Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

US women’s sports star Sophie Cunningham speaking up on defending women's sports

78 replies

fromorbit · 24/07/2026 08:05

Big development. In the US few big women's sports stars have dared to speak up in the defence of women having sports. Lots of coverage of this going viral. Demands that the WBNA [Women's Basketball league] take action against her.

Sophie Cunningham says it’s ‘common sense’ to keep trans athletes out of women’s sports

In the ESPN article, Cunningham said she wanted to “protect young girls in the locker room” and that “they shouldn’t have to go against biological men.”

“I said what I said. I think it’s kind of common sense,” Cunningham said before Indiana’s 123-88 victory over the Connecticut Sun on Wednesday. “And I think I’ll always believe in that. I think it’s really important to protect children, and that’s little girls who are also involved in that category. I stand on what I said.”

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7464960/2026/07/22/sophie-cunningham-trans-comments-womens-sports/

Trump Whitehouse speaking up in Cunningham's support so getting political.
https://www.aol.com/articles/sophie-cunningham-backed-white-house-003500000.html

Despite the recent Supreme Court verdict which said women can have sports a lot of Democratic leading states are continuing to say they should not have their own sports, but only mixed sex competitions.

Likely to be an ongoing political issue and be a topic in the upcoming midterms.

Sophie Cunningham says it’s ‘common sense’ to keep trans athletes out of women’s sports

In an ESPN article, the Indiana Fever guard said that girls and women "shouldn't have to go against biological men."

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7464960/2026/07/22/sophie-cunningham-trans-comments-womens-sports/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Iamnotalemming · 25/07/2026 18:38

Brilliant. What a woman.

fromorbit · 26/07/2026 07:13

Daft article irritates JKR rightly. Interesting it even admits that men in dresses in women's sports is a safety risk. Just says women should not talk about because "trans" people might kill themselves etc. However it rightly says Cunningham could change the discourse by speaking up which she seems ready to do so.

J.K. Rowling

Caution didn't win women the vote, or equal pay, or fair sport, or the right to single-sex spaces. Sophie Cunningham is standing up for women and girls everywhere and it's glorious. Fuck caution.

Sophie Cunningham must use caution in trans sports debate

She chose to be open about how she feels, but again, words have consequences. The spotlight will only get brighter, now from directions it hadn't previously been in the trans sporting debate. Cunningham will probably become an immediate poster child for the issue, whether she wants to or not; how far she takes that is up to her. Especially if she chooses to ally with Gaines, she will become the most prominent athlete, male or female, in the country to advocate on the issue.

https://ftw-eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/wnba/2026/07/23/sophie-cunningham-caution-trans-sports-debate-opinion-fever/91020647007/

Sophie Cunningham must use caution in trans sports debate | Opinion

Sophie Cunningham has a right to speak her mind, but she's got to be careful how she does so.

https://ftw-eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/wnba/2026/07/23/sophie-cunningham-caution-trans-sports-debate-opinion-fever/91020647007/

OP posts:
1984Now · 26/07/2026 07:51

fromorbit · 26/07/2026 07:13

Daft article irritates JKR rightly. Interesting it even admits that men in dresses in women's sports is a safety risk. Just says women should not talk about because "trans" people might kill themselves etc. However it rightly says Cunningham could change the discourse by speaking up which she seems ready to do so.

J.K. Rowling

Caution didn't win women the vote, or equal pay, or fair sport, or the right to single-sex spaces. Sophie Cunningham is standing up for women and girls everywhere and it's glorious. Fuck caution.

Sophie Cunningham must use caution in trans sports debate

She chose to be open about how she feels, but again, words have consequences. The spotlight will only get brighter, now from directions it hadn't previously been in the trans sporting debate. Cunningham will probably become an immediate poster child for the issue, whether she wants to or not; how far she takes that is up to her. Especially if she chooses to ally with Gaines, she will become the most prominent athlete, male or female, in the country to advocate on the issue.

https://ftw-eu.usatoday.com/story/sports/wnba/2026/07/23/sophie-cunningham-caution-trans-sports-debate-opinion-fever/91020647007/

Amazing, isn't it?
Whenever an athlete makes pro-transfemales in natal female sports comments, there's nothing controversial, nothing to see, nothing to have to be careful about.
But the moment the likes of Cunningham make comments that were considered non-hateful and following the science just 15-20 years ago, she has to watch it, because she's now going to be watched.
Coded language for it being fine for her life being made Hell.
And here we go again, it's ok for females to have their sporting chances taken away by males in their events/teams, but the fact that apparently there's an epidemic of trans identified individuals being killed by transphobes, or apparently transphobic hate speech and bullying is peaking, Cunningham should just shut her mouth.
The conflating of fake narratives to make a thinly-veiled warning to Cunningham is so reprehensible.
But it's all the trans allies have, no facts, just a constant need to shut down the debate.
Something has happened, and this isn't working anymore.

MarjorieWestriding · 26/07/2026 08:04

Something has happened, and this isn't working anymore.

I've been thinking about this too. From what I'm reading and seeing, companies and organisations are realising that most people really don't want this state of affairs to continue, it's a failed experiment. Sports have become unfair/unsafe for women, companies are putting in time and money that could be better used elsewhere and everyone's walking on eggshells. The TRAs will see this and so there's a power struggle going on.

Tanya de Grunwald's latest 'This Isn't Working' podcast talks about it in detail.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 26/07/2026 08:05

Thanks for the link

"... Gaines is now one of the leading anti-trans advocates in the country."

I think we can tell which side the author of this article is on, anyone who refers to women who are standing up for their rights as 'anti-trans' are biased and uninformed and their opinions are not worth listening to.

MarieDeGournay · 26/07/2026 09:57

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · 26/07/2026 08:05

Thanks for the link

"... Gaines is now one of the leading anti-trans advocates in the country."

I think we can tell which side the author of this article is on, anyone who refers to women who are standing up for their rights as 'anti-trans' are biased and uninformed and their opinions are not worth listening to.

Thanks for the link, fromorbit, interesting article and I agree with TheywontletmehavethenameIwant's take on it.

The author seems to be trying to push SC into being political, which she herself carefully avoids - suggesting she might align herself with Gaines, referring to the "MAGA Barbie" moniker she seems to want to shed" .

That's really sneaky because to the best of my limited knowledge of SC, she never wanted, sought or accepted the "MAGA Barbie" moniker but 'seems to want to shed' implies that she encouraged being called MAGA Barbie at some point.

This para is a tangle of contradiction, innuendo and speculation:
If Cunningham's goal is to ultimately translate her WNBA career into a political one, this may give her the glaring opportunity to do so. Maybe, like many people, she doesn't want to be "political" when sharing her views. That's fine, but she's got a mighty soapbox.

Has SC ever said she wants a political career? I don't think so. Has she denied being "political" ? I don't think that's a 'maybe', I think she has definitely says she is not.

But the article has set SC up as a right wing christian anti-trans campaigner who will use her sporting career as a springboard to politics.
Being re-tweeted by Gaines and praised by the White House adds fuel to that fire, but that's not in SC's control .

It is a long, detailed, and in some ways a thoughtful article. But it could be studied on journalism courses as an example of how to take some facts about an individual, and then weave a whole web of suggestion, innuendo and speculation around those facts to turn the subject into an avatar of something the writer disagrees with.

Maybe SC will end up with a political career, proudly wearing a 'MAGA Barbie' cap, on the 'right wing' of US politics, who knows?
My point is that she's being unjustifiably critiqued in this article as if she already was.

2021x · 26/07/2026 21:55

MarjorieWestriding · 26/07/2026 08:04

Something has happened, and this isn't working anymore.

I've been thinking about this too. From what I'm reading and seeing, companies and organisations are realising that most people really don't want this state of affairs to continue, it's a failed experiment. Sports have become unfair/unsafe for women, companies are putting in time and money that could be better used elsewhere and everyone's walking on eggshells. The TRAs will see this and so there's a power struggle going on.

Tanya de Grunwald's latest 'This Isn't Working' podcast talks about it in detail.

Edited

I saw this the other day and I think it is an excellent breakdown of what has gone wrong with the politicisation of trans.

At work the only really active political people are the ones with rainbow lanyards. I don't even mind pronouns in the bio as some peoples names can be ambiguous.

testmatchspecial · 26/07/2026 22:17

It’s so heartening to see her shoes sell out. And such a good sign to businesses and organisations generally. I wonder if her sponsorship companies would now worry about the backlash if they dropped her? I’m possibly being too optimistic there.

fromorbit · Yesterday 05:29

testmatchspecial · 26/07/2026 22:17

It’s so heartening to see her shoes sell out. And such a good sign to businesses and organisations generally. I wonder if her sponsorship companies would now worry about the backlash if they dropped her? I’m possibly being too optimistic there.

Some US companies learned from the Bud Light controversy in April 2023 when the brand partnered with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney which cost them a lot of sales.

So many are avoiding overt trans themed marketing.

This is a test case whether a prominent US sportswomen and celebrity can speak up publicly for women and keep endorsements because they still sell a lot. If it works then expect others to speak up.

Most Americans think women should have sports. Because America is about money that should sell a lot of product.

Latest development is Sophie's podcast cohost, a man a friend from school, has publicly disagreed with her over her pro women position.

Podcast "Show Me Something" brings together WNBA & Indiana Fever star Sophie Cunningham and her high school bestie–turned–reality star, West Wilson. I wonder if they will argue it out online.

Sophie Cunningham's Podcast Co-Host Faces Backlash For Publicly Disagreeing With Her
https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/sophie-cunninghams-podcast-co-host-125410017.html

Sophie Cunningham's Podcast Co-Host Faces Backlash For Publicly Disagreeing With Her

Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham believes it's "common sense" to keep transgender athletes out of women's sports. Cunningham, who has become quite popular during her second season with the Indiana Fever, sounded off on her opinion during an interv...

https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/sophie-cunninghams-podcast-co-host-125410017.html

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:51

fromorbit · Yesterday 05:29

Some US companies learned from the Bud Light controversy in April 2023 when the brand partnered with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney which cost them a lot of sales.

So many are avoiding overt trans themed marketing.

This is a test case whether a prominent US sportswomen and celebrity can speak up publicly for women and keep endorsements because they still sell a lot. If it works then expect others to speak up.

Most Americans think women should have sports. Because America is about money that should sell a lot of product.

Latest development is Sophie's podcast cohost, a man a friend from school, has publicly disagreed with her over her pro women position.

Podcast "Show Me Something" brings together WNBA & Indiana Fever star Sophie Cunningham and her high school bestie–turned–reality star, West Wilson. I wonder if they will argue it out online.

Sophie Cunningham's Podcast Co-Host Faces Backlash For Publicly Disagreeing With Her
https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/sophie-cunninghams-podcast-co-host-125410017.html

"Right-wingers have convinced a massive portion of people in our country that (transgender athletes) are a threat to sports in America, when mathematically that's not the case at all,"

Traditionally, allowing a small group of people to have an unfair advantage is not considered to be left wing, Rather the opposite in fact.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · Yesterday 09:52

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 07:51

"Right-wingers have convinced a massive portion of people in our country that (transgender athletes) are a threat to sports in America, when mathematically that's not the case at all,"

Traditionally, allowing a small group of people to have an unfair advantage is not considered to be left wing, Rather the opposite in fact.

"Right-wingers have convinced a massive portion of people in our country that (transgender athletes) are a threat to sports in America, when mathematically that's not the case at all,"

I see 'Left-wingers' are hiding the truth behind general lies, again, it's not 'transgender athletes ' and a 'threat to sport' but 'transIDing males' earasing female sport.

Perhaps the massive portion of people aren't buying the lies any more, and have started rejecting all the gaslighting this nasty ideology has cruised by on for years.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 10:19

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · Yesterday 09:52

"Right-wingers have convinced a massive portion of people in our country that (transgender athletes) are a threat to sports in America, when mathematically that's not the case at all,"

I see 'Left-wingers' are hiding the truth behind general lies, again, it's not 'transgender athletes ' and a 'threat to sport' but 'transIDing males' earasing female sport.

Perhaps the massive portion of people aren't buying the lies any more, and have started rejecting all the gaslighting this nasty ideology has cruised by on for years.

People like him are mired in the anecdotal, aren't they?
..mathematically... unique questions ...individual bases... case-by-case- tiny minority..

They don't seem to be able to work on the level of principle and consistency. Sport is a very rules-based system - the minutiae of VAR, a tennis serve clipping the line, a boxer's weight at the weigh-in.

The category 'women's sports' is for biological women, and that has to be applied consistently to make sense, not case-by-case - like yeah he was offside, but it was only by a teeny tiny little bit and it would have been such an amazing goal! or yeah he's actually too heavy for this weight category but he tried really really hard to get the weight down, and we don't want to disappoint all the people who have bought their tickets...

That's not the way sport works. It works on rules, categories, limits, clarity - that's one of the things that people like about sport: it is a microcosm where the rules are clear and known to all concerned, and their application is carried out swiftly by referees and umpires who are [supposed to be] objective and consistent.
The rest of life isn't like that😒

So West Wilson is missing the point when he says it's not true that '(transgender athletes) are a threat to sports' - they are not necessarily a threat on an anecdotal, personal, case-by-case basis, but they are a macro-level threat to the rules-based nature of sports in general.

MarieDeGournay · Yesterday 10:30

I wrote that trans people in sport 'are not necessarily a threat on an anecdotal, personal, case-by-case basis'.

To balance my use of the word 'necessarily', here's a photo of the transwoman Giulia Valentino, looking every inch an actual threat in a women's Gaelic football match a few years ago.

Giulia appears to have gone back to Italy, or London, or wherever, but Giulia said in interviews that Giulia wanted to 'leave a legacy' for transpeople in Gaelic games.

Always happy to oblige by sharing this photo of your brave 'legacy', Giulia!

[Topical Gaelic football derail: hup Mayo, BTW🏆😁]

US women’s sports star Sophie Cunningham  speaking up on defending women's sports
fromorbit · Yesterday 19:46

More dumb stuff.

TAs fans are now burning Sophie Cunningham jerseys.

She gets paid if you buy them !

Her merchandise sales are shooting up mainly from fans.

OP posts:
Iamnotalemming · Yesterday 20:01

Reminds me of the Harry Potter book burning idiots.

OldCrone · Yesterday 20:37

fromorbit · Yesterday 05:29

Some US companies learned from the Bud Light controversy in April 2023 when the brand partnered with transgender influencer Dylan Mulvaney which cost them a lot of sales.

So many are avoiding overt trans themed marketing.

This is a test case whether a prominent US sportswomen and celebrity can speak up publicly for women and keep endorsements because they still sell a lot. If it works then expect others to speak up.

Most Americans think women should have sports. Because America is about money that should sell a lot of product.

Latest development is Sophie's podcast cohost, a man a friend from school, has publicly disagreed with her over her pro women position.

Podcast "Show Me Something" brings together WNBA & Indiana Fever star Sophie Cunningham and her high school bestie–turned–reality star, West Wilson. I wonder if they will argue it out online.

Sophie Cunningham's Podcast Co-Host Faces Backlash For Publicly Disagreeing With Her
https://sports.yahoo.com/articles/sophie-cunninghams-podcast-co-host-125410017.html

The first sentence of that article misrepresents what she said.

Indiana Fever guard Sophie Cunningham believes it's "common sense" to keep transgender athletes out of women's sports.

No, she didn't say that. She said it's "common sense" to keep men out of women's sports.

Sophie Cunningham (G) Stats, News, Rumors, Bio, Video - Indiana - Yahoo Sports

Sports News, Scores, Fantasy Games

https://sports.yahoo.com/wnba/players/6164/

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · Yesterday 20:54

Well it is a post-truth ideology, so lying is second nature to them.

fromorbit · Yesterday 21:44

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · Yesterday 20:54

Well it is a post-truth ideology, so lying is second nature to them.

Thing is many are wise to this now. So what worked in 2020 does not work at all now. It is getting weaker.

OP posts:
OP posts:
1984Now · Today 10:44

fromorbit · Today 10:35

There are demands that a pro Sophie Cunningham rally outside a game today is cancelled:

https://jang.com.pk/en/69890-wnba-under-fire-as-fans-demand-to-cancel-rally-over-sophie-cunningham-comments-news

Remind me, how many pro-trans rallies have ever been cancelled?
Interesting to watch this jump the shark moment on cancel culture.

TheywontletmehavethenameIwant · Today 10:46

fromorbit · Today 10:35

There are demands that a pro Sophie Cunningham rally outside a game today is cancelled:

https://jang.com.pk/en/69890-wnba-under-fire-as-fans-demand-to-cancel-rally-over-sophie-cunningham-comments-news

Thanks, I'm taking what the article says with a pinch of salt because it's referring to SC's comments as 'anti-trans'.
Are the TRA's finding out they're not the only ones who can turn out in high numbers to make their feelings known. 🤣
They want to literally cancel a rally, because only they're allowed to wave flags and show support, it's not fair when anyone else does it. Boo hoo. 🤣

Iamnotalemming · Today 11:07

Wow this is becoming quite the moment, isn't it. A prime peaking opportunity.

lcakethereforeIam · Today 11:08

I noticed this happened

https://archive.ph/66eOj

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/football/2026/07/26/female-referee-hurt-knocked-to-ground-player-melee-france/

I hope the referee makes a full recovery. It demonstrates how dangerous it can be for women to share a pitch with men. This seems a fluke but imagine if a trans-identifying woman did try to play with the boys. There are a few mixed sex, trans inclusive teams I believe. Distinct from teams that play sports designed to be mixed sex. I think the only reason the women on these teams haven't been seriously hurt is because they're lower league, possibly not very good, and the men on the teams may curb themselves to avoid injuring the women. At least I hope so.