Normally I’m against deplatforming as well, but I’m also concerned how students increasingly seem to struggle with applying critical thinking.
And if there is critical thinking to be applied, at the very least there would need to be a strong counter argument being proposed on the same platform. I’m firmly of the belief that subject knowledge is required before critical thought can take place. But going by Darren McGarvey‘s substack, this is simply a straightforward presentation.
JIMS was invited to address fourth-year criminology students as part of a module examining criminal justice and fair-trial rights. While we must trust students to distinguish valid argument from reactionary recruitment, and maintain that controversial ideas have a legitimate place in academic study, there is a world of difference between critically examining such ideas and inviting their proponents into a lecture theatre to present them unchallenged. What, precisely, does JIMS have to offer criminology students that could not be provided by another organisation, without the same concerns surrounding its conduct and public rhetoric?
Darren McGarvey reviewed this organisation’s website and found disturbing misogynistic framing around women’s rights. Such as JIMS declares that “the real danger is misandry” and repeating the message of men as victims and feminism undermines men.
If he could do it, why hadn’t the university done a bit of due diligence? Would make me wonder about the university faculty member doing the inviting and their motivation.
Ultimately, there’s a good chance that at least some of the students would listen and believe JIMS and that’s concerning on multiple levels. Do we need more young men to buy into the idea that feminism has ‘gone too far’? That false accusations are common against the reality of epidemic violence against women and girls; including on university campuses. That future solicitors, barristers and judges buy into men as victims framing?