Winkel or Skwish rattle / toy?

[AngelDog]

I want to buy DS (4.5 months) either a Winkel teething rattle, or a Skwish toy. He had great fun with both at a friend's house, as he was able to immediately pick them up and chew them, which he can't do with other things yet.

Which should I buy? I'm only going to get one or the other. I'd probably be inclined to get whichever is going to last him the longest.

Any recommendations welcome.

The skwish seems to have pretty good resale value on ebay if that helps

DD still loves the skwish at 10 months as well.

I slightly regret not having got DS or DD a skwish when younger so would say to get that. I would quite like one at the age of 34

I got DS the winkel and wish that I had got the Skwish, as I think there's a lot more play in it.

Noah - me too

Thanks for the opinions, a skwish it is, I think.

But I wonder whether you'd chew it as much at 34 as you would at 4 months?

Probably less chewing but a lot of Skwishing