Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How physical space works, and gender beliefs

12 replies

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 09:17

It is me speculating, but I am starting to wonder whether having radical beliefs around gender, that obviously ignore the physical reality of female and male, leak through to other areas, where ability to judge oneself in relation to the physical world, is paramount.

Does it lead to a kind of 'magical thinking' that just doesn't get the immanence of physical realities or limitations ?

And the imminence of danger if you don't take account that immancence?

Ships that plough into bridges or ferries, and don't seem able to change course?

Baltimore was the major example, but we saw similar on the Mississippi yesterday.

Air forces, where expensive planes keep falling out of the air.

Railways where high speed trains keep crashing into each other?

OP posts:
Lovelyview · 15/11/2026 09:47

My immediate reaction was that the Titanic hit an iceberg before gender woo became a thing. But then I thought that the type of magical thinking in which declaring a ship unsinkable led those in charge to believe it was unsinkable is an example of very similar thought processes. Similar to a man declaring he is a woman now and expecting the world to rearrange itself around this ridiculous belief. Belief is a central part of human thinking but can lead us down some very dark paths.

ArabellaScott · 15/11/2026 10:01

I'd say it's more chicken and egg.

Dearth of critical thinking abilities, tribalism, silos, lack of contact with reality.

Perenelle · 15/11/2026 10:08

There is an example in pain therapy, maybe a little bit different but related to your question:

There was a guy working on a building site. He jumped of a wall and landed with his foot on a construction nail which went through and out the top of his shoe. He was in extreme pain, screaming and rushed to a hospital, given pain medication then they could pry his shoe off - to discover that the nail went clean between his toes, he didn't even have a scratch.

Our brains have the ability to create sensations so strongly we may believe them to be reality. The trick is to notice when they are not.

Indulging in feelings and sensations without regard for objective reality is not sensible, neither for the construction guy nor for gender identity or any other belief.

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 10:14

Does not believing in biological sex also mean people stop believing in gravity and the laws of motion? Literally erasing Newton and his observations because he was a white cis man?

Nothing would surprise me about people that fall for this nonsense to be honest.

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 15/11/2026 10:24

I sometimes ponder the queering of left and right, after all, as a left handed person I have been oppressed dontcha know. The world is arranged for right handed people so why shouldn't I be able to redefine my dominant side as the right hand side?
I should have the right to drive on the other side of the road to validate my identity, oh no hang on, nobody is going to do that because THEY WOULD ALL DIE!

Helleofabore · 15/11/2026 10:50

I find it very frustrating that there are so many people who believe their subjective belief about gender identity should be treated as if it is material reality because what seems to amount to philosophical theories.

And that so many other people go along with it all because they think that those using those theories to defend male people being described as female know what they are talking about. Or that they feel righteous because they have believed the arguments about how vulnerable those people with transgender identities are so therefore society must go along with their demands.

How many female people feel they would consent to male people being included in female single sex provisions if enough surgery was done? It seems narrow visioned to me. Because removing someone’s body parts don’t make them less male. Yet it seems either a reward for undergoing the surgery or it is some short sighted position that the only reason a male person is excluded is because they have a penis.

The inconsistencies just mount up.

Of course, there are also those people who have decided that in this situation a meet in the middle position is possible. How the fuck do you meet in the middle when one position has material reality underlining their arguments and the other position has no material reality supporting their arguments? It is like they believe that some material reality should be denied for what they perceive as the greater good ? (Or their own comfortable position maybe)

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 12:15

Shedmistress · 15/11/2026 10:14

Does not believing in biological sex also mean people stop believing in gravity and the laws of motion? Literally erasing Newton and his observations because he was a white cis man?

Nothing would surprise me about people that fall for this nonsense to be honest.

That's what I wonder.

They wouldn't spell it out that way, of course.

But the thing is, if you have the capacity to start to ignore something so obvious, what else can you convince yourself isn't real / doesn't matter ?

OP posts:
cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 12:18

>>Of course, there are also those people who have decided that in this situation a meet in the middle position is possible

I don't know whether that is lazy or just disingenuous.

Disingenuous, I think. Has to be.

Since it takes only a second's thought to realise that no such scenario can be plausibly constructed in one's head.

OP posts:
UtopiaPlanitia · 15/11/2026 21:29

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 09:17

It is me speculating, but I am starting to wonder whether having radical beliefs around gender, that obviously ignore the physical reality of female and male, leak through to other areas, where ability to judge oneself in relation to the physical world, is paramount.

Does it lead to a kind of 'magical thinking' that just doesn't get the immanence of physical realities or limitations ?

And the imminence of danger if you don't take account that immancence?

Ships that plough into bridges or ferries, and don't seem able to change course?

Baltimore was the major example, but we saw similar on the Mississippi yesterday.

Air forces, where expensive planes keep falling out of the air.

Railways where high speed trains keep crashing into each other?

I mean, we have an activist group called Queers for Palestine - if that's failing to assess reality and potential danger then I don't know what is.

IwantToRetire · 15/11/2026 21:30

Sorry OP, it isn't about "magical" beliefs IMO.

It is about male arrogance.

There assumption that what they want, and their ability to do it is always going to be right.

Many of the example you gave were the results or either bad design, failure to maintain equipment, or just as likely a male confidence that what they have done is totally and utterly reliable and so cant fail.

I suspect many women who spend their time tiding up after men, or in the traditional role of secretary or PA to some hot shot capitalist, know only too well that women have to deal with the little issues.

It isn't magical thinking that Ukraine cant at the moment defend itself from drones, it because arch male bull shitter Musk is deciding when and if Ukraine can access the internet.

Or trump starting or saying he will stop wars. Although these men are at the extreme of male arrogance, it is the assumption that because they belief something others should.

TRAs might not be quite at the extreme of not having any social conscience in relation to how damaging their actions and beliefs are to others, but as many on FWR and the feminist groups that are actually activists and doing something about this male pattern behaviour know only too well the harm it is causing - and the infringement on women's sex based rights.

In all honesty I dont understand this recent obsession with having threads about TRAs on FWR.

Who cares what they think or their rationale is?

FWR is for those who believe in women's sex based rights to have a forum where we can discuss how to fight back against the inroads TRAs (as just another branch of MRAs) have made on women's rights.

(edited to correct typos)

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 21:53

>>It isn't magical thinking that Ukraine cant at the moment defend itself from >>drones, it because arch male bull shitter Musk is deciding when and if >>Ukraine can access the internet.

The idea that Ukraine can beat Russia certainly falls into the category of magical thinking, however.

While primarily a male view, a number of women in senior EU roles seem to hold to this particular magical perspective too.

OP posts:
ChequerToRed · 16/11/2026 14:30

These sorts of things commonly don’t exist on their own, the average loudly ‘progressive’ TRA will have a whole raft of other things they consider righteous as well. What I noticed when such people are interviewed is that they are shockingly low information, will pretzel themselves to defend their beliefs in the face of ugly realities or worse get aggressive, and can easy be led by the nose to say things in support of the genuinely awful.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page