Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Woman with alopecia accused of being male while using female toilet at Tesco

1000 replies

MintBird · 08/11/2026 13:24

https://www.chroniclelive.co.uk/news/north-east-news/gateshead-woman-alopecia-accused-being-34873020

"The 37-year-old, who has had the hair loss condition since she was a child, said she was left shocked when a cleaner at the Trinity Square shop asked her "Are you aware you're in the female toilet?" She said she became distressed and burst into tears."

But I thought people "could always tell"?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:02

@nicepotoftea
Yes, the police do have this database. Facial recognition of adults does not require a recent photo. Obviously a photo of only the back of a head is going to be useless.

ME taking this seriously:
It is not a criminal offence to accidentally go into the wrong toilet but if a pattern of behaviour emerges from logged reports of repeated, deliberate entry into the wrong toilet and they have these reports where we have said we were alarmed and intimidated that is harrassment and they will take further action.

YOU minimising and I suspect not caring about the danger:
“All that when somebody could have just said 'I'm sorry, I think you might be in the wrong loo"?”

Mild comments from women are not a deterrent to these men as they view us as subhuman. It is almost like telling a shoplifter- oh the cash registers are that way and carrying on like nothing has happened.

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 11:02

I can imagine there’s lots of people that go on these threads to try and argue and find loopholes.

They won’t be able to without changing all sorts of legislation and regulations that have been in place for decades.

For instance Robin Moira White very persistently goes into women’s toilets, even when there is alternative. Women reported him and got an apology in a Parliament building yet the behaviour hasn’t stopped.
It is so well documented that it would be a good case to take to court.

I see the photos of different men posing in women’s public toilets in very sexual ways and putting these photos on to social media. I think that’s something that is very much leaning towards the spirit of the Sexual Offences Act and harassment.

I don’t think a woman taking a photo of a man in the ladies toilet to show he is there, is an offence as it can be argued effectively he shouldn’t be there. He doesn’t have Article 8 rights due to exemptions for safety and welfare of women. Safety is absolute. Privacy is not.

edit: because I am at work and rushing and realise I don’t want my words to be taken out of the safety context in which I am writing.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:03

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 10:55

Well all that is invisible labour we women should not have to do. In some cases, we can even be charged with harrassment if asking are you in right toilet morphs into a larger confrontation where we start demanding they tell us their sex and speculating on perverse intentions.

I'm getting a gut feeling that you are looking for excuses for men not to be challenged.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 11:07

An ideology that claims to reject gender stereotypes leading to laws that can only be implemented through enforcing them...

One of the many contradictions of "gender critical feminism".

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:07

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:02

@nicepotoftea
Yes, the police do have this database. Facial recognition of adults does not require a recent photo. Obviously a photo of only the back of a head is going to be useless.

ME taking this seriously:
It is not a criminal offence to accidentally go into the wrong toilet but if a pattern of behaviour emerges from logged reports of repeated, deliberate entry into the wrong toilet and they have these reports where we have said we were alarmed and intimidated that is harrassment and they will take further action.

YOU minimising and I suspect not caring about the danger:
“All that when somebody could have just said 'I'm sorry, I think you might be in the wrong loo"?”

Mild comments from women are not a deterrent to these men as they view us as subhuman. It is almost like telling a shoplifter- oh the cash registers are that way and carrying on like nothing has happened.

Comments from women absolutley do shatter the fantasy - even if only temporarily. I have to admit I'm now going to withdraw from this exchange with you. I feel I'm being manipulated.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:08

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 10:34

That’s my thought too.

Laughable really, the group saying that just doing a “hey are you sure you are in the right toilet’´ and then doing nothing is not letting men get away with this even though this is invisible and largely ignored by the men as it is not a consequence but a goad. So men are and continue to get away with it. Honestly has the saying the above actually worked for the decade its been done? No it has not.

But those of us who are saying it is more serious and we need to document, report and make sure the police are logging every incident are ‘setting up a charter for men to get away with it’. No, we are the ones who are fed up and think enough is enough, the police need to do their jobs.

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:09

I personally don't trust where this thread has gone, and feel it is turning into the usual tag team endeavoiur.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:10

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:03

I'm getting a gut feeling that you are looking for excuses for men not to be challenged.

I am getting a gut feeling you want these men to have clean records and are protecting them from the police. Why is that? You think they are just naughty boys and a wise word in a motherly way will stop them?

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:12

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:10

I am getting a gut feeling you want these men to have clean records and are protecting them from the police. Why is that? You think they are just naughty boys and a wise word in a motherly way will stop them?

I think you are employing multiple hyperbolic feminine stereotypes in order to justify men continuing to carry on doing whatever it is they want.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:13

Keeptoiletssafe · 11/11/2026 11:02

I can imagine there’s lots of people that go on these threads to try and argue and find loopholes.

They won’t be able to without changing all sorts of legislation and regulations that have been in place for decades.

For instance Robin Moira White very persistently goes into women’s toilets, even when there is alternative. Women reported him and got an apology in a Parliament building yet the behaviour hasn’t stopped.
It is so well documented that it would be a good case to take to court.

I see the photos of different men posing in women’s public toilets in very sexual ways and putting these photos on to social media. I think that’s something that is very much leaning towards the spirit of the Sexual Offences Act and harassment.

I don’t think a woman taking a photo of a man in the ladies toilet to show he is there, is an offence as it can be argued effectively he shouldn’t be there. He doesn’t have Article 8 rights due to exemptions for safety and welfare of women. Safety is absolute. Privacy is not.

edit: because I am at work and rushing and realise I don’t want my words to be taken out of the safety context in which I am writing.

Edited

Strongly agree, court cases should be brought.

Exactly my thoughts on the photo suggestion-, he is violating the single sex space so photographing him as evidence of this public order offence is not a violation of his privacy.

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 11:15

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 10:23

@nicepotoftea

The police have facial recognition databases on everyone in the UK.
They will run the photo against the database and their ID including their sex will come up.
If you saw a woman, they will tell you that and NFA
If you saw a man, they will tell you and log the incident.

It is not a criminal offence to accidentally go into the wrong toilet but if a pattern of behaviour emerges from logged reports of repeated, deliberate entry into the wrong toilet and they have these reports where we have said we were alarmed and intimidated that is harrassment and they will take further action.

Edited

I'm confused as to how saying 'Excuse me, this is the Ladies' equals 'police state', but the preferred alternative is to take photographs, presumably surreptitiously because it would be confrontational to do so openly, and pass the photos on to <checks notes> the police who have
facial recognition databases on everyone in the UK.
They will run the photo against the database and their ID including their sex will come up.

So very much less police-state-y than 'Excuse me, this is the Ladies' ..

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:16

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:12

I think you are employing multiple hyperbolic feminine stereotypes in order to justify men continuing to carry on doing whatever it is they want.

Rubbish. You are continuing to enable them to carry on with the mild comment that endangers your own safety approach as it has not made a drop of difference since this was started around 2015 if memory serves.

These men will only respect the full force of the law which means police and court. Time to do that.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 11:17

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:02

@nicepotoftea
Yes, the police do have this database. Facial recognition of adults does not require a recent photo. Obviously a photo of only the back of a head is going to be useless.

ME taking this seriously:
It is not a criminal offence to accidentally go into the wrong toilet but if a pattern of behaviour emerges from logged reports of repeated, deliberate entry into the wrong toilet and they have these reports where we have said we were alarmed and intimidated that is harrassment and they will take further action.

YOU minimising and I suspect not caring about the danger:
“All that when somebody could have just said 'I'm sorry, I think you might be in the wrong loo"?”

Mild comments from women are not a deterrent to these men as they view us as subhuman. It is almost like telling a shoplifter- oh the cash registers are that way and carrying on like nothing has happened.

No they do not have a database that covers everyone in the UK. Where do you think this would come from?

I cannot comment on whether you are taking this seriously. I assume that you are sincere but just haven't thought some of this through, and are sticking to your guns because that is what people do on social media. I appreciate that you acknowledge that using an opposite sex toilet is not a criminal offence and that something more is required to involve the police. Perhaps you are also just unusually sensitive to awkward social situations.

It is almost like telling a shoplifter- oh the cash registers are that way and carrying on like nothing has happened.

Have you not noticed how few shop lifters are prosecuted when they are clearly committing a criminal offence and almost always in a place with CCTV?

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 11:17

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 10:50

Reports to security should be passed on to the police who will be able to log different incidents anywhere in the country. A photo will mean they can ID the perpetrator and log multiple incidents against his record.

Direct confrontation with no reporting is invisible. They will just come back later or use a different one and keep getting away with it.

Also, according to sex matters, a man ignoring a sign or symbol for a women’s toilet is actually committing a public order offence by entering.
”A man who chooses to disregard the notice is not exercising a human right; he is breaking a rule that exists to protect women.
This could amount to harassment under the Equality Act and might amount to a public-order offence.”
https://sex-matters.org/posts/updates/the-truth-about-toilets/

This is bullshit.
There is no public order offence of entering a toilet designated for the opposite sex. None. Public order offences require threatening, abusive or disorderly behaviour. Walking in and using a cubicle is not that.

The claim about the Equality Act is even more stupid. Section 26 harassment is civil, not criminal, and the Act places duties on service providers and employers, not on a member of the public using a toilet. An individual user cannot "commit harassment under the Equality Act" by being in the room.

What the law actually says: a provider can lawfully run single-sex toilets, and someone who breaks the provider's rule can be asked to leave. That is it. Criminal liability only arises from what a person does beyond entering.

"Might amount to" is doing all the work in that quote, and stating it as "is actually committing an offence" is simply false. Telling people something is a crime when it isn't is misinformation.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 11:19

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 11:17

This is bullshit.
There is no public order offence of entering a toilet designated for the opposite sex. None. Public order offences require threatening, abusive or disorderly behaviour. Walking in and using a cubicle is not that.

The claim about the Equality Act is even more stupid. Section 26 harassment is civil, not criminal, and the Act places duties on service providers and employers, not on a member of the public using a toilet. An individual user cannot "commit harassment under the Equality Act" by being in the room.

What the law actually says: a provider can lawfully run single-sex toilets, and someone who breaks the provider's rule can be asked to leave. That is it. Criminal liability only arises from what a person does beyond entering.

"Might amount to" is doing all the work in that quote, and stating it as "is actually committing an offence" is simply false. Telling people something is a crime when it isn't is misinformation.

A stopped clock is right once a day, and I there is nothing here with which I disagree.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:21

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 11:15

I'm confused as to how saying 'Excuse me, this is the Ladies' equals 'police state', but the preferred alternative is to take photographs, presumably surreptitiously because it would be confrontational to do so openly, and pass the photos on to <checks notes> the police who have
facial recognition databases on everyone in the UK.
They will run the photo against the database and their ID including their sex will come up.

So very much less police-state-y than 'Excuse me, this is the Ladies' ..

I am confused too as I have not objected to challenge/confrontation on the basis of ‘police state’ but rather on the basis that it is useless, endangers safety, mostly hurts other women as mistakes are common, acts as a goad not a deterrent to these men and we need to take it more seriously and involve the police by documenting and reporting.

So in the case of men using the women’s toilets, I am all for a police state approach to put an end to it.

I guess I am taking it more seriously than my critics are.

DrudgeJedd · 11/11/2026 11:22

Shortshriftandlethal · 11/11/2026 11:12

I think you are employing multiple hyperbolic feminine stereotypes in order to justify men continuing to carry on doing whatever it is they want.

I agree, LiberteLynx seems to think that a police force who doesn't have the will or capacity to attend burglaries has access to some kind of Mission Impossible/007 instant facial recognition database and will create a naughty list of toilet creeps.
Seems too far-fetched to be credible

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:22

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 11:17

This is bullshit.
There is no public order offence of entering a toilet designated for the opposite sex. None. Public order offences require threatening, abusive or disorderly behaviour. Walking in and using a cubicle is not that.

The claim about the Equality Act is even more stupid. Section 26 harassment is civil, not criminal, and the Act places duties on service providers and employers, not on a member of the public using a toilet. An individual user cannot "commit harassment under the Equality Act" by being in the room.

What the law actually says: a provider can lawfully run single-sex toilets, and someone who breaks the provider's rule can be asked to leave. That is it. Criminal liability only arises from what a person does beyond entering.

"Might amount to" is doing all the work in that quote, and stating it as "is actually committing an offence" is simply false. Telling people something is a crime when it isn't is misinformation.

Ok, well it is what sex matters has published. Perhaps take your BS claim to them so they can make any corrections necessary.

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:27

DrudgeJedd · 11/11/2026 11:22

I agree, LiberteLynx seems to think that a police force who doesn't have the will or capacity to attend burglaries has access to some kind of Mission Impossible/007 instant facial recognition database and will create a naughty list of toilet creeps.
Seems too far-fetched to be credible

The database exists. It is not mission impossible sci fi either. It probably was twenty years ago. Today it is not that special. I don’t think people realise the technology the police have.

Lack of adequate police funding is another matter.
They seem to have the resources to prosecute women for tweeting sex is sex though?

It is a matter of demand. If we do not demand it by failing to report, we can be sure nothing will be done.

If we report and make a public fuss about tens of thousands of reports ignored or god forbid a girl is raped and then it comes to light there were a dozen reports of this man going into the women’s toilets.

I think there is a link, just like flashing was once considered to be harmless so no one reported it. Then they later found flashing is on the path to rape attacks…so now flashing is taken seriously and we are encouraged to report it.

or you can give up and think a mild comment is going to suddenly start working …

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 11:34

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:27

The database exists. It is not mission impossible sci fi either. It probably was twenty years ago. Today it is not that special. I don’t think people realise the technology the police have.

Lack of adequate police funding is another matter.
They seem to have the resources to prosecute women for tweeting sex is sex though?

It is a matter of demand. If we do not demand it by failing to report, we can be sure nothing will be done.

If we report and make a public fuss about tens of thousands of reports ignored or god forbid a girl is raped and then it comes to light there were a dozen reports of this man going into the women’s toilets.

I think there is a link, just like flashing was once considered to be harmless so no one reported it. Then they later found flashing is on the path to rape attacks…so now flashing is taken seriously and we are encouraged to report it.

or you can give up and think a mild comment is going to suddenly start working …

Edited

Again, where do you think they are getting this information.

In particular, where do you think they are acquiring information on people's sex?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 11:35

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cddjlmeqjgyo

I accept that some businesses are taking matters into their own hands and that that the technology described in the article below has been invented. It's just not yet clear that it works.

Close-up portrait of Matt Arnold, a man with light brown hair tied back, glasses, and a beard, wearing a white t-shirt outside with a Sainsbury's store blurred in the background.

Sainsbury's branch pauses AI cameras use after shopper ejected

Matt Arnold says he was asked to leave the store after being wrongly flagged as a shoplifter.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cddjlmeqjgyo

MarieDeGournay · 11/11/2026 11:36

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:21

I am confused too as I have not objected to challenge/confrontation on the basis of ‘police state’ but rather on the basis that it is useless, endangers safety, mostly hurts other women as mistakes are common, acts as a goad not a deterrent to these men and we need to take it more seriously and involve the police by documenting and reporting.

So in the case of men using the women’s toilets, I am all for a police state approach to put an end to it.

I guess I am taking it more seriously than my critics are.

Fair enough, I wasn't sure it who it was who first used the term 'police state' to characterise 'Excuse me, this is the Ladies'.

I sort-of agree with you, it would be great to have a crack team of law enforcers to get men the feck out of spaces they are not entitled to be in, just as it would be great to have a crack team of building regs inspectors to restore women's toilets as required by building regs...

But [a] how practical is it in the context of current law enforcement arrangements, and [b] can you imagine the decibel level of TRAs and their allies protesting about transwomen being marched out of women's toilets in the way you suggest?
Live-streaming their martyrdom?
Not to mention the likely appearance of bottles of urine?

Like you, I'd love it to be taken more seriously, but can you actually see it happening?

BackToLurk · 11/11/2026 11:38

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 11:07

An ideology that claims to reject gender stereotypes leading to laws that can only be implemented through enforcing them...

One of the many contradictions of "gender critical feminism".

The GRA enshrined in law the requirement to ‘live as your acquired gender’. You don’t get a more obvious example of enforced gender stereotypes than that. Good to see you reject it.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 11:38

LiberteLynx · 11/11/2026 11:27

The database exists. It is not mission impossible sci fi either. It probably was twenty years ago. Today it is not that special. I don’t think people realise the technology the police have.

Lack of adequate police funding is another matter.
They seem to have the resources to prosecute women for tweeting sex is sex though?

It is a matter of demand. If we do not demand it by failing to report, we can be sure nothing will be done.

If we report and make a public fuss about tens of thousands of reports ignored or god forbid a girl is raped and then it comes to light there were a dozen reports of this man going into the women’s toilets.

I think there is a link, just like flashing was once considered to be harmless so no one reported it. Then they later found flashing is on the path to rape attacks…so now flashing is taken seriously and we are encouraged to report it.

or you can give up and think a mild comment is going to suddenly start working …

Edited

If we report and make a public fuss about tens of thousands of reports ignored

Reports of what?

If the cleaner had not said anything but just continued to report this woman as using the wrong loo (having failed to get a new prescription for glasses), what would have happened next?

DrudgeJedd · 11/11/2026 11:38

Oh give over, the CPS and multiple police forces have years of evidence about grooming gangs and have had to be dragged into bringing these cases to court. They're not giving one minute of their time to this unless an actual assault happened.
A social contract is enforced, in the first instance, by members of society not the police.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread