Please or to access all these features

The royal family

Are we beginning to see through the mists of Palace PR? Thread two.

378 replies

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 19:26

For those of us particularly interested in how the Palace PR machine operates; I thought I would start a second thread.

There are plenty of potential obstacles up ahead that they will have to navigate:

**AMW being called as a witness in the Selman Turk civil case

**the ongoing investigation of AMW by TVP and the investigation of his alleged activities in Balmoral

**the proposed publication of more unredacted Epstein e-mails following the success of the Democrats in the mid-terms

to name but a few… .

No wonder William has hired a crisis manager!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Circumspection · 06/11/2026 19:55

auportees is tougher. Is this when you loan your friend money at au Bon pain because they are short? But who carries cash?

Circumspection · 06/11/2026 20:02

Just having a laugh. Sorry!!

CathyorClaire · 06/11/2026 20:33

And you are very aware of the risk that if you pay peanuts, you get moneys…

Given the chap in question got a 106% pay rise over five years he undoubtedly got the 'moneys'.

Serenster · 06/11/2026 21:50

CathyorClaire · 06/11/2026 20:33

And you are very aware of the risk that if you pay peanuts, you get moneys…

Given the chap in question got a 106% pay rise over five years he undoubtedly got the 'moneys'.

Indeed!

Reading the Annual Reports on this for the last few years is fascinating. The current CEO started in in the 2019-2020 financial year, when the Estate’s total value was £14.1bn and its net revenue was £345m. It’s not easy to see his base salary, as he joined part way through the year, but his predecessor’s base salary had been £345,000 the year before (the benefits package also includes a discretionary bonus, payments in lieu of the pension scheme and long-term incentive payments, which are essentially a deferred bonus paid out over several years).

The 2020/2021 year was extraordinary - no discretionary bonuses were paid and the CEO took a 20% pay cut to reflect the issues caused by Covid.

The 2021/2022 year was marked by a big jump in net asset values - up nearly £2.5bn to £16.5 (that is a huge jump). The CEO got a 5% rise in his base salary, and his discretionary bonus was 98% of his entitlement (in other words, he his was performing highly). For the first time the RemCo report states “It is the view of the Remuneration Committee that the Chief Executive’s total remuneration remains below peers within equivalent publicly listed real estate companies”.

They introduced a new pay framework the next year (22/23), set together with the Treasury. They went into great detail about the new framework for setting the CEO’s salary:

“To realise its full potential the organisation requires a Chief Executive who can
maximise the opportunity that comes from leading The Crown Estate given its unique status as a value—creating corporation for the nation. Equally, the Committee has a responsibility to balance attracting a world—class leader from a diverse pool of eligible candidates with someone who also recognises that some form of remuneration discount is appropriate to leading an organisation that serves the nation… The recruitment and retention of a world— class Chief Executive in this context is therefore vital to their obligations under the Crown Estate Act 1961”.

They explained that they had appointed an independent third party firm to benchmark appropriate salaries for the role. They also note that they consulted with Treasury, and then staggered the enhanced salary package over a series of years to recognise the sensitivity of increasing his remuneration. The framework increased the CEO’s base salary to £548,000 effective 1 January 2022 and to £708,000 effective 1 January 2023.

These changes then took effect as planned, but each subsequent annual reports also make has continued to make it clear that when viewed against the external market, Crown Estate CEO is paid at a substantial discount.

(Behind this I a guessing is a realisation by the Crown Estate’s Board and HMT that they have a genuine world-class CEO currently and that the remuneration package needed to reflect that in order to retain him…)

YourWatermelonship · 07/11/2026 07:33

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 19:30

I was going to add Prince Charles’s health to the above list but it seems rather heartless to just classify it as a PR issue, but nonetheless it will need managing in future.

As will the gradual transfer of power to William.

Actually Charles' health and age must be a concern. And Camilla's, judging from the videos of the latest Caribbean tour.

I have felt somewhat ambivalent about them in the past but looking at videos of the tour, I wonder if anyone under 50 can relate to our monarch and consort and feel they represent the country? Both Charles and Camilla came across as testy and impatient - and Camilla as confused and borderline frail.

They are both in their late 70s and I'm not sure Camilla was ever interested in being queen. And it shows. I don't know how you could give those images a positive spin. Maybe it's time for the next generation.

I don't think this latest trip was a PR success

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 09:37

It's Andrew who is the real pr threat. Charles gave a few million to prince Andrews payoff of Virginia. And yet more keeps coming out. Such as Andrew and under age girls I.e. children, and the financial shenanigans. Whilst Charles houses him, pays for his security and gives him £1 million a year.

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 09:40

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 09:37

It's Andrew who is the real pr threat. Charles gave a few million to prince Andrews payoff of Virginia. And yet more keeps coming out. Such as Andrew and under age girls I.e. children, and the financial shenanigans. Whilst Charles houses him, pays for his security and gives him £1 million a year.

So pretend you are Charles. What would you do?

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 09:42

YourWatermelonship · 07/11/2026 07:33

Actually Charles' health and age must be a concern. And Camilla's, judging from the videos of the latest Caribbean tour.

