Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Moral dilemma-how do I minimise the guilt from refusing to be bail address?

36 replies

Desperatelysadandangry · 09/11/2026 17:36

So our adult son is currently is currently on remand for serious crimes. This is the second time but for different crimes. Last time almost broke us, two of his siblings wont have anything to do with him. He is pleading not guilty to the most serious. Our dilemma is that he has asked to be bailed to our address. We are not agreeing to this, before anyone says not to. He has no one else at all. So he will be remanded until the trial. He will be upset at this and probably will see it as us assuming his guilt. I dont know if he is. I think he believes hes not guilty.
Our reasons are-it will damage our relationships with his siblings.
He is incredibly difficult to live with, we'd visit regularly and honestly a couple of hours was enough. He's got some out-there beliefs and does talk rubbish.
It will damage our health-last time my blood pressure went from normal to high and the stress was incredible. We both look like ghosts after his arrest.
We've had enough. He's had chance after chance. He's lost tenancies. He fucked up uni. He lurches from one unsuitable relationship to another. We aren't young, the thought of him here for our old age is awful. Our other kids will never come home if hes here.
We worry that if hes bailed here, gets off or a suspended sentence we'll be stuck with him. But also in that scenario, where will he go? The streets?
I know some will say this is an.awful way to talk about your son, I agree, I love him, I mourn for the little boy with such promise, but i dont like him, I don't like the choices hes made to get him here, I hate that I have to lurk about in case anyone connects us. But we've always said we'd help the child most in need, sadly that always seems to be him. His solicitor is gently pressuring us to have him. He hasnt yet called us, hes written saying he's not guilty. My heart is sinking anticipating when he does call, what we are going to tell him. We don't want to abandon him, but our well is dry.
I dont know what I want from this post. We know we are doing the right thing for us and the rest of the family. But I feel sick, at what hes potentially done and what is yet to happen.

OP posts:
AmserGwely · 09/11/2026 17:46

I think you are doing the right thing. He has made his choices, and now has to live with the consequences. Even if he is not guilty, his lifestyle has led him to this situation.

He won't learn if he is always being pulled out of the shit by someone else. Besides, him being in yulout house puts you at risk depending on what he has got himself into.

Being there and helping him doesnt have to mean throwing yourself under the bus

Dorothyperky · 09/11/2026 17:50

You must protect yourself and your wider family. You haven't said his crime but if it's violent (rape, gbh, murder) you must think of the victims.

I would mourn my child but I would never want to see him.

MarcellaGrace · 09/11/2026 17:52

Protect yourselves and your relationships with your other children as a priority. Then think about what, if anything, you’re prepared to do for your on-remand son.

Theinvite · 09/11/2026 17:53

By considering his past victims and no doubt his potential victims

spreadandsprinkles · 09/11/2026 17:54

Honestly, I think I would be very firm with the solicitor to the point if they badgered me I would cut contact with them. They have no right to do this. Hold firm for the sake of your other children.

WhatNoRaisins · 09/11/2026 17:55

I've said this before but there's setting yourself on fire to keep someone else warm and then there's setting yourself on fire and it achieving nothing.

Personally I'd prioritise my relationships with my other children here too.

holdabigbag · 09/11/2026 17:57

How old is he? Does he have a girl/boyfriend to stay with or a mate?

is he involved in drugs or addiction of some kind? Or one just being a dickhead? Either way I don’t blame you for not having him back.

just tell the solicitor your will to support him with love if he needs to go to rehab, or wants to get a job or uni or whatever but not under your roof. Enough is enough

Sometimessmiling · 09/11/2026 18:03

I think you are doing the right thing. Your other kids don't need this as you and your husband don't either. Hard as it is as a mum sometimes doing the very hard thing is the safest and most important. It may do him more good to face the reality that you're not there to continually prop him up. Solicitor has no right to pressure you. Be strong and be safe

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 09/11/2026 18:04

You need to protect yourself and your other children. Very hard but he needs to face the consequences of his actions. He will either sink or swim but you must protect yourself and your other children first.

Hatty65 · 09/11/2026 18:09

This is very sad, but I've watched my (extremely) elderly parents deal with my younger brother who is an alcoholic and who has lived with them for well over a decade. The stress it has caused them is unreal.

I agree with pp that you if you have contact from the solicitor suggesting this you need to say very clearly 'Neither of us is well enough to even consider having him bailed here. Please don't bring this up again as the answer will not change under any circumstances'. Make it clear that if they raise it again you will make a formal complaint against them.

Nighttimenoise · 09/11/2026 18:10

100% doing the right thing. I'd take control re the solicitor and email them to say you have made your decision and would appreciate it if they accepted it.

Monty36 · 09/11/2026 18:18

I feel so sorry for you and your husband.
Sadly, there are some souls who damage their world and others to an unbelievable degree. Be it drugs, violence. They often go together. Crime.
It must be so hard. Your heart is saying one thing, your head another.

I think you know the answer. But hard doesn’t come close to it. Whatever you do it will be painful. It is a case of loving him but unable to have him.

babyproblems · 09/11/2026 18:25

This sounds so hard - I think you’re doing the right thing @Desperatelysadandangry . You’re walking a fine line that keeps your health and your other children in contact, and you’re not cutting off your son. I think this is the correct and fair approach.

He is an adult and he is responsible for his actions and choices. Have you had any counselling to help you come to terms with his choices? I think I would consider it if I was in your shoes as his parent.

Wishing you the best of luck going forward. XXX

Desperatelysadandangry · 09/11/2026 18:47

holdabigbag · 09/11/2026 17:57

How old is he? Does he have a girl/boyfriend to stay with or a mate?

is he involved in drugs or addiction of some kind? Or one just being a dickhead? Either way I don’t blame you for not having him back.

just tell the solicitor your will to support him with love if he needs to go to rehab, or wants to get a job or uni or whatever but not under your roof. Enough is enough

In his 30s. No one, his neighbour was his friend but as hes called as a witness and he's not that close I don't think it would be acceptable.
No drugs. But its horrible and sordid. Stupid and arrogant.
A charity for families in our situation is going to arrange counselling.
Solicitor is going to be told of our decision.
To make it more difficult, he's autistic, so he got a lot of extra attention and time from us since he was a kid. He's high functioning, but he's increasingly used it as an excuse why his life has turned out as it has. We have never brought him up to think that way. But it dies make him potentially more vulnerable.

OP posts:
ThreeLocusts · 09/11/2026 19:11

OP I'm so very sorry. I'm not sure I've got anything useful to say, but here goes:

Would it help to:

Try and get ahead of the situation - email the solicitor (you'd get too much blowback if you called, I suspect) with the reasons that you're giving here: you have other children to think of, you've got to protect your own health and sanity, you have clear previous experience that shows that your son won't consider his siblings' needs or yours.

Be very clear that yes you do love him and no, that doesn't mean you have to or are willing to put up with him at your address. If he or the solicitor try to tell you that you can't love him if you won't have him, remind them that there's far too much painful history involved here for such simple reasoning.

Visit him, tell him you won't give up on him, but actions have consequences, including his actions towards you. He has to mend his ways in order to obtain the kind of help he is currently angling for, and because of his past actions you currently can't take the risk of taking him in on the mere promises he may be willing to make.

As for the guilt - I don't have experience with children with criminal convictions, but I have f*ed up spectacularly in other ways, and am paying a price for it. Tbh I still don't have a 'protocol' for dealing with the guilt, after rehashing certain decisions countless times. So at least I can tell you you aren't alone. Remember, you did what you thought was best with limited information and a limited store of time, nerves and so forth.

This too will pass. Here's a piece of music I listen to when I'm scraping the barrel:
May not work for you at all, but I hope you have something that does work.

Wishing you strength.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tz_llJqeax4

Dorothyperky · 09/11/2026 19:25

OP telling you this to try to help.
I was sexually abused as a child.
My mother was a police officer and I didn't tell her as my sibling threatened to kill me.
It has effected me all of my life.

If your son has done this he is a danger to your wider family. Please don't take that risk. fwiw my sibling is ND but it didn't excuse the abuse he subjected me to. I have always been very vigilant around my own children.

Desperatelysadandangry · 09/11/2026 19:41

Dorothyperky · 09/11/2026 19:25

OP telling you this to try to help.
I was sexually abused as a child.
My mother was a police officer and I didn't tell her as my sibling threatened to kill me.
It has effected me all of my life.

If your son has done this he is a danger to your wider family. Please don't take that risk. fwiw my sibling is ND but it didn't excuse the abuse he subjected me to. I have always been very vigilant around my own children.

Bless you, im so sorry for what you went through, but to be clear, none of his crimes or actions were directed at any of his siblings, they for reasons prior to his first arrest didnt speak to him much, they didnt get on with him, but tolerated him. Now they don't even want to hear about him. Which is their choice and I support (dh was at first less tolerant of their decisions, but now agrees)

OP posts:
Sweetandsours · 09/11/2026 20:32

OP, you have done the right thing in saying no.
As a parent you put in the effort and time.
Sometimes we have to accept and grieve what we cannot change.
Your other children will have seen your efforts and they deserve to be considered.

One of my sons primary school friends came from a lovely family where one son was ND and suffered from anxiety and depression.
His parents were the loveliest people.
He murdered his mother at home one day and went to the police station and turned himself in.
Horrendous shock to everyone.
The grief of her husband and children is raw years later.
She did everything for him, and his siblings believe that their mother gave her best to him, and yet they all still lost her.
They grieve her terribly still to this day.
They have such awful anger at what he took from them.

Protect yourselves and your health as best you can.
Your other children deserve no less.

