Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 02:23

Hiya! Created this thread to try to have a bit more of an understanding on a human level (not political or news based) why some people dislike and would not want to share space with trans people?

To be transparent, my sex assigned at birth is different than my current representation, I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation, challenged me or expressed discomfort. I do try to be as mindful as I can and I go out of my way to not cause discomfort, distress, or alarm (i.e. showering in my swimsuit in swimming pools).
(Pre-empting the they can always tell argument, in my lived experience it's definitely not true, at least for the last few years).

How does a trans person using a single sex person puts anyone in danger?
There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

Scotland stats are used as that is where I reside. Thanks for reading, looking forward your replies.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
NapsForTheWin · 10/11/2026 04:41

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:36

Hiya, thank you for another thoughtful reply.

I heard from friends of mine how most of them were being sexualised from a young age. It is a big problem that is enabled by patriarchy. Men aren't held accountable in this aspect.

From a personal experience, I regularly get harassed (you know the gist, people being uncomfortably close, people trying to unconsensually touch or kiss, cat calling, following, etc etc) and I have most empathy to all women who go through this, regardless of age.

Knowing that someone else has those uncomfortable shared experiences, and especially from a young age does give a sense of safety since you know that they understand.

It can be less obvious and different for people transitioning the other way.

There isn't right or wrong with feelings :)

Yes, that could be it, that I know they have lived it. I still felt a sense of sisterhood (I wouldn't have told them that). That budding friendship didn't actually go anywhere as we were at totally different stages of life, so it just didn't mesh.

In the same way, I have no idea what it really is to grow up as a male in this society. I have sons and am aware of issues, but that's not the same as living it.

Just adding, my nephew went through a period of time where he was considering transitioning. He decided not to but I was really worried for him. Worried about the violence and hostility he might experience if he transitioned, that his life would be harder. I'd have been as supportive as I could have been if he had, but I was relieved when he didn't. So I know that being trans isn't an easy road either.

popdepop · 10/11/2026 04:44

Trans women aren’t women, they are trans women and biologically men. I don’t want trans women in female spaces eg changing rooms or toilets. Probably in time there will be additional spaces for trans women and trans men which could be labelled that way. So you’d have the option of using your biological sex space or the trans space of how your identity, who knows

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 04:46

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:10

Hiya, appreciated the detailed response.

"How does a trans person using a single sex provision put anyone in danger?
An alternative phrasing of this question is ‘how does a male using female only provision put anyone in danger? Or, ‘how does a males with a trans identity using female only provision put anyone in danger? When looking at it at an individual level, Tom, Dick and Harry may present no danger but Fred, Jack and Russell do. Because of this, a blanket rule, making a service or provision single sex, is lawfully."

I would disagree with the proposition that trans people are in the same category of their born sex. Medically transitioing changes them phenotypically, which effect how they are precieved. In this example that would create a new category, of people who are trans. Unless you meaningfully establish that being trans is correlated, linked, with assaulting others, at the same rates or higher as non trans men. They are different.

It's already established that trans people are more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators.

"It is harmful to trans people to perpetuate ideas that those wanting transwomen to stay out of female only provision hate or dislike transwomen."

How so? From my pov excluding trans people directly increases their risk to be outed and attacked (which you don't do to people you don't dislike!)

"Using female only provision when you are male is harmful to females, it completely violates our boundaries."

Could you define the boundaries and how trans people violate them?

In the UK, where I am based, the law states that access to sex provision should be based on biological sex/ natal sex. There has to be a legitimate and proportionate rationale to exclude males from a space and make it female only. Therefore, biological/ natal males unilaterally deciding that the rule doesn’t apply to them and using the provision anyway are, in my view a risk. They are undermining the rule of law and, in turn, paving the way for others to do the same.

I think expect that this thread is going to come down to you claiming you are not biologically male or a natal male, that sex is complex etc.

