Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Anti-trans media undermine human rights.

209 replies

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 10:31

The University of Birmingham has published a report (and associated timeline) on its website, to the above effect. Report and timeline are also linked by Trans Media Watch here:

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that - I only found the report by accident, and haven't seen it mentioned in MSM.

How Anti-Trans Media Undermines Human Rights and Equality for Everyone – Trans Media Watch

https://transmediawatch.org/how-anti-trans-media-undermines-human-rights-and-equality-for-everyone

OP posts:
StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 22:45

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 20:17

The main proposal for countering the problem appears to involve press regulation, although it's unclear how they intend to drum up support for that.

Regulation of misinformation/disinformation & a balance of views would seem to be the obvious answer which are already journalistic standards so perhaps a review of practices is in order? Education of school children on media bias & its consequences?

"We need to recognise anti-trans media as part of a wider reactionary agenda."

Whatever you think about trans people, like immigrants & gay people they are the canaries in the coal mine in an effort to erode general human rights. History shows us that sustained media hate campaigns primed citizens for acceptance & participation of the human rights abuses that followed in the Holocaust, Rwanda, Bosnia, Myanmar & Cambodia.

"First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me"

-Niemoller

What human rights do transpeople not have that everyone else does?

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:25

While I agree with your rage bait point, I suspect your knowledge of history may be limited. It's not right vs left that determines human rights outrages and atrocities, it's authoritarianism/totalitarianism vs freedom of choice.

If you are thinking more in terms of more recent times since the 60's rather than Nazi Germany or Stalin's Russia, its usually the right in modern western democracies that's more on the authoritarianism/totalitarianism side of the ledger.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:52

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:44

Yes, when you know the content of the rseearch, if you squint a bit you can see how the title fits it.

But, again, the title is - I would say deliberately - written to imply something much wider and more insidious than the research actually captured. To the degree I consider the title and the summary politically motivated misinformation in their own right. The fact you happen to agree with it should not give it a free pass.

It's been interesting watching you go through the process as your posts have gone on of going from what you thought the research was saying to what it was actually saying.

Edited

I also very much think that the phrase "Anti trans media..." is a weaselly one. It means, in the context of the research, anti LGBTQIA+ media content was being leverged the Eurosceptic media to undermine the ECtHR. But it reads as if there is a cabal of "Anti trans media" who are actively working to undermine human rights.

Two meanings of media - the content, and the entities that produce it - are being elided to imply something different to what was actually found.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:56

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:46

If you are thinking more in terms of more recent times since the 60's rather than Nazi Germany or Stalin's Russia, its usually the right in modern western democracies that's more on the authoritarianism/totalitarianism side of the ledger.

I don't disagree. But then again, there's a big world out there, not just the West.

Framing matters. If you think the danger can only come from one side, you make yourself very vulnerable in the direction you aren't looking.

Not to mention, your concept of Left and Right is basically the US-imported one that focuses on individual liberties/identities and ignores economics. That's fine, as long as you realise that you may not be comparing like with like when you look back at history.

I tend to think less about labels and more about patterns and power.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:59

The title is technically correct in terms of how media advocacy works to undermine ideas & institutions to the public so I suspect you're overstating the matter which is to effectively imply the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception. You might want to ask yourself why deny the obvious rather than project bias onto others who are just stating a fact? Are you attempting to divert attention from the findings of this report by this bizarre obtuseness?

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:00

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 22:44

Yes, when you know the content of the rseearch, if you squint a bit you can see how the title fits it.

But, again, the title is - I would say deliberately - written to imply something much wider and more insidious than the research actually captured. To the degree I consider the title and the summary politically motivated misinformation in their own right. The fact you happen to agree with it should not give it a free pass.

It's been interesting watching you go through the process as your posts have gone on of going from what you thought the research was saying to what it was actually saying.

Edited

The title is technically correct in terms of how media advocacy works to undermine ideas & institutions to the public so I suspect you're overstating the matter which is to effectively imply the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception. You might want to ask yourself why deny the obvious rather than project bias onto others who are just stating a fact? Are you attempting to divert attention from the findings of this report by this bizarre obtuseness?

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 23:01

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:59

The title is technically correct in terms of how media advocacy works to undermine ideas & institutions to the public so I suspect you're overstating the matter which is to effectively imply the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception. You might want to ask yourself why deny the obvious rather than project bias onto others who are just stating a fact? Are you attempting to divert attention from the findings of this report by this bizarre obtuseness?

Bizarre obtuseness? Interesting that you're insulting a poster who has very respectfully engaged with your biased nonsense.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:01

StealthTroublemaker · 07/11/2026 22:45

What human rights do transpeople not have that everyone else does?

I never made such a claim.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:04

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 23:01

Bizarre obtuseness? Interesting that you're insulting a poster who has very respectfully engaged with your biased nonsense.

Sorry? Insult? Stating a comment reasonably comes across as obtuse isn't a personal insult.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 07/11/2026 23:07

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:04

Sorry? Insult? Stating a comment reasonably comes across as obtuse isn't a personal insult.

Ok. If alleging bizarre obtuseness is how you respond to others, crack on mate. Flirts doesn't need me to defend her - she's more than capable.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 23:17

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 22:59

The title is technically correct in terms of how media advocacy works to undermine ideas & institutions to the public so I suspect you're overstating the matter which is to effectively imply the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception. You might want to ask yourself why deny the obvious rather than project bias onto others who are just stating a fact? Are you attempting to divert attention from the findings of this report by this bizarre obtuseness?

You misunderstand me. In no way am I suggesting "the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception" - that seems to be a projection of your own.

But if you have to resort to saying something is "techincally" correct you are admitting it is misleading.

I am posting because I was so shocked by what the report title appeared to say that I read the report (not just the summary) and dug into the methodology to understand just how much evidence there was for it. Which is how I came to understand that what the title and summary imply, and what the research was actually looking at, are not quite the same. And I think that does matter.

You ask what is my motivation? It's very simple. I care about honesty. I care that decisions are made on good information not hyperbole and insinuation.

And as a woman I find it terrifying how hyperbole and insinuation and false narrartives have been leveraged to promote trans narratives over women's voices. So misleading, vested interest reports like this frighten me because I believe in practice they will be leveraged not to highlight a risk to human rights as a whole, but to silence women questioning why we should have to accept male people as "women" at all.

Finally, please do not insult me. Objecting to the use of misleading language, and taking the time to find out what it actually means, is not "bizarre obtuseness". You may think a misleading statement is ok if it aligns to something you believe is also true, but it's hardly "obtuse" not to agree with you.

LouisTheYardTeacher · 07/11/2026 23:29

"First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me"

And if this poem teaches us anything , it's not to trust non-binary people.

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 23:32

All of this ignores the fact that it's not the reactionary press who have been taking away rights (that trans people thought they had): it's the courts. In the last ten years, they have been asked again and again to balance the rights of trans people against those of other groups, particularly, but not exclusively, women: and with only one or two exceptions, I feel they've done a pretty conscientious job.

In what sense is it hateful for the press to report judgments approvingly and treat the winning parties sympathetically? Unless you think the highest court in the land is actually on a par with the Nazis??

Now, the authors of the report are not wrong to think (although they don't spell it out) that parliamentary democracy plus an independent judiciary alone do not guarantee perfect Rawlsian outcomes: a human rights framework is needed too. And no doubt the press are being a bit disingenuous when they pretend to worry that the ECtHR might undo the gains we've made. But I'm sure there's a genuine element of pride in our institutions in there too.

The captured press, on the other hand, moan and whine about these judgments, but never explain exactly how they are wrong. They're not even doing a good job for trans people. Criticise them.

OP posts:
AstonCanKissMyArse · 07/11/2026 23:35

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 21:51

The report has examples of how the media has specifically advocated for the roll back of rights. See above comment for particulars.

I don't want to waste my time reading it; people I trust have summarised it on this thread.

I was asking you about what you think.

I was particularly interested in:
what human rights that you think have been infringed by these outcomes (actual human rights, ref the universal declaration on human rights, not some vague manufactured sense of injustice).

I won't hold my breath, I know you don't have a (coherent) answer.

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:56

FlirtsWithRhinos · 07/11/2026 23:17

You misunderstand me. In no way am I suggesting "the absurd idea that the media has no influence on public perception" - that seems to be a projection of your own.

