Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Lucie Manette would never sleep with Sydney Carton.

3 replies

Kayemm · Today 12:22

Would she?

Earlier in the year, chatting to a friend about how Tale of Two Cities was due a new tv series.
It's one of the best books ever, no debate there.

Then I read that it's happening. Let joy be unconfined! Kit Harrington is cast, fabulous.

And then I read that Lucie sleeps with Sydney!

No, no, no, no, no. Absolutely not. Hmph.

OP posts:
AlexandraCarrington · Today 12:32

I don't think Sydney would ever have thought of it. He thought Lucie was beyond his reach.

And no, she wouldn't even if he had. Way out of character.

Kayemm · Today 12:56

Exactly! When he goes to her and declares his love. I'm always in bits reading that speech.

OP posts:
Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Today 14:39

How absolutely unnecessary.

Some years go we started buying the Classic Drama series of Dvds - they were sent out on a regular basis. And there were some absolute crackers. But what we found as the series progressed was that the early adaptations of the books were really quite faithful to their original novels. But the more recent adaptations began increasingly not to stick to the books and attempted to " modernise" the stories . We actually stopped buying the Dvds because of this.
It's an insult to the viewer that the makers of such modernised interpretations think that the general public are incapable of understanding the context and mores of the time that these great works of fiction were set in.
Just what does Sydney having sex with Lucie add to the story apart from introducing a carnal element to their relationship which is just not part if the original novel? And it is obviously just done to try and increase viewing figures. Very sad actually.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page