New article here:
www.indexoncensorship.org/2020/08/scotlands-hate-crime-bill-would-stifle-free-speech/?fbclid=IwAR2YIdboHt6X75H4fXCBxJCZIaY1yOSPxZiyRbjuQtSuKkp_vzOfABaGe-Y#
'The bill directly undermines freedom of expression in Scotland. Artistic expression is challenged and our rights to engage in public debate would be threatened with potential prosecution for “stirring up hatred”. The legislative language is so vague that someone could be charged with a criminal offence (with a maximum seven-year prison tariff) if an individual’s actions were deemed to be insulting or offensive, with no consideration of the intent behind the action. Comedians could face criminal proceedings for insulting their audiences, commentators for exploring issues of gender or even for discussing religion.'
Index on Censorship have joined the 'Free to Disagree' campaign.
This campaign is run, I believe, by the Christian Society - I think this is the reason Patrick Harvie of the Scottish Greens stepped down from the Secular Society, because he disapproves of the Christian Society.
Anyway, good to see IoC weighing in. Hopefully this bill will be toast very soon. Maybe I'm being too optimistic.