Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Newsnight whistleblowers for the Tavistock scandal but silence ever since

5 replies

JustTiredOfAllOfThis · 12/11/2026 10:27

I do like to watch Newsnight but I’m increasingly fed up with the lack of coverage on a topic on which they were whistle blowers. They love to keep updating viewers on :
Post Office Scandal victims
Nuclear Test Veterans
Epstein Victims (most of whom are American women)
Victims of rape gangs.
Scandals in maternity care.

But they haven’t followed up with the Tavistock.
There are various topics connected to this that they could've and should’ve covered but they don’t.
There are Detransitioners
Theres the controversy of the puberty blocker trial.
And now we have the much criticised Conversion Practices Bill. None have been covered by Newsnight.
Maybe I’m the only person still watching it but it’s become glaringly obvious that the editors of the show believe it’s absolutely fine to forget the topic now that Deb Cohen and Hannah Barnes have left.
Anyone else find it an astonishing oversight/ deliberate avoidance?

OP posts:
BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 12/11/2026 12:00

Astonishing oversight? No, it's the BBC.
Deliberate avoidance? Yes, it's the BBC.

Am I fed up? Yes and no. I don't watch TV anymore and I refuse to fund the BBC. I am, however, frustrated that a publicly-funded state broadcaster is allowed to ignore issues and be economical with the truth. If they'd been reporting the truth these past 10 years, the public wouldn't still be mainly in the dark about Tavistock and transactivism in general.

Am I surprised that if Newsnight haven't followed up on Tavistock? Not in the slightest.

ed. clarification

JustTiredOfAllOfThis · 12/11/2026 18:08

BridgetYourFortyDaysAreUp · 12/11/2026 12:00

Astonishing oversight? No, it's the BBC.
Deliberate avoidance? Yes, it's the BBC.

Am I fed up? Yes and no. I don't watch TV anymore and I refuse to fund the BBC. I am, however, frustrated that a publicly-funded state broadcaster is allowed to ignore issues and be economical with the truth. If they'd been reporting the truth these past 10 years, the public wouldn't still be mainly in the dark about Tavistock and transactivism in general.

Am I surprised that if Newsnight haven't followed up on Tavistock? Not in the slightest.

ed. clarification

Edited

Yeah I understand your feelings.
I thought it was interesting how they went on about “Data Centres” being a really important topic in the American Mid Term Elections. No mention of the real “kitchen table” topic of boys being allowed in girls sports. Several States had it on their ballots and and won protection for women’s sports! And the Democratic candidate in Texas only won by declaring on new channels that he supported sex based sports. Of course there was no mention on the BBC. Just “Data Centres” and the price of groceries. People voted to save women’s sports and it didn’t get a mention…

OP posts:
alcovecupboards · 12/11/2026 18:20

Was this the thousand families who were preparing to sue? They've done a great job of hiding themselves, haven't they? Where are they? Have you considered that a handful of clearly unwell individuals (conspiracy theorists, racists, nutters etc) aren't exactly prime candidates to talk about how actually it's trans people and doctors who are the evil ones?

JustTiredOfAllOfThis · 12/11/2026 19:04

I don’t recognise your characterisation of people who don’t believe in gender ideology and ‘wrong body’ ideology. It not my experience of any other families I know.
Some detransitioners have tried to take gender practioners to court. Settlements are usually confidential. Some haven’t been successful or couldn’t afford to take the costly risk. Certainly the private insurance industry is pulling back from offering “gender affirming care”. A BUPA hospital will stop surgeries from 30th November.
The GMC doesn’t provide figures on the number of cases they have handled. We’re only just beginning to see the fallout from “gender affirming care”. 3 years ago we were told there are no detransitioners; that is not the case now.

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · 12/11/2026 20:18

Hi OP - admit I gave up watching newsnight some time ago, but had a vague memory of follow up. So asked AI as my brain in totally unindexed and unsearchable! So according to AI:

BBC Newsnight aired multiple follow-up reports and films over several years investigating the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) at the Tavistock and Portman NHS Foundation Trust. Led primarily by investigative producer Hannah Barnes and reporter Deborah Cohen, the coverage evolved from an initial whistleblower report in 2019 into an ongoing series that ultimately contributed to the independent Cass Review and the clinic's closure. 1, 2, 3, 4]

Timeline of Newsnight Follow-Up Reports

  • Initial Investigation (July 2019): Newsnight broke the story regarding concerns over an unpublished early intervention study on puberty blockers. Early data obtained by the programme indicated that some young patients reported an increase in thoughts of suicide and self-harm. 1, 2]
  • Leaked Staff Transcripts (June 2020): In a major follow-up report, Newsnight obtained transcripts from an internal 2019 review. The documents revealed that clinicians felt safeguarding and welfare concerns were "shut down" and that vulnerable children were being referred onto a medical transitioning pathway too quickly. 1, 2]
  • Historical Review Obtained via FOI (October 2020): Following a Freedom of Information appeal, Newsnight aired a segment exposing a suppressed 2005 internal report by former medical director Dr. David Taylor. It showed that identical concerns about rushed assessments and a lack of long-term patient follow-up had been raised and ignored 15 years earlier. 1]
  • Reform Pushback Investigation (May 2023): After NHS England announced GIDS would close and be replaced by regional hubs, Newsnight broadcast an investigation featuring leaked audio of a senior GIDS clinical lead questioning the need for the reforms recommended by Dr. Hilary Cass. 1, 2]
  • Puberty Blocker Data Analysis (October 2023): In a special episode hosted by Kirsty Wark, the programme examined fresh analysis of the clinic's puberty blocker data and tracked delays in opening the new regional NHS youth gender services. 1, 2]

Expanded Coverage Beyond Television
Because the investigation uncovered more evidence than could fit into television broadcast slots, Hannah Barnes expanded the Newsnight reporting into other formats: 1, 2]

  • BBC Radio Documentary: Barnes produced an accompanying radio documentary exploring the testimonies of former patients and clinicians.
  • Investigative Book: In February 2023, Barnes published Time to Think: The Inside Story of the Collapse of the Tavistock's Gender Service for Children, which compiled over 100 hours of interviews and thousands of documents gathered during her years on the Newsnight investigation. 1, 2, 3]

----------
Not saying it is good enough, or consistent, but newsnight (IMO) stopped being about in depth news and just another media personality platform. And in fact an issue like this shouldn't be tucked away on late night tv. It should be part of news coverage. Not sure that any tv news have ever mentioned anything about conversion for instance!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread