Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

ur sons are bonding over a game that humiliates women for fun

180 replies

IwantToRetire · 19/11/2026 19:23

... The fantasy world of Leonida sounds like the manosphere on steroids: a hyper-realistic online world proliferated with orgies, porn-magnate mansions, strip clubs raining down lap dances and dollar bills, and public, transactional sex.

It’s true that you can no longer hire sex workers, and there’s a lead woman character for the first time – Lucia, apparently developed to combat longstanding accusations of gender-based violence. But you can still punch women, abuse women, kill women. Just like real life too, then (let’s not forget that in the UK alone, according to the Femicide Census, around 120 to 160 women are killed by men each year – about one woman every three days).

Women in the game are still mostly shown as exotic dancers, as arm candy for men – or pregnant – while a lot of the talk on radios is about pursuing women for sex, or how women are trying to “scam” men. Which could be a satirical takedown of manosphere “bros”, if it wasn’t so similar to what we constantly hear and see online. ...

https://inews.co.uk/opinion/sons-bonding-game-humiliates-women-for-fun-4914695

Our sons are bonding over a game that humiliates women for fun

Victoria Richards: My children's school has even sent parents a warning letter about allowing them to play Grand Theft Auto VI

https://inews.co.uk/opinion/sons-bonding-game-humiliates-women-for-fun-4914695

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
alcovecupboards · 20/11/2026 14:48

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/11/2026 14:33

If you don't know, maybe don't hang out in feminism. I know your username though. So I can guess why.

What a bizarre post. If you are unable to answer then just say that. It seems very strange to me that all the examples of this games supposed sexism and misogyny aren't actually from this game. Don't you find that weird?

oldtiredcyclist · 20/11/2026 14:51

This is the BBC article on it. It is pretty bad if schools have to bribe their pupils to attend school, rather than play a game which they are too young for, particularly given the negative stereotypical sexist, misogynist attitudes which are present,

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6z74ep2n17zo

A close up image shows a hand reaching down and pulling out a GTA 6 game from a display in a store in Berlin on Thursday.

UK joins in GTA 6 frenzy as game becomes available worldwide

The game, which was in development for 13 years, is set become one of the world's most popular entertainment products ever.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c6z74ep2n17zo

moto748e · 20/11/2026 15:01

Test

ChequerToRed · 20/11/2026 15:58

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 14:05

Thanks for this. Very interesting.

Although I’ve just shouted “watch out for the hurricane” to son2 and I’m not sure he was impressed.

The inevitable hurricane (it’s will happen, it’s been confirmed by RockStar, and you couldn’t really recreate Florida without one) has caused some discussion with my son and myself. He’s hoping it’ll be the backdrop for a really big heist, I’m interested as to how far they’ll take it- will it be a Cat 2 mainly causing some of the map to flood and take out the power, or will it be a Cat 4-5 causing major destruction to infrastructure? It’s highly likely to take out the essential in-game phone network, and maybe distribute alligators into unexpected places as happens irl.

ForOchreBear · 20/11/2026 16:09

Many of these comments are from people who've never played this game, or any GTA game, and I suspect don't really understand what a video game even is these days.

GTA is a narrative game. It primarily tells a story and you complete the game by following the story to its end, although there are a range of other activities to do and things to explore which are optional. It is possible to kill anyone in the game but it isn't rewarded unless it is part of a story mission and has a specific context, on the contrary doing so will cause the police to come after you and make it more difficult for you to finish the game. There is also apparently an honour system, where performing unnecessarily evil deeds will affect your characters reputation, if this is similar to Rockstar's previous game (Red Dead Redemption 2), it will make things more difficult for you, the world and other characters will guilt trip you, and if you finish the story you will likely get the bad ending.

So it is telling a story. The world of GTA is, in a nutshell, a parody of the American dream. It is satire, not an endorsement, and it is for adults.

Rockstar's last game was Red Dead Redemption 2 which is basically another GTA game but set in 1895. The tone was more serious and it was a tragedy rather than a satire. In the game you play as a member of a band of outlaws on the run led by a charismatic leader who presents himself as a Robin Hood type idealist character. The Old West is dying and industrialization and civilisation is bringing the age of outlaws and the Wild West to an end and your gangs way of life. You get to know all the members of your gang well and they are all well written and acted characters with well developed back stories and personalities. It's a story about the loss of the American dream of freedom and the frontier, and deals with themes including women's suffrage, the legacy of slavery, labour exploitation, the plight of the Native Americans, the rise of industrial capitalism and its environmental impact. The story charts the decline of the gang and I cried at the end, it seems most people did. It's a fully realised world with hundreds of characters and the total text involved - including all potential dialogues as well as newspapers, journals, poems, and letters you can read throughout the game - is over 3x the length of War and Peace. The quality of the writing and voice acting - as well as the animation of facial expressions and body language - is outstanding, it's really at the level of prestige TV, and the game to me felt like living in an epic 19th Century novel. It was an absolutely outstanding cultural and artistic achievement by any measure.

People scoffing at the idea of this being a cultural event are just closed minded and think video games are just about killing people to get points and high scores and have no idea how sophisticated they are as a narrative medium these days.

I haven't played GTA6 yet, but people are excited because of the precedent set by Rockstar's previous game which 8 years later is still unmatched in attention to detail, world building, writing and visual and technical splendour. GTA is more anarchic and South Park-esque than Red Dead Redemption but apparently this new one is cut from the same cloth (which is why the usual suspects are crying that it's gone woke) and several reviewers have said that they cried at the end.

Yes, strip clubs exist in the game. So do male strippers. But you can also take some binoculars and go bird watching in the Everglades to find all 62 types of bird which are part of fully simulated ecosystems. You can doomscroll satirical social media feeds in-game and read crazy comments and also watch in-game TV shows. There are dozens of hours of content on radio shows, including music channels and satirical talk radio. You can go to the gym, go bowling, go gambling at the casino, there are in-game mini video games you can play. You can go fishing and you can feed stray animals. You switch between a male and female protagonist and there is complex relationship mechanics where you have to plan dates, do chores, and respond to text messages promptly. It's a level of detail in a simulated city which is what people are excited about, the game is absolutely not about misogynistic violence and that isn't why people are excited for it.

It's ridiculous that so much controversy about this is generated by journalists who haven't played it or any video game and seem to be relying on half-true controversies about the franchise from 25 years ago, also reported on by people who didn't play or understand the medium.

You wouldn't allow journalists to write about how awful a movie they haven't seen is, especially when they also don't watch movies at all and don't really understand what one is.

alcovecupboards · 20/11/2026 16:14

Just seen that Róisín Murphy's music features. I assume she'll now be cancelled by the GC Mumsnetters for partaking in such an awful, sexist, misogynistic game.

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2026 16:35

DotDotDoorDash · 20/11/2026 08:41

In fact they’ve removed prostitutes from the game in GTA6 so you can’t hire them.

the game is partly about maintaining the relationship between the two main characters. I saw someone building a table and the main characters going on a coffee date and holding hands yesterday.

people really should do a bit more research on what these games actually involve and what content is in them instead of just believing absolutely everything they read online on places like MN.

Regardless of the ins and outs of the content - which I've not speculated on and don't have a clue about - the game remains rated as PEGI 18.

So yeah either way, I have a problem with 12 year olds getting excited about it and parents enabling them to play the game.

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 16:53

alcovecupboards · 20/11/2026 16:14

Just seen that Róisín Murphy's music features. I assume she'll now be cancelled by the GC Mumsnetters for partaking in such an awful, sexist, misogynistic game.

Desperate stuff.

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 16:55

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2026 16:35

Regardless of the ins and outs of the content - which I've not speculated on and don't have a clue about - the game remains rated as PEGI 18.

So yeah either way, I have a problem with 12 year olds getting excited about it and parents enabling them to play the game.

That’s a parent problem.

alcovecupboards · 20/11/2026 17:02

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 16:53

Desperate stuff.

Obviously she must be desperate to take cash from such an awful sexist company. Perhaps JK could throw her a few quid so she doesn't have to sink to such lows?

70percent · 20/11/2026 17:04

This is a great thread, glad to read the Vix Richards article, thanks @IwantToRetire

I was glad to see this in the Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/games/2026/nov/19/grand-theft-auto-parents-please-dont-buy-gta-6-vi-for-your-child as Keza has also reviewed the game giving it 5 stars and saying: gaming’s most depraved world is now also its greatest love story.

She's not wrong when she says this: For some reason there remains an immense knowledge gap between children and parents when it comes to the content of video games, and I think it’s in everyone’s interests for parents to make informed decisions.

The mum who thought an 18 meant it was difficult, not inappropriate. 😩

However, I still wouldn't want it in my house, even if my DS was over 18.

Parents: please don’t buy Grand Theft Auto VI for your child

Rockstar Games’ brilliant 18-rated criminal caper is the most explicit game I’ve ever played, stuffed with sex, drugs and violence. It really is not for kids

https://www.theguardian.com/games/2026/nov/19/grand-theft-auto-parents-please-dont-buy-gta-6-vi-for-your-child

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2026 17:07

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 16:55

That’s a parent problem.

How do you figure that?

It's marketed in a particular way to a particular demographic and it DOES have certain subjects as glorified to teens.

We have movies which have adult content but the way it's marketed is very different. Particularly in the way it's targeted.

I do think there's an issue. It's more subtle than other posters are talking about though.

I say this as a long term gamer who has found gaming culture particularly misogynistic in a way that is different to film cults and nerds.

I'm very much a tom boy and I do like 'male' targeted films. It's the way it's targeted and the marketing pitched that's fundamentally different.

I'd argue here, there much to be said in the context of advertising and marketing of products which subsequently have controls to make them less desirable to teens. For example beer can't be advertised as good for your social life not can it be sold in packaging which may be particularly attractive to kids (noting alcopops as a case study).

In terms of it being a parent problem - when I have a twelve year old coming home and commenting on the hype - from a kid who isn't remotely interested in the game itself (for various reasons) I'm telling you this is very much about marketing a lifestyle teens are keen to buy into and a large amount of it has fuck all to do with the game itself at all and everything to do with the culture surrounding it.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · 20/11/2026 17:08

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/11/2026 14:32

It is. And the explanation is often 'it's how boys socialise now'. Which is very depressing and worrisome. And yes, a gateway to NEEThood, incel, manosphere nonsense.

I think about a family I know. Dad didn't do any parenting. Now his boy is glued to a console, depressed, heading to be a NEET. And dad has lots of cool, boy-coded hobbies he could have shared. But didn't bother. So here we are.

Do you know how many households in the UK have a gaming console? Are you really claiming all that boys / men that are going to become incells?!
Gaming is not for me and I also wouldnt reskin want a partner who spent most of his time gaming either. Because it’s just not my thing. But for the vast vast majority of people who game it is just a hobby like any other.
My 18yo bought GTA yesterday. I’ve refused for him to have it up to now because he was too young. We’ve been chatting about it. He’s told me some of the things he’s come across so far. We’ll keep taking about it because that’s what we do.
Right now, he’s in his room with his friends showing them the game and chatting about 6th form and what they want for Xmas Later on he’ll be at a party with his big mixed friend group. Tomorrow he’ll play football them go to watch his team with his dad.
I think he’s probably quite typical of teens who game as (one of their) hobbies.

RedTagAlan · 20/11/2026 17:31

ChequerToRed · 20/11/2026 15:58

The inevitable hurricane (it’s will happen, it’s been confirmed by RockStar, and you couldn’t really recreate Florida without one) has caused some discussion with my son and myself. He’s hoping it’ll be the backdrop for a really big heist, I’m interested as to how far they’ll take it- will it be a Cat 2 mainly causing some of the map to flood and take out the power, or will it be a Cat 4-5 causing major destruction to infrastructure? It’s highly likely to take out the essential in-game phone network, and maybe distribute alligators into unexpected places as happens irl.

Like the riot in San Andreas you mean ? That was pretty cool. Just getting to your next mission was an ordeal.

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 17:34

RedToothBrush · 20/11/2026 17:07

How do you figure that?

It's marketed in a particular way to a particular demographic and it DOES have certain subjects as glorified to teens.

We have movies which have adult content but the way it's marketed is very different. Particularly in the way it's targeted.

I do think there's an issue. It's more subtle than other posters are talking about though.

I say this as a long term gamer who has found gaming culture particularly misogynistic in a way that is different to film cults and nerds.

I'm very much a tom boy and I do like 'male' targeted films. It's the way it's targeted and the marketing pitched that's fundamentally different.

I'd argue here, there much to be said in the context of advertising and marketing of products which subsequently have controls to make them less desirable to teens. For example beer can't be advertised as good for your social life not can it be sold in packaging which may be particularly attractive to kids (noting alcopops as a case study).

