Swim or Gym?

[ConstantHeadache]

Next year I have the option to either join the swimming club (meaning I can go swimming 3 times a week) or join the gym (I could go to the gym as many times as I wanted to. I know swimming is supposed to be the best exercise for you but I really want to lose weight and tone up in as shorter time as possible.
I also plan to be training in karate twice a week.
So, do I go for swimming or Gym?

i do bpoth one after the other..i lost 4 stone

I take it you do the swim afterwards? this is also an option for me

yes i do an hour in the gym and then swim 60 lengths

how long did it take you to lose the weight? how often do you go?

a year and i try to go three times but i did a lot more for about 3 months and less for the last couple as i am too busy

3 times is my aim and trying to do that at the mo

i went from 14st7 to about 10st2 at the mo