I have felt somewhat ambivalent about them in the past but looking at videos of the tour, I wonder if anyone under 50 can relate to our monarch and consort and feel they represent the country? Both Charles and Camilla came across as testy and impatient - and Camilla as confused and borderline frail.

They are both in their late 70s and I'm not sure Camilla was ever interested in being queen. And it shows. I don't know how you could give those images a positive spin. Maybe it's time for the next generation.

I don't think this latest trip was a PR success

It was a resounding success, actually.

There are cultures that don’t discard their old, but honor and treasure them. I think most cultures in the world, actually, will not see someone of their age the way you do, as a liability.

dreamerhereawake · 07/11/2026 09:44

I don’t think Andrew is the only one who is the real PR threat now.

And I don’t mean anyone who got soaked by rain recently.

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 09:47

dreamerhereawake · 07/11/2026 09:44

I don’t think Andrew is the only one who is the real PR threat now.

And I don’t mean anyone who got soaked by rain recently.

One can try, though.

Whentherainsetin101 · 07/11/2026 09:49

Serenster · 06/11/2026 21:50

Indeed!

Reading the Annual Reports on this for the last few years is fascinating. The current CEO started in in the 2019-2020 financial year, when the Estate’s total value was £14.1bn and its net revenue was £345m. It’s not easy to see his base salary, as he joined part way through the year, but his predecessor’s base salary had been £345,000 the year before (the benefits package also includes a discretionary bonus, payments in lieu of the pension scheme and long-term incentive payments, which are essentially a deferred bonus paid out over several years).

The 2020/2021 year was extraordinary - no discretionary bonuses were paid and the CEO took a 20% pay cut to reflect the issues caused by Covid.

The 2021/2022 year was marked by a big jump in net asset values - up nearly £2.5bn to £16.5 (that is a huge jump). The CEO got a 5% rise in his base salary, and his discretionary bonus was 98% of his entitlement (in other words, he his was performing highly). For the first time the RemCo report states “It is the view of the Remuneration Committee that the Chief Executive’s total remuneration remains below peers within equivalent publicly listed real estate companies”.

They introduced a new pay framework the next year (22/23), set together with the Treasury. They went into great detail about the new framework for setting the CEO’s salary:

“To realise its full potential the organisation requires a Chief Executive who can
maximise the opportunity that comes from leading The Crown Estate given its unique status as a value—creating corporation for the nation. Equally, the Committee has a responsibility to balance attracting a world—class leader from a diverse pool of eligible candidates with someone who also recognises that some form of remuneration discount is appropriate to leading an organisation that serves the nation… The recruitment and retention of a world— class Chief Executive in this context is therefore vital to their obligations under the Crown Estate Act 1961”.

They explained that they had appointed an independent third party firm to benchmark appropriate salaries for the role. They also note that they consulted with Treasury, and then staggered the enhanced salary package over a series of years to recognise the sensitivity of increasing his remuneration. The framework increased the CEO’s base salary to £548,000 effective 1 January 2022 and to £708,000 effective 1 January 2023.

These changes then took effect as planned, but each subsequent annual reports also make has continued to make it clear that when viewed against the external market, Crown Estate CEO is paid at a substantial discount.

(Behind this I a guessing is a realisation by the Crown Estate’s Board and HMT that they have a genuine world-class CEO currently and that the remuneration package needed to reflect that in order to retain him…)

You are obviously knowledgeable in this area Serenster but even if the CEO is paid what is deemed a “reasonable” salary in industry terms, I thought the latest PAC inquiry 2025-26, backed up by an NAC investigation report, not only highlighted that AMW was paying "peppercorn rent" for the 30-room Royal Lodge while secretly subletting three cottages which added to his private income, it fiercely criticised the Crown Estate's broader financial management. It not only flagged the CEO’s salary that more than doubled, it found that the overall administration costs skyrocketed by 129% between 2020 and 2026. And that does seem strange given the “slimmed down” monarchy we are supposed to have now and fewer royals carrying out engagements.

What is the justification for this I wonder?

Also I would argue that if the “rigorous” outside scrutiny is working well, why did it take a public outcry about Prince Andrew to catalyse an investigation in to the peppercorn rents and the grace and favour flats of Beatrice and Eugenie in the first place?

Also let’s be clear in case anyone is in any doubt that whereas the Crown Estates’s annual reports are subject to outside scrutiny,
the duchies maintain that because they are private estates, they are not audited by the NAC.

This has drawn criticism from PAC which has previously flagged concerns regarding the lack of truly independent checks on the information that the duchies provide.

OP posts:
Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:04

Whentherainsetin101 · 07/11/2026 09:49

You are obviously knowledgeable in this area Serenster but even if the CEO is paid what is deemed a “reasonable” salary in industry terms, I thought the latest PAC inquiry 2025-26, backed up by an NAC investigation report, not only highlighted that AMW was paying "peppercorn rent" for the 30-room Royal Lodge while secretly subletting three cottages which added to his private income, it fiercely criticised the Crown Estate's broader financial management. It not only flagged the CEO’s salary that more than doubled, it found that the overall administration costs skyrocketed by 129% between 2020 and 2026. And that does seem strange given the “slimmed down” monarchy we are supposed to have now and fewer royals carrying out engagements.

What is the justification for this I wonder?

Also I would argue that if the “rigorous” outside scrutiny is working well, why did it take a public outcry about Prince Andrew to catalyse an investigation in to the peppercorn rents and the grace and favour flats of Beatrice and Eugenie in the first place?

Also let’s be clear in case anyone is in any doubt that whereas the Crown Estates’s annual reports are subject to outside scrutiny,
the duchies maintain that because they are private estates, they are not audited by the NAC.

This has drawn criticism from PAC which has previously flagged concerns regarding the lack of truly independent checks on the information that the duchies provide.

The justification is contain in the reports.

And the sublet didn’t need to be secret; it’s allowed in the lease.

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:15

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 09:40

So pretend you are Charles. What would you do?

Contact the police and tell them what I know. Tell all staff to talk to the police and promise their ndas don't apply. When in reality they have had a reminder of their ndas.

kaparo · 07/11/2026 10:18

Whatever you might say, most of the pics/clips I saw of Camilla in the Caribbean showed a woman who appeared slightly bewildered by it all. Charles did well and represented us as he was told to do, yes that is his job.

In a way I feel for Camilla, she often looks like a rabbit in the headlights, and I am sure she would much prefer to be sitting by the fire with a fag and a G+T! But this is what she signed up for I suppose.

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:18

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:15

Contact the police and tell them what I know. Tell all staff to talk to the police and promise their ndas don't apply. When in reality they have had a reminder of their ndas.

Rihhhgt

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:19

The original lease to Andrew was against the duchy terms. They are supposed to be let even to royals at the market rate. The leaked minutes of the meeting about the rent Andrew pays basically decided Andrew is refusing to pay market rate, but we are hardly going to let it to anyone else, so we will accept the much lower amount Andrew is offering.

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:20

kaparo · 07/11/2026 10:18

Whatever you might say, most of the pics/clips I saw of Camilla in the Caribbean showed a woman who appeared slightly bewildered by it all. Charles did well and represented us as he was told to do, yes that is his job.

In a way I feel for Camilla, she often looks like a rabbit in the headlights, and I am sure she would much prefer to be sitting by the fire with a fag and a G+T! But this is what she signed up for I suppose.

I think she looks lien great fun! The photos of her laughing are really great.

It may be an awkward role at times but she’s doing a wonderful job. Seems quite genuine.

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:22

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:18

Rihhhgt

But I care about the rape of trafficked children and teenagers

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:23

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:20

I think she looks lien great fun! The photos of her laughing are really great.

It may be an awkward role at times but she’s doing a wonderful job. Seems quite genuine.

She looks like she does not want to be there. Look at her before they get onto the plane

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:25

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:22

But I care about the rape of trafficked children and teenagers

I honestly don’t think you do.

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:25

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:23

She looks like she does not want to be there. Look at her before they get onto the plane

Righto.

Whentherainsetin101 · 07/11/2026 10:30

YourWatermelonship · 07/11/2026 07:33

Actually Charles' health and age must be a concern. And Camilla's, judging from the videos of the latest Caribbean tour.

I have felt somewhat ambivalent about them in the past but looking at videos of the tour, I wonder if anyone under 50 can relate to our monarch and consort and feel they represent the country? Both Charles and Camilla came across as testy and impatient - and Camilla as confused and borderline frail.

They are both in their late 70s and I'm not sure Camilla was ever interested in being queen. And it shows. I don't know how you could give those images a positive spin. Maybe it's time for the next generation.

I don't think this latest trip was a PR success

Speaking as a Republican, I think Charles has been a better king than many expected and obviously working at his age while being treated for cancer can’t be easy and deserves recognition.

I’m afraid I must agree though that the demands of the job are such nowadays with lenses everywhere that it needs a more professional approach.

And this is one of the issues with a hereditary monarchy that the person with the top job can be both elderly and frail.

Some European monarchs have no problem abdicating in favour of their sons, I don’t see why it would be a problem in the UK?

Also when even a Pope decided it was time to abdicate then I think that sends a signal that it’s not a bad thing. I think it would be better for the people concerned themselves who presumably could then enjoy a normal retirement.

OP posts:
BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:45

Circumspection · 07/11/2026 10:25

I honestly don’t think you do.

Yeah I would expect yet another personal attack from someone like you.
My life's work would show you are wrong. It's prince Andrew and the royal family cover up that made me question the whole royal family.

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:47

Charles and Camilla look exactly what they are. Two elderly people, one who has cancer.
They don't look frail, but neither looks well. That is to be expected for most people their age.

IAmATorturedPoet · 07/11/2026 10:51

BeLemonMoose · 07/11/2026 10:15

Contact the police and tell them what I know. Tell all staff to talk to the police and promise their ndas don't apply. When in reality they have had a reminder of their ndas.

🤔