Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Celebrity authors gaslighting readers

74 replies

TheAverageJoanne · 04/11/2026 09:54

I'm not naming either person in this post. My friend is a very successful author of women's contemporary fiction (not chick lit exactly). She's aware that a female celebrity author doesn't write her own books. She has a 👻 writer to "help out". She probably comes up with the premise and hands it over.

What are your thoughts on this? The woman in question isn't a reality show person, is in her 50s. I find it to be gaslighting, myself.

OP posts:
JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 08:43

CherryKerry · Yesterday 00:25

So, George Foreman didn't really make my lean mean fat reducing grilling machine? 😱

I can’t believe that’s not true! Not George Foreman. I had an image of him manufacturing them in his shed.

If anyone says that Paul Newman doesn’t personally make all of Newman’s Own in his own kitchen, well that’s me done with celebrities…Grin

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Yesterday 09:45

Like with the books, though, you never know just how much (or how little) input the celebrity whose name goes on the appliance/product may have had.

It could be like on The Apprentice, whereby they get stuck in and make lots of decisions and specific choices, but they have an expert to tie it all together for them, who is carrying out their instructions... or they could equally just say "Do whatever you reckon, slap my name on it and send me 50% of the profits" and then bugger off on holiday to Barbados for three months!!

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Yesterday 09:52

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 08:43

I can’t believe that’s not true! Not George Foreman. I had an image of him manufacturing them in his shed.

If anyone says that Paul Newman doesn’t personally make all of Newman’s Own in his own kitchen, well that’s me done with celebrities…Grin

Oh, you have nothing to worry about: Paul does indeed remain hands-on and he makes every single bottle of his product himself, personally. In fact, he also blows the glass bottles and produces the paper for the labels himself and drives the lorry to take them to the supermarkets, as well as doing all of the company accounts himself.

He's an absolutely remarkable person, and passionately committed to his own personal cause, whatever happens. He actually suffered an extremely major health event 18 years ago, but even that didn't stop him!!

PollyBell · Yesterday 09:54

How is it gaslighting?

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Yesterday 09:57

George Foreman was far too busy producing little George Foremans to have time to produce any kitchen appliances himself.

All of the 5 boys were also called George Edward, and one of his 7 daughters was Georgetta!

Atlastarest · Yesterday 10:13

Just name changed for this - I have done a bit of ghostwriting and had to stop as even though I am an old experienced hand in publishing, even I was shocked at the level of lying involved. And getting hampered by NDAs.

I think people have it covered mostly though - obvious ones like Marcus rashford I don’t think he’s pretending to write his kids’ books is he? But I have ghostwritten a book for a ‘beloved’ screenwriter for a cult show, who went on radio repeatedly and said how much they’d loved writing this project, it was so special to them. There was a clause in my contract saying I’d get a credit (fully expecting it to be size 4 font on the imprint info page) which obviously would have helped my own profile and career, that didn’t happen and this means that my NDA didn’t expire like I expected it to on publication (when I expected the credit). Fuming! Got it checked out by a contracts lawyer who had also previously worked inhouse who was like wow, you got done. Meanwhile ‘screenwriter’: ‘I really LOVED writing this book’ - I’m sure you did love! One thirty minute meeting as I recall..

Then another ghostwriter/editor passed my details to a multi million pound a-list celebrity. My contact had ghostwritten for them, another two ghostwriters had previously worked (on the one short book) and she was looking for another ghostwriter. But she 100% believed that she had written it and gave lots of interviews about her writing practice etc. I think the problem is that a lot of ghostwriters come out of editing, and the lines get blurred between the two (a lot more books have extremely heavy editing than you’d think anyhow) and so celebs, many of whom have an iron clad ability to think the best of themselves and constantly PR themselves, really start to think that having a few ideas and getting an editor to write the whole thing IS them writing it, and getting it edited.

Someone also has been already mentioned who I know multiple ghostwriters had to audition for as part of an extensive marketing, editorial and publicity team to create the whole pipeline of books over say a decade. Celeb author maintains they write them.

Katie Price, in the bizarre bundle of contradictions she is, was well known for being the most honest and giving the most credit to her ghostwriter, who tragically died of cancer.

Anyway, I had to leave publishing entirely for several years as I was so over it. I’m now back but don’t ghostwrite.

TheAverageJoanne · Yesterday 11:30

JustaSongAboutPingPong · Yesterday 08:43

I can’t believe that’s not true! Not George Foreman. I had an image of him manufacturing them in his shed.

If anyone says that Paul Newman doesn’t personally make all of Newman’s Own in his own kitchen, well that’s me done with celebrities…Grin

Let's not get started on Meghan's jam.

OP posts:
StillSpartacus · Yesterday 11:35

And all those celebs who colour their hair with a box dye kit.

TheAverageJoanne · Yesterday 11:35

@Atlastarest Thanks for this. I'm a published author myself, and my friend is a prolific fiction writer who took ten years to become published, so it grinds our gears.

Of course it's disingenuous.

There's no comparison with George Foreman grills, Paul Newman pickles or Mrs Hinch cleaning spray.

OP posts:
Atlastarest · Yesterday 12:01

TheAverageJoanne · Yesterday 11:35

@Atlastarest Thanks for this. I'm a published author myself, and my friend is a prolific fiction writer who took ten years to become published, so it grinds our gears.

Of course it's disingenuous.

There's no comparison with George Foreman grills, Paul Newman pickles or Mrs Hinch cleaning spray.

I am so truly thrilled to be working with writers themselves again. Congrats to you and your friend on your success.

Atlastarest · Yesterday 12:03

And yes, hard agree, of course there is a massive difference between those who tacitly or directly acknowledge ghostwriters, and the ‘I love my writing practice’ hoodwinkers.

AllPlayedOut · Yesterday 12:12

If you’re a published author then why are you posting this as though it’s some new shocking revelation that most celebrity authors use ghostwriters? It’s the norm for both fiction and non-fiction. I think that ghostwriters should always be credited but it’s very common for them not to be and your friend is only one of many who does this.

latetothefisting · Yesterday 12:39

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 08:52

Using a ghostwriter is completely normal for celebrity authors. In some cases they may be name checked in the acknowledgements, but often not. Sometimes a ghostwriter signs an NDA before they even know who they’re writing for.

Im not sure why you think this is some kind of scam…?

um, because you're telling people something that's completely untrue?
How is that NOT a scam?

By all means if the ghost writer is credited somewhere (quite obviously), then that's fine. But if someone buys a book that says it's written by 'X' then it's not unreasonable to assume it was written by 'x'.

Otherwise where does it end? If you buy free range chicken reared in the UK does it matter if it's actually factory farmed in romania? What if the books said 'all proceeds to X charity,' would it matter if the money didn't actually go there?
What if the book says first edition but it's not actually?

Atlastarest · Yesterday 12:47

Yeah, I agree, and that’s why I don’t really have an issue with the way James Paterson does it - he has elevated so many partner writers’ careers.

AllPlayedOut · Yesterday 13:00

Sorry that should say the author whom your friend discussed with you.

nopiesleftinthisvehicle · Yesterday 13:07

Lomonald · 04/11/2026 09:59

Celebrity authors mostly have ghost writers i don't think anybody thought (for example )Katie Price wrote her books.

She famously hadn't even read it when asked some basic questions about the storyline.

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · Yesterday 13:11

I don't think Prince Harry and Katie Price even read their own books did they?

Atlastarest · Yesterday 13:34

That’s so sad, I thought she was a fantastic writer. I didn’t realise Katie p hadn’t even gone to her funeral.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Yesterday 13:56

TheAverageJoanne · Yesterday 11:35

@Atlastarest Thanks for this. I'm a published author myself, and my friend is a prolific fiction writer who took ten years to become published, so it grinds our gears.

Of course it's disingenuous.

There's no comparison with George Foreman grills, Paul Newman pickles or Mrs Hinch cleaning spray.

Why is there no comparison, though? Why do we accept that celebrities who peddle products that other people came up with are only cashing in on their own name, and obviously had/have no involvement in its development; but if that product happens to be a book, where is the material difference?

MiaKulper · Yesterday 18:56

@TheAverageJoanne , they're not gaslighting.
Gaslighting is the practice of psychologically manipulating someone into questioning their own sanity, memory, or powers of reasoning.

CheeseyNacho · Yesterday 19:03

How do people get into ghostwriting?

Does someone - presumably an agent - approach them and say “I like your previous stuff, can you please do it, but a bit more like Celebrity X”?

Hadroncollideer · Yesterday 20:15

Pierrederesistance · 04/11/2026 11:40

I'm a ghostwriter - it's much, much more prevalent than you could ever imagine!

It would be great if you could do an AMA.

Pierrederesistance · Today 10:46

Hadroncollideer · Yesterday 20:15

It would be great if you could do an AMA.

I'd be happy to but I've signed NDAs on all the juicy ones 😂

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread