Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stilitz and Crash are at it again: the GLP's latest challenge to the EHRC guidance

35 replies

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 04:51

The latest GLP challenge is a JR of the EHRC guidance for services claiming that trans-inclusive services are legal after all:

https://goodlawproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/EHRC-Code-of-Practice-SFG-For-GLP.pdf

The legal argument appears (to me) to have bus-sized holes in it, and Stillitz hasn't so far demonstrated much understanding of the EA2010 - but who knows.

OP posts:
MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 05:00

Here's one hole:

52. Further, in such a case, applying section 23 EA 2010, the relevant comparator in a direct sex discrimination claim for e.g. a cis man who was excluded from a service provided to those who live as women would be a trans man. The trans man would be of a different “biological sex” to the claimant, but there would otherwise be no material difference between them, as both would be living as men.

Na-ah. A hypothetical comparator for the purposes of discrimination must not materially different, but a woman (living as a man) and a man (living as a man) are (other than their sex) materially different in EA terms, because the woman living as a man has an additional protected characteristic, that of Gender Reassignment, which the man-living-as-a-man doesn't have. That's why it's the wrong comparator.

OP posts:
Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 07:50

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 05:00

Here's one hole:

52. Further, in such a case, applying section 23 EA 2010, the relevant comparator in a direct sex discrimination claim for e.g. a cis man who was excluded from a service provided to those who live as women would be a trans man. The trans man would be of a different “biological sex” to the claimant, but there would otherwise be no material difference between them, as both would be living as men.

Na-ah. A hypothetical comparator for the purposes of discrimination must not materially different, but a woman (living as a man) and a man (living as a man) are (other than their sex) materially different in EA terms, because the woman living as a man has an additional protected characteristic, that of Gender Reassignment, which the man-living-as-a-man doesn't have. That's why it's the wrong comparator.

Well let's hope it goes the way of their challenge to the interim guidance and ends up reinforcing it.

ProfessorRedshoeblueshoe · 17/11/2026 07:58

When they lose we all know they will claim they have won

LadyinPainting · 17/11/2026 08:03

Interesting. I don’t think the code prohibits a service just for transwomen? In this case I would have thought such a service would be justified and legal, but for some reason the centre and the transwomen want a ‘gender based’ service for women and transwomen.

But as we know from Brighton, even if such a provision were legal, and I suspect the court will find it isn’t, in practice that generally means women don’t get a single sex option. And so even if this court finds it isn’t legal, I suspect either the inclusive service will have very few women users, or the women will take it back to court arguing indirect sex discrimination as the service will reduce the single sex provision.

An impartial observer would see this quite quickly, and would suggest that a transwomen only service should suffice??

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 17/11/2026 08:12

Stilitz trotted out all these fallacious arguments on a podcast earlier this year. Naomi Cunningham has done a very effective demolition job in this blog post.

www.legalfeminist.org.uk/2026/03/25/podcasting-and-partisanship/

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 17/11/2026 08:18

This really has degenerated into purely toddler-level behavior now, hasn't it? They are losing on all fronts, and their response is:

Give it to me because I want it!!
<foot stamp>

Princessdebthe1st · 17/11/2026 08:26

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 17/11/2026 08:18

This really has degenerated into purely toddler-level behavior now, hasn't it? They are losing on all fronts, and their response is:

Give it to me because I want it!!
<foot stamp>

I was reading a very entertaining thread on here yesterday about reasons why your toddler has got upset. One child got upset because “they wanted to be a triangle’. I think that argument might have more legal sense than this one! The good thing about the toddler is with time and maturity they will grow to understand the difference between fantasy and reality; I fear the members of the GLP never will.

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 17/11/2026 08:29

Princessdebthe1st · 17/11/2026 08:26

I was reading a very entertaining thread on here yesterday about reasons why your toddler has got upset. One child got upset because “they wanted to be a triangle’. I think that argument might have more legal sense than this one! The good thing about the toddler is with time and maturity they will grow to understand the difference between fantasy and reality; I fear the members of the GLP never will.

I saw that thread! And the "want to be a triangle" post was the funniest thing I've seen on MN since cutted-up pear!

Shedmistress · 17/11/2026 08:32

LadyinPainting · 17/11/2026 08:03

Interesting. I don’t think the code prohibits a service just for transwomen? In this case I would have thought such a service would be justified and legal, but for some reason the centre and the transwomen want a ‘gender based’ service for women and transwomen.

But as we know from Brighton, even if such a provision were legal, and I suspect the court will find it isn’t, in practice that generally means women don’t get a single sex option. And so even if this court finds it isn’t legal, I suspect either the inclusive service will have very few women users, or the women will take it back to court arguing indirect sex discrimination as the service will reduce the single sex provision.

An impartial observer would see this quite quickly, and would suggest that a transwomen only service should suffice??

What would be the 'legitimate aim' of a service just for men who say they are women?

If we can get that buttoned down into legalese then maybe they can all go there and leave all female services alone.

Wishesandhorses · 17/11/2026 08:40

Princessdebthe1st · 17/11/2026 08:26

I was reading a very entertaining thread on here yesterday about reasons why your toddler has got upset. One child got upset because “they wanted to be a triangle’. I think that argument might have more legal sense than this one! The good thing about the toddler is with time and maturity they will grow to understand the difference between fantasy and reality; I fear the members of the GLP never will.

And that is the heart of it really - that this is trying to have a reasonable, rational conversation with a position that starts from a personal alternative reality.

Mountainlarch · 17/11/2026 08:42

I can imagine services supporting victims of violence being beneficial for only TW, or only TM, because of specific issues linked to being trans. It seems they are actually already provided.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 08:46

The legal argument isn't anything to do with who can be included, really. It's to do with who can legally be excluded.

A service can exclude men, but it can't exclude men-unless-they-say-they-feel-womanly or even men-who-look-feminine.

Shedmistress · 17/11/2026 08:52

Mountainlarch · 17/11/2026 08:42

I can imagine services supporting victims of violence being beneficial for only TW, or only TM, because of specific issues linked to being trans. It seems they are actually already provided.

Seperate out those two groups.

A 'men who say they are women' group would have to be seperate from a 'men' group...because? Why would some men who have been subjected to violence be refused support whilst others are not?

A 'women who say they are men' group would have to be seperate from a 'women' group...because? Why would some women who have been subjected to violence be refused support whilst others are not?

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 08:54

https://archive.ph/iG9se

GLP's fundraising page.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 08:58

The statement from the head of SARSVL is interesting.

She says that they take care in group work to carefully consider anything that may distress a survivor - smell, sound, surroundings, etc. And talks about how they can't possibly include men because that would distress survivors.

How on earth does she square this with being 'inclusive' of transwomen in group work?

There's also mention on an 'incident' where a 'transwoman' survivor's presence in group work become 'relevant', but she discreetly draws a veil over it. (point 36) Why bring it up if you're going to then refuse to discuss the details? Bit odd.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 09:06

She says SARSVL supported 12 'transwomen' in 2025.

Most of their work is phone or online support, with some one to one and group work.

teawamutu · 17/11/2026 09:06

Just read NC's blog. God, she's tremendous. We're lucky to have her in the terven camp.

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 09:08

Adding this to the thread, because it seems pertinent.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/07/17/predator-cameron-downing-trans-inclusive-rape-crisis-centre/

ArabellaScott · 17/11/2026 09:08

SARSVL also wish to include 'nonbinary' people.

What would be their exclusion criteria?

MrPrettyDamnCosmic · 17/11/2026 09:38

It's interesting that they couldn't find a trans identifying female to bolster their case.

Mountainlarch · 17/11/2026 09:59

Mountainlarch · 17/11/2026 08:42

I can imagine services supporting victims of violence being beneficial for only TW, or only TM, because of specific issues linked to being trans. It seems they are actually already provided.

I'm not suggesting TW (or TM) only services, with no single sex space available for men and women. I was basically thinking of four separate services offered. I think TW and TM might have specific needs that would not be covered in mixed "gender", but single sex groups (women + TM, or men +TW).

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 18:10

Shedmistress · 17/11/2026 08:32

What would be the 'legitimate aim' of a service just for men who say they are women?

If we can get that buttoned down into legalese then maybe they can all go there and leave all female services alone.

Neovaginal cleaning services.

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · 17/11/2026 18:21

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 04:51

The latest GLP challenge is a JR of the EHRC guidance for services claiming that trans-inclusive services are legal after all:

https://goodlawproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/EHRC-Code-of-Practice-SFG-For-GLP.pdf

The legal argument appears (to me) to have bus-sized holes in it, and Stillitz hasn't so far demonstrated much understanding of the EA2010 - but who knows.

Why can't trans organisations (and Stonewall) set up counselling services for trans people? Why are they trying to get services from women's services that have been over-stretched and underfunded for decades?

In the case of TIMS, their service needs will be different from the needs of female sexual assault victims and, in the case of TIFS, their needs will be different to male sexual assault victims; it makes no sense to argue for access to a service that doesn't match your requirements when you could tailor one for your community's precise needs.

The needs of the other service users are important too - having someone of the opposite sex in group meetings could disturb and alarm sexual assault victims or make them reticent to speak about their experience/feelings.

Women's groups initially set these services up by themselves without government support or funding, why can't trans organisations do the same?

^^ I know the answers that will be given by trans orgs i.e. because we want access so shut up.

But I still think these are questions that should be borne in mind.

Hoardasurass · 17/11/2026 18:33

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 18:10

Neovaginal cleaning services.

🤢
Please its dinner time

MyAmpleSheep · 17/11/2026 18:49

UtopiaPlanitia · 17/11/2026 18:21

Why can't trans organisations (and Stonewall) set up counselling services for trans people? Why are they trying to get services from women's services that have been over-stretched and underfunded for decades?

In the case of TIMS, their service needs will be different from the needs of female sexual assault victims and, in the case of TIFS, their needs will be different to male sexual assault victims; it makes no sense to argue for access to a service that doesn't match your requirements when you could tailor one for your community's precise needs.

The needs of the other service users are important too - having someone of the opposite sex in group meetings could disturb and alarm sexual assault victims or make them reticent to speak about their experience/feelings.

Women's groups initially set these services up by themselves without government support or funding, why can't trans organisations do the same?

^^ I know the answers that will be given by trans orgs i.e. because we want access so shut up.

But I still think these are questions that should be borne in mind.

It's yet another contradiction at the heart of trans issues. A trans organization ideologically cannot set up trans-only services, because they would be both "othering" and "outing" to anyone for whom they were set up, which is anathema.

The trans "community" feels it is served best and is strongest when it makes itself so invisible that it's members are undetectable.

OP posts: