, and spreading them endangers real human beings, individuals who are all different. None of whom chose to be trans, or were created trans by anyone else.

Being trans is a a really small element of who someone is, same as being cis. Trans people are not defined by who they are - they simply are.

Creating origin stories for them is really odd.

Being gay was thought to be a social contagion too in the 80s. Probably one of the reasons why we ended up with Section 28 and weren't allowed to be taught anything about being same sex attracted in case we got ideas or something. 🙄
Can you imagine this MN board being around then? It'd be saying the same arguments but for Harry people and lesbians instead.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:36

IME men who think they are women think women have it easy. If they actually cared about the hardship of women’s lives they would respect women as people, and respect our boundaries and feelings. Which as we can see, many do not.

murasaki · 20/11/2026 16:39

OhTheCowsInTheMeadowGoMoo · 20/11/2026 16:35

Being gay was thought to be a social contagion too in the 80s. Probably one of the reasons why we ended up with Section 28 and weren't allowed to be taught anything about being same sex attracted in case we got ideas or something. 🙄
Can you imagine this MN board being around then? It'd be saying the same arguments but for Harry people and lesbians instead.

I'm now wondering what Harry people are.

Transperson · 20/11/2026 16:40

Ereshkigalangcleg · 20/11/2026 16:15

I’m just making a point. It’s the same shaky principle, no?

"Where a transgender person has received a Gender Recognition Certificate, their legal gender will therefore match their self-defined gender identity and, per the Grand chamber judgement of the European Court of Human Rights case in Goodwin v UK 6(2002) 35 E.H.R.R 18 their right to keep private their gender history is legally established."

"in general, all sexual offences directed against adults of full capacity require proof that the complainer did not consent and that the accused had no reasonable belief that the complainer consented;"

From the prosector crown page regarding trans people in specific cases like this.
Tldr for adults, trans people with GRC have the right to not disclose in Scotland.

Consent in Scotland is defined as:
"in terms of section 13(2) free agreement is presumed to be absent in a number of circumstances including “(d) where B agrees or submits to the conduct because B is mistaken, as a result of deception by A, as to the nature or purpose of the conduct..” This presumption is likely to be interpreted narrowly by the courts and examples of where this has been held to apply include where an accused falsely states that the act is a medical procedure – Baillie v HMA 2007 SCCR 26."

They acknowledge that trans people aren't causing deception and that finding out about birth sex of trans people can be distressing when you find out after the fact.