Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The ick is so important. Our instincts are good. Part 2 What gives you the ick?

52 replies

KenwoodMagicWand · 13/11/2026 08:36

Part 1 was deleted because it isn’t alright for us to talk about what gives us the ick. I know why this thread was deleted, and it’s fascinating that we’re not really allowed to talk about it. Well we can if it’s Russell Brand, or David Walliams, or men who are obsessed with sex, or comedians making sex jokes, but there is a line and there are certain things we are not allowed to get the ick about.

Things that give me the ick:
men who are obsessed by sex
comedians, men and women, making sexually explicit jokes
most meat
men wearing make-up
jellied eels
People watching porn

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 08:15

dracn · 13/11/2026 23:32

The “ick” is something entirely frivolous and superficial which suddenly kicks in and puts us off someone we like for reasons that would be cruel to be honest about.

That’s not the same as listening to our instincts and making clear boundaries when there is a rationality to our feelings.

Things like surrogacy, men pretending to be women, political allegiances etc are serious issues that we may or may not have strong views on and which show the values of that person. These things aren’t “the ick”, they are simply disagreements or incompatibility.

The ick is things like how someone’s hair sticks up in the wind, or how they hold their knife and fork, or how their voice sounds when they’re congested. Things that you can’t mention without sounding like a playground bully but which you can’t easily shake off.

I think the point is that an 'ick' may not be or appear rational. Its about women trusting their gut and instincts.

Political stuff is thought and rationality and assessment. Ick is not always explicable at all.

I suppose the crux here is 'prejudice'.

Women recoiling or feeling unsettled or wary is often instinctive.

It may be informed by prejudice, which can encompass feelings or beliefs that are considered forbidden. And it overlaps with pattern recognition.

How many times are women called hysterical or prudish or bigoted for raising concerns about a man?

Wishihadanalgorithm · 14/11/2026 08:27

There’s a man who is a step parent of a girl i have taught. He really gives me the ick. He’s slimy and fake. I think insincere might be a better word.

Anyway, a friend works with him in a different school and she has reported him for real safeguarding issues but nothing has come of it.

I have only spoken to him briefly twice and I felt grubby afterwards, each time. That’s the ick, isn’t it?

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 08:35

Jacobolordy · 13/11/2026 19:00

Some of these lists are strange. 'Ick' seems to be being used in a whole range of ways which is confusing.

Men who keep pushing boundaries after a no are definitely problematic, not just an 'ick'

Something like surrogacy is an ethical issue for logical consideration - seems strange to lump it in with a glass of milk or hair that smells bad.

I completely agree that sometimes we might pick up on something that tells us not to trust someone - humans have evolved to try to avoid danger - but I would call this gut instinct rather than the ick.

Question what you might be picking up on sure if you feel 'vibes' from someone sure, but also be aware that sometimes the ick might be based on prejudice to others who are different from us eg different race, visible difference/ disfigurement, disability etc.

Yes that last paragraph is what I was talking about.

I do wonder if 'ick' is the right term, OP? When I've seen it used on here its generally in the context of someone a woman has previously been attached/attracted to.

I had a partner who took off a necklace he'd always worn, and I got the ick. For example.

Maybe needs a bit of parsing.

In respect of the last para and what I was referring to - its chastising or judging women for 'being prejudiced' that is potentially risky.

Women have to risk assess constantly and a big part of that is pattern recognition, which is by definition prejudice.

And the boundaries between what is considered acceptable (having preferences for, say, people one is attracted to), and what is considere morally wrong (discrimination), can get blurred.

This creates a vulnerability that abusers can, will, and do, exploit.

Women get shamed or chastised for being prudish or uptight or unfair or judgy. And sometimes it might be justified, but the problem is that the shaming and chastising can lead women to doubt and second guess their own instincts.

Women and girls need.to be taught to listen to their instincts, trust themselves, and maintain boundaries. They need to know they can say 'no'. Social conditioning can make that hard for women and girls, who are subject to a lot of pressure to 'be kind' and 'fair' and obliging and acquiescent.

