Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Please help me find a thriller I read circa 2006!!

8 replies

MyFavouriteMugHasCatsOn · 15/10/2026 23:01

I have been desperately trying to remember a book that I read in 2006 or a couple of years before. It was a women's thriller, and I can't remember what it was called or who it was by.

It was about two mums, Mum A who was confident and carefree and had two children who may or may not have been called Scarlet and Laurence, and Mum B who was anxious and shy and needy and had two children who may or may not have been called Poppy and Joshua. The mums became friends because Mum A felt sorry for Mum B, who became incredibly clingy and stifling, and Mum A tried to wriggle free. Their lives became intermeshed and the book ends with one of the mums killing the other, and they leave it deliberately unclear as to which it was, and one of the Dads (married to Mum B, a bland guy who may have been called Graham) raises all four children. I keep thinking about it and I'd really like to reread it. Any clues?

The only other detail I remember is that the women get drunk and share a kiss one night but are definitely straight.

I asked Google and AI and have ruled out all the authors it suggested! Not Ruth Rendell, Barbara Vine, Nicci French, Marsha Ward, Jane Green, Adele Parks...

Very grateful if anyone can help!

OP posts:
Silverbirchleaf · 16/10/2026 03:15

‘Copycat’ by Gillian white ?

www.amazon.co.uk/Copycat-Gillian-White/dp/0552148857

MyFavouriteMugHasCatsOn · 16/10/2026 03:41

Silverbirchleaf · 16/10/2026 03:15

‘Copycat’ by Gillian white ?

www.amazon.co.uk/Copycat-Gillian-White/dp/0552148857

THANK YOU!!!!!!! YOU ARE AMAZING! God I love Mumsnet.

OP posts:
DontTellMama · 16/10/2026 06:03

I had no idea, but had to comment that I am incredibly impressed with your recollection of the character names from a book you read 20 years ago!! (I checked, and you were right about them all).

zen1 · 16/10/2026 07:07

This is so weird! Back in 2003 (I remember because it was the year I had my first child), I heard or read a book review giving a (more general) synopsis of this book and made a mental note to look out for it next time I was in a bookshop. I didn’t pay attention to the author though, only recalling she was female, so for the last 23 years I’ve been wondering if I’d ever stumble across it. After the first year of looking in the new releases section, I pretty much gave up of hope of ever finding it. So thank you OP and @Silverbirchleaf - I have now added to my Amazon basket before I forget it again!

MyFavouriteMugHasCatsOn · 16/10/2026 09:06

zen1 · 16/10/2026 07:07

This is so weird! Back in 2003 (I remember because it was the year I had my first child), I heard or read a book review giving a (more general) synopsis of this book and made a mental note to look out for it next time I was in a bookshop. I didn’t pay attention to the author though, only recalling she was female, so for the last 23 years I’ve been wondering if I’d ever stumble across it. After the first year of looking in the new releases section, I pretty much gave up of hope of ever finding it. So thank you OP and @Silverbirchleaf - I have now added to my Amazon basket before I forget it again!

Oh amazing, glad to have helped you too (sorry about spoilers!)! It's on the Borrowbox App if you use it!

OP posts:
MyFavouriteMugHasCatsOn · 16/10/2026 09:07

DontTellMama · 16/10/2026 06:03

I had no idea, but had to comment that I am incredibly impressed with your recollection of the character names from a book you read 20 years ago!! (I checked, and you were right about them all).

I was a teenager at the time and it was one of the first properly grown up books I read which I think is why it stuck with me so very vividly! And it had the gay kiss at a time when I was questioning my sexuality so it felt like a Very Important Book haha.

OP posts:
Silverbirchleaf · 16/10/2026 11:10

Glad to have helped, although I admit it was a slightly lucky google search in the middle of the night when I was wide awake.

I got a real thrill last year when I decided to search for and found a book I read as a teen. I roughly knew the title and found it on a second hand bookshop. I don’t know all the character’s names, but I could give you a fairly decent summary of plot.

Timefortruths · 16/10/2026 22:35

Ive just ordered this book from eBay as getting serious FOMO! 🤣

New posts on this thread. Refresh page