I'd be interested in other FE/A-level teachers' perspectives on a situation I've found myself in.
I'm teaching A-level Religious Studies at an FE college and have recently been asked to meet with my line manager following complaints from a small number of students.
One student has stopped attending lessons altogether. When he attended a meeting with my line manager, he apparently said that he didn't feel the lessons were challenging enough and that they were more akin to GCSE level. I would strongly dispute this assessment, particularly given the demands of the A-level RS specification, but I'm uncomfortable with the fact that this student's opinion seems to have been given considerable weight, despite his lack of attendance.
There are also two female students who are finding the academic demands of the course difficult. They have complained that I'm setting too much homework and that I'm expecting them to complete work that hasn't been sufficiently explained in lessons. Examples included listening to a podcast and answering accompanying questions, and watching a 30-minute documentary and completing questions on it.
My understanding is that A-level students should be undertaking approximately five hours of independent study outside the classroom each week. I explained this to my line manager, but she told me not to expect students to do that amount of independent work.
She suggested introducing a system she had used successfully in Business Studies, whereby students learn key terminology and definitions before each lesson and are then tested on them.
I have several reservations about this. Firstly, I think there is a danger of lowering expectations to accommodate a couple of students who are struggling, rather than supporting them to meet the demands of the qualification. Secondly, Religious Studies is a very different subject to Business Studies. Whilst learning terminology is important, A-level RS requires students to engage with complex philosophical and theological arguments, evaluate different perspectives, engage with academic material and develop sophisticated written arguments. I don't think learning definitions and being tested on them is an adequate substitute for the different forms of independent study these skills require.
I also feel quite uncomfortable with the idea that students who are struggling with the academic demands of the course, or who perhaps lack confidence and resilience, should effectively dictate the level of challenge and the amount of independent work expected of the whole group.
I absolutely accept that homework needs to be purposeful, appropriately scaffolded and accessible. I'm not suggesting that students should simply be left to work things out for themselves. However, I do think there is a distinction between supporting students and removing the academic challenge that makes A-level study what it is.
I'm also questioning how much weight should be given to the opinion of a student who has stopped attending when evaluating the quality and level of challenge in teaching.
Am I being unreasonable here? How do other FE colleges balance student feedback, retention and supporting struggling learners with maintaining appropriate A-level standards and expectations? Do you feel there is an increasing pressure to reduce expectations because students are less willing or able to undertake independent study?