Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

845 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Davros · 14/11/2026 09:16

I feel proud of myself for seeing it quite early on, for seeing it at all really. The things that influenced me were having a DD who was becoming a teenager and, having been on MN for over 20 years and always reading the feminist section, I very much felt that I really understood the issues and the terrible potential impact on women and girls. So yes, I feel self satisfied and smug if you like! I feel quite confident in understanding the issues and being able to discuss them if ever required to. That hasn’t happened to me because, so far, whenever it begins to be raised, everyone I know supports us. I am VERY proud of TERF Island

MagpiePi · 14/11/2026 09:23

Being gender critical is a mixture of bafflement and acute vicarious embarrassment that supposedly intelligent people make such tits of themselves by defending gender ideology.

It is rage that children and vulnerable people have been deliberately lied to and irreversibly physically damaged.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 09:37

MagpiePi · 14/11/2026 09:23

Being gender critical is a mixture of bafflement and acute vicarious embarrassment that supposedly intelligent people make such tits of themselves by defending gender ideology.

It is rage that children and vulnerable people have been deliberately lied to and irreversibly physically damaged.

Yes - the cringing embarrassment listening to politicians beclowning themselves talking about women with a penis and the most vulnerable in society ever. And the sense of disappointment as I realise that there's another politician unable to exercise critical thinking.

ScrollingLeaves · 14/11/2026 09:41

MrsOvertonsWindow · 14/11/2026 09:37

Yes - the cringing embarrassment listening to politicians beclowning themselves talking about women with a penis and the most vulnerable in society ever. And the sense of disappointment as I realise that there's another politician unable to exercise critical thinking.

They don’t think there is anything to think about as to them it’s just a minority of poor people born trans, in the same way as gay people are born gay. No further details needed.

Too arrogant and important to listen further.

Catiette · 14/11/2026 10:32

caprioska · 13/11/2026 08:02

Australia is distinct from the UK as there's no long history of social hierarchies or class structure or victorian prudish mores. In other words its culture is very egalitarian & openness conscious so equality & anti discrimination are natural conclusions.

This is remarkable given the history of Aboriginal rights and "the Stolen Generation".

No long history of... etc.

Its culture is...

Equality and anti-discrimination are natural conclusions.

And thanks to the poster referencing Gillard's misogyny speech - outstanding and horrifying in equal measure.

Is this you modelling the nuance we lack, Caprioska?

NotInMyyName · 14/11/2026 10:48

MagpiePi · 14/11/2026 09:23

Being gender critical is a mixture of bafflement and acute vicarious embarrassment that supposedly intelligent people make such tits of themselves by defending gender ideology.

It is rage that children and vulnerable people have been deliberately lied to and irreversibly physically damaged.

Its like being the kid in the Sixth Sense who can see the creepy dead people.

Imdunfer · 14/11/2026 11:09

Catiette · 14/11/2026 10:32

This is remarkable given the history of Aboriginal rights and "the Stolen Generation".

No long history of... etc.

Its culture is...

Equality and anti-discrimination are natural conclusions.

And thanks to the poster referencing Gillard's misogyny speech - outstanding and horrifying in equal measure.

Is this you modelling the nuance we lack, Caprioska?

Yes, no discrimination.

There also seems to be plenty of discrimination, legally upheld, against the rights of any of group of lesbians to declare themselves same sex attracted.

Catiette · 14/11/2026 12:06

caprioska · 13/11/2026 21:16

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

If any of this were a real problem mixed teams would cease to exist in practical reality but instead they continue to flourish for many reasons including a desire for parents to socialise their children with the opposite sex that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'.

Most sport played isn't at the elite level & isn't just about 'winning' but is motivated by character building, social & health reasons. Sport teaches children valuable psychological skills that translate to real world personal & social benefits in their day to day lives that a reductionist 'winning' approach ignores.

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

Edited

I find your language curious for someone who professes to model nuance:

I do wonder if people actually have parental experience commenting on this forum.

that's ironically completely lost on gender critical 'feminists'

nor does it say anything about

are strikingly reductive generalisations, particularly given your own claim to focus on the individual, as below:

The logical flaw here is averages say nothing about individuals nor does it say anything about how grading in sports works to mitigate physical advantages & risks that also occurs within a sex.

In addition to the logical flaws in your own post, above, you also seem to misapply the concept of a logical flaw to mine. My choice not to engage in more detailed exploration of "grading in sports" - preferring simply to focus on the primary differentiator of sex - isn't in any way inconsistent. I could quite happily go into the complementary issues of different age and weight categories, or distinguish between the amateur and the professional, as well. But none of that would be remotely logically incompatible with the reality that the average physical difference between males and females post-puberty (up to 150%) is an overwhelming justification for single-sex sports in a majority of contexts.

I really do find it fascinating to see where visitors here apply the paramountcy of the individual, and where they don't - and particularly to wonder if they're aware of how often they undermine their own argument within the very same post, or if they just don't care that they're doing this.

The unconscious irony would be comical if the consequences weren't so significant. The preservation of life and limb, and enabling the equal participation and competition of a full half of society in sport must always supersede individual need and "valuable psychological skills". Inclusion is what matters here.

Catiette · 14/11/2026 12:49

Sorry for engaging with derails when the thread began so powerfully, OP. I'd probably have focussed more on answering you if so many other people hadn't already so perfectly expressed the way it feels for me. Pretty much every response "nails it" in this sense!

I'd add, perhaps, that it's - maybe ironically? - given me a bit of a confidence boost.

At school I was always the one who refused to join in when a majority ganged up on a minority, and at work I seem to be one of the few who are trusted to speak up rationally and fairly in the face of any conflicts or interest or potential abuses of power. Both have come at some personal cost, but always led me to hope, cautiously, that I may just be one of the minority to retain the courage of my convictions in the face of larger scale political oppression. I'm not arrogant enough to think I'd be one of the few within that minority brave enough to join the resistance or equivalent - I don't think I would, and the people I care about matter too much to me. But I do now feel fairly confident that I wouldn't have been a flag-waving cultural revolutionary / self-interested Party informant / namer-of-names / Salem's Mary Warren!

I find it quite striking that one of the most controversial political issues of our time, with government and trusted national institutions aligning with "the other side", would have left me with this conviction. You'd think it would have the opposite effect - overwhelming and absorbing me where the secondary school cliques and abusive work culture couldn't. That it hasn't leaves me feeling cautiously... proud. Like I passed a test I never thought I'd have to sit.

It's been so much more difficult than the other times I had to stand up, alone, have been. It touches on so many issues, with so many different demographics vulnerable to harm, and so has demanded serious, extensive thought, wide reading and constant questioning. To see in all this, despite the sheer weight of the "opposing side", the fundamental emptiness of its foundations has really confirmed for me the importance of independent thought and how unusual it is. Humanity is as vulnerable to groupthink as it ever was, and to know that despite this, I've kept reasoning and questioning, is somehow deeply validating.

Perhaps counter-intuitively - or not - this also drives me to continue to monitor myself, my standards, my views etc. I'm continually startled and reaffirmed by the unconscious irony of posts like those above. They sharpen my insight into the logical traps into which we can fall, and my resolve to be alert to any such unthinking tendencies myself. I'd also add, with reference to this, that being GC is quite intellectually satisfying!

I hope all this makes sense. It feels a bit uncomfortable to put some of it into words, as pride and sheer pleasure in writing analytical essays and knocking down arguments in debate maybe shouldn't be a part of it, when the stakes are so high. But on the other hand, doesn't even acknowledging that suggest that GC feminism often begins with an admission of our own fallibility? So many of us started from TWAW, or on the fence, only to take a side. And this self-awareness is, to me, is what's missing from all those oppressive "other sides" of history. (I'm aware of the potential paradox of self-congratulation here, but at risk of entering a hall of mirrors, will stop there!)

Edited a bit for typos & similar.

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 14/11/2026 13:13

Catiette · 14/11/2026 12:49

Sorry for engaging with derails when the thread began so powerfully, OP. I'd probably have focussed more on answering you if so many other people hadn't already so perfectly expressed the way it feels for me. Pretty much every response "nails it" in this sense!

I'd add, perhaps, that it's - maybe ironically? - given me a bit of a confidence boost.

At school I was always the one who refused to join in when a majority ganged up on a minority, and at work I seem to be one of the few who are trusted to speak up rationally and fairly in the face of any conflicts or interest or potential abuses of power. Both have come at some personal cost, but always led me to hope, cautiously, that I may just be one of the minority to retain the courage of my convictions in the face of larger scale political oppression. I'm not arrogant enough to think I'd be one of the few within that minority brave enough to join the resistance or equivalent - I don't think I would, and the people I care about matter too much to me. But I do now feel fairly confident that I wouldn't have been a flag-waving cultural revolutionary / self-interested Party informant / namer-of-names / Salem's Mary Warren!

I find it quite striking that one of the most controversial political issues of our time, with government and trusted national institutions aligning with "the other side", would have left me with this conviction. You'd think it would have the opposite effect - overwhelming and absorbing me where the secondary school cliques and abusive work culture couldn't. That it hasn't leaves me feeling cautiously... proud. Like I passed a test I never thought I'd have to sit.

It's been so much more difficult than the other times I had to stand up, alone, have been. It touches on so many issues, with so many different demographics vulnerable to harm, and so has demanded serious, extensive thought, wide reading and constant questioning. To see in all this, despite the sheer weight of the "opposing side", the fundamental emptiness of its foundations has really confirmed for me the importance of independent thought and how unusual it is. Humanity is as vulnerable to groupthink as it ever was, and to know that despite this, I've kept reasoning and questioning, is somehow deeply validating.

Perhaps counter-intuitively - or not - this also drives me to continue to monitor myself, my standards, my views etc. I'm continually startled and reaffirmed by the unconscious irony of posts like those above. They sharpen my insight into the logical traps into which we can fall, and my resolve to be alert to any such unthinking tendencies myself. I'd also add, with reference to this, that being GC is quite intellectually satisfying!

I hope all this makes sense. It feels a bit uncomfortable to put some of it into words, as pride and sheer pleasure in writing analytical essays and knocking down arguments in debate maybe shouldn't be a part of it, when the stakes are so high. But on the other hand, doesn't even acknowledging that suggest that GC feminism often begins with an admission of our own fallibility? So many of us started from TWAW, or on the fence, only to take a side. And this self-awareness is, to me, is what's missing from all those oppressive "other sides" of history. (I'm aware of the potential paradox of self-congratulation here, but at risk of entering a hall of mirrors, will stop there!)

Edited a bit for typos & similar.

Edited

Excellent piece.
I'm someone who on a few occasions found myself backing the wrong horse.
Some work related issues, some politics. Personal life...too many to mention, lol.
I've found as I've got older I've become more sure of my politics while also realizing I've trusted some politicians too much.
Recently I've done a 180 on the most prominent leader of our age.
On national stuff, I've moderated certain views, and moving from London to the provinces, my world view has become less harsh and more communitarian.
On that basis, I'd have expected a moderate GC take a decade ago maybe moved to more borderline trans ideology minded today.
I mean, as a therapist I'm dealing with individuals and individuals needs and self actualisation.
If I'd been doing my job in the NHS, corporate sector, third sector, in Europe, likely my GC takes would have evaporated into pro-TRA lanyard class luxury views.
But actually of all my previous positions, GC is the one that's become shored up, way more certain and confident.
I'll freely admit, initially as a male only tangentially personally affected by TRA, for purely classic liberal Enlightenment/free speech reasons, but as the decade has worn on, more and more taking on the emotions of the existential risks as pertain to women. And teens.
I have no idea if this is in tandem with me shedding some borderline harsh views I used to subscribe to in the Noughties, my borderline Manosphere takes 15 years ago, or whether deep immersion in trans ideology takes has actually pivoted me to shedding those opinions.
All I know is that my continued interest in, and motivated opposition to TRA, is now hand in glove with a wholly different appraisal of politics, social issues, the post liberal future, and how I feel about women's rights and what's critical to women and kids.
For the first time in my life I've taken a stand, and an improved self has been a major benefit.

HPFA · 14/11/2026 13:59

Mistachio · 13/11/2026 23:18

I know which sordid throuple of which you speak 🤣

Sophie “Punch TERFS in the face” Molly - he of the massive shoes. Heather “Let me just lie on this toilet floor and take a selfie while I dilate my rot pocket” Herbert. And the other one.
Not a bottle of shampoo or a functioning brain cell between them.

They sound like lovely people!!

I do find it fascinating that everyone who claims to believe TWAW are women will eventually reveal that they don't. The arguing throuple are a good example because it's not too complicated to explain the scenario even to people who've never heard of them.

FanOfGailDines · 14/11/2026 14:58

I just watched Sesame Street

Brilliant! I'm new to having the conversations, only read Helen Joyce's book in June, although I've always been a sex realist and knew pronouns and the trans child thing was really messed up. I have to say that I really enjoy having the conversations. I mean it an amazing topic. It is so mind blowing, the capture and the gravity, and it impacts everyone and everyone has their own story. Also, there is an art to choosing the right angle for the right audience. And it makes having a chat feel very important, which I think it always is, but it makes you realise that. Talking to people and taking the ear plugs out and taking a risk is important. I'm also trying to be really respectful to those I'm taking to. For most people they are just trying to do the right thing. So, I wish I didn't need to have the conversations but given that Gender Identity Ideology is with us I'm finding the conversations very rich and challenging and it is helping me think more carefully about human beings and all their foibles.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NVEgEhg2meQ

kitex · 14/11/2026 15:39

Being gender critical means thinking about my daughters’ futures. I want them to be safe going into female single-sex spaces. It makes me so angry that TIMs have the audacity to think they can use our spaces.

I also find it absurd that people actually believe you can change your sex!

CarobBean72 · 14/11/2026 16:12

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 13/11/2026 19:52

I'd like to endorse this to a certain extent. I think it is a slightly lazy analogy and won't help to win the argument with anyone who does have a belief in God or who is maybe just agnostic. When phrased well it can work, but quite often it just comes across as a bit 'smug atheist'.

Edited

My point is that the existence of people who believe in certain things that cannot be empirically established does not

  • show that those things exist (just that believers in them do, which is not in question)
  • is no argument to compel non-believers, or believers in rival non-empiricals, to act as if we did believe.

Sorry if you find that ‘smug’.

i find cultists, heresy hunters & those who insist I should accord undeserved respect less smug & more totalitarian.

Most of Europe has been through these arguments already at some point in history, & it ends up with a lot of people burning others, or acting as if they’d like to, if the precise shibboleths of their preference are not observed.

I’ve seen that close up with two religious groups & one political one, and recognised it in Genderism as soon as I heard it proselytised.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 14/11/2026 16:36

CarobBean72 · 14/11/2026 16:12

My point is that the existence of people who believe in certain things that cannot be empirically established does not

  • show that those things exist (just that believers in them do, which is not in question)
  • is no argument to compel non-believers, or believers in rival non-empiricals, to act as if we did believe.

Sorry if you find that ‘smug’.

i find cultists, heresy hunters & those who insist I should accord undeserved respect less smug & more totalitarian.

Most of Europe has been through these arguments already at some point in history, & it ends up with a lot of people burning others, or acting as if they’d like to, if the precise shibboleths of their preference are not observed.

I’ve seen that close up with two religious groups & one political one, and recognised it in Genderism as soon as I heard it proselytised.

You took my point too personally, I think. The TRA raised the God/belief argument so you were absolutely entitled to respond to his point, and I think you did so very well.

My opinion is simply that when GC women/people lead with 'gender identity belief is just like belief in God because......' it does not always land well with the recipient, particularly if the gist of the argument is 'belief in gender identity is batshit just like belief in God is batshit'. That is when it sounds 'smug'.

IMHO all of the dogmatic ideologies that the human race has come up with so far have ended up with someone being burnt at the stake, metaphorically or otherwise.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 14/11/2026 16:46

Australia is distinct from the UK as there's no long history of social hierarchies or class structure or victorian prudish mores. In other words its culture is very egalitarian & openness conscious so equality & anti discrimination are natural conclusions.

Must have imagined that White Australia policy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_Australia_policy

Must have imagined the aboriginal children taken away from parents

https://australianstogether.org.au/discover-and-learn/our-history/stolen-generations

As for the Victorian social mores - to the horror of the TPTB, according to Robert Hughes, sodomy was rife among convicts, at least in the early years of the colony. There was also a prevailing attitude that women convicts, even if they were in long standing relationships (some of them years) with a man, were described as prostitutes - and you can't get a more Victorian attitude than 'if you're a woman, having sex and you're not married, you're a prostitute.'

Australia is so horrified at its history that it has swung to the opposite extreme - and is now so open minded its brains seem to have fallen out.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 14/11/2026 17:36

I realised I haven't answered OP's question yet😳

How does it feel to be gender critical? Apart from the raging fury that so much has been sacrificed by children and women for, what turned out to be, such a stupid, vacuous, virtue-signalling, lanyard-class, first-world cult?

I am not that bothered by what people think of me, beyond immediate family and friends and I don't feel a strong urge to conform with tribal thinking. This makes it much easier for me to resist #bekind. So I feel pleasantly surprised to find that my low Agreeableness actually has a useful function in society.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 14/11/2026 21:46

caprioska
The unearned arrogance is breathtaking.

He who smelt it, dealt it.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 14/11/2026 22:01

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:39

By this flawed logic dictionary definitions are now 'compelled speech' given their meanings have been broadened via social usage.

Whether you approve or not 'woman' & 'man' now encompass gender identity & by extension so do pronouns. So if you consider dictionary accepted descriptors as 'compelled speech' that would mean just about everything. 😂

It absolutely does become compelled speech when not using the demanded pronouns is a one way ticket to estrangement. This ideology that most people were barely aware of ten years ago claims that the old usages are bigoted, and tries to shame and coerce people into the new usage.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 14/11/2026 22:15

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:50

'Ive answered this before' isn't a particularly valid argument given the level of illogical incoherence these 'answers' usually result in.

The unearned arrogance is breathtaking.

Said by caprioska at 06:18 on Friday 13th:

"Gender has already been explained upthread."

Hypocrite?

cryupmykingdom · 14/11/2026 22:27

We're really just 'sex realists'. We think what people always have thought, for thousands of years, and what most people the world over think today.

The weird religion of gender is just a temporary thing.

When you get rid of a society's dominant religion or it fades away, the simple fact is, that as humans are a religious species, other faiths will arise in its place. Some of these will be immature, dogmatic and extreme.

Marxism in its varying forms, has spawned a few faiths. And it is not unknown for religions to encourage castration or emasculation. Mostly they are shortlived. The current gender thing meets these criteria.

Manyanamanyana · 14/11/2026 22:29

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:58

So people really don’t believe TIM are women, and the fact there are exemptions prove it doesn’t it? Why would they be excluded from female spaces if everyone truly believes they are women? Surely if they are women they should be allowed anywhere a woman is allowed to be? So do please explain why there have to be exceptions…..

Mind you, in the last few years, no-one has had an exemption granted, because TWAW. (Sal Grover anyone?). So, there's never any good enough reason to "exclude some women". Not even the Lesbian Action Group were granted an exemption to keep men out of their public events. Because the benefits of same-sex attracted women being able to meet with other same-sex attracted women, and start to rebuild their community, thus providing support and friendship to younger lesbians for example, were deemed not to outweigh the "costs" of hurting the feelings of lesbian-idemtified men. If there is any way to make that make sense, I'm yet to hear it. And, to make it worse, the Australian Equal and Human Rights Committee, on having been taken to court by the Lesbian Action Group, then went for costs against the Lesbians.
The process is the punishment, and it is set-up to make sure women fail.
So, when out TRAs talk about "exemptions", they are a loophole excuse for a completely captured Public Service.

Tears0fTheMushroom · 15/11/2026 01:19

Mistachio · 13/11/2026 23:18

I know which sordid throuple of which you speak 🤣

Sophie “Punch TERFS in the face” Molly - he of the massive shoes. Heather “Let me just lie on this toilet floor and take a selfie while I dilate my rot pocket” Herbert. And the other one.
Not a bottle of shampoo or a functioning brain cell between them.

Plenty of Pot Noodles and Angel Delight though tbf.

Cattywillow · 15/11/2026 02:23

cryupmykingdom · 14/11/2026 22:27

We're really just 'sex realists'. We think what people always have thought, for thousands of years, and what most people the world over think today.

The weird religion of gender is just a temporary thing.

When you get rid of a society's dominant religion or it fades away, the simple fact is, that as humans are a religious species, other faiths will arise in its place. Some of these will be immature, dogmatic and extreme.

Marxism in its varying forms, has spawned a few faiths. And it is not unknown for religions to encourage castration or emasculation. Mostly they are shortlived. The current gender thing meets these criteria.

Edited

This post nails it. But for me personally I would add deep grief and outrage to how I feel. My entry to learning about the whole thing was because someone I care about was sucked into it. As I learn more about it my horror increases even as people I once respected encourage and glorify it while branding anyone who so much as questions it despicable bigots. It’s been quite destabilising to see the hold such a frankly bizarre belief has taken on people who were previously very measured, non religious and science respecting.