In terms of it being a parent problem - when I have a twelve year old coming home and commenting on the hype - from a kid who isn't remotely interested in the game itself (for various reasons) I'm telling you this is very much about marketing a lifestyle teens are keen to buy into and a large amount of it has fuck all to do with the game itself at all and everything to do with the culture surrounding it.

If parents are enabling children to play a game rated 18 then that is very much a parent problem. It doesn’t start with those games. It starts with ignoring PEGI ratings all through those children’s lives. ‘They are marketed in a way that appeals to them’ doesn’t wash as an excuse for games any more than it would if they were buying their 12 year olds BuzzBallz.

In relation to films, it may be less common with 18 rated films, but there are certainly many certificate 15 films that are marketed in a way that appeals to younger teens. Again, it’s not an excuse to let them watch those films.

sittingonabeach · 20/11/2026 18:13

PeppercornMill · 20/11/2026 14:42

I think it's more of a case of whether people have found the sexism and misogyny by playing the game themselves or just reading about it from various sources such as social media that are full of misinformation.

But if certain males are complaining that some of the misogynistic content has been removed it was misogynistic before and that does influence, together with other media etc, how many males act, relate to females etc. It all adds up.

IwantToRetire · 20/11/2026 18:20

Interesting that there are now so many who have no interest in feminism and think that coming in and making condescending comments they are going to have an impact.

It is just more that the usual suspect clogging up a thread, because of course feminists aren't entitled to have a view point.

And also a bit too over the top in terms of justifying why it is all so important and relevant, which seems much more a knee jerk response to finding not everyone has fallen for yet another consumer promoted fad, that becomes cult like.

All a bit OTT.

And of course misses the core of the article about the impact on this on young (underage) children particularly boys.

For me it is no different than the type of puerile US tv programmes that promote being on the cutting edge of illegality is some how cutting edge.

If you dont want to grow up fine.

But to try and pretend it is important is just pathetic self justification for becoming a victim.

But it is just getting out of hand that so many non feminists just pop in, and derail threads.

Is it any wonder that women looking for support no longer post on FWR for advice.

The last woman who did, who was clearly in distress was told not to be a drama queen.

OP posts:
OakTreesAreTheBest · 20/11/2026 18:28

sittingonabeach · 20/11/2026 18:13

But if certain males are complaining that some of the misogynistic content has been removed it was misogynistic before and that does influence, together with other media etc, how many males act, relate to females etc. It all adds up.

If it was misogynistic before (I don't know if it was, I never played the older games) and it's less so - or even not at all - now (again, I'm not stating whether it is or not - I haven't played enough to comment) then isn't that a good thing? Lots of misogynistic TV etc has changed and improved over the years.

IwantToRetire · 20/11/2026 18:39

OakTreesAreTheBest · 20/11/2026 18:28

If it was misogynistic before (I don't know if it was, I never played the older games) and it's less so - or even not at all - now (again, I'm not stating whether it is or not - I haven't played enough to comment) then isn't that a good thing? Lots of misogynistic TV etc has changed and improved over the years.

Oh aren't we women lucky.

Some tediously male view of the world aimed at immature menboys has added a few tokenistic female(s) to behave like them.

Sort of Girl Power feminism. And what did that achieve?

It seems even on a feminist forum, being a feminist isn't something we should be too caught up in.

Not when we could all be spending our time in some fantasy world.

Grin
OP posts:
IwantToRetire · 20/11/2026 18:41

Thought this is interesting in terms of how who you are determines who you view the game, and its impact on young boys.

Those who feel the article misrepresents GTA VI typically point to the franchise's long-standing design philosophy and specific gameplay changes:

  • Satirical Intent Over Endorsement: Proponents argue that the series operates as a dark, over-the-top parody of modern American culture. In this view, the "manosphere on steroids" landscape, radio shows, and exaggerated gender roles are explicitly designed to mock those cultural elements rather than glorify them. 1]
  • Equal Opportunity Chaos: A core mechanic of GTA is its open-world sandbox format, which grants players absolute freedom to commit violence against any non-player character (NPC), regardless of gender. Critics of the article note that treating female NPCs the same as male NPCs within the context of a crime simulator represents mechanical neutrality rather than targeted misogyny. 1]
  • Removal of Targeted Mechanics: The article itself acknowledges that certain controversial mechanics from past entries—such as the ability to hire sex workers to boost health and then kill them to retrieve the money—have been removed in this installment. Critics argue that ignoring these active steps toward reform downplays the developer's efforts to address past criticisms. 1]
  • Substantive Dual Protagonists: Rather than a "token" addition, defenders point out that Lucia is a fully realized co-lead with her own narrative arc, agency, and complex motivations, serving as a structural shift away from the series' historically male-dominated narratives. 1]

Conversely, those who agree with Richards' perspective argue that structural elements of the game continue to perpetuate harmful tropes:

  • Persistent Structural Tropes: The article highlights that despite a female protagonist, the background world remains populated by highly sexualized depictions of women, such as exotic dancers and "arm candy," maintaining a hostile or degrading environment. 1]
  • The Real-World Context of Violence: From this viewpoint, satire ceases to be harmless when it normalizes or gamifies violence against demographic groups that experience high rates of real-world violence. The argument is that the ability to abuse or kill female characters for "entertainment" cannot be separated from societal contexts of misogyny, regardless of the developer's intent. 1]
  • Player Agency and Reception: Even if the developers intend for the game to be a satirical takedown of toxic subcultures, the open-world format means the game cannot control how players engage with it. As the article's interviews suggest, some players actively value the game for its "slide into hedonistic violence" and lack of moral guardrails. 1, 2, 3]

Ultimately, whether the article is viewed as a total misrepresentation depends on whether one evaluates GTA VI by its overarching satirical themes and mechanical neutrality, or by the broader societal impact of its imagery and player freedom.

OP posts:
Rockyroadminibites · 20/11/2026 18:42

Is it any wonder that women looking for support no longer post on FWR for advice.

That is the aim of those posters, they are trying to shut FWR up by drowning women out.

BackToLurk · 20/11/2026 18:50

If you ignore the ploppers and derailers, it is still evident that among feminists there is disagreement about the nature of the game and about other surrounding debates, for example the role of parents, the differences between child and adult content. Anyone who starts a thread on an online forum should be prepared for such disagreement, without just writing all the dissenters off as just not good enough feminists.

And the repeated use of AI slop is at least as likely to put people off posting as the tedious (and increasingly unimaginative) usual suspects.

Three4 · 20/11/2026 18:54

I thought this was an active thread anyone can join. If you want an actual discussion and you stand by your views, you’re going to have to tolerate other people’s opinions. Including those who actually have knowledge of the game.

Making FWR an exclusive club nobody is allowed to partake in isn’t helpful if the aim is to get people on board. That goes for all topics.

RedTagAlan · 20/11/2026 18:57

IwantToRetire · 20/11/2026 18:20

Interesting that there are now so many who have no interest in feminism and think that coming in and making condescending comments they are going to have an impact.

It is just more that the usual suspect clogging up a thread, because of course feminists aren't entitled to have a view point.

And also a bit too over the top in terms of justifying why it is all so important and relevant, which seems much more a knee jerk response to finding not everyone has fallen for yet another consumer promoted fad, that becomes cult like.

All a bit OTT.

And of course misses the core of the article about the impact on this on young (underage) children particularly boys.

For me it is no different than the type of puerile US tv programmes that promote being on the cutting edge of illegality is some how cutting edge.

If you dont want to grow up fine.

But to try and pretend it is important is just pathetic self justification for becoming a victim.

But it is just getting out of hand that so many non feminists just pop in, and derail threads.

Is it any wonder that women looking for support no longer post on FWR for advice.

The last woman who did, who was clearly in distress was told not to be a drama queen.

Maybe because you posted it on the "Feminism: Sex and gender discussions" board ?

I have read most of the thread, and while we are all used to hearing politicians blame video games for all ills of society, I have not seen anyone post a link to a scientific study that proves that to be the case.

Rockyroadminibites · 20/11/2026 19:01

RedTagAlan · 20/11/2026 18:57

Maybe because you posted it on the "Feminism: Sex and gender discussions" board ?

I have read most of the thread, and while we are all used to hearing politicians blame video games for all ills of society, I have not seen anyone post a link to a scientific study that proves that to be the case.

Has any posted a scientific study showing it is not the case?