choice of three

[doziduck]

does anyone have any feedback on the following books for me please. I don't know which one to choose and recently seem to have been reading books that are just 'o.k' but not 'fab' iykwim.
they are :

Mothers boys - margaret forster

the lovely bones - Alice Sebold

Red leaves - Paullina simons

the Lovely Bones is brill IMO (made me cry! and makes you think about families and how they work and all that...) not read the other two

Read Mothers Boys years ago (I think, unless I'm mixing it up with something else). If it's the one I'm thinking of it's excellent.
Lovely Bones was also good, wierd and interesting. Haven't read the other.

try 'the lazarus child' robert mawson ....made me get tears in my eyes...any1 else agree?

i was underwhelmed by the lovely bones i have to say. Haven't read the other two.

I also thought The Lovely Bones was wonderful - don't know the other two.

There is a long thread about the Lovely Bones somewhere doziduck.