Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans woman in female bathroom at work

1000 replies

Stupidsong · 11/11/2026 19:03

Does anyone know with the new supreme court ruling whether trans women can use the female toilets? I googled it and it comes up saying they must use the bathroom that aligns with their biological sex, but then I also read something else that say that’s for other spaces and doesn’t include toilets.

Is this something worth bringing up at work? If so, how? I’m in two minds because while I did feel very uncomfortable and think it’s wrong, I also know I could lose my job. Is this something that we have to just accept in the workplace? I have never come across it before in person. I have heard other people talk about these issues and I have always been against it and am very GC. But this is the first time I have first hand had an experience of it and it’s left me feeling a bit down that I feel like I have to just accept this or risk losing my job

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 11:50

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 11:45

Sorry I just don't care! I just picture myself as a trans woman and picture how I would hope to be treated... and treat people accordingly. Thought that was a common thing. I'm on the wrong thread!

If you think most people are happy with men in women’s spaces, it’s you that’s out of step with what the public on the whole thinks about this issue.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 11:52

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 11:43

I'm sure it's much harder being Trans than it is being a woman... I'm not in line with what people are saying on this thread at all. I'm quite shocked. I'm a lot more 'live and let live' and I wish people peace and dignity.

Intention matters, if someone is dressing as a woman to cause women harm, then yeah. Or if it's a single sex space for specific reasons like it's a womans charity, fine.

Otherwise nah.

How is it harder being a man claiming to be a woman, than being a woman exactly?

Grammarnut · 12/11/2026 11:53

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

kitex · 12/11/2026 11:57

@YourPlumTree I’m a woman and I don’t feel comfortable with men using female single sex spaces. You might not care but plenty of us do. Men are an inherent danger to women in confined spaces.

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 11:57

What are your views @alcovecupboards on men attempting lactation to ‘feed’ babies? Any 🚩

What are your views on surrogacy? Any 🚩

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 11:58

kitex · 12/11/2026 11:57

@YourPlumTree I’m a woman and I don’t feel comfortable with men using female single sex spaces. You might not care but plenty of us do. Men are an inherent danger to women in confined spaces.

Here here!!

Additionally we do not consent to it. Consent matters.

kitex · 12/11/2026 11:59

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 11:52

How is it harder being a man claiming to be a woman, than being a woman exactly?

Men don’t have to contend with periods in public, which makes it easier for them!

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 12:00

kitex · 12/11/2026 11:49

“I'm a lot more 'live and let live' and I wish people peace and dignity.”

What about women’s peace and dignity? Not all of us are comfortable having to share female single sex spaces with a male.

Why are you putting a man’s need before a woman’s need in a woman’s toilet?

Because I would hope to be treated like a human being rather than a threat if I was a trans woman, so that's how I'll proceed to treat others. It's just luck that you are a woman and not a trans person... it's not some moral fortitude. Being trans must be really hard, and wherever they chose to use a toilet, feel most comfortable/brave/included is fine by me. I'm in no position to tell them otherwise. And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

That's why I asked what the workplace and intentions were, because that is hugely relevant. My above statement is the default position, but obviously has exceptions, as I've already said.

I really like all my colleagues, including those non-binary. That's part of why I'm shocked that the majority here take a different (indecent in my opinion) stance.

Kirschcherries · 12/11/2026 12:03

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 09:38

I have had a look on the intranet this morning and can’t find any policies or anything to do with this. I asked a colleague who I trust and she said what’s the point in reporting it or bringing it up when nothing actually happened. They went into the toilet, used it, and left. This is why I feel like I can’t really ask anyone else or bring it up, because I don’t know who agrees with me and who doesn’t, and if I ask the wrong person, I don’t know what it will lead to. My colleague does agree with me, but she’s just saying is it worth it when nothing actually happened. But something DID happen! I’m leaning towards an anonymous email to HR instead maybe

@Stupidsong A couple of posters have given you some good wording. Personally I would keep it quite brief along the lines of

Dear HR
I have been using the women’s toilets and was distressed to hear and see a man using the next cubicle. I understand that men should not be using women’s toilets. As we also have men’s toilets and a unisex disabled toilet would it be possible to make it clear the women’s toilet is for women only.

Thank you

Don’t at this stage try and argue the law, regulations etc or get into a debate. Short and simple is the way to go and see what happens.

murasaki · 12/11/2026 12:03

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 12:00

Because I would hope to be treated like a human being rather than a threat if I was a trans woman, so that's how I'll proceed to treat others. It's just luck that you are a woman and not a trans person... it's not some moral fortitude. Being trans must be really hard, and wherever they chose to use a toilet, feel most comfortable/brave/included is fine by me. I'm in no position to tell them otherwise. And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

That's why I asked what the workplace and intentions were, because that is hugely relevant. My above statement is the default position, but obviously has exceptions, as I've already said.

I really like all my colleagues, including those non-binary. That's part of why I'm shocked that the majority here take a different (indecent in my opinion) stance.

There's only one indecent stance here and it's the one taken by the male person in the ladies.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:07

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 12:00

Because I would hope to be treated like a human being rather than a threat if I was a trans woman, so that's how I'll proceed to treat others. It's just luck that you are a woman and not a trans person... it's not some moral fortitude. Being trans must be really hard, and wherever they chose to use a toilet, feel most comfortable/brave/included is fine by me. I'm in no position to tell them otherwise. And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

That's why I asked what the workplace and intentions were, because that is hugely relevant. My above statement is the default position, but obviously has exceptions, as I've already said.

I really like all my colleagues, including those non-binary. That's part of why I'm shocked that the majority here take a different (indecent in my opinion) stance.

It’s not whether he’s a threat, it’s whether he’s violating women’s privacy and dignity. The rest of your virtue signalling is just empty burble. This isn’t AIBU and she didn’t ask if she was being unreasonable. She isn’t. This is the sex and gender discussions section of the feminist board. You continue to do you and pat yourself on the back for how amazingly progressive you are if you like, it’s not relevant to op.

Verisregina · 12/11/2026 12:07

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 11:36

The person's intentions would be so key to how I would feel about it.

@YourPlumTree How would you identify their intentions?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:08

Kirschcherries · 12/11/2026 12:03

@Stupidsong A couple of posters have given you some good wording. Personally I would keep it quite brief along the lines of

Dear HR
I have been using the women’s toilets and was distressed to hear and see a man using the next cubicle. I understand that men should not be using women’s toilets. As we also have men’s toilets and a unisex disabled toilet would it be possible to make it clear the women’s toilet is for women only.

Thank you

Don’t at this stage try and argue the law, regulations etc or get into a debate. Short and simple is the way to go and see what happens.

Yes, this is perfect.

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:10

Verisregina · 12/11/2026 12:07

@YourPlumTree How would you identify their intentions?

Shhhh…. Don’t ask awkward questions.

Kirschcherries · 12/11/2026 12:14

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 11:43

I'm sure it's much harder being Trans than it is being a woman... I'm not in line with what people are saying on this thread at all. I'm quite shocked. I'm a lot more 'live and let live' and I wish people peace and dignity.

Intention matters, if someone is dressing as a woman to cause women harm, then yeah. Or if it's a single sex space for specific reasons like it's a womans charity, fine.

Otherwise nah.

I agree being trans will be harder in many ways but riding roughshod over women’s rights to a single sex toilet is not the way to gain sympathy. This is what this thread is about.

A good example of live and let live or being kind backfiring spectacularly is the case where transman having a mental health crisis self admitted to an NHS psychiatric facility. They were placed on the men’s ward. Within one hour they were brutally raped for being correctly sexed as a biological female.

Respecting that at times biological sex matters on the ground of privacy and dignity and that single sex spaces be they toilets, changing rooms, hospital wards, prisons etc. should be respected is not an unreasonable position.

The op is legally entitled to a single sex toilet at work simply asking for that is not unreasonable.

Many posters on here have been arguing for 3rd spaces and provisions for trans people on the basis of privacy and dignity for 10 years+. When we get a poster that tries to derail a thread, like has happened on this one, there is a lot of pushback challenging their position.

allthingsinmoderation · 12/11/2026 12:15

MintThymeSage · 11/11/2026 20:46

This won’t be a popular comment but have you asked yourself why you are very uncomfortable? Presumably there are toilet cubicles, so you go to the toilet privately with a closed locked door. Is washing your hands next to someone a big deal? What is it you want to use these toilets for?
You have thought about your own feelings but not the dignity of the other person.

Can you not think of any reasons why a woman would feel uncomfortable with a male in a female space? The issue of the right to a female bathroom at work (workplace regs)
I can think of many: Heres a few; privacy,dignity,safety and respect for religious and cultural practices, My daughter was videod under a toilet cubicle ,my neice pushed into a cubicle and raped,my muslim neighbour doesnt want to adjust her hijab next to a make,i dont want to wash my period stained hand next to a male.Why cant they have a female bathroom.

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 12:16

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 12:00

Because I would hope to be treated like a human being rather than a threat if I was a trans woman, so that's how I'll proceed to treat others. It's just luck that you are a woman and not a trans person... it's not some moral fortitude. Being trans must be really hard, and wherever they chose to use a toilet, feel most comfortable/brave/included is fine by me. I'm in no position to tell them otherwise. And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

That's why I asked what the workplace and intentions were, because that is hugely relevant. My above statement is the default position, but obviously has exceptions, as I've already said.

I really like all my colleagues, including those non-binary. That's part of why I'm shocked that the majority here take a different (indecent in my opinion) stance.

Oh dear. This is really upsetting. I wish that all of this empathy you have for men, you could have for women. Even if I felt comfortable with men in the toilets, knowing other women don’t feel comfortable would be enough for me to be against it. Because all my empathy goes to women who feel vulnerable, unsafe, undignified, and perhaps have trauma around male violence. A poster on this thread explained how seeing a male in a female only space triggered PTSD. This is who my empathy lies with, it’s never going to be with the man who is forcing himself into our spaces. Why is your first thought that WE should have empathy for him, and not that HE should have empathy for all of the women that would be uncomfortable or even frightened at the presence of him in the toilets?

OP posts:
Verisregina · 12/11/2026 12:16

MyAmpleSheep · 12/11/2026 12:10

Shhhh…. Don’t ask awkward questions.

oh dear, I suspect most of my questions are awkward. 🙃

kitex · 12/11/2026 12:18

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 12:16

Oh dear. This is really upsetting. I wish that all of this empathy you have for men, you could have for women. Even if I felt comfortable with men in the toilets, knowing other women don’t feel comfortable would be enough for me to be against it. Because all my empathy goes to women who feel vulnerable, unsafe, undignified, and perhaps have trauma around male violence. A poster on this thread explained how seeing a male in a female only space triggered PTSD. This is who my empathy lies with, it’s never going to be with the man who is forcing himself into our spaces. Why is your first thought that WE should have empathy for him, and not that HE should have empathy for all of the women that would be uncomfortable or even frightened at the presence of him in the toilets?

Excellent post, thank you!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 12/11/2026 12:21

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 12:16

Oh dear. This is really upsetting. I wish that all of this empathy you have for men, you could have for women. Even if I felt comfortable with men in the toilets, knowing other women don’t feel comfortable would be enough for me to be against it. Because all my empathy goes to women who feel vulnerable, unsafe, undignified, and perhaps have trauma around male violence. A poster on this thread explained how seeing a male in a female only space triggered PTSD. This is who my empathy lies with, it’s never going to be with the man who is forcing himself into our spaces. Why is your first thought that WE should have empathy for him, and not that HE should have empathy for all of the women that would be uncomfortable or even frightened at the presence of him in the toilets?

Very well said 👏

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 12:33

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 12:00

Because I would hope to be treated like a human being rather than a threat if I was a trans woman, so that's how I'll proceed to treat others. It's just luck that you are a woman and not a trans person... it's not some moral fortitude. Being trans must be really hard, and wherever they chose to use a toilet, feel most comfortable/brave/included is fine by me. I'm in no position to tell them otherwise. And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

That's why I asked what the workplace and intentions were, because that is hugely relevant. My above statement is the default position, but obviously has exceptions, as I've already said.

I really like all my colleagues, including those non-binary. That's part of why I'm shocked that the majority here take a different (indecent in my opinion) stance.

It is all so virtue signalling isn’t it. The assumption because we are sex realists we do not then go on to treat people like human beings.

Good for you not caring about being next to a man.

And coming out of a cubicle and washing my hands next to someone who's sex is male is nothing. Does nothing to me. I don't care, I probably would feel proud of my colleague actually.

But you do not speak for all women. Women washing their hands having changed sanitary products for example.

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 12:49

It’s pretty astonishing to me as well that @YourPlumTree can’t see the bigger picture. This isn’t just one man, using the women’s toilet, one time. Either men are allowed in the women’s toilets, or they aren’t. So if he’s allowed in, then that would mean all men are allowed in. And if men are allowed in the womens toilets, it wouldn’t make sense to say “well they can go into the women’s toilets but they can’t go in any other women’s spaces” so that would mean they can also go into women’s changing rooms, women’s prisons, women’s support groups, and if they can do all of that, then it would only make sense for them to be able to compete in women’s sports etc. Then they have completely gotten rid of female only spaces. There can be no wishy washy rules like “well, if they wear a dress and seem kind, they can come in. But if their intentions are bad, they can’t” or “well they can come into the toilets, but not the changing rooms. They can compete in the olympics, but have to be separate in prison” that’s not going to work. It has to be a hard rule. No men in women’s spaces, at all, ever.

About 10 years ago, my mum was walking down the street when she noticed a car driving very very slowly alongside her. She looked down and he had his penis out and was masturbating while looking at her. She was obviously terrified and distressed and quickly scanned her surroundings for a place to get away from him. She was near a Morrisons so she went to the women’s toilets in there. Imagine if my mum had absolutely nowhere to go in that situation, if there was no safe space. She went into the women’s toilets knowing that was the one place he couldn’t go. Are you advocating for a society where our safe spaces that we have a right to are taken away from us?

OP posts:
kitex · 12/11/2026 12:50

@BlueLegume “Women washing their hands having changed sanitary products for example.”

Dealing with heavy periods in public can be hard, especially after childbirth.

BlueLegume · 12/11/2026 12:55

kitex · 12/11/2026 12:50

@BlueLegume “Women washing their hands having changed sanitary products for example.”

Dealing with heavy periods in public can be hard, especially after childbirth.

Not to mention menopause but hey @YourPlumTree would you say we are the ones being unreasonable?

YourPlumTree · 12/11/2026 13:13

Stupidsong · 12/11/2026 12:49

It’s pretty astonishing to me as well that @YourPlumTree can’t see the bigger picture. This isn’t just one man, using the women’s toilet, one time. Either men are allowed in the women’s toilets, or they aren’t. So if he’s allowed in, then that would mean all men are allowed in. And if men are allowed in the womens toilets, it wouldn’t make sense to say “well they can go into the women’s toilets but they can’t go in any other women’s spaces” so that would mean they can also go into women’s changing rooms, women’s prisons, women’s support groups, and if they can do all of that, then it would only make sense for them to be able to compete in women’s sports etc. Then they have completely gotten rid of female only spaces. There can be no wishy washy rules like “well, if they wear a dress and seem kind, they can come in. But if their intentions are bad, they can’t” or “well they can come into the toilets, but not the changing rooms. They can compete in the olympics, but have to be separate in prison” that’s not going to work. It has to be a hard rule. No men in women’s spaces, at all, ever.

About 10 years ago, my mum was walking down the street when she noticed a car driving very very slowly alongside her. She looked down and he had his penis out and was masturbating while looking at her. She was obviously terrified and distressed and quickly scanned her surroundings for a place to get away from him. She was near a Morrisons so she went to the women’s toilets in there. Imagine if my mum had absolutely nowhere to go in that situation, if there was no safe space. She went into the women’s toilets knowing that was the one place he couldn’t go. Are you advocating for a society where our safe spaces that we have a right to are taken away from us?

Edited

I think all of those what-then-isms can be handled quite easily, and separately actually.

I've read others' opinions, I don't personally agree, and I think women need to know there's a spectrum of opinions on the issue. You've heard mine, which has been considered virtue signalling etc 🤷🏻‍♀️

I was just surprised people would feel this way about a colleague, and in a workplace (again never ascertained size of workplace, so it might be a busy anonymous type workplace). I wonder how people treat their trans colleagues generally - I hope it's well.

It also seems you're all focusing on a very small part of a wider systemic issue of male violence against woman, and lumbering a lot on a very vulnerable and miniscule group of people who statistically face higher rates of gender based violence.

I'm not going to convince anyone here, and you're all not going to convince me, but it's been eye-opening.

Lastly, I think your mum did the wrong thing there! She put a lot of trust into an attacker respecting a sign on a door! She should have gone to the busiest mixed gender space, and got help to phone the police..!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.