Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

'Silence is not an option' - full statement of wife abused for 13 years

90 replies

IwantToRetire · 19/11/2026 18:34

A woman who was drugged and raped by her husband over a 13 year period has said "silence is not an option" in tackling violence against women and girls.

Speaking outside court, Joanne Young urged victims of sexual abuse to come forward. Her statement in full follows:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr3wg1e6854vo

Joanne Young wearing a blue jumper and black trousers is standing in front of microphones and journalists delivering a statement outside of court.

Joanne Young says 'silence is not an option' on sexual violence - full statement

Joanne Young urges victims of sexual abuse to come forward and tells them they are not alone.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cr3wg1e6854vo

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
MFL · 20/11/2026 16:44

@KnickerlessParsons People who are DBS checked aren’t checked for future or current criminal behaviour that’s not known about. It checks historic records. So - not caught - clean DBS.

Talkinpeace · 20/11/2026 16:47

PeppercornMill · 20/11/2026 16:34

I find this talk about the third-party consent rather strange, as the BBC has confirmed that it doesn't exist and isn't a valid defence, indeed all the men were found guilty.

Watch Joanne's statement
and read the detailed court reporting.

the change is ABSOLUTELY needed

MFL · 20/11/2026 16:54

@Talkinpeace I’ve chatted to DD about this : she’s a barrister. There is no third party consent to sex. There has been a lot of confusion about this. It was raised as a defence. It’s not a defence and the Justice system didn’t accept this defence. @PeppercornMill is totally correct. The men tried to say they had consent from the DH, but that’s impossible under our laws. This is why their prosecution was successful. Reading the prosecuting lawyers statements might be more illuminating and the judge’s summing up.

SirenScream · 20/11/2026 16:55

He must have believed that his wife would never realise, and that if she did she would never speak out and/or would not be believed.
Is it a kind of addiction? Having total power over someone is so all consuming that it becomes a compulsion?
I am absolutely not trying to condone him in any way shape or form, but what was likely going on in his mind?

MFL · 20/11/2026 17:04

For those who find consent a bit confusing, and using third party consent as a defence, the best explanation as to the current law is provided by the CPS who successfully prosecuted this case. I’ve attached a summary. Men having sex with a women must get consent directly from
the woman. There is no other form of consent. To not do so, is rape. It’s clear.

'Silence is not an option' - full statement of wife abused for 13 years
'Silence is not an option' - full statement of wife abused for 13 years
Finallyseenthelights · Yesterday 06:07

BrandiedAromatics · 19/11/2026 19:27

It is harrowing. I am encouraged at the words of the judge in the Brand case and the police. Also today, the BBC says that Joanne beamed at police as she left court wiping her eyes - so have worked together well there. I also noted that, as with the Brand case, the jury was 4 women and 8 men. There is some hope .... at last.

I wonder why there were more men on the jury in both cases - surely they should have divided it 50-50?

BrandiedAromatics · Yesterday 08:04

Finallyseenthelights · Yesterday 06:07

I wonder why there were more men on the jury in both cases - surely they should have divided it 50-50?

It doesn't work that way. You are called as a large group of potential jurors and then if your name is called in the jurors' waiting room you go into court and if you are accepted you are sworn in. When I was called, for the 2nd and 3rd times, I was exempt for two reasons - I had already served within a certain time and the 2nd time I had a new baby (this in itself would change the figures for female availability on a jury).

Why I commented, in a positive way, on the gender ratio in these cases - there are statistics to show that when women were 'admitted' for jury service the conviction rates where women were victims/defendants were increased.

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 18:48

BrandiedAromatics · Yesterday 08:04

It doesn't work that way. You are called as a large group of potential jurors and then if your name is called in the jurors' waiting room you go into court and if you are accepted you are sworn in. When I was called, for the 2nd and 3rd times, I was exempt for two reasons - I had already served within a certain time and the 2nd time I had a new baby (this in itself would change the figures for female availability on a jury).

Why I commented, in a positive way, on the gender ratio in these cases - there are statistics to show that when women were 'admitted' for jury service the conviction rates where women were victims/defendants were increased.

Edited

Well that's changed. In the past those supporting victims of rape were concerned about women being on the Jury because it became well known that they argue that it wouldn't be "fair" to ruin a man's life and employment because of one "mistake".

This was why partly, many of those providing services to rape victims, were behind the proposals that rape trials should not be a jury trial.

I cant remember what the outcome was of the campaign to make sure that those serving on a jury for a rape trial were given training about rape myths.

OP posts:
BrandiedAromatics · Yesterday 19:10

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 18:48

Well that's changed. In the past those supporting victims of rape were concerned about women being on the Jury because it became well known that they argue that it wouldn't be "fair" to ruin a man's life and employment because of one "mistake".

This was why partly, many of those providing services to rape victims, were behind the proposals that rape trials should not be a jury trial.

I cant remember what the outcome was of the campaign to make sure that those serving on a jury for a rape trial were given training about rape myths.

I feel that there has gradually been a change in attitude which was encapsulated in the judgement in the recent rape trial:

Mr Justice Bennathan told Southwark Crown Court: "Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent."

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 19:24

BrandiedAromatics · Yesterday 19:10

I feel that there has gradually been a change in attitude which was encapsulated in the judgement in the recent rape trial:

Mr Justice Bennathan told Southwark Crown Court: "Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent."

I did do a quick check online, and without going into actual stats, it is now being said that age is now more likely to influence Juries. Although they seem to contradict each other.

One is that young people on rape trial Juries are more likely to convict. But on the other hand, there is another figure that says younger men are more likely to not be convicted of rape because (some of) a jury thinks it isn't fair to blight their prospects with a conviction. (Although nothing compares to the situation in Scotland - not sure if this is still true - that a man under 25 can be excused his "bad behaviour" because his brain hasn't finished maturing!)

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · Yesterday 19:27

Some women attended court throughout the trial, listening to difficult evidence before returning outside. Others simply wanted Joanne to know she was not alone.

Most had never met her. Some had never met each other.
Beverley Siddle, from Hampshire, was among those who came to support Joanne after reading about the case online.

"I've long considered myself a feminist and a supporter of women's rights and anti-male violence against women," she said.

"I'm retired now, I feel very strongly about the issue.

"All these women came out to support Gisèle Pelicot, I thought [Joanne] needs support too."

One of the women helping organise support was Cid Dixon, from Oxfordshire.

"I'd read about the case earlier this year and saw that it was coming to Winchester Crown Court. I thought I'd like to go and stand outside of court to support this brave woman," she said.

"We just wanted to be there - against male violence."

Inspired by the public support shown to French survivor Gisèle Pelicot during her rape trial, Dixon contacted women in Winchester and asked Wiltshire Police to pass a message to Joanne about their plans.

The public response to the support exceeded expectations.

"We had a number of people walking up to us, a lot of them had not even heard of the case, they were very interested in what we were doing," she said.

"They were all very supportive and thanked us for being there."

For Dr Fiona Vera Gray, professor of sexual violence and co-director of the Child and Woman Abuse Studies Unit at London Metropolitan University, the scenes outside court reflected something larger.

"I think what we're starting to see is a huge resurgence in solidarity amongst women around sexual violence," she said.

"It started in the Gisèle Pelicot trial in France, and we've also seen it with some of the discourse around the Russell Brand conviction."

She said support for survivors was once a central part of the women's liberation movement but became less visible over time.

"But this feels to me like there's some kind of movement back towards women standing up and supporting other women who are standing up to their abusers," she said.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmqj5d2442r2o

A close-up image of Joanne Young - a white woman with dark brown hair wearing stud earrings.

Joanne Young: 'Resurgence of solidarity' by women in husband drug-rape case

Joanne Young was met by applause from women she had never met after a guilty verdict was returned.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmqj5d2442r2o

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · Yesterday 21:27

There were noises about revising the.Scottish under 25 sentencing guidance.

But I think there is similar in E&W, though?

IwantToRetire · Yesterday 23:02

I've just checked or rather asked AI for a summary and it seems although there was a review it hasn't changed:

Despite intense public backlash following the Sean Hogg case, the guideline remains in effect exactly as originally drafted, applying to all individuals under the age of 25. 1, 2]

The Scottish Sentencing Council proceeded with a standard, evidence-based review process rather than an immediate policy reversal: 1]

  • Routine Monitoring: The council fulfilled its statutory obligation by launching a formal review into how the guideline operated. It published its one-year review report in January 2025, which found no unintended consequences or unexpected shifts in sentencing patterns. 1, 2]
  • Ongoing Evaluations: A more comprehensive three-year review has since been undertaken by the council to analyze data up to 2025 and 2026, keeping the guideline under scrutiny without scrapping it. 1, 2]
  • The Sean Hogg Case Outcome: The specific case that caused the public outcry came to an unexpected end when the Court of Criminal Appeal completely quashed Sean Hogg's conviction in October 2023 due to an unrelated judicial misdirection regarding evidence. Because the conviction itself was overturned, the Crown's appeal regarding his "unduly lenient" community service sentence became legally moot, meaning the high court never formally ruled on the appropriateness of his original sentence under the youth guideline. 1, 2, 3, 4]

While the "under-25" framework remains fully active for general offences, the Council did separately introduce tough, specific sentencing guidelines for rape and rape of a young child which came into force in March 2026. These guidelines increased standard sentencing ranges to ensure that rape convictions consistently result in long-term prison sentences, regardless of the offender's background. 1, 2]

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · Yesterday 23:07

Nothing similar in E&W or NI but ...

there is no equivalent standalone law or specific youth guideline that applies up to the age of 25 in England, Wales, or Northern Ireland. 1]

Instead, the criminal justice systems in those regions handle young adults differently, treating the age of 18 as the legal dividing line for "youth justice," while still offering more flexible mechanisms to consider maturity. 1, 2]

🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿 England and Wales: "Age and Lack of Maturity" as a Mitigation Factor

In England and Wales, the Sentencing Council for England and Wales has a dedicated guideline for Sentencing Children and Young People. However, this strictly applies only to those under 18 at the date of conviction. 1, 2]

Once an offender turns 18, they are tried and sentenced in adult courts. Rather than a strict "under-25 guideline," maturity is accounted for under general rules: 1]

  • The "Age and/or Lack of Maturity" Factor: In 2019, the Sentencing Council expanded its general guidelines to mandate that judges consider a lack of maturity as a mitigating factor for young adults aged 18 to 25. Judges look at neurological development, susceptibility to peer pressure, and a high capacity for reform. 1, 2, 3]
  • Case Law Precedent: The Court of Appeal established in key cases (such as R v Clarke, 2018) that the age of 18 is not a "cliff edge" for sentencing. The court ruled that young adults are still developing neurologically and socially, and sentences should reflect their developmental maturity rather than just their chronological age. 1, 2, 3]
  • Deferred Sentences: English and Welsh courts frequently use deferred sentencing specifically for the 18–25 age bracket to allow young adults time to show they are engaging in rehabilitation before a final sentence is passed. 1]

🏴 Northern Ireland: Distinct Youth Rules up to 18

Northern Ireland operates entirely under its own distinct legal framework, separate from England, Wales, and Scotland. 1]

  • Like England and Wales, Northern Ireland sets the legal threshold for youth sentencing at under 18 years of age.
  • For under-18s, rehabilitation and the welfare of the child are enshrined as primary legal considerations.
  • Once an individual reaches 18, they enter the adult sentencing framework. While defense lawyers routinely cite an offender's youth and brain development as general mitigation, Northern Ireland does not possess a formal guideline or statutory rule acknowledging the 18–25 bracket as a protected or distinct developmental category in the way Scotland does.
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page