Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

P G Wodehouse: Blandings vs Jeeves

24 replies

Dappy777 · 10/08/2026 17:43

Which are better, the Jeeves novels or the Blandings series? I love the Jeeves stuff but have never read any of the Blandings books.

OP posts:
whistlesandbells · 10/08/2026 19:46

I love both but my real treat is Ukridge.

Dappy777 · 10/08/2026 20:42

I am reading a book on Wodehouse atm and have been amazed at how well-educated he was. People often confuse him with Bertie Wooster and imagine he was a slightly brighter version of Bertie himself. In fact, Wodehouse was a brilliant classics scholar who could read both Latin and Greek. He even got the idea for Jeeves and Wooster from reading comic Roman writers. He also re-read all of Shakespeare’s play every year, as an intellectual exercise, and he could read books in French and German!

OP posts:
capitalcapitalcapital · 10/08/2026 20:44

My username is from the Blandings stories - I love them! If you can listen to Martin Jarvis reading them, all the better!

Iamateadrinker · 10/08/2026 20:46

I love Jeeves and Wooster, Stephen Fry reading the ( very long!) audio books had me laughing out loud much to the bemusement of fellow travellers...I have yet to try the Blandings books

IceBrownie · 10/08/2026 20:50

I couldn't possibly choose between them.

I'm not British and English is my third language, but Wodehouse is one of the few authors that genuinely makes me laugh out loud. Actually LAUGH.

Jeeves is brilliant, but the characters in the Blandings are just amazing.

IceBrownie · 10/08/2026 20:52

Just to add, as per PP Martin Jarvis is an excellent narrator for the audio version (but my favourite is Jonathan Cecil)

Iamateadrinker · 10/08/2026 23:21

Just ordered Ukridge from Audible 😀

IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · 10/08/2026 23:59

Having loved the Fry and Laurie J&W series all those years ago and rewatching them on dvd I thought, during Covid, that it was about time I tried some Wodehouse books.

What a sensible decision. I've read one every month, more or less, since then, so only have about 30 left to go. Only a few have been disappointing (mostly his earliest stuff) and while I enjoy Blandings I find J&W his best series. I think it's the Bertie narrations that clinch it (Ring for Jeeves aside).

For me, Thank You, Jeeves, Right Ho, Jeeves and The Code of the Woosters, collectively, are the absolute peak of his output. They're perfection.

Bonden · 11/08/2026 03:44

Oh but Lord Emsworth and his horrible sisters … are surely an unmissable joy, no matter how much one loves BW and Jeeves.

Bonden · 11/08/2026 03:45

do you folks think Jeeves likes Bertie? I think he does. I think he must find life with Bertie an absolute hoot. Far better than being some stuffed bore of a Lord’s personal gentleman.

IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · 11/08/2026 09:40

Bonden · 11/08/2026 03:44

Oh but Lord Emsworth and his horrible sisters … are surely an unmissable joy, no matter how much one loves BW and Jeeves.

I did say I enjoyed Blandings. But if I could only take one Wodehouse to a desert island, it would be one of the aforementioned J&W tomes.

There must be some form of affection towards Bertie from Jeeves beyond thinking he can make something of him. Jeeves could readily take permanent employment elsewhere if he so chose.

capitalcapitalcapital · 11/08/2026 12:12

I love this thread! I like J & W but I much prefer Blandings. They are so funny! The relationships are brilliantly observed and more nuanced that J & W. Galahad is one of my favourite ever characters. Closely followed by Lord Emsworth.

IceBrownie · 11/08/2026 12:49

Bonden · 11/08/2026 03:45

do you folks think Jeeves likes Bertie? I think he does. I think he must find life with Bertie an absolute hoot. Far better than being some stuffed bore of a Lord’s personal gentleman.

Not as much as Lord Elsworth likes Empress, that's for sure!

I think Jeeves has the same type of affection you have for a very silly pet. He's also a master manipulator, when it comes to having his way - be it with specific holidays or sartorial choices!

Dappy777 · 11/08/2026 13:29

IceBrownie · 10/08/2026 20:50

I couldn't possibly choose between them.

I'm not British and English is my third language, but Wodehouse is one of the few authors that genuinely makes me laugh out loud. Actually LAUGH.

Jeeves is brilliant, but the characters in the Blandings are just amazing.

I am in awe of people who can read books in more than one language. I have been trying for years to read books in French, with mixed results. If you can read (and appreciate) a writer like Wodehouse in your third language, then I take my hat off to you.

Interesting little fact, Ludwig Wittgenstein loved Wodehouse. He thought one of his short stories was the funniest thing he'd ever read. It makes me smile to picture Wittgenstein (a tortured Austrian genius) chuckling away to Wodehouse.

OP posts:
Dappy777 · 11/08/2026 13:32

Bonden · 11/08/2026 03:45

do you folks think Jeeves likes Bertie? I think he does. I think he must find life with Bertie an absolute hoot. Far better than being some stuffed bore of a Lord’s personal gentleman.

In one of the short stories, Bertie overhears Jeeves call him "an exceedingly amiable young fellow," before adding "but mentally he is negligible" 😝

OP posts:
SettledAndHappy · 11/08/2026 13:43

Another vote here for the Martin Jarvis audio books. They are FANTASTIC. My teens love them to bits and Bertie's phrases have become a standard part of our family vocabulary. We've not read/listened to any of the Blandings ones though.

IceBrownie · 11/08/2026 16:41

Dappy777 · 11/08/2026 13:29

I am in awe of people who can read books in more than one language. I have been trying for years to read books in French, with mixed results. If you can read (and appreciate) a writer like Wodehouse in your third language, then I take my hat off to you.

Interesting little fact, Ludwig Wittgenstein loved Wodehouse. He thought one of his short stories was the funniest thing he'd ever read. It makes me smile to picture Wittgenstein (a tortured Austrian genius) chuckling away to Wodehouse.

I didn't know that; I struggle to think of a more unlikely pairing!!

Dappy777 · 11/08/2026 17:33

IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · 11/08/2026 09:40

I did say I enjoyed Blandings. But if I could only take one Wodehouse to a desert island, it would be one of the aforementioned J&W tomes.

There must be some form of affection towards Bertie from Jeeves beyond thinking he can make something of him. Jeeves could readily take permanent employment elsewhere if he so chose.

If I am ever invited onto Desert Island Discs (unlikely, I admit), the collected J&W will be my book choice.

OP posts:
Dappy777 · 11/08/2026 17:51

IdentifyingAsAWoollyMammoth · 10/08/2026 23:59

Having loved the Fry and Laurie J&W series all those years ago and rewatching them on dvd I thought, during Covid, that it was about time I tried some Wodehouse books.

What a sensible decision. I've read one every month, more or less, since then, so only have about 30 left to go. Only a few have been disappointing (mostly his earliest stuff) and while I enjoy Blandings I find J&W his best series. I think it's the Bertie narrations that clinch it (Ring for Jeeves aside).

For me, Thank You, Jeeves, Right Ho, Jeeves and The Code of the Woosters, collectively, are the absolute peak of his output. They're perfection.

I haven’t read that many Wodehouse books (probably around a dozen or so), but I totally agree with you. I read the very first Blandings book and was a little disappointed. Same goes for the short stories. But the best J&W novels are just sublime. I cannot think of enough superlatives. If you can learn to imitate the voices (I do a pretty good aunt Agatha, and a first class Jeeves), and then read them out loud, they are better than Prozac.

Many writers have written beautifully. There are lines of T S Eliot and Larkin and Tennyson that send a shiver down my spine. And I love the way Evelyn Waugh and Iris Murdoch and Oscar Wilder write prose. But with Wodehouse it’s different. His language is funny and beautiful but also light and joyful - like swimming in champagne, as someone said. Stephen Fry once said that it’s no coincidence Wodehouse is popular in prisons and psychiatric hospitals. He is ideal for those in pain.

OP posts:
Pinkclarko · 11/08/2026 18:02

IceBrownie · 10/08/2026 20:52

Just to add, as per PP Martin Jarvis is an excellent narrator for the audio version (but my favourite is Jonathan Cecil)

Agree, Jonathan Cecil is the best!

slughater · 11/08/2026 18:11

martin jarvis also a good narrator of the Just William stories

SpareVanKeys · 11/08/2026 18:46

slughater · 11/08/2026 18:11

martin jarvis also a good narrator of the Just William stories

Just William too! Just as I thought the thread couldn’t get any better 😊

I can’t choose a favourite Wodehouse but perhaps I could add Psmith into the mix

EmpressaurusKitty · 11/08/2026 18:54

It sounds like I’ve been listening to the wrong audiobooks. I listened to the BBC ones & got thoroughly irritated by the changes they made - Stinker Pinker played ‘soccer’ not rugby & cupboards were closets.

Dappy777 · 12/08/2026 15:00

In case anyone is interested, these are some pasted/chopped up bits from a wonderful article by Stephen Fry on P G Wodehouse. It's a superb bit of writing. If you want to read the whole thing, you can soon find it online.

What ho! My hero, PG Wodehouse

Then there is a passage such as this, Lord Emsworth musing on his feckless younger son, Freddie Threepwood.
Unlike the male codfish, which, suddenly finding itself the parent of three million five hundred thousand little codfish, cheerfully resolves to love them all, the British aristocracy is apt to look with a somewhat jaundiced eye on its younger sons.
If you are immune to such writing, you are fit, to use one of Wodehouse's favourite Shakespearean quotations, only for treasons, stratagems and spoils. You don't analyse such sunlit perfection, you just bask in its warmth and splendour. Like Jeeves, Wodehouse stands alone, and analysis is useless.

