Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

UK violated the rights of a woman prosecuted by the man she accused of rape - UN

15 replies

IwantToRetire · 09/11/2026 00:04

The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has found that the UK violated the rights of Eleanor de Freitas who took her own life after being prosecuted for allegedly making a false rape accusation.

In a landmark decision and the first ever decision by CEDAW against the UK under its optional protocol, the Committee has found in favour of the case brought by Centre for Women’s Justice on behalf of Eleanor’s father. It recommends reform of the law to ensure effective safeguards are in place to help protect women from retaliation and revictimisation by those they accuse of rape.

A summary of the facts of the case and decision is set out in the Committee’s press release. The committee recommends that the UK amends its legislative framework to prevent the use of private prosecutions in such cases.

Full press release https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/uk-failed-to-protect-woman-prosecuted-by-man-she-accused-of-rape

UK failed to protect woman prosecuted by man she accused of rape — CWJ

The UN Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has found that the UK violated the rights of Eleanor de Freitas who took her own life after being prosecuted for allegedly making a false rape accusation. In a landmark decisio...

https://www.centreforwomensjustice.org.uk/updates/uk-failed-to-protect-woman-prosecuted-by-man-she-accused-of-rape

OP posts:
NowSober · 09/11/2026 11:44

Two DPPs Keir Starmer & Alison Saunders thought it correct to prosecute Eleanor de Freitas for making false rape allegations. Doctors thought her fit for trial. She was vulnerable & possibly had a defence of insanity so should have been better supported but it wasn't wrong to prosecute her. It's a mirror of the current case of the mysterious celebrity threatening suicide if allegations are published.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/11/2026 12:21

I remember this case, and I don’t think alleged perpetrators should be allowed to bring private prosecution for false accusations- it’s obvious that many rich people will take advantage of that.

Manxexile · 09/11/2026 14:15

Ereshkigalangcleg · 09/11/2026 12:21

I remember this case, and I don’t think alleged perpetrators should be allowed to bring private prosecution for false accusations- it’s obvious that many rich people will take advantage of that.

But this case wasn't as simple as that, was it?

It wasn't about the alleged perpetrator being wealthy enough to initiate a private prosecution after the met decided not to prosecute the original allegation against him

As @NowSober has pointed out, not only did the CPS take over the case (quite usual in private criminal prosecutions) but they also decided to continue to prosecute it (pretty unusual for private prosecutions) and, AIUI, this decision was backed by two DPPs - Keir Starmer and his successor, Alison Saunders.

Yes it's terrible that she committed suicide, but AIUI her doctors did not consider her to be a suicide risk.

Unfortunately people facing criminal trial do sometimes decide to end it all. We don't always know why.

It is a strange sort of parallel with the celebrity recently arguing for the law to gag a couple of news outlets otherwise they'll kill themselves.

SockPlant · 09/11/2026 19:03

so what that means, using this as a precident, that person can get to fuck with the injunction and take his chances with his own mental health

IwantToRetire · 09/11/2026 20:33

Thanks for the background information, although depressing.

I just happened to see the press release from Centre for Women's Justice.

I dont think this made the national news.

But it should have done. Even if some of us have doubts about the UN its good to have the UK scrutinised, and found at fault.

OP posts:
IwantToRetire · 10/11/2026 01:59

MrsOvertonsWindow · 09/11/2026 10:39

Thank you IWTR.
That's very telling following the revelations about the injunction convicted rapist Brand & Jemima Khan have against a women who accused him of assault.

https://x.com/DanNeidle/status/2119006130588303432

Don't want to hijack this thread to make it about Brand but there is a statement from Jemima Khan about their injunction.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c95ynylr8j6xo

OP posts:
womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:11

IwantToRetire · 10/11/2026 01:59

Don't want to hijack this thread to make it about Brand but there is a statement from Jemima Khan about their injunction.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c95ynylr8j6xo

I don't care if the allegations are true or not, argue with the allegations. Silencing people entirely to the extent they can't even talk to their friends or family because you're rich is vile, inhumane and should be illegal.

