Please or to access all these features

30 days only

AIBU not to let my son’s father meet our 6 year old son

357 replies

BeWaryBeaker · 08/11/2026 21:33

I have a six year old son. His father and I were never in a relationship; we knew each other casually and slept together a few times. We always used protection, but the last time, he removed it without my consent. I wasn’t happy about it, but I didn’t want to argue, so I cut contact completely.

About a month later, I found out I was pregnant. I initially planned to have an abortion, but I couldn’t go through with it and became attached to the pregnancy.
Before I found out I was pregnant, I’d bought a three bedroom house in a fairly nice area of Surrey, commutable to London because of work. My parents helped me with the deposit because they were fed up with me living in house shares and complaining about my two housemates! I’d been saving, but their help made it possible. I have a good job and salary, and at 35 I can support my son without help from his father. I earn around £140k.I’m now in a relationship. We’ve been together for two years but haven’t moved in together yet; we hope to in the future. He doesn’t have children.

I never removed my son’s father from Facebook, but we’d had no contact for years. After I changed my profile picture to one of me and my son for his birthday, his father messaged to ask if the child in the picture was mine. My son looks very much like him. I didn’t reply at first, but then he called. I confirmed that it was my son and told him I didn’t want him involved in our lives. I feel we’ve managed perfectly well as the two of us, and I don’t want someone who broke my trust back in my life.

He asked what would happen if our son wanted to know about him. I said we’ve talked about it and will talk more when he’s older. I’m struggling to know what to do. Should I consider letting his father make contact, or am I right to keep that door closed for now. My son and I are very happy, he has positive male figures in his life, I have 4 brothers, they have children, one has a son a few weeks older than my son and they’re very close. He has a community, his father hurt me and I don’t know how I feel about it. I forgot he even existed I got used to being a single mother it’s all I’ve ever known.

OP posts:
StartleBright · 09/11/2026 08:15

Wow, this child was conceived after rape and people are jumping straight over that rather big issue to the needs of the child. Goodness gracious. OP, you sound like you are level headed and sensible. Of course you feel conflict over what choice to make. But you do not have to let your precious son be influenced by a toxic rapist. Your son can make the decision when he is an adult as to how much contact to have with the man, and knowing the context for you. Don’t keep secrets on the rapists behalf, and let your son know about your decision and the factors that influenced you at an age appropriate time.

Passaggressfedup · 09/11/2026 08:17

Posters are conflicting two things. Your experience, and your child's rights to create a bond with his father.

In courts the two are unrelated. The only factor that would be considered as to whether he could have contact with the child is whether he would be a safeguarding concern in the present and future.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:17

Decisionfatiguemum · 09/11/2026 08:11

What good will come of a child having a relationship with a father who a) raped his mother and b) who will have a frozen if not acrimonious relationship with his mother as she as a victim can't exactly be super warm to him? And if she is expected to be then what world are we living in where a man wrongs a woman so deeply and unlawfully and then can enjoy being a father while the woman puts up and shuts up?

No, not the world we want to raise boys to men in.

I don't see your solution as in any way in the best interests of this child or potentially of his future relationship with his mother.

She was wronged but she has from that harm a child she adores. She made the choice to continue the pregnancy and keep the baby. She knew at that point how he was conceived and in the age of DNA and social media (which she placed him in full view on) she must have realised that she would not be able to keep him hidden from his father.

If she wants what's best for him now and she wants to maintain her relationship with him as an adult, she needs to do what's right for him now.

laurini · 09/11/2026 08:23

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:15

IMO, there's not a hope in hell of this man ever being prosecuted for rape unless there was a camera in the room or a live independent witness 7 years ago.

Condoms fail, unwanted pregnancies happen.

The police will view this as another estranged mother trying to prevent having to have contact with her child's father.

If he admits it in a text message to OP, that would be useful. He's previously admitted to OP he did it because it felt better.

Decisionfatiguemum · 09/11/2026 08:23

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:17

I don't see your solution as in any way in the best interests of this child or potentially of his future relationship with his mother.

She was wronged but she has from that harm a child she adores. She made the choice to continue the pregnancy and keep the baby. She knew at that point how he was conceived and in the age of DNA and social media (which she placed him in full view on) she must have realised that she would not be able to keep him hidden from his father.

If she wants what's best for him now and she wants to maintain her relationship with him as an adult, she needs to do what's right for him now.

Edited

Agree is a mess of a situation, but caused by this man. He is the disrupting factor from conception to now. Its an almost impossible situation for the poster, but what is better, a boy grows up without the influence of a man who in lawful and moral terms raped his mother, or a boy grows up with both parents, one of whom raped him mother.

We also don't know anything about this man except what he did and yet people are just seeing the need for a father son relationship. Is he a good man now? Is he a good example? Will his input be good for the relationship between mother and son anyway?

The poster shouldn't be held hostage to a possible future where her son resents her for not letting his father near him so aquiescing now just in case.

She chose to keep the baby but that choice was thrust on her by a man removing a condom. If she'd gone the other way she'd have had an abortion and that's not undertaken lightly either. His decision made her have to agonise over the choice.

She also chose to not have her rapist in the baby's life.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:25

Rape is a broad word these days.

In the context of a father's right to see his child, do people really see no difference between nonconsensual penetration and consensual penetration with no consent to remove the condom?

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:27

Decisionfatiguemum · 09/11/2026 08:23

Agree is a mess of a situation, but caused by this man. He is the disrupting factor from conception to now. Its an almost impossible situation for the poster, but what is better, a boy grows up without the influence of a man who in lawful and moral terms raped his mother, or a boy grows up with both parents, one of whom raped him mother.

We also don't know anything about this man except what he did and yet people are just seeing the need for a father son relationship. Is he a good man now? Is he a good example? Will his input be good for the relationship between mother and son anyway?

The poster shouldn't be held hostage to a possible future where her son resents her for not letting his father near him so aquiescing now just in case.

She chose to keep the baby but that choice was thrust on her by a man removing a condom. If she'd gone the other way she'd have had an abortion and that's not undertaken lightly either. His decision made her have to agonise over the choice.

She also chose to not have her rapist in the baby's life.

Edited

She is likely to have no choice. He is likely to either go to the law now, or approach the boy when he is older.

Wouldn't it be better to try to keep this under her own control now than for either of those to happen?

Decisionfatiguemum · 09/11/2026 08:28

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:27

She is likely to have no choice. He is likely to either go to the law now, or approach the boy when he is older.

Wouldn't it be better to try to keep this under her own control now than for either of those to happen?

No.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:32

angelasim · 08/11/2026 22:26

Is removing contraception without the partner's consent, officially classed as rape?
Are women accused of rape if they stop taking the pill without telling their partner?

Yes removing a condom without consent is rape by deception.
No a woman lieing about being on the pill is not rape

Decisionfatiguemum · 09/11/2026 08:33

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:27

She is likely to have no choice. He is likely to either go to the law now, or approach the boy when he is older.

Wouldn't it be better to try to keep this under her own control now than for either of those to happen?

It won't be under her control. She can't explain to a child about his conception, so he will go and build a relationship with his father, out of her sight as he'd have custody at times. She will never be able to tell him what happened, dropping it on him as an adult would most likely cause a bigger fall out.

So she either accepts she can never say what happened and her son goes to a man who did rape her, perhaps 50% of the time away from her. Or she tells him when he's old enough to know and risks a huge fallout anyway, and turmoil in her son who knew his dad as a child now but has to look at him with new eyes as an adult.

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:36

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:32

Yes removing a condom without consent is rape by deception.
No a woman lieing about being on the pill is not rape

It is fairly similar in terms of moral blame though, as both acts constitute a deception. Personally I don't think stealthing belongs in the same category as rape though.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:45

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:36

It is fairly similar in terms of moral blame though, as both acts constitute a deception. Personally I don't think stealthing belongs in the same category as rape though.

Apart from the fact that it is the female who carries the child it's exactly the same deception. Though women do it to get pregnant and men normally because they don't like the feel of a condom, which are completely different.

I have real problems with the law calling this form of non-consensual sex rape and huge problems with anyone thinking this boy should be told at any time that his father is a rapist.

IMO rape should be a term reserved for when penetration of itself was non consensual.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:47

squarecrow · 08/11/2026 23:14

Unfortunately, although no parent ever has automatic right to meet or otherwise have contact with their children, a man who r*ped his partner would not automatically have contact to his children restricted.

He could apply to the court, and he could pass a risk assessment if there is no background of harming children. It’s not uncommon.

Under the new rules that have come into force in family crt fathers who abuse the mother and/or rape her are to be treated as if they are child abusers because DV against the mother has finally been recognised as child abuse too.
The presumption that contact is always in the best interest of the child has also been removed.
So thankfully you are wrong now and his chances of passing a risk assessment are slim to none under the new rules

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 08:48

If a woman tampers with a condom she is committing sexual assault and reproductive coercion. I would argue that’s what he has done too. I don’t know exactly why it doesn’t count for a woman to lie about being on the pill, when the result would obviously be the same.

OP was not forced to have sex with him, but of course the violation of then finding out you were tricked into something you didn’t agree to (doing it with no protection) and then being faced with a difficult choice: to violate your body further with an abortion or to actually grow inside you and then raise a child you didn’t try to conceive, is a bit different from the consequences for a man. Maybe that’s why it’s treated more seriously.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 08:49

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:47

Under the new rules that have come into force in family crt fathers who abuse the mother and/or rape her are to be treated as if they are child abusers because DV against the mother has finally been recognised as child abuse too.
The presumption that contact is always in the best interest of the child has also been removed.
So thankfully you are wrong now and his chances of passing a risk assessment are slim to none under the new rules

Respectfully, the rules are irrelevant. In practice, children who have been abused are ignored and forced to have contact with their abusers. A risk assessment may take into account abuse to the mother, but if the child wasn’t present then the courts are very unlikely to care. Speaking from experience, both first and second hand.

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:50

Timeforachange26 · 08/11/2026 23:19

If I had been in that position id have taken the morning after pill

You do know that the morning after pill doesn't always work right

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:50

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:47

Under the new rules that have come into force in family crt fathers who abuse the mother and/or rape her are to be treated as if they are child abusers because DV against the mother has finally been recognised as child abuse too.
The presumption that contact is always in the best interest of the child has also been removed.
So thankfully you are wrong now and his chances of passing a risk assessment are slim to none under the new rules

Which rules are these?

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:54

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:45

Apart from the fact that it is the female who carries the child it's exactly the same deception. Though women do it to get pregnant and men normally because they don't like the feel of a condom, which are completely different.

I have real problems with the law calling this form of non-consensual sex rape and huge problems with anyone thinking this boy should be told at any time that his father is a rapist.

IMO rape should be a term reserved for when penetration of itself was non consensual.

I agree. On mumsnet, people actively encourage women to become pregnant 'accidentally' if they want a baby though, yet a man removing the condom is rape. There's also been an unhelpful widening of the rape category by some people to include any deception, eg if a man doesn't tell you that he is already in a relationship, this is rape. It's not helpful. Rape in my eyes is non-consensual penetration at the time that it happens. Not finding out details later where you would have made different choices had you known.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 08:57

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 08:47

Under the new rules that have come into force in family crt fathers who abuse the mother and/or rape her are to be treated as if they are child abusers because DV against the mother has finally been recognised as child abuse too.
The presumption that contact is always in the best interest of the child has also been removed.
So thankfully you are wrong now and his chances of passing a risk assessment are slim to none under the new rules

On what basis do you think he will fail a risk assessment for custody of a 6 year old child?