If this is the case, I’m out. I’m willing to have a conversation about the rights and wrongs of natal males with trans identities using female only provision, but I’m not willing to engage in nonsense about the complexity of sex.

Over 99.9% of humans can be straightforwardly categorised as male or female and this is easily identifiable. The remaining population have disorders of sexual development that has nothing to do with identity and they are still are male or female.

Put it another way, over 90% of the population could conceive if they chose to. There is no doubt in any sane person’s mind as to which role in conception anyone would play. Of the remaining 90% with fertility issues, the issues arising would not have anything to do with uncertainty over which reproductive role a individual plays.

If your role in sexual reproduction is/would be / could have been sperm production, you are male. And, no, this isn’t reductionist, it is a straight forward, factually based definition of sex.

allthemind · 10/11/2026 04:48

Also your thread title is disingenuous. You know why there is dislike, distrust and hostility towards men who say they are the same as women and are no longer male. Its offensive to females and women. Nobody cares if a man wants to present in a stereotypically female way, though we find it ridiculous that trans identifying men seem to equate that with skirts, makeup, large breasts (which women afflicted with them generally hate) and either a porn based or very out of date presentation of a middle aged woman from the 60s. But we do object to men telling us they are the same as us, when they aren't and haven't had the same lived experience. I'd be perfectly happy to be friends with a man that liked wearing makeup and dresses, though its not my bag personally. Nobody has an issue with effeminate, or gay men. But I dont want to be friends with someone that appropriates me and claims to have the same lived experiences as me, when they dont.

But you know all this. You aren't struggling to understand and your motive in starting this thread isnt to gain more understanding. Like many, many before you, its just an opportunity to lecture and hector us and try and force us to believe your assertion, which we know is a delusion, that you have somehow magically become female because you've taken female hormones or had surgery. Unfortunately you've come to the wrong place for that. Most women, and men, will never affirm you in that delusion because we know its not true. That doesnt mean we wish you ill in any way, or want to stop you existing and presenting as you choose, but its not really a position that engenders like or trust is it?

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 04:48

When women and girls discuss the need for female single sex provision, it is also not just about physical risk to safety. There are many types of harms that female people need female single sex provisions to be safeguarded against, risk of violence is of course included but it is not the entire cause of harm :

Harms include:

-Rape and sexual assault.
-Violence.
-Sexual abuse that is not rape or sexual assault.
-Sexual abuse that also includes solo sexual acts or using the experience in future sexual acts.
-Any other abuse that may include verbal abuse, intimidation in any way etc, this includes inappropriate questions and comments.
-A male person's presence where female people need privacy and dignity.
-A male person's presence where female people need to feel safe from any male person's presence (over the age of about 8 years old).
-Female people self-excluding knowing that there may be a male person accessing that provision.
-Female people not having the freedom to discuss the issues that cause them distress, concern, or that they need to talk about because a male person is present.
-Female children (and female adults) learning to have no or too low personal boundaries because they have been taught that male people are female people and that they should ignore and overcome feelings of discomfort.

Narrowing the discussion to sex and violence offences does not remove these other harms from consideration for female single sex spaces and vice versa.

They are all important.

Of course, one of those harms is any type of physical assault.

This is from the latest IOC policy.

Magnitude of Advantage: At the elite level, the magnitude of the Male performance advantage is different depending on the sport or event:

There is a 10-12 per cent Male performance advantage in most running and swimming events.

There is a 20+ per cent Male performance advantage in most throwing and jumping events.

The Male performance advantage can be greater than 100 per cent in events that involve explosive power, e.g. in collision, lifting and punching sports.

Here is the statement:

https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/international-olympic-committee-announces-new-policy-on-the-protection-of-the-female-women-s-category-in-olympic-sport

here is the policy
https://stillmed.olympics.com/media/Documents/International-Olympic-Committee/EB/policy/policy-on-the-protection-of-the-female-category-english.pdf

I can link you up to the reviews that the IOC drew on to make this statement. By the way, I can also link up the now many reviews for boys having greater power than girls from the age of 7 years old too.

It is not just sexual assault as you seem to focus on. It is also any violent act at all while they are in the female single sex space.

Of course, it is also not just violence, the risk of harm includes many other aspects too.

There really is no change significant enough to move a male person with a transgender identity out of the male category for safeguarding considerations. They remain male and like all male people are subject to exclusion based on being a male person. No other groups of male people get exemption from being regarded as having the same risk of harming female people as the general male population.

Male people with transgender identities remain part of the male population for the purpose of making safeguarding decisions for the safety, privacy and dignity of female people.

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 04:52

NumberTheory · 10/11/2026 04:38

I very much agree that we should take action to protect trans people from assault. Just as we should take action to protect other groups who are at greater risk from assault. I don't see what that has to do with your question? We don't let all groups at greater risk of assault into women's spaces. that would be ludicrous.

My point about the statistics is that we have plenty of statistical evidence that men as a sex class are a danger to women as a sex class. You seem to think we should make an exception for a small group of men to let them into women's spaces without any evidence that they provide a different risk profile from other men.

While it wasn't originally based on rigorous statistics, as a society we realised that a long time ago, which is one of the reasons we have provided women with single sex spaces. But it's only one of the reasons we have single sex spaces. If safety of women were the only reason we'd have general spaces and women's spaces. But we have male spaces too, because it isn't just about safety from the opposite sex, it's also about dignity and, in the case of some single sex spaces, a broad shared experience that is different from the experience of people who aren't of that sex and a need to be able to talk about that without it being derailed.

💯

Female only provision is not a refuge for vulnerable men. Indeed, if it were, it would cease being a female only provision, it would be mixed sex for females and certain males.

I too believe that measures should be taken to keep everyone safe, but reducing the safety of one group to increase the safety of another, isn’t an acceptable approach in my view.

2021x · 10/11/2026 04:55

People don’t dislike trans people as trans people have been led to think. There will always be bigots; who also racist and misogynistic as well we can’t control people’s thoughts only prevent them from affecting others unfairly.

People are tackling and exhausted by Trans-activism, and especially by the group of trans people who put their personal satisfaction over the needs of another group.

Females have loudly and persistently objected to any males on female spaces. Females know better than any male what is good for them. Any male that is ignoring that clear signal to satisfy their own personal wants is the problem whether they are trans or not.

Males in the other hand have expressed no such objection-so transmen are not disrespecting men by using their space. I would also suggest it is better for women as well.

TakingMyChancesWithTheRabbits · 10/11/2026 04:55

There's no evidence that transwomen are less likely to commit violent crime than any other male, let alone that their offending rates approach the far lower levels of women. Consequently they don't belong in female only spaces that are provided for reasons of dignity privacy and safety, as to do so would compromise the women who generally belong there. Personally, I'm not that fussed about transwomen using the ladies loos, but I know there are many women who are for various reasons. I'm not going to give that right away, just as I wouldn't want some other woman to give away my right to a female only changing room, as that is something that would bother me.

I'd also be interested in what you're counting as "phenotype" here, given that transition isn't going to change bone structure and other physiological changes that occur during male puberty.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 04:55

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:18

"Transwomen are male" - not phenotypically, although most are in terms of genetic and gonadal sex.

I believe my last reply covers the rest of the message.

Human sex categories are determined based on reproductive roles of humans.

A male person’s sex category is determined as being male because their body was formed around the production of small gametes regardless of whether they ever have produced those small gametes or will ever. Even if they have had their testes removed for any reason, that doesn’t change their sex category.

A human cannot change sex category even if they have chosen to undergo extreme body modification.

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 04:57

OP - Please can you clarify whether your starting point is that transwomen are biologically male and so the discussion about the rights or wrongs of inclusion in female only provision is operating on this basis, or if you think that transwomen are not classifiable as male.

Unless these foundations are clarified, discussion is pretty pointless.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 05:03

Since male prisoner with transgender identity prisoner stats have been introduced by the OP, here is an academics perspective that might be useful.

PROFESSOR ALICE SULLIVAN'S LETTER TO THE JUDICIAL OFFICE REGARDING KEMP'S MISUNDERSTANDING OF THE CRIME RATE FOR MALE PEOPLE WITH TRANSGENDER IDENTITIES

https://x.com/ProfAliceS/status/2000532626243756399?s=20

I have written to the Judicial Office for Scotland in relation to errors in the interpretation of evidence in the Sandie Peggie case.

To: Judicial Office for Scotland [email protected]

Dear Sir/Madam,

I write in relation to the Judgment in the case of Peggie vs Fife Health Board and Upton.

While some of these points have already been discussed in the public domain, the judgment suggests a preference for a ‘skilled witness’ regarding research evidence. As a professor of sociology at UCL with many years of experience in the field of social statistics, I trust that I meet the criteria to be considered as a skilled witness.

Paragraph 1047 suggests some confusion on the part of Judge Kemp regarding the following publication: Dhejne, C., Lichtenstein, P., Boman, M., Johansson, A.L., Långström, N. and Landén, M., 2011. Long-term follow-up of transsexual persons undergoing sex reassignment surgery: cohort study in Sweden. PloS one, 6(2), p.e16885.
The judgment notes: ‘The following was stated “Transsexual individuals were at increased risk of being convicted for any crime or violent crime after sex reassignment (Table 2); this, however was only significant in the group who underwent sex reassignment before 1989.” ‘

However, this is sentence is irrelevant to the point at hand. The judge appears to have either misinterpreted the evidence or missed the point.

The paper states ‘regarding any crime, male-to-females had a significantly increased risk for crime compared to female controls (aHR 6.6;95% CI 4.1–10.8) but not compared to males’. In other words, the paper finds that ‘male-to-females’ retained a male pattern of criminal convictions.

The judge’s misinterpretation of Dhjene et al, combined with his dismissal of Ministry of Justice data on the grounds that clicking on hyperlinks would have been required to gain access to the relevant documents, underpinned his conclusion in paragraph 1049 ‘In our view, having read all of the documents, there is very far from sufficient reliable evidence to establish as a fact that a trans woman who is legally and biologically male is a greater risk to any person assigned female at birth within a changing room environment at a workplace than another woman assigned female at birth’.

This conclusion is based in error. In addition, it misunderstands the burden of proof. It is well-established that males are far more likely to commit violent and sexual crime than females. In order to argue that this does not apply to a subset of males, one would need strong positive evidence of this point.

I would add some further evidence. The most recent data from His Majesty’s Prison and Probation Service (HMPPS, 2025) further supports the view that males who identify as transwomen retain a male pattern of offending. Only around 4% of the prison population in England and Wales is female. The transgender prison population in 2025 (0.4% of prisoners) included over four times as many biological males (276) as females (63). If transwomen were counted as women, they would constitute 7.3% of women prisoners.

I hope this is helpful.
Yours faithfully,
Professor Alice Sullivan, UCL

Professor Alice Sullivan profile picture

Professor Alice Sullivan (@ProfAliceS) on X

I have written to the Judicial Office for Scotland in relation to errors in the interpretation of evidence in the Sandie Peggie case. To: Judicial Office for Scotland [email protected] Dear Sir/Madam, I write in relation to the Ju...

https://x.com/ProfAliceS/status/2000532626243756399?s=20

OffTheMap · 10/11/2026 05:03

My Gender Critical views in no way mean I ‘dislike’ trans people.
There is nothing about being trans that would lead me to assume a person wasn’t as friendly, good at their job etc as anyone else.
I would also fight against prejudice, abuse, discrimination against a person for being trans.

But there are certain limited circumstances in which sex matters more than gender.

Sport

The changing rooms and showers in my local pool, in a borough which has said they won’t recognise the law. I do not want to be naked in the cramped showers and have a male bodied person with a penis 2’ away and between me and the exit.

Survivor groups that choose to be based on sex not gender (fine if people want to also establish groups that are trans inclusive)

Lesbian social clubs that choose to establish on sex not gender.

I also think that Trans people should be able to establish Trans only survivor / social clubs. I don’t expect to be included.

It may be uncomfortable that there are some sex based rights that I will protect - but it doesn’t mean I ‘dislike’ Trans people.

I don’t dislike men either - I just don’t want them in my female spaces in certain circumstances. Not even if they are my DH or Ds.

2021x · 10/11/2026 05:05

MyAmpleSheep · 10/11/2026 04:13

It's already established that trans people are more likely to be victims of crime than perpetrators.

Irrelevant. Being part of a cohort that (it is claimed) is more likely to suffer from crime doesn't have any bearing on how likely a given member of that cohort is to commit a crime. In fact in many groups where people suffer from crime they are more likely to turn to criminal behaviour themselves.

Trans people can be BOTH more likely to be victims of crime AND more likely to be perpetrators of crime. It is not an either/or scenario.

Edited

Agreed it’s a false equivalence.

All minority groups are statistically going to be more at risk of crime than perpetrators.

The relevant statistic we should be asking is how much a risk transwomen to women compared to other men. That statistic is the only one that is relevant to this discussion.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 05:06

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 04:57

OP - Please can you clarify whether your starting point is that transwomen are biologically male and so the discussion about the rights or wrongs of inclusion in female only provision is operating on this basis, or if you think that transwomen are not classifiable as male.

Unless these foundations are clarified, discussion is pretty pointless.

Hiya, thanks for another reply, to your previous replies & others I would get back to them tomorrow.

Sex is divided to phenotypic, gonadal, and genetic. Medically transitioing effects phenotypic sex.

By this I am not saying it's 100% one or another, but that it simply has an effect.

So a medically transitioned trans women most commonly is genotypically and gondally male. Phenotypically somewhere leaning towards female.

Hope this helps.

OP posts:
SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 10/11/2026 05:13

Transperson · 10/11/2026 04:18

"Transwomen are male" - not phenotypically, although most are in terms of genetic and gonadal sex.

I believe my last reply covers the rest of the message.

Having boobs doesn't stop a man being a man. Nothing you have done to your body stops you being a man. Nothing else needs to be said really. Everything else is cope.

allthemind · 10/11/2026 05:13

Even the most passing trans woman is still a male. And the vast majority dont pass very well, due to male bone structure, gait and having gone through male puberty. Boys who are castrated before puberty might end up looking a bit more typically female, but that's child abuse. Degree of passing, or phenotypical presentation as you call it, is irrelevant anyway. Humans cant change sex. If you're born male and choose to identify as trans and present as a stereotypical woman, fine, up to you, but you remain a male and dont qualify under the legal protections for access to female spaces.

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 05:15

Also on UK prison stats. Although this is of course useful for analysing the risk of physical harm to female people for the safeguarding decision to exclude all male prisoners, as mentioned up thread there are many other harms that inclusion of male people can result in for the female people who need that provision to exclude male people.

This was a question answered in Parliament in 23 December 2024:
https://questions-statements.parliament.uk/written-questions/detail/2024-12-16/20298.

Question from Rebecca Paul (MP Reigate): To ask the Secretary of State for Justice, with reference to the HMPPS Offender Equalities Annual Report 2023-2024, published on 28 November 2024, how many of the 50 transgender prisoners who reported their legal gender as female were convicted of a sexual offence.

Answer from Sir Richard Dakin (MP Scunthorpe): 23 December 2024
Of the 245 transgender prisoners who reported their legal gender as male (i.e. those who now identify as women, non-binary or gender-fluid) on 31 March 2024, 151 were convicted of a sexual offence. This includes both contact and non-contact sexual offences. Offence data was not available for 1 individual.

Of the 50 transgender prisoners who reported their legal gender as female on 31 March 2024, the number convicted of a sexual offence is five or fewer. We do not provide exact data for such small sample sizes as it risks identification of individuals. This approach is in line with our standards on data disclosure.

Just a note on this:

Regarding the % of male prisoners in UK with transgender identities. The mentioned above for the year ending 31 March 2024 had the figure that 151 of the 243 male prisoners in the UK prisons had at least one sex offence on their record.

The ratio changed from 43.3% (88/203) having at least one sex offence to their name at 31 March 2023 to 151/243 to 62.1% as at 31 March 2024.

The increase of the overall number of male prisoners with transgender identities in the UK prisons between 2023 and 2024 was only 42 yet the increase in the sex offenders was 63.
In 2019, there were 3.3% of female people in UK prisons were sex offenders. I haven’t looked up the stats since. But I wouldn’t expect this will be different. Last time I looked at the raw stats for female sex offences, they had remained stable numbers for a decade or more despite population growth.
For male people with transgender identities to have the same rate of committing sex offences, there would be 8 (3.3% of 243) prisoners with trans identities in the UK prison population with sex offences.

8
Not 151.

And if someone tries to suggest that the majority of these male prisoners have declared that they are women to gain access to the female prisons, I doubt this is true.

Considering the sex crime numbers for that prison population jumped from 88 to 151 male prisoners with a sex offence that declared they were women in a year (31 March 2024 to 31 March 2024) AFTER the publishing of the guidance in early February 2023, I seriously doubt these new prisoners are making declarations for the benefit of getting into the female prison.

Adding this:

Here is data from the MoJ

Here is an FOI request from 30 April 2024

https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/populationoftransgenderoffend/response/2641337/attach/html/7/FOI%20240322022%20Annex%20A.xlsx.html

Up to the 31st March 2023, the MoJ stated that of the 88 male transgender prisoners with one or more sexual offences.

The breakdown was
48 rapes,
0 attempted rapes,
10 Sexual assault or attempted sexual assault,
13 causing or inciting a child under 16 to engage in sexual activity,
0 indecent assault or gross indecency
6 sexual activity with a child under 16
0 other
77 listed here.... BUT there is a total of 88 in the total so there is 11 crimes not noted.

Possessing or making indecent photographs or pseudo photographs of child has not been recorded in this FOI.

However, there is are further discrepancies in the data of the following when you look at TOTAL NUMBER OF TRANSGENDER PRISONERS SENTENCED FOR A PRINCIPAL SEXUAL OFFENCE.

1 causing or inciting a child under 16 to engage in sexual activity
3 rapes
2 sexual activity with a child under 16
3 Sexual assault or attempted sexual assault,

This equals 9 additional... however the sum for TOTAL NUMBER OF TRANSGENDER PRISONERS SENTENCED FOR A PRINCIPAL SEXUAL OFFENCE is 99.

Therefore 2 more sex crimes have been hidden from this data.

There were 203 males who were declared as transgender in the prison at the time.

There were 24 NB who were not segregated into male and female.
What is key here, is that THIS IS NON-GRC HOLDERS. And we all know that males holding GRCs have increased and they are excluded from this data. NO female people with transgender identities were sentenced to a principal sexual offence. There were 41 female people with transgender identities in UK prisons at that time.

As a comparison, I have stats that say as of April 2019 that the general male MoJ data for male sex offenders was just 16.8% of the male prison population.

And there were 3.3% of female people in UK prisons were sex offenders.
I will leave you to do your own sums.

But... even using the figure of 88/203 is 43.3%. (And that doesn't include making or possessing indecent photographs of a child remember.)
By the way this exercise was done in 2021. And I checked this data myself from the data source and it was correct at the time. So, it will give some back ground to the above.

The ones that say that in the March/April 2021 data collection period, the MoJ stated that of the 97 transgender prisoners with one or more sexual offences.

The breakdown was
40 rapes,
8 attempted rapes,
31 possessing or making indecent photographs or pseudo photographs of child,
32 Sexual assault or attempted sexual assault,
20 causing or inciting a child under 16 to engage in sexual activity,
10 indecent assault or gross indecency
9 sexual activity with a child under 16
27 other

The 97 sex offender transgender prisons collected 177 sentences between them.

And that according to that FOI 197 prisoners are transgender.

This is why NO SUB GROUP OF MALE PEOPLE SHOULD BE EXEMPT FROM RISK ASSESSMENT. This group of male people still retain the same male pattern of committing sex and violent crime, at any stage of transition. And this is analysis is not covering any other harms to female people with the inclusion of male people in female prison.

How much additional harm (any type of harm) to female prisoners should be considered acceptable to justify allowing male people with transgender identities to access any female single sex provision ?

Helleofabore · 10/11/2026 05:25

Transperson · 10/11/2026 05:06

Hiya, thanks for another reply, to your previous replies & others I would get back to them tomorrow.

Sex is divided to phenotypic, gonadal, and genetic. Medically transitioing effects phenotypic sex.

By this I am not saying it's 100% one or another, but that it simply has an effect.

So a medically transitioned trans women most commonly is genotypically and gondally male. Phenotypically somewhere leaning towards female.

Hope this helps.

Edited

”By this I am not saying it's 100% one or another, but that it simply has an effect”

How?

“Medically transitioing effects phenotypic sex.”

in what way?

A cavity seen into the groin of a male person is in no way a vagina?

Many male people have their testes removed, it doesn’t make them no longer male. Many male people develop breast tissue however, those breasts are in no way the complete interactive feeding system that female breasts are. Male breast development, even when male people produce a substance from their breast, is not the complete interactive feeding system because those breasts lack the feedback system that female people have with their infant.

So, please provide the evidence that has been written by medical experts that support your claim about male people phenotypically changing sex. Because a male person who chooses to have extreme body modification is still a male person. They are a male person with a body modification.

They are in no way a female person.

Simulated body parts are not change a person’s phenotypical sex. Those additional body parts are facsimiles in appearance (depending on the success) and the removal of sex organs that were once present doesn’t change a person’s sex.

A woman who has her ovaries removed has not become closer to being male than she did before.

ChocolateCinderToffee · 10/11/2026 05:27

MyAmpleSheep · 10/11/2026 04:10

There are about 20 trans people in Scottish jails, that's roughly 0.000360652% of the population and 0.23% of the jail population (20/8517) or 0.36 per 100k. General populace rate is 154 per 100k. At that sample count you can't really conclude any patterns since they are so few trans people in prisons (pre-empting the argument that trans people are sexual offenders and dangerous, feel free to double check my maths).

If you provide some actual maths, I'm happy to critique it. A sample size of 20 is plenty big enough for a lot of things. Google tells me 26 trans people are serving prison sentences in Scotland as of March 2026, and "prison reports generally summarize that most prisoners in the transgender cohort are serving time for violent or sexual offenses".

Any group of people would have a few bad apples but it doesn't mean we treat the entire group as bad.

You're missing the point. We don't let any other good (or bad) men use facilities for women either, and we don't exclude just the bad men. We simply exclude men. All of them. That is, we don't exclude men because they're bad. We exclude them because they're men.

In your opinion does it matter if the trans person is being respectful?

The respectful trans person is the one using the correct facilities for their sex.

If not, what is it about their presence that could make someone uncomfortable

It is the presence of someone of the inappropriate sex for the service or situation that makes people uncomfortable.

Any statistician will tell you that a good sample size is 1,000.

Twenty is nowhere near large enough for a sample.

Prekoc2 · 10/11/2026 05:27

I use single sex spaces that align with my phenotypic presentation and no one precieved me differently than my representation...

Did you ask everyone in those spaces? Because otherwise, unless you're a mind-reader, you can't possibly know this.

TheSandgroper · 10/11/2026 05:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mellongoose · 10/11/2026 05:28

Phenotypically you might be “leaning towards female “, but this is defined as “observable traits “. It does not mean you are female and therefore you, as well as any other male, has no business being in female only spaces.

It has no bearing on whether I want to spend time with you as my friend. My friends are respectful, law abiding people.

Mapletree1985 · 10/11/2026 05:31

I have no feelings about trans individuals one way or the other, unless I know them personally. If I know them personally, my feelings about them are based on who they are as a person.

I deeply dislike trans ideology, by which I mean the array of ideas which, taken collectively, are used to justify the belief that human beings can change sex and men can become women. I hate what it has done to our society, the way it has systematically undermined the rights of women, corrupted the language, damaged so many childhoods, wounded women's sport, created a great deal of injustice, undermined once-great civil rights institutions, and denied to human beings the rights to their own experiences and perceptions.

You aren't a woman, OP. I don't know what you mean by saying you're "phenotypically" a woman, but I'm guessing what it boils down to is that you have spent a lot of time and money altering your appearance so that you outwardly resemble a woman. You aren't a woman, because your body cannot do naturally what most women's bodies (unless they have a medical condition) can do without surgery, hormones, or other interventions. Being born male is not a medical condition.

I am a woman. I am also a person, and of course I'm much more than just a woman, just as you are a person and much more than just a man. My womanhood doesn't define my personhood. But the sex of my body dictates my status as a woman. I could undergo all kinds of procedures to alter the appearance of my body and interfere with its natural functions, but nothing could alter the fundamental fact of its sex.

Owenspannas · 10/11/2026 05:33

I have been the victim of male on female violence/ abuse during two separate periods in my life. Single sex spaces are often areas where women are vulnerable. Unfortunately I would not feel safe in areas like toilets or on a hospital ward if I was there with a man. I’m aware the vast majority of men would never hurt me but that doesn’t alleviate my fears as I’ve encountered men who did. A transwoman is still male. They still have the extra strength and power that their male DNA gives them, like the strength a man used to beat me. They still have a penis like a man used to rape me. Please understand that I’m not saying that I expect a trans woman to hurt me. I don’t expect any male to hurt me. I know that they have the power to do so if they wanted to. Surely I have a right to feel safe in certain, private, spaces? Men and women are segregated for a reason and a person deciding that they feel different from the sex they are shouldn’t trump that.

Brainworm · 10/11/2026 05:41

Transperson · 10/11/2026 05:06

Hiya, thanks for another reply, to your previous replies & others I would get back to them tomorrow.

Sex is divided to phenotypic, gonadal, and genetic. Medically transitioing effects phenotypic sex.

By this I am not saying it's 100% one or another, but that it simply has an effect.

So a medically transitioned trans women most commonly is genotypically and gondally male. Phenotypically somewhere leaning towards female.

Hope this helps.

Edited

Thanks for responding to the question.

From your position, the question you are posing is why should a people who were born male but are no longer male be excluded from female only provision.

Before discussing the rights/ wrongs of exclusion/ inclusion, the issue as to whether people can stop being the sex they were born arises.

I expect back in the day, before transactivism resulted in widespread promotion of bonkers ideas, I expect this discussion would be framed around whether post op transwomen who had had their penises removed should access female only provision. This would result in a range of responses both philosophical and pragmatic.

Linking this back to your original post - I maintain that few people dislike trans people. I think the majority are happy to share unisex spaces with transwomen, but believe they should not access female only spaces. Amongst this group, I think there is probably a 50:50 split between those who make an exception for those who have had their penis removed. However, statistics suggest that this involves around 5% of the UK’s transwomen population.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.