Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

A court of splintered harmony *WITH SPOILERS*

23 replies

Soubriquet · 01/11/2026 15:16

this is a new thread for those spoilers

this is my theory

when nesta winnowed, she didn’t go to the prison, but the bone quarter in CC. Gwydion aka the starsword became a compass in some form, and now back in the world with Bryce has vanished to reappear to her

I reckon we will get a new CC book starting with Bryce being rather startled to get the Starsword back

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 01/11/2026 16:10

Oh, wow! I didn't even think about that. I love it.

My predictions:

I guess Az will somehow end up either training the Valkyrie again or fight alongside Gwyn in the library, and they will become mates.

Elaine must meet Lucien somehow. They must interact at one point and collaborate on some mission. Two very lonely and miserable people.

Emerie and Mor will also get together.

I hope we see the Autumn Court and find out what happened to Mor and Eris.

Who will have the Blood Duel? I do not think it would be Lucien and Az. It is too obvious. Eris and Cassian is too obvious as well.

I just want to see baby Nyx and his parents all the time. They are so sweet!

The series is titled Valkyries. Why do we think that is and how would it fit with the possible CC connection?

Wehaditsogood · 01/11/2026 16:36

Oh, and I thought Amren let Bryaxis loose on the naming day ceremony. I don't know why, but I had that impression.

Clotho is is shady.

Soubriquet · 01/11/2026 16:59

there’s a theory that Clotho is a Stygian spider and the thread for Nyx was made out of spider silk

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 01/11/2026 17:36

My mind is blown. Thank you. Any other theories?

I haven't read any theories until now and was shocked by the hate for Cassian. Readers really ship Nesta and Eris 😲

Soubriquet · 01/11/2026 19:36

I will admit being disappointed by Cassian in this book. He doesn’t put his mate first, to the point where she realises she has to censor herself around him, and watch what she says

That’s sad. I don’t agree with her being paired with Eris though

I do wonder what’s going on with Mor. Obviously the fact that she’s gay isn’t the only reason she hasn’t told Azriel or anyone else apart from Feyre

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 01/11/2026 22:08

That is why I want to know what exactly happened between Mor and Eris. Why does Mor not trust her best friends about her sexuality? Why didn't she put Azriel out of his misery 499 years ago? He could have moved on. What is going on there?!

Cassian and Azriel are disappointing, but I always preferred the women in the book.

I wouldn't pair Nesta or any woman with Eris either. Unless it comes out that he is totally innocent with regards to Mor. And he can't be. Eris is mentioned a lot, so it would be interesting to know more about him.

Soubriquet · 02/11/2026 08:30

I also keep reading that since the ceremony was never completed, Nyx is technically nameless.

Circling back to Nameless is my price.

OP posts:
Soubriquet · 02/11/2026 09:18

People are also speculating that Amren isn’t Amren at the end, which is interesting and I can see why. The fact she uses the phrase Miss Quinlan and not Bryce, is causing people to think it could have been Aidas.

To be honest I was irritated with the way they treated Nesta through out the whole film regarding the mask.

She did it, because she wanted to help others, and Bryce handed it back!! If it was their world in danger, they took would have taken it without a second thought, likely without even asking, and then would never have given it back, stating it would be safer with them

I felt so sorry for Nesta

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 02/11/2026 11:25

These are all very good shouts. Thank you. Nameless is my price. Hmmm. That is a good one.

There was a lot of needless bitching about Nesta and Az being jealous of his sword.
Feyre did many things without consulting anyone.

Rhys and Feyre's death pact is just stupid. Noone would do that if they expect to have children in the future and Rhys needs an heir.

I always quite liked Aidas.

I saw the speculation that Elaine might be under Koschei's spell.

CraftySeal · 02/11/2026 18:49

I was really disappointed with the first two thirds of this book. Very dull and politics-y, it really annoyed me that all Nesta and Cassian's growth from last book was "reset" by something that didn't even happen in this series, I was sick of hearing about Feyre's milk-laden breasts, and all I could think about was how bad the writing was and that I definitely wouldn't read any more ACOTAR after this.

Then of course in typical Maas style the last third well and truly sucked me in and left me dying for the next installment.

I definitely got the impression that Amren summoned Bryaxis to try to wake up the various members of the inner circle and get them motivated to act in the way she thinks they should be acting.

I read quite an interesting theory on Reddit that Elain is possessed by an enemy manipulating and spying on everyone through her, and the reason it was constantly pointed out that she stays away from Lucien and won't even look at him or talk to him is because his magic eye would see the truth of that. And that Azriel's shadows run away from her not because she's so good and pure but because they are scared of her. Not sure what I think about that.

I'm fed up with Rhys and Feyre, their bits of the story are my least favourite now. Agree with comment above that their death pact is stupid, and I just can't be bothered with their perfect sexy love any more. Other characters are much more interesting now.

DogBagKite · 04/11/2026 11:29

Poor Az was left standing naked for an awfully long time whilst they all slowly came in and gawped and then shouted at him 😂😂😂

Soubriquet · 04/11/2026 12:17

Bet Feyre still gawked trying to work out of Rhys or Azriel had the bigger wingspan

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 04/11/2026 14:40

😆

Soubriquet · 04/11/2026 18:22

I’m also querying whether Nesta and Cassian really are mates.

He doesn’t feel her when she nearly drowned. He doesn’t come to check on her when she had a broken arm after saving them from Bryaxis.

He still prioritises the inner circle over Nesta.

OP posts:
Wehaditsogood · 04/11/2026 22:06

Good point. We were made to think males go crazy when their mate is in trouble.
Are we thinking this is a Rowan's first mate situation? Or is Cassian just not that attentive / powerful?

DogBagKite · 05/11/2026 08:05

Feyre and Rhys can mind speak so maybe that's why they know the other is in trouble instantly as the comms are always open. It was sad but realistic that Cassian isn't perfect and that Nesta realises she can't trust him completely, and that she needs different needs meet by different people e.g. her friends. They are my favourite couple as it's a bit complicated and Feyre and Rhys are always too perfect. I feel like Maas has made Azriel look foolish in this book. For Elaine?! Who does nothing except look pretty? I was pleased Nesta was cross with her too about Az, it takes two to tango and they both risked the alliance. Poor old Lucien. I wish they had put a line of context about where the bonus chapters from previous books fit into the story, my memory struggled. I'm also struggling to remember the finer details of the Crescent City books, I read them all but the lore is so dense and convoluted now!

Soubriquet · 05/11/2026 09:18

Feyre and Rhys can mind speak because they are both damaeti. Nothing to do with mates

OP posts:
DogBagKite · 05/11/2026 10:27

Yes exactly, that's what I mean. So that's why they seem 'matier' than other couples.

Wehaditsogood · 05/11/2026 11:18

TBH I don't mind that the Night Court inner circle consists of imperfect people. I much prefer messy people in books.

Opus3 · 10/11/2026 19:30

I thought the same re Bryaxis and Amren.

Clotho is puzzling me, but I believe that she locked the doors to keep people out.

Az's shadows staying away from Elain too, is it because she is evil or good, I don't have enough to go on to form an opinion on this yet.

I hate that Maas split the book this way. This small one does nothing, and there is zero reason not to have it with the next.

Idstillratherbepaddleboarding · 10/11/2026 20:28

I’ve heard al these theories and don’t disagree with any of them but my theory that I haven’t head before is that Feyre becomes Queen of Prythian since Rhys is refusing.

The IC need to focus on what’s going on in their own court instead of sticking their noses in everywhere else.

I think by then end we’ll have a full ACOTAR, CC and TOG crossover.

And all the books should be released together if they’re meant to be read as one story.

Opus3 · 10/11/2026 20:58

Idstillratherbepaddleboarding · 10/11/2026 20:28

I’ve heard al these theories and don’t disagree with any of them but my theory that I haven’t head before is that Feyre becomes Queen of Prythian since Rhys is refusing.

The IC need to focus on what’s going on in their own court instead of sticking their noses in everywhere else.

I think by then end we’ll have a full ACOTAR, CC and TOG crossover.

And all the books should be released together if they’re meant to be read as one story.

I have read that. Also people calling her a fascist, somewhat jokingly. I can't see it. But I don't like the character, and I don't see her doing something that interesting. Now, Nesta... I can see doing that, she'd save the world's in all 3 series and the IC would still hate her.

Troubledwords · 17/11/2026 13:51

I finished it, and like Rhys less and less with each book.

Nesta is by far my favourite character, and I hope she continues to be central to the story.

Amren is definitely up to something, encouraging Nesta to go to the prison.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page