This shouldn't mean prioritising others over oneself.

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 08:40

In the past I've had subtle slight bells ringing around very charming and friendly and nice men. Only after a lifetime of learning have I got to the point I dont really chastise or question myself so much anymore, and just take extra steps to feel safe, look out for a kid, not be alone or leave my DD alone with a certain man, etc.

Unfortunately my vague odd unease has often proved to be justified.

I wouldn't call that ick though. Just ... wariness. And sometimes shows up as being flustered and angry by turn. Watching Russell Brand clips over the past week and seeing the responses of women to his behaviour - often flustered, confused, voicing it and looking uncomfortable above all has been interesting, if quite disturbing.

SkyBlueTopper · 14/11/2026 08:44

I'm agreeing that this is a strange thread with an important message that may be getting lost.
Being creeped out is different from feeling an ick.
An ick can be trivial things that usually fall into 2 camps either hygiene related or slightly petty, irrational personal preference (disliking men who sing in the shower, who walk a small dog, who makes Dad jokes, who havent moved out of their home town, who eat soup for breakfast), collecting Pokemon, being into football, or golf or model airplanes). This is all fine to dislike but doesn't inherently mean they are dangerous, bad men just that they are not your cup of tea usually romantically. That's fine that's personal choice. Sometimes people are far too fussy about this sort of thing and it means they can lose out on really good potential relationships or friendships. A few of my friends are like this and then wonder why they never have nice romantic relationships and sometimes it is because they turned down about a decent man or woman for a spurious reason.

Some of these are red flag behaviour (sensing David Walliams, Brand, Saville, the bloke at work who stares a bit too long, your mum's new fella. Etc are creepy or off is a innate feeling that must be listened to. Sadly, some people have terrible spidy sense about this sort of thing, because being around these sorts of men was normalised when they were in their informative years.

Lastly, because of this board some of these are people pointing out some of the ways some men have used the trans movement for sexual gratification and getting into women's spaces. Again not an ick but a red flag.

Floristian · 14/11/2026 09:02

It's an interesting subject, the important ick rather than just things that make you go eurgh.

There's a man in our small town who makes my flesh creep. He's pleasant, friendly, but I cannot bear him. He kisses my cheek (normal here) and I recoil. We were out with a friend last week and he asked to sit with us to drink his coffee; there was nowhere else to sit so a reasonable request. When he left, the friend was visibly relieved. It turns out she feels exactly the same. I was telling another female friend about this and she gets the same feeling.

So three of us have independently picked up something, yet there's nothing really obvious. Interestingly though, one friend says when he kisses her, his hands rest on her a shoulder a second too long.

Verisregina · 14/11/2026 09:15

@ArabellaScott Thank you! I’ve just been trying and failing to find words to frame that sentiment or something like it.

I found it useful to think about it in Peter Parker terms - how would it work if we used the phrase Spidey Senses?

That idea of a heightened sense of caution/ wariness that alerts us to danger? Or intuition that warns us that something is ‘off’, whether it’s the physicality of someone in a space you wouldn’t expect them, or the sense that someone has less than benign intentions towards you?

The ick to me, is superficial - I don’t like facial piercings, or band t-shirts on people who weren’t even born when that band was performing, but that’s irrelevant to anyone but me, and I quash that feeling down.

I also get the social conditioning aspect, especially for women. We might feel our spidey senses tingle, but we don’t want to cause offence, disrupt ongoings or upset group cohesion so we are either forced to quash the Spidey senses or somehow act upon them inconspicuously without drawing attention to them. And when we do that, we run the risk of not fully protecting ourselves, or alerting others to the danger. Does that make sense?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 09:23

ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 08:40

In the past I've had subtle slight bells ringing around very charming and friendly and nice men. Only after a lifetime of learning have I got to the point I dont really chastise or question myself so much anymore, and just take extra steps to feel safe, look out for a kid, not be alone or leave my DD alone with a certain man, etc.

Unfortunately my vague odd unease has often proved to be justified.