But if you have to resort to saying something is "techincally" correct you are admitting it is misleading.

I am posting because I was so shocked by what the report title appeared to say that I read the report (not just the summary) and dug into the methodology to understand just how much evidence there was for it. Which is how I came to understand that what the title and summary imply, and what the research was actually looking at, are not quite the same. And I think that does matter.

You ask what is my motivation? It's very simple. I care about honesty. I care that decisions are made on good information not hyperbole and insinuation.

And as a woman I find it terrifying how hyperbole and insinuation and false narrartives have been leveraged to promote trans narratives over women's voices. So misleading, vested interest reports like this frighten me because I believe in practice they will be leveraged not to highlight a risk to human rights as a whole, but to silence women questioning why we should have to accept male people as "women" at all.

Finally, please do not insult me. Objecting to the use of misleading language, and taking the time to find out what it actually means, is not "bizarre obtuseness". You may think a misleading statement is ok if it aligns to something you believe is also true, but it's hardly "obtuse" not to agree with you.

The problem is you've taken 'undermine' to mean something that conveniently aligns with the agenda of being 'misled' rather than for what its is as I have laid out. Is this interpretation obtuse? In my view yes it is because you obviously misunderstood it & particularly because its a fact you are still denying despite 'undermine' being explained to you. That you are insulted by being called out for a misinterpretation seems very blame shifting.

You ask what is my motivation? It's very simple. I care about honesty. I care that decisions are made on good information not hyperbole and insinuation.

But do you really? Given that after your misinterpretation of 'undermine' has been explained you still insist it means something else.

And as a woman I find it terrifying how hyperbole and insinuation and false narrartives have been leveraged to promote trans narratives over women's voices. So misleading, vested interest reports like this frighten me because I believe in practice they will be leveraged not to highlight a risk to human rights as a whole, but to silence women questioning why we should have to accept male people as "women" at all.

Whilst that's understandable, it seems to have created a hyper paranoia where a all amount of exploitation has been assumed at a title that you have misinterpreted. You may want to take stock of you reactions & whether they are always justified.

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:00

theilltemperedmonster · 07/11/2026 23:32

All of this ignores the fact that it's not the reactionary press who have been taking away rights (that trans people thought they had): it's the courts. In the last ten years, they have been asked again and again to balance the rights of trans people against those of other groups, particularly, but not exclusively, women: and with only one or two exceptions, I feel they've done a pretty conscientious job.

In what sense is it hateful for the press to report judgments approvingly and treat the winning parties sympathetically? Unless you think the highest court in the land is actually on a par with the Nazis??

Now, the authors of the report are not wrong to think (although they don't spell it out) that parliamentary democracy plus an independent judiciary alone do not guarantee perfect Rawlsian outcomes: a human rights framework is needed too. And no doubt the press are being a bit disingenuous when they pretend to worry that the ECtHR might undo the gains we've made. But I'm sure there's a genuine element of pride in our institutions in there too.

The captured press, on the other hand, moan and whine about these judgments, but never explain exactly how they are wrong. They're not even doing a good job for trans people. Criticise them.

None of this is relevant to the point of the report which is to say the press are exploiting trans rights to undermine rights in general.

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:17

AstonCanKissMyArse · 07/11/2026 23:35

I don't want to waste my time reading it; people I trust have summarised it on this thread.

I was asking you about what you think.

I was particularly interested in:
what human rights that you think have been infringed by these outcomes (actual human rights, ref the universal declaration on human rights, not some vague manufactured sense of injustice).

I won't hold my breath, I know you don't have a (coherent) answer.

About the media? They are attempting to shape public opinion to undermine their belief in general rights but they have not been successful as yet in actually infringing upon changing human rights.

But that is the goal. If you spend any time in many right wing circles you will find they aren't shy to tell you that its not just trans rights that are their problem but equal rights in general which they openly blame for all of societies 'problems'. They use terms like a 'feminised society' 'anti meritocracy' 'white replacement' 'lgbtq grooming' 'DEI' 'censorship' & so on as evidence of societal decay. Trans rights are simply the low hanging fruit they can weaponise against equal rights & unite strange bedfellows against.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 00:19

Aisha176 · 07/11/2026 23:56

The problem is you've taken 'undermine' to mean something that conveniently aligns with the agenda of being 'misled' rather than for what its is as I have laid out. Is this interpretation obtuse? In my view yes it is because you obviously misunderstood it & particularly because its a fact you are still denying despite 'undermine' being explained to you. That you are insulted by being called out for a misinterpretation seems very blame shifting.

You ask what is my motivation? It's very simple. I care about honesty. I care that decisions are made on good information not hyperbole and insinuation.

But do you really? Given that after your misinterpretation of 'undermine' has been explained you still insist it means something else.

And as a woman I find it terrifying how hyperbole and insinuation and false narrartives have been leveraged to promote trans narratives over women's voices. So misleading, vested interest reports like this frighten me because I believe in practice they will be leveraged not to highlight a risk to human rights as a whole, but to silence women questioning why we should have to accept male people as "women" at all.

Whilst that's understandable, it seems to have created a hyper paranoia where a all amount of exploitation has been assumed at a title that you have misinterpreted. You may want to take stock of you reactions & whether they are always justified.

Edited

You've lost me. What meaning do you think I took from "undermine", and what meaning do you think I should have taken?

Frankly, I feel like you are arguing with what you imagine I think not what I actually said. You clearly had preconceptions in mind when you started the thread because I've seen your understanding of what the report actually said shift as you read it properly.

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:23

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 00:19

You've lost me. What meaning do you think I took from "undermine", and what meaning do you think I should have taken?

Frankly, I feel like you are arguing with what you imagine I think not what I actually said. You clearly had preconceptions in mind when you started the thread because I've seen your understanding of what the report actually said shift as you read it properly.

This is what I posted upthread:

"The title is How Anti Trans Media Undermines Human Rights. The fact the media hasn't actually been successful in the removal of rights yet in the examples given doesn't change the fact the media has undermined those rights by advocating against them. That's what the point of advocating for their removal is. Advocating against rights alters public perception and institutional priorities creating a pathway to dismantle protections."

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 00:25

The hatred directed to Trans people, particularly on here tbh, is disgusting.

We can do our best to respect single sex spaces without being cruel to a minority who are a lightning rod for so much anger.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 00:26

dementedpixie · 07/11/2026 10:34

Is the writer not some bloke in a dress? Not biased at all!

Apparently not, but even so does that mean a feminist article written by a woman would be biased too???

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 00:35

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:23

This is what I posted upthread:

"The title is How Anti Trans Media Undermines Human Rights. The fact the media hasn't actually been successful in the removal of rights yet in the examples given doesn't change the fact the media has undermined those rights by advocating against them. That's what the point of advocating for their removal is. Advocating against rights alters public perception and institutional priorities creating a pathway to dismantle protections."

Right. So you are extrapolating from the Eurosceptic leverage of ECtHR support of LGBTQIA+ cases to undermine public support for the EU and ECtHR to a wider scope. Which is fine, but it's not what the research was looking at.

You don't think the title was misleading because it aligns with your own preconceptions.

I do think the title and summary are misleading, because they make claims beyond the scope of the content.

We aren't going to agree here. But only one of us is insulting the other.

EmpathyMatters77 · 08/11/2026 00:37

Dragonasaurus · 07/11/2026 12:52

Another uni to cross off the list. Not because it is pro/anti trans, but because such a lax approach to academic rigour makes them unfit to teach

Calm down.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 00:39

Oh yay. Another patronising poster who thinks women should just stop making a fuss and let men play at being us if they want to.

Aisha176 · 08/11/2026 00:39

FlirtsWithRhinos · 08/11/2026 00:35

Right. So you are extrapolating from the Eurosceptic leverage of ECtHR support of LGBTQIA+ cases to undermine public support for the EU and ECtHR to a wider scope. Which is fine, but it's not what the research was looking at.

You don't think the title was misleading because it aligns with your own preconceptions.

I do think the title and summary are misleading, because they make claims beyond the scope of the content.

We aren't going to agree here. But only one of us is insulting the other.

Yes we will have to agree to disagree.

This thread prevents users from posting on it until they have been members for at least 2 days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread