Please or to access all these features

30 days only

Buying a property where we aren't keen on area or wait to buy where we want.

48 replies

Karma1387 · 07/11/2026 13:56

So I am finally in a situation where I can start to see a light at the end of the financial tunnel so I am starting to think about buying a property eventually.

I have 2 options. First is to only put down a 5k deposit which means we can only borrow a max of 300,000 but means I don't have to clear all our debt and can take advantage of the bad market lowering prices over the next 12-24 months but it means living more rurally with a longer commute for me and DP in an area we aren't overly keen on.

Alternatively I focus on paying off debt and save a 5-10% deposit to borrow more (closer to 450-500k) to live in the house and area that we like but this will likely take 5-6 years.

What would people do in our situation? My mind says owning a house even if we dont like the area or love the house is better than spending the next 5-6 years paying rent?

OP posts:
clareykb · 08/11/2026 09:34

In your case I wouldn't worry about the secondary school we moved when DD was 6 to slightly further out than we planned to get a bigger house (slightly less salubrious suburb at the time secondary was requires improvement) plastic was to move again in u6 however in the time we have lived here the secondary schools have flipped. The one round the corner is now very good and massively over subscribed DD is in Y8 and lots of her friends from where we used to live are on the waiting list as the on near our old house is now dreadful

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 09:37

Mosaic123 · 08/11/2026 09:01

Can you find something in that right area with an annex on the side or some other rentable section. Ideally with some shared facility so you can use the Rent A Room allowance.

This will help pay a mortgage that is stretching you.

When things are better you can take this part over yourselves.

Two maisonettes that you can knock together eventually. Or some land you can offer for grazing/dogs/ storage? Anything that makes a bit of extra money for you.

We can easily afford the mortgage payment on the cheap houses thats not an issue. We just dont like the area much.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 09:39

Mosaic123 · 08/11/2026 09:01

Can you find something in that right area with an annex on the side or some other rentable section. Ideally with some shared facility so you can use the Rent A Room allowance.

This will help pay a mortgage that is stretching you.

When things are better you can take this part over yourselves.

Two maisonettes that you can knock together eventually. Or some land you can offer for grazing/dogs/ storage? Anything that makes a bit of extra money for you.

Unfortunately the issue with renting in the right area isnt about not being able to afford the mortgage payment. Its the fact we would need a 5% deposit ( so 20-25k) and we would also have to clear debt first.

OP posts:
ChapmanFarm · 08/11/2026 09:55

How was your debt accumulated? Maternity leave, a one off event like business going under or over a long period?

I'd be worried about taking on the large mortgage if you've overstretched before but it's obviously hard to gauge the full picture from one post.

Does renting or buying allow you to chuck more at the debt? Are you clearing it at a rapid rate now?

Nourishinghandcream · 08/11/2026 10:08

I would buy.
Every year you are paying mortgage is another chunk of equity built whereas paying rent is dead money.
I bought in an area I hated (was single) but after 3yrs I was able to buy the house I actually wanted as I had created equity and my salary had increased. Yes there were fees but being on the ladder made it all so much more achievable.

westisbest1982 · 08/11/2026 10:17

Nourishinghandcream · 08/11/2026 10:08

I would buy.
Every year you are paying mortgage is another chunk of equity built whereas paying rent is dead money.
I bought in an area I hated (was single) but after 3yrs I was able to buy the house I actually wanted as I had created equity and my salary had increased. Yes there were fees but being on the ladder made it all so much more achievable.

That was then and this is now. Falling prices, higher than usual interest rates which will increase, and a shit economy that's going to get shittier. Also, OP has a really low deposit, which is never a good thing.

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:36

ChapmanFarm · 08/11/2026 09:55

How was your debt accumulated? Maternity leave, a one off event like business going under or over a long period?

I'd be worried about taking on the large mortgage if you've overstretched before but it's obviously hard to gauge the full picture from one post.

Does renting or buying allow you to chuck more at the debt? Are you clearing it at a rapid rate now?

Majority of the debt was prior to meeting current partner and a series of mistakes/not working.

Both buying and renting are about the same cost wise per month. In terms of paying it off now that is the choice I am trying to make. Pay 1k off a month and start clearing it all down and then save a deposit and buy somewhere we like (will probably take 5-6 years in total) or leave the debt and save to buy somewhere was don't like very much (would take maybe 18 months)

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:37

westisbest1982 · 08/11/2026 10:17

That was then and this is now. Falling prices, higher than usual interest rates which will increase, and a shit economy that's going to get shittier. Also, OP has a really low deposit, which is never a good thing.

Yeah I appreciate 5k isnt a big deposit it would just allow us to get on the property ladder a lot quicker than waiting to pay off debt and save a deposit for somewhere we actually like.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:39

MrsMoastyToasty · 08/11/2026 09:08

I wouldn't worry too much about secondary schools at this point. The school can change a lot in a few years (the one my DS went to was threatened with closure at one point and is now very good).
I would pay more attention to getting the debt cleared at this point. Have you sought help from a debt advice charity or CAB?

No we havent go any advice. Its mainly all on loans so its just a case of paying it down and clearing the credit card.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:41

Doubleskunk · 08/11/2026 09:16

Would the cost of moving cost more than the rent? Probably would over one year, but maybe not over two plus.