I wouldn't call that ick though. Just ... wariness. And sometimes shows up as being flustered and angry by turn. Watching Russell Brand clips over the past week and seeing the responses of women to his behaviour - often flustered, confused, voicing it and looking uncomfortable above all has been interesting, if quite disturbing.

Yes. Watching Vanessa Feltz getting increasingly unsettled and stern while Brand "joked" about sex with her daughters. She obviously felt she couldn't call him out for being a predator yet her body language changed significantly. The Brand Walliams stuff does show how dangerous it has been to society to continually push boundaries until even the most unacceptable issues (paedophilia, rape etc) become jokes. The focus of humour. Supposedly light hearted.

Women need to feel more confident in displaying disapproval - especially when it involves those targeting the young. Is that letting our ick show or something else?

Goldengirl123 · 14/11/2026 09:23

People who say ick

KenwoodMagicWand · 14/11/2026 09:25

dracn · 13/11/2026 23:32

The “ick” is something entirely frivolous and superficial which suddenly kicks in and puts us off someone we like for reasons that would be cruel to be honest about.

That’s not the same as listening to our instincts and making clear boundaries when there is a rationality to our feelings.

Things like surrogacy, men pretending to be women, political allegiances etc are serious issues that we may or may not have strong views on and which show the values of that person. These things aren’t “the ick”, they are simply disagreements or incompatibility.

The ick is things like how someone’s hair sticks up in the wind, or how they hold their knife and fork, or how their voice sounds when they’re congested. Things that you can’t mention without sounding like a playground bully but which you can’t easily shake off.

I know you’re right in some ways, but I maintain that whilst the ick is about disgust, often in a frivolous or superficial way (dirty hair, milk, slugs) it can also evoke a sense of disgust in a way which is important for our safety, and we should listen to it.
i think David Walliams is icky, I’ve always found him uncomfortable, ditto Brand. The reasons are obvious.
Maybe your point about something like surrogacy is good, it’s of course a very important issue and rational arguments explain why it’s awful. However, it is also gross. The idea of renting a woman’s body, buying a baby… having such little regard for humans. It does evoke the ick in me. Ditto a man paying for sex. Not the same but also gross.
I know the ick can be silly but we should also listen to it.
I was at the pond and a man in a Betty boop mini skirt came and sat in the changing meadow exposing his testicle and his bikini bottoms . He was wearing sunglasses whilst women and girls unwittingly changed around him. This is a serious transgression but it’s also gross and I got the major ick from him.

OP posts:
ArabellaScott · 14/11/2026 09:33

It may just be that we are unclear on the definitions of what is a bit of a vague term!

Disgust/distaste/repulsion is one thing. Wariness and being unsettled is another.

KenwoodMagicWand · 14/11/2026 10:18

Yes, I think ick refers to a disgust response. Often sexual or physical. I think getting the ick isn’t the same but often happens as well as feeling unsettled, wary or frightened. Ick isn’t a rational argument.
Louise Perry talks about the ick a lot. Often in relation to porn.

OP posts:
overhare · 14/11/2026 11:10

EmpressDomesticatednottamed · 13/11/2026 19:17

Men trying to mimic womens voices, I've heard some very strange and creepy sounding ones.
(That's excluding an actual performance that requires it, but then those men don't sound creepy, even when singing as a roasting swan)

Me nunc propinat dapifer!

Men who stand too close me.
Any man who makes my dogs edgy (ever since our old boy barked like blazes when I started walking along with a local bloke who I later found was a noted sex pest).
Porn.

Perenelle · 14/11/2026 12:14

Drag queen reading hour for kids
Parents who cart their kids to pride parade to wave at the furries

🙊

I mean, everyone please live out their kinks in private with a consenting adult. I am not sure if parents are aware of the sexual connotation? The kids surely look uncomfortable.

KenwoodMagicWand · 14/11/2026 13:06

Kinks. Always ick. Exactly @overharejust do it in private. It’s gross.

OP posts:
Mapletree1985 · 14/11/2026 15:25

Fake nails, acrylic nails. The more elaborate the nail art, the worse the ick.

It's not a sexual unattractiveness ick, just a "don't touch me with those things" ick.

alteredimage · 14/11/2026 15:27

A swim coach at my daughter’s swim club. It was just something about the way he looked at some of the young swimmers. Then by chance I discovered he was a friend of a couple of acquaintances, unconnected with the club. All single and slightly odd men in their fifties.

Nothing to go on except the ick, but luckily the sports development man at the local council seemed to have similar antennae and explained the framework of safeguarding (Sport England Clubmark/ASA Swim 21.) To help he offered to make gaining those credentials a requirement for the Club to use Council facilities. The coach was popular and rallied support against me, but the Council’s threat meant the Committee had to support my quest for accreditation.

Rather than pass over paperwork the coach quit. A few stories came out later which, had we known, would have caused him to lose his job and which explained why he quit rather than submit paperwork. But luckily nothing related to my original ick. I never shared my concern with other parents, so as far as I know I was the only one.

GreenEyesMillennial · 14/11/2026 15:36

Men who burp or fart loudly, pretend they can’t hold a fart.
Disgusting!!!!

ChequerToRed · 14/11/2026 16:56

Slugs
Ticks
Richard Tice and his big, arrogant gob
Very performatively ‘progressive’ men because I always suspect it’s a mask for being an utter shitbag. I’m rarely wrong on that, either.

TempestTost · 15/11/2026 02:10

I don't think this thread is really saying what you want it to, op.

Like, we are supposed to trust our ick feelings about men in bad lipstick, but they're the same ick feelings we get about a beard or a glass of milk. Which are not actually things to worry about even if we don't like them?

It seems to me the logical conclusion would be that feeling the ick isn't a reliable indicator of anything.

thirdfiddle · 15/11/2026 13:11

TempestTost · 15/11/2026 02:10

I don't think this thread is really saying what you want it to, op.

Like, we are supposed to trust our ick feelings about men in bad lipstick, but they're the same ick feelings we get about a beard or a glass of milk. Which are not actually things to worry about even if we don't like them?

It seems to me the logical conclusion would be that feeling the ick isn't a reliable indicator of anything.

Edited

Maybe rather than trusting the instinctive aversion completely we should trust it as a cue to look deeper.

TempestTost · 15/11/2026 22:03

thirdfiddle · 15/11/2026 13:11

Maybe rather than trusting the instinctive aversion completely we should trust it as a cue to look deeper.

Sure.

localnotail · 15/11/2026 22:12

"Tough" looking guys with beards who look like fashioned models
Men in tight clothing, especially chunky meaty guys with big bums in tight jeans
Any men trying to explain to me how women should act/ behave
Any woman who is saying "I wish there was no feminism"

MrsOvertonsWindow · 15/11/2026 23:05

alteredimage · 14/11/2026 15:27

A swim coach at my daughter’s swim club. It was just something about the way he looked at some of the young swimmers. Then by chance I discovered he was a friend of a couple of acquaintances, unconnected with the club. All single and slightly odd men in their fifties.

Nothing to go on except the ick, but luckily the sports development man at the local council seemed to have similar antennae and explained the framework of safeguarding (Sport England Clubmark/ASA Swim 21.) To help he offered to make gaining those credentials a requirement for the Club to use Council facilities. The coach was popular and rallied support against me, but the Council’s threat meant the Committee had to support my quest for accreditation.

Rather than pass over paperwork the coach quit. A few stories came out later which, had we known, would have caused him to lose his job and which explained why he quit rather than submit paperwork. But luckily nothing related to my original ick. I never shared my concern with other parents, so as far as I know I was the only one.

Well done you. That's incredibly important.
Coaching used to be a magnet for perverted men to access children - especially swimming which has had some dreadful cases both at elite and non elite levels. The majority of sporting bodies have cracked down dramatically over the years but the power dynamics etc still mean parents have to be vigilant (while trying not to be paranoid).

Bobbymoore123 · 17/11/2026 07:13

People who don't wash their sheets
Low cut tops
Rising hemlines
Bear traps

Swipe left for the next trending thread