Domestic violence against a mother is abuse of the children who exist at the time. It cannot be abuse against a child who doesn't yet exist. He has not abused any children.

He has been convicted of nothing. His mother is extremely unlikely to be able to get the CPS to prosecute in a case with no witnesses where she was not using a backup contraceptive (knowing that condoms can and do fail) and where she chose to keep the child and then voluntarily put his face on the internet under her name.

And even if she did, he isn't a paedophile, in company with a huge number of men he prefers naked sex and selfishly chose to take that without permission. He's no danger to a 6 year old boy who has a right to know his father, however painful his mother finds that.

She's in a right bind, but she needs to do what's right for that boy and for her future relationship with him.

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 08:58

Glowingup · 09/11/2026 08:54

I agree. On mumsnet, people actively encourage women to become pregnant 'accidentally' if they want a baby though, yet a man removing the condom is rape. There's also been an unhelpful widening of the rape category by some people to include any deception, eg if a man doesn't tell you that he is already in a relationship, this is rape. It's not helpful. Rape in my eyes is non-consensual penetration at the time that it happens. Not finding out details later where you would have made different choices had you known.

While I agree in principle, there is a grey area when we talk about “informed consent”. What if the man has HIV? Wouldn’t you feel you had been absolutely violated and never would have agreed to the penetration had you known? What if you agreed and the lights went out and it was a different man? You actually consent in the moment, believing it’s someone else? So, while I understand your point, if consent isn’t informed, is it actually consent? And then where do you draw the line?

Hoardasurass · 09/11/2026 09:00

Timeforachange26 · 08/11/2026 23:41

I've not read anything about russel brand so no clue on the details

Wherever id I say she wasnt raped ffs. Not am I " deciding" how people including rape victims behave but obviously all actions have consequences.

Well thankfully you dont make the laws.
Removing a condom during sex without consent aka stealthing is considered rape by deception and is prosecuted fairly regularly.
So whether you consider it rape or not is irrelevant as the law says it is

LancashireButterPie · 09/11/2026 09:01

I'd threaten to report him to the police for the rape by deception.

Pinkflamingo10 · 09/11/2026 09:01

yanbu. Stealthing is a sexual assault and a crime.
I would 100% keep my child away from this man. cut all contact. Get new phone number, delete FB etc.

LancsMa · 09/11/2026 09:09

I'm so sorry this is happening to you OP. For some reason some people are being very aggressive towards you. I think you need to approach this as a woman whose beloved child is the product of rape. He's not just a father, he's a rapist father. I would take legal advice personally, and probably get some counselling to help me through it (if affordable, I know these things don't grow on trees), because this is not a 'normal' parental rights/responsibility issue. Please don't let this awful man disrupt your life for a second time. And yes, your son may well want to meet this person later in life, but as a rule we don't not introduce children to known rapists, so don't let the mumsnet mafia bully you into it.

Imdunfer · 09/11/2026 09:10

squarecrow · 09/11/2026 08:58

While I agree in principle, there is a grey area when we talk about “informed consent”. What if the man has HIV? Wouldn’t you feel you had been absolutely violated and never would have agreed to the penetration had you known? What if you agreed and the lights went out and it was a different man? You actually consent in the moment, believing it’s someone else? So, while I understand your point, if consent isn’t informed, is it actually consent? And then where do you draw the line?

You draw the line at whether there was agreement for that one man to penetrate you at that time.

Finding out it was someone else is rape. Finding out he had HIV is assault, potentially ABH or GBH if infected by him, and in the past might have been attempted murder. Finding out he took off a condom is a sexual assault.

I'm puzzled that women don't think there is a huge difference between being penetrated against your will at the moment of penetration and finding out later that you would have refused if you had known other information.

If finding other information retrospectively turns consensual sex into rape, then where is the line drawn about what information passes that threshold?

And I think if these sort of events are going to be rolled into the "reported rape" statistics it will affect the way rape is viewed.

Swipe left for the next trending thread