And I note that Khan is free to talk about this apparently to the biased broadcaster and give her version of events but the other side is not. That's horrific bullying and removal of this woman's human right to free speech whatever the truth of what happened.

I tend to think if the allegations were completely made up they wouldn't have bothered with an injunction though. Unless they just enjoy abusing poorer people for no reason. Maybe that's it.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:17

NowSober · 09/11/2026 11:44

Two DPPs Keir Starmer & Alison Saunders thought it correct to prosecute Eleanor de Freitas for making false rape allegations. Doctors thought her fit for trial. She was vulnerable & possibly had a defence of insanity so should have been better supported but it wasn't wrong to prosecute her. It's a mirror of the current case of the mysterious celebrity threatening suicide if allegations are published.

Well it seems there's one rule for the rich and one for the not rich.

The CEDAW report says that de Freitas's counselling was reduced due to the court case - this is just plain wrong.

I wonder what the downside of the CPS dropping the case was? Why did they spend taxpayers money taking it forward and was that decision really in the public interest? In the context of grooming gang abusers and enablers never facing justice?

There is nuance as with everything but my conclusion is the rich can use the law in a variety of ways to strip the poor of their human rights. Any sunlight on this is good.

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:21

IwantToRetire · 09/11/2026 20:33

Thanks for the background information, although depressing.

I just happened to see the press release from Centre for Women's Justice.

I dont think this made the national news.

But it should have done. Even if some of us have doubts about the UN its good to have the UK scrutinised, and found at fault.

Agree, any scrutiny is good. I haven't read the full report, but I think it may well be the case that there is some nuance.

It seems, as in the Jemima silencing poorer women case, restrictions on basic liberties may have contributed.

Women should be able to talk to counselors and a court case should not be able to halt or reduce essential medical care.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 14:47

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:11

I don't care if the allegations are true or not, argue with the allegations. Silencing people entirely to the extent they can't even talk to their friends or family because you're rich is vile, inhumane and should be illegal.

And I note that Khan is free to talk about this apparently to the biased broadcaster and give her version of events but the other side is not. That's horrific bullying and removal of this woman's human right to free speech whatever the truth of what happened.

I tend to think if the allegations were completely made up they wouldn't have bothered with an injunction though. Unless they just enjoy abusing poorer people for no reason. Maybe that's it.

I agree with you. If it met the definition of harassment which the claimed posts do, then why not just go to the police? Like pp I think these type of injunctions are usually just a shady way people with money shut down scrutiny and silence critics.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 14:49

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:17

Well it seems there's one rule for the rich and one for the not rich.

The CEDAW report says that de Freitas's counselling was reduced due to the court case - this is just plain wrong.

I wonder what the downside of the CPS dropping the case was? Why did they spend taxpayers money taking it forward and was that decision really in the public interest? In the context of grooming gang abusers and enablers never facing justice?

There is nuance as with everything but my conclusion is the rich can use the law in a variety of ways to strip the poor of their human rights. Any sunlight on this is good.

I do agree with you, and also as someone who has alleged rape I don’t see why her lifelong anonymity was removed.

Grammarnut · 10/11/2026 23:16

womendeserveequalhumanrights · 10/11/2026 09:17

Well it seems there's one rule for the rich and one for the not rich.

The CEDAW report says that de Freitas's counselling was reduced due to the court case - this is just plain wrong.

I wonder what the downside of the CPS dropping the case was? Why did they spend taxpayers money taking it forward and was that decision really in the public interest? In the context of grooming gang abusers and enablers never facing justice?

There is nuance as with everything but my conclusion is the rich can use the law in a variety of ways to strip the poor of their human rights. Any sunlight on this is good.

But the man accused was not rick afaik? And false rape allegations are damaging. But the poor woman should never have faced a trial if her mental state was vulnerable.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 00:45

When Julie was a Guardian writer still!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread