Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

841 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 14:29

Biological sex is no more 'believed in' than it is 'assigned'.

It is just observed.

It's nonetheless a characteristic of the cultist or religionist that they understand the world in terms of belief, I guess.

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 14:35

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 13:58

yes, but the commenter was implying that the White Australia Policy was regressive and was part of being pro the existing hierarchies, class structures and pro-prudery.

the WAP most certainly was not. it was seen as very progressive and as the foundation for making australia a country for the white working man who would rise up to challenge and beat off hierarchies, class, snobbery and prudery

trying to read AU through leftish UK spectacles doesn't work

Edited

The White Australia Policy was racist. Defending it is like pretending the Jim Crow Laws were about protecting white women.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 15/11/2026 15:26

the WAP most certainly was not. it was seen as very progressive and as the foundation for making australia a country for the white working man

Isn't that apartheid by another name? progressive it wasn't.

Immediately following Federation in 1901, policies were designed to keep Australia white and British. Non-racial language was used to minimise international condemnation, but the xenophobic concern was plainly evident. Australia’s first prime minister, Edmund Barton, explicitly stated his belief in white superiority:
There is no racial equality. There is that basic inequality. These races are, in comparison with white races – I think no-one wants convincing of this fact – unequal and inferior.

https://cass.anu.edu.au/news/australian-politics-explainer-white-australia-policy

trying to read AU through leftish UK spectacles doesn't work

Is that me? I've never been called 'leftish' before.

inkymoose · 15/11/2026 16:19

@MarcTheGenderSkeptic "Recently I've done a 180 on the most prominent leader of our age."

Could you tell me who this is?

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 15/11/2026 16:33

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 09:51

And what we see today is the same rationale deployed. A recent example :

"As a biological woman, you should check yourself as you have the privilege of menstruating, a privilege that trans women don't have."

Edited

Only a man could think that painful bleeding with cramps strong enough to make adult women pass out was a "privilege".

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 16:36

I've been enjoying the privilege of a tooth abscess, a privilege that ducks don't have.

Poor toothless ducks, deprived by mother nature.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 17:35

inkymoose · 15/11/2026 16:19

@MarcTheGenderSkeptic "Recently I've done a 180 on the most prominent leader of our age."

Could you tell me who this is?

Of course I lay myself open to ridicule saying I didn't always used be a Trump naysayer.

UnaPersson · 15/11/2026 17:43

kitex · 15/11/2026 11:29

"As a biological woman, you should check yourself as you have the privilege of menstruating, a privilege that trans women don't have."

What the f**k!!

It's so extremely weird. 🙃

kitex · 15/11/2026 18:09

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 15/11/2026 16:33

Only a man could think that painful bleeding with cramps strong enough to make adult women pass out was a "privilege".

They have absolutely no clue! Passing blood clots is such a privilege!

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 15/11/2026 19:16

One slight problem I have with being a sex realist is that I notice how stark raving bonkers so much of what is said by so many gender ideologues is. What beats me is why apparently sensible/intelligent people I know do not also see how completely bananas these folk are.

Manyanamanyana · 15/11/2026 20:40

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2026 16:46

Australia is distinct from the UK as there's no long history of social hierarchies or class structure or victorian prudish mores. In other words its culture is very egalitarian & openness conscious so equality & anti discrimination are natural conclusions.

Must have imagined that White Australia policy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Australia_policy

Must have imagined the aboriginal children taken away from parents

https://australianstogether.org.au/discover-and-learn/our-history/stolen-generations

As for the Victorian social mores - to the horror of the TPTB, according to Robert Hughes, sodomy was rife among convicts, at least in the early years of the colony. There was also a prevailing attitude that women convicts, even if they were in long standing relationships (some of them years) with a man, were described as prostitutes - and you can't get a more Victorian attitude than 'if you're a woman, having sex and you're not married, you're a prostitute.'

Australia is so horrified at its history that it has swung to the opposite extreme - and is now so open minded its brains seem to have fallen out.

100%agree with this. An element of society so determined to make reparations for the past that they are vulnerable to any claims of bullying from any group.
Noting also that the State police forces were historically horrific to gay men and lesbians (state sactioned murder you could call it) and so the forced teaming of the T with the LGB has certainly been effective in scaring people from even considering what the difference between them is... trans are the most vulnerable etc).

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 20:53

Australians are wonderful.
They're God's own chosen race.
And if I ever hear
A pommy queer
I'll punch him in the face.

Monty Python from a long time ago.

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 20:58

And the previous verse:

Australia is wonderful.
It's full of bonza blokes.
Sheilas, beer and no-one's queer
Except in pommy jokes.

I dunno? Were they onto something?

cryupmykingdom · 15/11/2026 21:00

DeanElderberry · 15/11/2026 14:35

The White Australia Policy was racist. Defending it is like pretending the Jim Crow Laws were about protecting white women.

Come back when you've something useful to add and which hopefully doesn't reveal how ignorant you are.

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 21:03

Oh, and finally: any country that thinks 'cunt' is an appropriate epithet for a close friend and has replaced 'Bluey' with 'Ranga' as the nickname for a redhead because Bluey is racist, is a country that needs to give its moral compass a gentle tap.

Manyanamanyana · 15/11/2026 21:11

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 15/11/2026 16:33

Only a man could think that painful bleeding with cramps strong enough to make adult women pass out was a "privilege".

And thier handmaidens who nod along!

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:32

Catiette · 14/11/2026 10:32

This is remarkable given the history of Aboriginal rights and "the Stolen Generation".

No long history of... etc.

Its culture is...

Equality and anti-discrimination are natural conclusions.

And thanks to the poster referencing Gillard's misogyny speech - outstanding and horrifying in equal measure.

Is this you modelling the nuance we lack, Caprioska?

Tsk tsk tsk! So much 'derailing' & no scolding? 🤔

My quote specifically states "Australia has no long history" that's because its only just over 200 years old as compared to England's 1000 plus years. And given its such a short period its a remarkable turnaround in terms of class/social structures where as the UK still very much has a class structure that's firmly supported by its reverence to royalty, wealth & status. I never suggested was an Australia an egalitarian utopia btw but it certainly doesn't have as many of the 'constraints' to being closer to one that the UK has & has long had systems in place to rectify their colonial influences.

I strongly suspect its 'sex realist' culture is particularly exclusive to the UK because of hierarchical structures being so historically embedded in the British psyche.

Again nuance & historical education matters!

Manyanamanyana · 15/11/2026 21:38

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 21:03

Oh, and finally: any country that thinks 'cunt' is an appropriate epithet for a close friend and has replaced 'Bluey' with 'Ranga' as the nickname for a redhead because Bluey is racist, is a country that needs to give its moral compass a gentle tap.

#notallAussies
😎

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:52

Catiette · 14/11/2026 12:06

I find your language curious for someone who professes to model nuance:

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'

nor does it say anything about

are strikingly reductive generalisations, particularly given your own claim to focus on the individual, as below:

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

In addition to the logical flaws in your own post, above, you also seem to misapply the concept of a logical flaw to mine. My choice not to engage in more detailed exploration of "grading in sports" - preferring simply to focus on the primary differentiator of sex - isn't in any way inconsistent. I could quite happily go into the complementary issues of different age and weight categories, or distinguish between the amateur and the professional, as well. But none of that would be remotely logically incompatible with the reality that the average physical difference between males and females post-puberty (up to 150%) is an overwhelming justification for single-sex sports in a majority of contexts.

I really do find it fascinating to see where visitors here apply the paramountcy of the individual, and where they don't - and particularly to wonder if they're aware of how often they undermine their own argument within the very same post, or if they just don't care that they're doing this.

The unconscious irony would be comical if the consequences weren't so significant. The preservation of life and limb, and enabling the equal participation and competition of a full half of society in sport must always supersede individual need and "valuable psychological skills". Inclusion is what matters here.

Err I didn't use "all," "every," "always," or "never" to describe groups of people that flattens human individuality and curdles into prejudice or stereotypes so no generalisation 'sin' here as opposed to your doubling down on sex sorry, 'focus' to 'engage' on.

As I said upthread regarding 'zero sum' thinking, denial of existence (sorry 'focus') is the sex realist strategy. That's probably why the movement has shifted from 'gender critical' as a label because it can't be admitting a concept exists if that concept justifies the 'opponents' existence. And let's not forget being gender critical was justified by gender identity perpetuating sex stereotypes. In other words gender identity did exist under a gender critical conceptual lens.

Now think about what's actually being said here: 'If we pretend gender doesn't exist by strawmanning the actual claim then we delegitimise trans people as an identity'.

Seems the cookie monster analogy is relevant but not in the way the OP thinks.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 22:03

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:32

Tsk tsk tsk! So much 'derailing' & no scolding? 🤔

My quote specifically states "Australia has no long history" that's because its only just over 200 years old as compared to England's 1000 plus years. And given its such a short period its a remarkable turnaround in terms of class/social structures where as the UK still very much has a class structure that's firmly supported by its reverence to royalty, wealth & status. I never suggested was an Australia an egalitarian utopia btw but it certainly doesn't have as many of the 'constraints' to being closer to one that the UK has & has long had systems in place to rectify their colonial influences.

