Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Stop the Consent Gap - new Campaign

53 replies

IwantToRetire · 15/11/2026 21:51

It is time to close the consent gap

Protecting 16–17 year olds from significantly older adults

At 16 and 17, young people are still legally recognised as children in safeguarding terms. Yet the law currently allows adults of any age to have sex with those same 16–17 year olds. That is the gap we are campaigning to close.

We are not trying to criminalise teenage relationships. We are trying to stop grown adults having legal sexual access to children.

Our proposed reform

It should be an offence for a person aged 20+ to engage in sexual activity with a person aged 16–17, unless the age difference is no more than three years.
✓17 and 19: legal
✓16 and 19: legal
✗16 and 20: illegal
✗17 and 21: illegal

Help us close the consent gap.

Full details https://closetheconsentgap.com/

Stop the Consent Gap - new Campaign
OP posts:
AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 23:02

Is there a TL:DR?

I'm interested but not enough to wade through all the references.

I've been thinking about this a lot. I don't think complicating age of consent rules is helpful. We already have laws about coercion and about positions of authority (a school teacher or youth leader can't date a 6th former).

I don't think you can put conditions on ability to consent. Either you are old enough, or you aren't. All age cut offs in law have this element of sometimes allowing through those they should protect, or conversely prohibiting something that would likely be OK.

20 seems really arbitrary. And what happens to the 16 and 19 year old when they both get a year older - is 17 and 20 ok? Its not included on the table and it doesn't sound like it would be allowed from the wording. So they'd have to break up for a year before resuming their relationship whet they turn 18 and 21? That's not going to happen. Or you have a 'nearly 20 but still 19' year old going out with a 16 year old - once the 19 year old has a birthday, the relationship will be illegal until the younger partner turns 17 (or 18? Its not clear).

ETA its not unusual for 17 year olds to go to university in Scotland. The would potentially legally barred from dating some other students on the same Batchelors degree programme. Which seems utterly daft.

I don't think the age of consent is the answer. Some people are not going to be mature enough to make these decisions at 16 - and those same people may well not be at 18 either. We can't keep rolling it forward when as a society we have deemed that you can pretty much do everything once you're 18. It would be inconsistent to make sex the exception.

The social acceptance of way older men chasing young women needs to change. Putting the age of consent up a couple of years won't do that, they will either ignore it or look for very slightly older victims. Age is only one of may axes of vulnerability.

'Barely legal' porn has a lot to answer for.

PeppercornMill · 15/11/2026 23:18

Saw the charts on this and it was clear that there are periods in the relationships between 16 and 19 years where the relationships moves into and out of criminality.

But hey, much easier to start a campaign for yet another law change, instead of anyone at the BBC, Channel 4, ITV, MTV actually putting a stop to the activity of their stars in their studios.

I remember all the stories of people being tasked with finding children for Jimmy Savile and standing guard outside his caravan. Yet no one was held accountable.

Theskyisblue2026 · 15/11/2026 23:24

As someone that was groomed by a 40 year old man, a man that deliberately waited for me to be ‘legal, aged 16, I support this. Had I been protected by the law, my life would’ve had a completely different outcome.

Raiderofthelostbattenburg · 15/11/2026 23:27

I am definitely in favour of this law change. I think it affirms the social norm that adults should not have sex teenagers, and that teenagers having sex with each other is different to an adult seeking to have sex with a child of sixteen (because under most other safeguarding laws, a sixteen year old is considered a child - for good reason).

Huckleberries · 15/11/2026 23:29

I nearly married my first boyfriend (and I should have that too late to regret it now)

We met when I was 17 and he was 21. Don’t other countries have something like this, but with more flexibility on ages? I don’t actually know.

Imnobody4 · 15/11/2026 23:37

I'm in favour of this change as well. It fits well with the raising of the age for marriage to 18 for the similar reason of deterring forced marriages of vulnerable girls. It's about safeguarding and establishing clear social norms.

EntirelyUnnecessary · 16/11/2026 00:14

Seems a bit overcomplicated tbh. It would be easier to say that eg it is illegal for someone over 25 to sleep with someone under 18.

TempestTost · 16/11/2026 02:59

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 23:02

Is there a TL:DR?

I'm interested but not enough to wade through all the references.

I've been thinking about this a lot. I don't think complicating age of consent rules is helpful. We already have laws about coercion and about positions of authority (a school teacher or youth leader can't date a 6th former).

I don't think you can put conditions on ability to consent. Either you are old enough, or you aren't. All age cut offs in law have this element of sometimes allowing through those they should protect, or conversely prohibiting something that would likely be OK.

20 seems really arbitrary. And what happens to the 16 and 19 year old when they both get a year older - is 17 and 20 ok? Its not included on the table and it doesn't sound like it would be allowed from the wording. So they'd have to break up for a year before resuming their relationship whet they turn 18 and 21? That's not going to happen. Or you have a 'nearly 20 but still 19' year old going out with a 16 year old - once the 19 year old has a birthday, the relationship will be illegal until the younger partner turns 17 (or 18? Its not clear).

ETA its not unusual for 17 year olds to go to university in Scotland. The would potentially legally barred from dating some other students on the same Batchelors degree programme. Which seems utterly daft.

I don't think the age of consent is the answer. Some people are not going to be mature enough to make these decisions at 16 - and those same people may well not be at 18 either. We can't keep rolling it forward when as a society we have deemed that you can pretty much do everything once you're 18. It would be inconsistent to make sex the exception.

The social acceptance of way older men chasing young women needs to change. Putting the age of consent up a couple of years won't do that, they will either ignore it or look for very slightly older victims. Age is only one of may axes of vulnerability.

'Barely legal' porn has a lot to answer for.

Edited

This is my feeling. It won't actually do anything to stop predators. And I don't think will do much to secure more convictions.

There are already laws that cover many of these situations.

And it makes for some odd complications the way it's being discussed.

But mainly, I tend to think if 16 years is really too young to consent, it is too young to consent to sex at all. Users don't suddenly appear at age 30.

I'm also concerned about the continued pushing up of childhood.

TempestTost · 16/11/2026 02:59

EntirelyUnnecessary · 16/11/2026 00:14

Seems a bit overcomplicated tbh. It would be easier to say that eg it is illegal for someone over 25 to sleep with someone under 18.

So a couple would be ok till the older has a birthday?

I think maybe it would be simpler to say, under 20, no more than 2 or 3 years age difference.

Justme56 · 16/11/2026 03:18

Relationships are complex. My mum was 17 when she met my dad who was 23. They married when she was 18. They have been married for 66 years. They were in love then and still are. My mum was working and was well aware what she wanted from a relationship. It’s just not that simple.

NibliaBiblia · 16/11/2026 06:53

I'm from the States, so to me it's crazy that it's legal for an adult to have sex with a 16yo child. Pretty much everywhere it's 18 with an exception of the age gap is small. I think there are some states that still have a lower age of consent or allow underage marriage with parental consent, unfortunately.

PeppercornMill · 16/11/2026 06:55

Thinking about this further, it's lot more simpler to just raise the age of consent in it's entirety to 18.

This proposal is a mess from the off, and will only get more complicated when made into legislation.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/11/2026 07:21

TempestTost · 16/11/2026 02:59

So a couple would be ok till the older has a birthday?

I think maybe it would be simpler to say, under 20, no more than 2 or 3 years age difference.

Edited

I think the table in the OP has confused some people by missing the 17 and 20 case which by my understanding would be legal.

So a 16/19 pair could continue their relationship.

PeppercornMill · 16/11/2026 08:00

ErrolTheDragon · 16/11/2026 07:21

I think the table in the OP has confused some people by missing the 17 and 20 case which by my understanding would be legal.

So a 16/19 pair could continue their relationship.

No the 16/19 relationship is legal, 19 has birthday it then becomes a 16/20 illegal relationship and then becomes legal again on the 17th birthday.

nutmeg7 · 16/11/2026 08:10

ErrolTheDragon · 16/11/2026 07:21

I think the table in the OP has confused some people by missing the 17 and 20 case which by my understanding would be legal.

So a 16/19 pair could continue their relationship.

Agreed, the proposed rule (also included in the OP) is no more than 3 years difference in age.

It includes some examples, but it is not an exhaustive list.

17 to 20 is 3 years and therefore legal in this scenario, it just wasn’t listed.

1dayatatime · 16/11/2026 08:15

PeppercornMill · 16/11/2026 06:55

Thinking about this further, it's lot more simpler to just raise the age of consent in it's entirety to 18.

This proposal is a mess from the off, and will only get more complicated when made into legislation.

Exactly my thoughts- the idea is to prevent a power imbalance situation of say a 30 year old male having sex with a 16 year old girl.

But putting the proposal of a staggered age of consent will be nearly impossible legislatively and create a legal mess - reminds me of knee jerk legislation like the Dangerous Dogs Act.

ErrolTheDragon · 16/11/2026 08:57

Some of the countries which have ‘Romeo and Juliet’ laws seem to have more nuanced wording like ‘similar maturity’ - IDK how those work in practice.
As it is in the U.K., under 16s having sex with each other are technically breaking the law but won’t in practice be prosecuted, and the first to turn 16 won’t suddenly be criminalised. I’d imagine that the same sort of discretion in implementation would apply if staggered age was legislated.

Manteiga · 16/11/2026 09:58

Presumably it'd be three years to the day, so that sexual relationships couldn't bounce between legality and illegality. And presumably prosecutorial discretion would apply.

All the same, it might be better to campaign for more protection for 16 to 17 year-olds leaving the legal details to be determined.

MagpiePi · 16/11/2026 10:11

AstonCanKissMyArse · 15/11/2026 23:02

Is there a TL:DR?

I'm interested but not enough to wade through all the references.

I've been thinking about this a lot. I don't think complicating age of consent rules is helpful. We already have laws about coercion and about positions of authority (a school teacher or youth leader can't date a 6th former).

I don't think you can put conditions on ability to consent. Either you are old enough, or you aren't. All age cut offs in law have this element of sometimes allowing through those they should protect, or conversely prohibiting something that would likely be OK.

20 seems really arbitrary. And what happens to the 16 and 19 year old when they both get a year older - is 17 and 20 ok? Its not included on the table and it doesn't sound like it would be allowed from the wording. So they'd have to break up for a year before resuming their relationship whet they turn 18 and 21? That's not going to happen. Or you have a 'nearly 20 but still 19' year old going out with a 16 year old - once the 19 year old has a birthday, the relationship will be illegal until the younger partner turns 17 (or 18? Its not clear).

ETA its not unusual for 17 year olds to go to university in Scotland. The would potentially legally barred from dating some other students on the same Batchelors degree programme. Which seems utterly daft.

I don't think the age of consent is the answer. Some people are not going to be mature enough to make these decisions at 16 - and those same people may well not be at 18 either. We can't keep rolling it forward when as a society we have deemed that you can pretty much do everything once you're 18. It would be inconsistent to make sex the exception.

The social acceptance of way older men chasing young women needs to change. Putting the age of consent up a couple of years won't do that, they will either ignore it or look for very slightly older victims. Age is only one of may axes of vulnerability.

'Barely legal' porn has a lot to answer for.

Edited

Can you do a TLDR?
🤣

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:16

PeppercornMill · 15/11/2026 23:18

Saw the charts on this and it was clear that there are periods in the relationships between 16 and 19 years where the relationships moves into and out of criminality.

But hey, much easier to start a campaign for yet another law change, instead of anyone at the BBC, Channel 4, ITV, MTV actually putting a stop to the activity of their stars in their studios.

I remember all the stories of people being tasked with finding children for Jimmy Savile and standing guard outside his caravan. Yet no one was held accountable.

This campaign has been long on a lot longer than the Russel brand trail they are just getting more public attention now

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:21

At the moment, a forty five year old man can take a school girl by the hand, lead her to his car or home and have sex with her - she may have been too scared to say no and went along with it or he may have not listened or coerced her or held her down. At the moment, he has the argument that the child consented, with the proposed law the child wouldn’t have to go through a horrible trial to prove she didn’t which would traumatize her. If she did genuinely want to do this (unlikely!) then she’s not likely to report him to the police so wouldn’t be an issue.

it would also help for example the parents or foster parents of the children being targeted by grooming gangs to have those men arrested as the children might think they’re in love with their traffickers and woudnt report themselves.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:22

When speaking with girls with mental health issues /autism they often tell me they are targeted by adult men who want to meet up with them and sometimes do when promised presents or lifts of friendship, then the men try to have swx with them and sometimes do- at the moment this is perfectly legal.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:23

Huckleberries · 15/11/2026 23:29

I nearly married my first boyfriend (and I should have that too late to regret it now)

We met when I was 17 and he was 21. Don’t other countries have something like this, but with more flexibility on ages? I don’t actually know.

if he was a really good guy and wanted to abide by the law surely he would wait to have sex until you are 18?

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:26

I remember there was a yuck student at my uni who was 21 and somehow managed to meet 16 year olds from the local comp and bring them back to halls for sex, we found this revolting (especially as they didn’t seem like mature or confident girls, probably vulnerable ones) but we couldn’t report or do anything about it at the time. With the new law, we could report him to the police or uni officials.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 16/11/2026 10:26

Theskyisblue2026 · 15/11/2026 23:24

As someone that was groomed by a 40 year old man, a man that deliberately waited for me to be ‘legal, aged 16, I support this. Had I been protected by the law, my life would’ve had a completely different outcome.

So sorry this happened to you, I hope you can find some healing and peace.

Swipe left for the next trending thread