Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trans woman in female bathroom at work

1000 replies

Stupidsong · 11/11/2026 19:03

Does anyone know with the new supreme court ruling whether trans women can use the female toilets? I googled it and it comes up saying they must use the bathroom that aligns with their biological sex, but then I also read something else that say that’s for other spaces and doesn’t include toilets.

Is this something worth bringing up at work? If so, how? I’m in two minds because while I did feel very uncomfortable and think it’s wrong, I also know I could lose my job. Is this something that we have to just accept in the workplace? I have never come across it before in person. I have heard other people talk about these issues and I have always been against it and am very GC. But this is the first time I have first hand had an experience of it and it’s left me feeling a bit down that I feel like I have to just accept this or risk losing my job

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:36

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:31

A mother wanting to connect with her baby is one of the most human things, I don't think it's about them being trans.

If a male person cannot produce the milk that is required in stage needed, in consistency needed, or in quantity needed, please do tell what benefit is this decision to the infant?

Please again, be specific. How is that male person's decision meeting the needs of the infant?

'Connecting' with the infant can be done in many ways. Feeding an infant an untested substance just because a male person 'can' is in no way centring the infant.

Can you please tell us how a male person develops the interactive feeding system that a female body has if the genetic coding and the body parts are not present?

Or, for the infant, is near enough good enough too?

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:37

StealthTroublemaker · 11/11/2026 22:35

So if “transwomen” are female @Transperson , you’ll be recruiting one to be your surrogate right? If not, why not?

They gonandally male, it's impossible for them even if they are phenotypically female.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:38

A reminder of how the female breast is part of a complete feeding system and no male breast has this ability.

https://www.facebook.com/share/p/19f8K414tC/?mibextid=wwXIfr

In 2008, Katie Hinde stood in a California primate lab staring at hundreds of milk samples. Male babies got richer milk. Females got more volume. Science had missed half the conversation.

She was a postdoctoral researcher at the California National Primate Research Center, analyzing milk from rhesus macaque mothers. For months, she'd been measuring fat content, protein levels, mineral concentrations. The data showed something she hadn't expected: monkey mothers were producing completely different milk depending on whether they'd given birth to sons or daughters.

Sons received milk with higher concentrations of fat and protein—more energy per ounce. Daughters received more milk overall, with higher calcium levels. The biological recipe wasn't universal. It was customized.
Hinde ran the numbers again. The pattern held across dozens of mother-infant pairs. This wasn't random variation. This was systematic.

She thought about what she'd been taught in graduate school. Milk was nutrition. Calories, proteins, fats. A delivery system for energy. But if milk was just fuel, why would it differ based on the baby's sex? Why would mothers unconsciously adjust the formula?

The answer shifted everything: milk wasn't passive. It was a message.
Hinde had arrived at this question through an unusual path. She'd earned her bachelor's degree in anthropology from the University of Washington, then completed her PhD at UCLA in 2008. While most lactation research focused on dairy cattle or developing infant formulas, Hinde wanted to understand what milk actually did in primate mothers and babies.

At UC Davis, she had access to the largest primate research center in the United States. She could collect milk samples at different stages of lactation, track infant development, measure maternal characteristics. She could ask questions that had never been systematically studied.

Like: why do young mothers produce milk with more stress hormones?
Hinde discovered that first-time monkey mothers produced milk with fewer calories but higher concentrations of cortisol than experienced mothers. Babies who consumed this high-cortisol milk grew faster but were more nervous and less confident. The milk wasn't just feeding the baby's body—it was programming the baby's temperament.

Or: how does milk respond when babies get sick?

Working with researchers who studied infant illness, Hinde found that when babies developed infections, their mothers' milk changed within hours. The white blood cell count in the milk increased dramatically—from around 2,000 cells per milliliter to over 5,000 during acute illness. Macrophage counts quadrupled. The levels returned to normal once the baby recovered.

The mechanism was remarkable: when a baby nurses, small amounts of the baby's saliva travel back through the nipple into the mother's breast tissue. That saliva contains information about the baby's immune status. If the baby is fighting an infection, the mother's body detects the antigens and begins producing specific antibodies, which then flow back to the baby through the milk.

It was a dialogue. The baby's body communicated its needs. The mother's body responded.

Hinde started documenting everything. She collected milk from over 250 rhesus macaque mothers across more than 700 sampling events. She measured cortisol, adiponectin, epidermal growth factor, transforming growth factors. She tracked which babies gained weight faster, which were more exploratory, which were more cautious.

She realized she was mapping a language that had been invisible.
In 2011, Hinde joined Harvard as an assistant professor. She began writing about her findings, but she also noticed something troubling: almost nobody was studying human breast milk with the same rigor applied to other biological systems. When she searched publication databases, she found twice as many studies on erectile dysfunction as on breast milk composition.

The world's first food—the substance that had nourished every human who ever lived—was scientifically neglected.

She started a blog: "Mammals Suck...Milk!" The title was deliberately provocative. Within a year, it had over a million views. Parents, clinicians, researchers started asking questions. What bioactive compounds are in human milk? How does milk from mothers of premature babies differ from milk produced for full-term infants? Can we use this knowledge to improve formulas or help babies in NICUs?

Hinde's research expanded. She studied how milk changes across the day (fat concentration peaks mid-morning). She investigated how foremilk differs from hindmilk (babies with bigger appetites who nurse longer get higher-fat milk at the end of feeding). She examined how maternal characteristics—age, parity, health status, social rank—shaped milk composition.

In 2013, she created March Mammal Madness, a science outreach event that became an annual tradition in hundreds of classrooms. In 2014, she co-authored "Building Babies." In 2016, she received the Ehrlich-Koldovsky Early Career Award from the International Society for Research in Human Milk and Lactation for making outstanding contributions to the field.

By 2017, when she delivered her TED talk, she could articulate what she'd discovered across a decade of research: breast milk is food, medicine, and signal. It builds the baby's body and fuels the baby's behavior. It carries bacteria that colonize the infant gut, hormones that influence metabolism, oligosaccharides that feed beneficial microbes, immune factors that protect against pathogens.

More than 200 varieties of oligosaccharides alone. The baby can't even digest them—they exist to nourish the right community of gut bacteria, preventing harmful pathogens from establishing.

The composition is as unique as a fingerprint. No two mothers produce identical milk. No two babies receive identical nutrition.

In 2020, Hinde appeared in the Netflix docuseries "Babies," explaining her findings to a mass audience. She'd moved to Arizona State University, where she now directs the Comparative Lactation Lab. Her research continues to reveal new dimensions of how milk shapes infant outcomes from the first hours of life through childhood.

She works on precision medicine applications—using knowledge of milk bioactives to help the most fragile infants in neonatal intensive care units. She consults on formula development, helping companies create products that better replicate the functional properties of human milk for mothers who face obstacles to breastfeeding.

The implications extend beyond individual families. Understanding milk informs public health policy, workplace lactation support, clinical recommendations. It reveals how maternal characteristics,
environmental conditions, and infant needs interact in real time through a biological messaging system that's been evolving for 200 million years—longer than dinosaurs.

Katie Hinde didn't just study milk. She revealed that the most ancient form of nourishment was also the most sophisticated. What science had treated as simple nutrition was actually a dynamic, responsive communication between two bodies—a conversation that shapes human development one feeding at a time.

Here is another artlicle about her work
https://nihrecord.nih.gov/2016/04/22/breast-milk-liquid-gold-infants-hinde-says
a study
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35352583/
And where her work has led to so far
https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2024/09/11/breast-milks-benefits-are-not-limited-to-babies

Facebook

https://www.facebook.com/login/?next=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.facebook.com%2Fstory.php%3Fstory_fbid%3D1412851413960522%26id%3D100057070315212%26mibextid%3DwwXIfr%26rdid%3DQzDxCG0nE5o8fBdP%26share_url%3Dhttps%253A%252F%252Fwww.facebook.com%252Fshare%252Fp%252F19f8K414tC%253Fmibextid%253DwwXIfr&rdid=QzDxCG0nE5o8fBdP

murasaki · 11/11/2026 22:38

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:37

They gonandally male, it's impossible for them even if they are phenotypically female.

So exploiting actual women while cosplaying the easy bits.

StealthTroublemaker · 11/11/2026 22:39

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:37

They gonandally male, it's impossible for them even if they are phenotypically female.

But you said they were female! Were you lying? Tut tut.

murasaki · 11/11/2026 22:40

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:36

That's quite an assertion, you are claiming that because there is insufficient quantity or questionable quality then it must be for sexual reasons. That's a big jump that you have no evidence for. There is a lot of research about the psychological impact of breastfeeding, both on the baby and mother.

You said sexual reasons, I said validation. You need to have a word with yourself given your mind went straight to sexual, which I had not said.

Operation let them speak in full force there.

FairViewRosie25 · 11/11/2026 22:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 22:46

murasaki · 11/11/2026 22:40

You said sexual reasons, I said validation. You need to have a word with yourself given your mind went straight to sexual, which I had not said.

Operation let them speak in full force there.

Yes, illuminating isn’t it.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:47

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:05

Trans women can breastfeed, it's well established in literature.

I suggest you actually read the 'literature' again, but before you do so, perhaps you should actually gain some understanding on what breastfeeding is and what it is not.

Because I think you are simply not understanding the deficiencies that women who are knowledgable about breastfeeding are pointing out to you.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:52

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:26

There are other studies where feeding was for months. Don't know if any followed the trans person for years.

The study that was of a male 'feeding for months' ended up showing that the male person was not producing anywhere near enough milk to provide adequate nutrition for the infant at that development stage.

Other studies have also shown that exact same limitation.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:56

MrsOvertonsWindow · 11/11/2026 22:32

Quite unbelievable to see a man descend on a parenting site of predominantly women and starts lecturing women and mothers that men can breastfeed newborns.

It's hard to express my contempt for men who do this (and not get deleted). Suffice to say, this is the type of arrogant / ignorant overreach that results in the negative view that so many have of transactivism. When transactivists go for babies, they show everyone precisely who they really are.

I know right.

A man tells the women of mumsnet that men can breastfeed too, don't we know?

'When transactivists go for babies, they show everyone precisely who they really are.'

Indeed.

FairViewRosie25 · 11/11/2026 22:58

Also you are not the mother

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:58

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:32

If it's erotic sure. But I really doubt that it's the case for most lactating trans women.

And yet, how many have I posted here?

I have yet to see a female person publish how erotic they find breastfeeding.

You seem to have no fucking idea about what you were talking so confidently about.

murasaki · 11/11/2026 23:01

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:58

And yet, how many have I posted here?

I have yet to see a female person publish how erotic they find breastfeeding.

You seem to have no fucking idea about what you were talking so confidently about.

What's that thing again about having the confidence of a mediocre man?

FairViewRosie25 · 11/11/2026 23:01

Breast feeding isn’t erotic it’s a means to an end which doesn’t always happen and it bloody hurts

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 23:03

murasaki · 11/11/2026 22:33

How can it be anything else when it doesn't nourish the child and is only about validation?

Exactly.

There is no evidence at all that the substance has been even adequately tested for all compounds nor interactions, there is no feedback system, there is no staging of the milk, no consistency changes for the weather or the infant's health, there was no collostrum, there is not enough produced...., yet.... we are to believe that it is about centring the infant.

It is not about centring the infant.

'Cow Achievement ' apparently.

Transperson · 11/11/2026 23:04

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 22:36

If a male person cannot produce the milk that is required in stage needed, in consistency needed, or in quantity needed, please do tell what benefit is this decision to the infant?

Please again, be specific. How is that male person's decision meeting the needs of the infant?

'Connecting' with the infant can be done in many ways. Feeding an infant an untested substance just because a male person 'can' is in no way centring the infant.

Can you please tell us how a male person develops the interactive feeding system that a female body has if the genetic coding and the body parts are not present?

Or, for the infant, is near enough good enough too?

seems like the main thing is lower stress levels in the mother and baby. It also more the mother more responsive and sensitive.

"Can you please tell us how a male person develops the interactive feeding system that a female body has if the genetic coding and the body parts are not present?"

Oh found a case study where a baby was solely fed by a trans woman while searching papers vivo.weill.cornell.edu/display/pubid29372185

NGL I don't understand the biology behind that enough, it seems very complicated 😅
But as far as I understand cells respond to hormones regardless of genetic code. As the case studies I sent in this reply and earlier show trans women's breasts function somewhat similarly to non trans women, less milk is also common in any woman who hasn't actually gave birth, it isn't unique to trans women.

JellySaurus · 11/11/2026 23:04

Trans-identifying males do not lactate. They experience galactorrhea as a consequence of drug use.

FairViewRosie25 · 11/11/2026 23:06

It’s pretending. Just like filling your Tiny Tears with water then watching her wee in her nappy

StealthTroublemaker · 11/11/2026 23:07

FairViewRosie25 · 11/11/2026 23:06

It’s pretending. Just like filling your Tiny Tears with water then watching her wee in her nappy

Exactly.

StealthTroublemaker · 11/11/2026 23:07

Transperson · 11/11/2026 23:04

seems like the main thing is lower stress levels in the mother and baby. It also more the mother more responsive and sensitive.

"Can you please tell us how a male person develops the interactive feeding system that a female body has if the genetic coding and the body parts are not present?"

Oh found a case study where a baby was solely fed by a trans woman while searching papers vivo.weill.cornell.edu/display/pubid29372185

NGL I don't understand the biology behind that enough, it seems very complicated 😅
But as far as I understand cells respond to hormones regardless of genetic code. As the case studies I sent in this reply and earlier show trans women's breasts function somewhat similarly to non trans women, less milk is also common in any woman who hasn't actually gave birth, it isn't unique to trans women.

Nah mate. Just….. nah.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 23:07

Transperson · 11/11/2026 22:36

That's quite an assertion, you are claiming that because there is insufficient quantity or questionable quality then it must be for sexual reasons. That's a big jump that you have no evidence for. There is a lot of research about the psychological impact of breastfeeding, both on the baby and mother.

The male person is NOT the infant's MOTHER!!

That psychological impact you are referring to, it is about the woman that carried and gave birth to the infant. It is about the infant knowing its mother's body already and finding comfort and being feed individualised milk from its mother's nipples.

Transperson · 11/11/2026 23:08

murasaki · 11/11/2026 22:40

You said sexual reasons, I said validation. You need to have a word with yourself given your mind went straight to sexual, which I had not said.

Operation let them speak in full force there.

Context matters? It's a reply to a reply to a reply. Good job taking it out of context.

murasaki · 11/11/2026 23:09

Transperson · 11/11/2026 23:04

seems like the main thing is lower stress levels in the mother and baby. It also more the mother more responsive and sensitive.

"Can you please tell us how a male person develops the interactive feeding system that a female body has if the genetic coding and the body parts are not present?"

Oh found a case study where a baby was solely fed by a trans woman while searching papers vivo.weill.cornell.edu/display/pubid29372185

NGL I don't understand the biology behind that enough, it seems very complicated 😅
But as far as I understand cells respond to hormones regardless of genetic code. As the case studies I sent in this reply and earlier show trans women's breasts function somewhat similarly to non trans women, less milk is also common in any woman who hasn't actually gave birth, it isn't unique to trans women.

Well no man claiming to be a mother can ever be described as sensitive to a baby's needs. They can be described as many other things though.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.