I strongly suspect its 'sex realist' culture is particularly exclusive to the UK because of hierarchical structures being so historically embedded in the British psyche.

Again nuance & historical education matters!

Edited

You're really lost in some fantasy world of conflating Empire and colonialism with this subject. France is also colonialist and ran an empire. Spain a very large one too. Belgium had it's territories. Yet all these nations are more on your TRA wavelength.
Of course you're not the first TRA with such lack of imagination, portraying biological sex as the delineator of women's ID and rights as consequence of Victorian values via Empire.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 15/11/2026 22:04

What a load of asinine flannel.

When someone is posting in good faith, even if they vehemently disagree with the person or people they are enagaging with, indeed especially if they vehemently disagree with the person or people they are enagaging with, they are scrupulous about making sure they properly represent the views they are about to take down. Because otherwise, far from showing up the "other side", they end up beclowning themselves by arguing passionately, in public, against something they have clearly totally misunderstood 🤡

When a poster is new, I assume it's just because no one has explained the basics yet. But when someone isn't new the only explanation is bad faith.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 15/11/2026 22:12

MarcTheGenderSkeptic
Of course you're not the first TRA with such lack of imagination, portraying biological sex as the delineator of women's ID and rights as consequence of Victorian values via Empire.

As opposed to those of us who have noticed the three hundred and fifteen thousand years or more of human existence on the planet during which (apart from the past say forty years or so) it seems generally to have been pretty clear who was male and who was female to everyone in every country or on every continent. This continues to be the case in spite of recent, valiant attempts by a very small minority to write a back-story in which it wasn't so; these attempts are very similar to the push last century to assert that every king or queen of England was either gay or lesbian, which push now seems to have fallen by the wayside a bit except when it's about the ones who quite obviously were, or at least were bi.

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:15

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 22:03

You're really lost in some fantasy world of conflating Empire and colonialism with this subject. France is also colonialist and ran an empire. Spain a very large one too. Belgium had it's territories. Yet all these nations are more on your TRA wavelength.
Of course you're not the first TRA with such lack of imagination, portraying biological sex as the delineator of women's ID and rights as consequence of Victorian values via Empire.

Yes but each country has its own set unique of variables that influence its present cultural standards & mitigate historical constraints. France & Spain like Australia operate as social democracies with stronger interventionist traditions for example larger public sectors and more generous welfare safety nets than the United Kingdom.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 15/11/2026 22:22

caprioska · 15/11/2026 22:15

Yes but each country has its own set unique of variables that influence its present cultural standards & mitigate historical constraints. France & Spain like Australia operate as social democracies with stronger interventionist traditions for example larger public sectors and more generous welfare safety nets than the United Kingdom.

Ah, these empires weren't totally fascist, they were a heart run by people's who became social democracies, Britain on the other hand is still stuck in the 19th century. And that's why we're TERF Island.
You really are grasping.

JanesLittleGirl · 15/11/2026 22:35

caprioska · 15/11/2026 21:52

Err I didn't use "all," "every," "always," or "never" to describe groups of people that flattens human individuality and curdles into prejudice or stereotypes so no generalisation 'sin' here as opposed to your doubling down on sex sorry, 'focus' to 'engage' on.

As I said upthread regarding 'zero sum' thinking, denial of existence (sorry 'focus') is the sex realist strategy. That's probably why the movement has shifted from 'gender critical' as a label because it can't be admitting a concept exists if that concept justifies the 'opponents' existence. And let's not forget being gender critical was justified by gender identity perpetuating sex stereotypes. In other words gender identity did exist under a gender critical conceptual lens.

Now think about what's actually being said here: 'If we pretend gender doesn't exist by strawmanning the actual claim then we delegitimise trans people as an identity'.

Seems the cookie monster analogy is relevant but not in the way the OP thinks.

That's probably why the movement has shifted from 'gender critical' as a label because it can't be admitting a concept exists if that concept justifies the 'opponents' existence. And lets not forget being gender critical was justified by gender identity perpetuating sex stereotypes. In other words gender identity did exist under a gender critical conceptual lens.

Oh boy! Tell me that you have no understanding of Gender Critical Radical Feminism without telling me that you have no understanding of Gender Critical Radical Feminism. I gave you a brief intro to GCRF upthread as a response to one of your previous posts. I don't know if you didn't read it, didn't like it or simply decided to ignore it but, at this point, I am struggling to regard you as a meaningful interlocutor.

GCRF is one of the main frameworks of Radical Feminism. Your misinterpretation of it, be it through ignorance or wilfulness, doesn't become your desire to be a credible actor in this debate.

Sorry to play the woman rather than the ball but there isn't a ball here.