In total with deposit to buy where we aren't keen we need 10k. 5k of that is fees/stamp duty which is 4 months rent for us.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:43

westisbest1982 · 08/11/2026 09:22

What makes you think house prices are going to go up again? From what I've read this isn't the case, as the impact of AI increases and the economy deteriorating. The cycles we've seen in the past are over.

I would focus on paying off your debt for at least one year and increasing your deposit.

I mean I would guess that over 6 years they are likely to increase to a certain extent maybe not like the past of course.

OP posts:
Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:44

Thank you everyone for the input. Seems very 50/50 on opinions so I think we will have to have a think about our options.

OP posts:
NotMeekNotObedient · 08/11/2026 10:45

Buy now.

PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2026 10:48

I’d personally put the idea of the ‘property ladder’ to one side. In a falling market things don’t work like that. Right now people are stuck unable to move, and though in my view it’s still worth buying a place to live, imo you should be thinking you’ll be staying there long term, like ten years. Moving to the more expensive place costs a lot.

Im sorry but on balance I still think your focus over the next year should be reducing your spending as much as possible and getting that debt down. That will reduce your costs significantly and give you confidence that you can afford to buy. Even if you only do it for a year, could you halve the debt?

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:58

PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2026 10:48

I’d personally put the idea of the ‘property ladder’ to one side. In a falling market things don’t work like that. Right now people are stuck unable to move, and though in my view it’s still worth buying a place to live, imo you should be thinking you’ll be staying there long term, like ten years. Moving to the more expensive place costs a lot.

Im sorry but on balance I still think your focus over the next year should be reducing your spending as much as possible and getting that debt down. That will reduce your costs significantly and give you confidence that you can afford to buy. Even if you only do it for a year, could you halve the debt?

We could probably half the debt in a year maybe 18 months but to buy where we want to live we would need to clear all of it and then save a full 5% deposit £25k plus and then stamp duty at around 12.5k plus solicitors etc we would probably need about 40k which will take a good 4 years to get together so we will be looking at around 6 years before we could buy where we want to live which just feels like a long time paying a lot of rent on a tiny house.

OP posts:
HaenschenKlein · 08/11/2026 11:23

i think you need to think very carefully here. The property ladder is only a ladder if prices are going up. They aren’t! They are reducing. You have 5k deposit. That’s not huge and property prices can quickly reduce by that amount. You’d then be stuck in negative equity when interest rates are increasing. The Bank of England have mentioned there may be 3 increases next year.
tbh if I were you I’d pay off the debt and wait 4 years.

PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2026 11:31

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 10:58

We could probably half the debt in a year maybe 18 months but to buy where we want to live we would need to clear all of it and then save a full 5% deposit £25k plus and then stamp duty at around 12.5k plus solicitors etc we would probably need about 40k which will take a good 4 years to get together so we will be looking at around 6 years before we could buy where we want to live which just feels like a long time paying a lot of rent on a tiny house.

Yeah I do see that. I was worrying about my post and hoping i wasn’t giving bad advice, sorry! As long as you are going into this with a good understanding that you may be buying into that area long term and that the property ladder is currently not in operation, by all means go for it. The desire not to be at the mercy of rent increases is a completely reasonable one.

Somersetbaker · 08/11/2026 11:54

I wouldn't borrow £200K - £250K, when you have only a £5K deposit, other debt and Interest rates are going up. You say yourself it's a falling market, so you could very easily be in negative equity, your options than are very limited. That £45K of debt is a big problem.

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 11:56

Somersetbaker · 08/11/2026 11:54

I wouldn't borrow £200K - £250K, when you have only a £5K deposit, other debt and Interest rates are going up. You say yourself it's a falling market, so you could very easily be in negative equity, your options than are very limited. That £45K of debt is a big problem.

The debt is a big problem which prevents us borrowing and saving for the house we want.

Which is why I want to compromise and get a cheaper house somewhere we dont like.

OP posts:
ChapmanFarm · 08/11/2026 13:27

Would it be cheaper to rent in the place you don't like?

Can you rent somewhere cheaper and chuck every spare penny at the debt/deposit to get there sooner?

Are you snowballing your payments?

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 13:33

ChapmanFarm · 08/11/2026 13:27

Would it be cheaper to rent in the place you don't like?

Can you rent somewhere cheaper and chuck every spare penny at the debt/deposit to get there sooner?

Are you snowballing your payments?

The commuting costs to rent in the other area would outweigh the rental difference unfortunately as there isnt a big difference.

I have only just got a full time job sorted so we haven't started overpaying yet. Hence the post to make a decision between paying off debt or getting a 5k deposit sorted to buy or waiting 6 years to buy somewhere we like.

OP posts:
PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2026 19:48

Ah I’ve just seen you have small children. It is a surprisingly short time until choosing secondary schools in my book. Are there not any other areas to look at? I’m leaning back away from buying again. God. I’m sorry, I’ll shut up eventually.

Karma1387 · 08/11/2026 19:55

PermanentTemporary · 08/11/2026 19:48

Ah I’ve just seen you have small children. It is a surprisingly short time until choosing secondary schools in my book. Are there not any other areas to look at? I’m leaning back away from buying again. God. I’m sorry, I’ll shut up eventually.

Unfortunately without a complete relocation somewhere more north (which my partner isnt keen on as he already misses being in Essex) we are kind of stuck between living in the fens area which is cheaper and we could just put down a 5k deposit or buying closer to the city/towns nearby which will involve a significantly bigger deposit and the need to pay off the debt first as the mortgage payment will be more than half our income so we need to be completely debt free to achieve it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread