@MeghanAndTheSeals Cut and paste from the DT
If my mother had still been alive, I don’t think I would have invited her to my wedding.
She died in 2001, four years before I got married. By then she was in the grip of alcoholism with no hope of recovery. I’m afraid to say she would probably have ruined my big day.
Similarly, although I was desperately sad to lose her at the age of 54, there was a small part of me that was relieved she died before I had children of my own. I don’t think I would have been able to trust her to look after them as babies, which would have presented an agonising dilemma.
It pains me to write this. I loved my mother very much. But that is the reality of having a dysfunctional parent: you can love someone deeply while recognising that their behaviour makes it impossible to have the relationship you wish you could.
So, to an extent, I understand what Meghan is going through in relation to her father, Thomas Markle Snr, who has been charged with possession of child pornography, which he denies.
There are, of course, obvious and important differences. My mother was never accused of criminal wrongdoing, let alone anything of this appalling nature.
But for much of my adult life, our relationship was strained, and her erratic behaviour meant she remained largely estranged from my two older brothers.
Like Meghan and Harry, my parents were divorced, and we had to navigate the emotional complications of growing up in a so-called “broken” home. Like Harry, too, we lost our mother while we were still relatively young, although thankfully we did not have to endure that grief in the glare of the public spotlight.
These experiences are far from unique to the Sussexes. Countless families struggle with estrangement, addiction and the painful realisation that sometimes the people who should protect us are simply incapable of doing so.
The allegations against her father must have been devastating for Meghan. This week, she withdrew from a speaking engagement in Brussels. A source told The Telegraph that she was “not strong enough, emotionally” to introduce Harry at the opening of the Lost Screen Memorial, an event supporting families who have lost a child as a result of online harm.
Meghan’s reluctance to speak publicly is entirely understandable. Yet the circumstances raise some difficult questions that deserve to be considered, not least because this story is about something considerably bigger than the Sussexes.
This week, a survivor of child sexual abuse wrote to me and my colleague Hannah Furness, The Telegraph’s royal editor, asking why the couple had remained silent about the allegations against Markle Snr for seven years, having allegedly received a letter from the Metropolitan Police setting out concerns about his “serious offending” in 2019.
Meghan subsequently issued a statement saying: “I hope it can now be understood that, despite certain media publications’ distortion over the years, any distance from my father, and my choice to not allow him to have contact with our children, was for one reason: to protect them. I trusted that the authorities were doing the same for other families.”
But the survivor who contacted us was unconvinced.
They went on to argue that seven years had passed without Meghan apparently establishing whether an investigation was taking place, while her father remained at liberty, first in Mexico and subsequently in the Philippines. “I must ask: when did we as a society stop treating the children of strangers as precious and innocent?”
It is a profoundly uncomfortable question, but an important one.
To be absolutely clear, none of this makes Meghan responsible for her father’s alleged crimes. If he has done what he is accused of, the responsibility lies entirely with him. Nor should anyone underestimate the emotional toll of discovering such allegations about a parent, particularly when that relationship is already deeply troubled.
But it is reasonable to ask why the couple, who have been remarkably candid about their private lives in their interview with Oprah Winfrey, their Netflix documentary and Harry’s memoir, Spare, appeared so reluctant to discuss this particular issue.
Moreover, whatever this revelation about Meghan’s father may tell us, it does not rewrite history or absolve the couple of their decision to publicly turn against members of their own family.
Compassion for Meghan’s predicament should not mean an exemption from scrutiny.