would u give a 1yr old a mini milk ice lolly?

[misdee]

dd3 is trying to grab the older dd's ice lollies. she just seems too young IMO to have one lol.

yes I would

but then I'm not a very good mother

Yes as a treat!

Personally, yes I would. Probably shouldn't, but I still would.

do you think the cold would shock her too much?

yes.

ds3 had his first taste of ice cream at 7-8 months when he stole it out of my hands...at a MN meet up!!!

I did with the DTs. Fab but messy!

Yes I would.

Ds1 hated icecream of any description until very recently (he's almost 5). Ds2 (2 in May) adores icecream and we quite often have some good ish quality vanilla in the freezer for treat quick desserts.

Yes, at a year old DD was eating pretty much normal food, with the odd treat allowed.

i would too

(and Twiglett - you bloody are... false modesty is very unbecoming, m'dear )

yes
what twiglett said

DD was having strwaberry and chocolate ice-cream at 9 months - we were on holiday in Spain and everyone else was having some...so it seemed mean not to give her a taste of it too!

YES!

Jess loved them last summer when she had just turned 1. Bit cold but their faces are a picture!

did yesterday actually for the first time..... he LOVED it!!

Yes! They're just the right size tooProbably don't tend to think about ice cream this time of the year though. And yes, I'd do choc buttons too.

Yes of course I would.

But I also used to buy those ice pop bags and make orange or apple juice ice pops for our kids when they were small.

yes I would - in fact I think I did but then again in MN eyes I am a bad mummy - bottle feeder, disposable user, jar user etc....

yes, as a treat. they love ices at that age and more goes on the ground than in their mouths!

Yes. Neither ds them had them regularly, they've probably only had 6 between them in their entire lifetimes, but didn't see anything wrong with them. They're much more manageable than ice cream at that age.

Does anyone have a pack? - what ingredients does it have? - the walls website doesnt have any details.

I prob would too, they're not too bad iirc. My most food fascist friend lets her ds have one at the zoo etc.

Yes, defo would xx

Of course.
I remember dd2 having them at 4 months old and loving them.

DONT GIVE THE CHOCOLATE ONES!

they stain clothes really badly. other than that, yes. ds3 loves them

Yes, my kids loved them at that age. Is it really such a crime then?!