Wherever lovers of Wodehouse cluster together, they fall into debate about whether it is the Jeeves stories or the Blandings stories that take the trophy as Wodehouse's greatest achievements. The group will, of course, dispel, muttering embarrassedly, for they know that such questions are as pointless as wondering whether God did a better job with the Alps or the Rockies. The question is bound to be asked, however, because each time you read another Blandings story, the sublime nature of that world is such as to make you gasp.
The cast of resident characters here is greater than that of the Wooster canon. There is Lord Emsworth himself, the amiable and dreamy peer, whose first love – pumpkins – is soon supplanted by the truest and greatest love of his life, the Empress of Blandings, that peerless Black Berkshire sow, thrice winner of the silver medal for the fattest pig in Shropshire; Emsworth's sister, Connie, who, when sorely tried, which was often, would retire upstairs to bathe her temples in eau-de-Cologne; the Efficient Baxter, Emsworth's secretary and a hound from hell; Emsworth's brother, Galahad, the last of the Pelicans (that breed of silk-hatted men about town who lived high and were forever getting thrown out of the Criterion bar in theEighties and Nineties); the younger son, Freddie, the bane of his father's life... The cast list goes on and is frequently supplemented by young men we will have met elsewhere, Ronnie Fish, Pongo Twistleton and even Psmith himself.
Blandings comes, in the Wodehouse canon, to stand for the absolute ideal in country houses. Its serenity and beauty are enough to calm the most turbulent breast. It is an entire world unto itself and, one senses, Wodehouse pours into it his deepest feelings for England. Once you have drunk from its healing spring, you will return again and again. Blandings is like that: it enters a man's soul.
The young men I mention as visiting Blandings are all members of Wodehouse's great fictional institution the Drones Club, in Dover Street, off Piccadilly. There are dozens of individual stories about members of the Drones, and two principal collections, Eggs Beans and Crumpets and Young Men in Spats. The title of the first derives from the Drones' habit of referring to each other as "old egg", "old bean", "my dear old crumpet" and so on. The Drones Club is a refuge for the idle young man about town. Such beings are for the most part entirely dependent on allowances from fat uncles. Indeed the name Drones is a reference to the drone bee, which toils not, neither does it spin, unlike its industrious cousin, the worker. An archetypal member would be Freddie Widgeon, intensely amiable, not very bright up top and always falling in love. The only Drone who is distinctly unlikeable is Oofy Prosser, the richest and meanest member. He sports pimples, Lobb shoes and the tightest wallet in London.
The second-richest member of the club is the most likeable. He is Bertram Wilberforce Wooster, descendant of the Sieur de Wooster who did his bit in the Crusades, and young Bertram retains the strict code of honour handed down from his ancestor, the code of the preux chevalier, the gentil parfit knight. Bertie Wooster is, of course, the employer of Jeeves, the supreme gentleman's personal gentleman.

While not intelligent within the meaning of the act, Bertie is desperate to learn, keen to assimilate the wisdom of his incomparable teacher. He may only half-know the quotations and allusions with which he peppers his speech, but proximity to the great brain has made him aware of the possibilities of exerting the cerebellum.
Wodehouse's genius in the Jeeves and Wooster canon lies in his complete realisation of Bertie as first-person narrator. Almost all the other stories depend upon standard, impersonal narration. The particular joy of a Jeeves story comes from the delicious feeling one derives from being completely in Bertie's hands. His apparently confused way of expressing him- self both reveals character and manages, somehow, to develop narrative with extraordinary economy and life. Since the Jeeves stories often lead one from the other, he will often need to repeat himself, which he manages to do with great ingenuity. He is called upon more than once, for example, to remind the reader about the dread daughter of Sir Roderick Glossop. The first example shows Bertie's way with Victorian poetry:

I once got engaged to his daughter Honoria, a ghastly dynamic exhibit who read Nietzsche and had a laugh like waves breaking on a stern and rockbound coast.

Another description of precisely the same characteristics in Honoria give us a very Woosteresque mixture of simile:
Honoria... is one of those robust, dynamic girls with the muscles of a welter-weight and a laugh like a squadron of cavalry charging on a tin bridge.

Sometimes Bertie's speech moves towards a form of comic imagery so perfect that one could honestly call it poetic:
As a rule, you see, I'm not lugged into Family Rows. On the occasions when Aunt is calling to Aunt like mastodons bellowing across primeval swamps... the clan has a tendency to ignore me.
The masterly episode where Gussie Fink-Nottle presents the prizes at Market Snodsbury grammar school is frequently included in collections of great comic literature and has often been described as the single funniest piece of sustained writing in the language. I would urge you, however, to head straight for a library or bookshop and get hold of the complete novel Right Ho, Jeeves, where you will encounter it fully in context and find that it leaps even more magnificently to life.
I think I should end on a personal note. I have written it before and am not ashamed to write it again. Without Wodehouse I am not sure that I would be a tenth of what I am today – whatever that may be. In my teenage years, his writings awoke me to the possibilities of language. His rhythms, tropes, tricks and mannerisms are deep within me. But more than that, he taught me something about good nature. It is enough to be benign, to be gentle, to be funny, to be kind.
He mocked himself sometimes because he knew that a great proportion of his readers came from prisons and hospitals. At the risk of being sententious, isn't it true that we are all of us, for a great part of our lives, sick or imprisoned, all of us in need of this remarkable healing spirit, this balm for hurt minds?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page