Ruella1 · 10/11/2026 07:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

cuckoolodger · 10/11/2026 07:50

I’ve been in your shoes op. We were told no chance of bail at all and so packed up all of his stuff and put it into storage. 6 weeks later the judge said he could have bail but my other son didn’t want him back in the property ( they shared a flat). The solicitor spoke to shelter and they said they couldn’t help unless he was released, but he couldn’t be released unless he had an address so arrived in circles. He was remanded until trial. A few weeks later my son did a turn around after learning that if he didn’t have an address, the judge was suggesting a custodial sentence of 2-3 years. He said he could come back but was going into the small room and they would be distant house mates and it would take a v v long time to earn trust back if ever. I wrote to the judge and said were would support him, I’d looked at the recidivism rates and I knew he had more chance of staying “clean” with family support etc. my dd and my DH attended court bit I couldn’t do it. Thankfully the judge released him as he would not do well in prison due to being AuDhd. My family is destroyed though. My daughters refuse to see him but do still love him on a kind of historic level I guess? I obviously love him and I’m so sad and sorry that I clearly did something very wrong. He had a very very formal relationship with his brother who he lives with and they don’t really speak as he just can’t get over it. So realistically my family will never be whole again. The next time I have my 4 children united it will be because either myself or my Dh has died and that’s a horrible thought…. But I totally respect my kids right to cut him off. He’s currently planning to do a hgv course and move down south where he has some friends for a fresh start.

He was arrested for illegal images at 18yo. Been groomed online for 2-3 years into believing he was trans etc. He had such promise. ,A* student, loved by his peers and member of local theatre group. It destroyed us when it went public. It’s a horrible horrible thing for any family to go through desire the fact that I know 100% justice needs to happen.

Dorothyperky · 10/11/2026 08:40

@cuckoolodger I feel for you.
One of my children was groomed online.

If you can bare it listen to the podcast of Dr Soh.
She interviews Chole Cole a former ftm.
It explains so much of this cult like ideology.
I think her summation explains so much.

something2say · 10/11/2026 08:44

Dear OP,

In your shoes, I would do the same. Your son meeds to start reaping what he sows. Then he may start to learn.

When I was younger, I saved people. Then I grew up and realised that it was a way to keep the peace and to keep myself safe, and to maintain control. But it is not my job to keep the peace, especially if someone else is that willing to breach it or to have control over everything.

Your job now is to help your son learn how to be independent, and he will not learn if Mummy keeps saving him from the consequences of his actions.

In fact the quicker he learns, the happier everyone will be, including you.

X

NoNonsense79 · 10/11/2026 08:50

The pain must be so strong. But I do think you’re doing the right thing. You have a responsibility to your other children as well, and while it sounds like you have tried and tried with your son, there comes a time when he has to take responsibility for his actions. He’s an adult. But be kind to yourselves, none of this is easy.

I worked in criminal legal offices for many years (support not as a solicitor) and the impact on families of offenders is often overlooked. Quite rightly the victims are the focus, but that doesn’t mean you aren’t also impacted. You are allowed to feel angry, aghast, and disappointed. It’s ok to let him feel the consequences of his behaviour. It is. If your fault.

Gassylady · 10/11/2026 08:52

AmserGwely · 09/11/2026 17:46

I think you are doing the right thing. He has made his choices, and now has to live with the consequences. Even if he is not guilty, his lifestyle has led him to this situation.

He won't learn if he is always being pulled out of the shit by someone else. Besides, him being in yulout house puts you at risk depending on what he has got himself into.

Being there and helping him doesnt have to mean throwing yourself under the bus

First answer has nailed it

Desperatelysadandangry · 10/11/2026 09:27

Irs hard to reply to individuals, but thank you all for replying with empathy. I think as parents of nd children, no.matter what you do, there's always a bit of guilt that you've done something wrong. I know for us, 30 years ago, we had no idea what Aspergers, as it was termed then, was. Support was patchy. The internet was new. But that the internet was a contributi g factor in his mindset. No matter how strange, or repugnant(to us) his interests were(im not talking illegal at that point) there was someone out there to validate him. And he was alone/lonely/a loner. He had doomed relationships with women who had their own problems. Only two weeks previously he'd asked us to be guarantors for him.and his latest very new "partner". We said no, thank god, or at this point we'd be screwed.
We are clearing his flat(supplied by an amazing charity, which he fucked up by moving this person in)and he wants us to store everything for him. We are going to be firm, only valuable, useful or minimal sentimental stuff.
I didnt sleep last night, horrible thoughts going through my head, I even wished he wasn't alive, just so this unsolvable problems would go away. He'll have no life on release, he should never be in a relationship. He's hurt everyone who's ever loved him, but just sails along thinking his life choices are ok.
Sorry, thi is turning into a venting session, but apart from dh I haven't anyone. Im not burdening friends or our other kids. We will tell them, but not till after his initial court date.
Thank you everyone.

OP posts: