Please or to access all these features

The royal family

Are we beginning to see through the mists of Palace PR? Thread two.

378 replies

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 19:26

For those of us particularly interested in how the Palace PR machine operates; I thought I would start a second thread.

There are plenty of potential obstacles up ahead that they will have to navigate:

**AMW being called as a witness in the Selman Turk civil case

**the ongoing investigation of AMW by TVP and the investigation of his alleged activities in Balmoral

**the proposed publication of more unredacted Epstein e-mails following the success of the Democrats in the mid-terms

to name but a few… .

No wonder William has hired a crisis manager!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
jeffgoldblum · 16/11/2026 23:53

righteye · 16/11/2026 21:57

The OW is generally despised and reviled on MN and with good reason - but not here obviously. Some sins can be forgiven just not Harry's. Sisterhood at it's best !

Oh please…..Diana was an other woman many times……

jeffgoldblum · 16/11/2026 23:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 00:21

righteye · 16/11/2026 22:01

Just came across this rather entertaining and pretty damning FT piece on the Commonwealth. Will Lloyd spends five days at CHOGM in Antigua and proceeds to dismantle much of the official narrative, from the royal media circus and its carefully managed coverage to the grand claims of Commonwealth unity and influence. It's sharp, frequently funny and doesn't pull its punches. Well worth a read.

This is the FT so not some grubby Republican rag

https://archive.is/2GdZ3

On brolleygate...

“Rain had not been forecast that evening. The Sir Vivian Richards stadium, designed and built by the Chinese like so much of Antigua’s infrastructure, was about half full — a poor turnout for what had been billed as a historic celebration: King Charles came to inspect a few more platoons of Antiguans. As soon as the Royal Standard reached the top of its flagpole, the deluge began.

“Camilla stalked away, leaving Charles alone on a ceremonial plinth. The hot rain howled and swirled, omnidirectional, a Valhalla of vengeful water dumped on the King. I stood a few metres from him, in my bib. He was shouting for his flunkies, really screaming at them for an umbrella. The Girl Guides and Boy Scouts in the field looked shaky, as if they might break for cover.

“What a nightmare it was to be the King, the whole scene seemed to say. Your quasi-bankrupt kingdom being banged over the head with a Commonwealth begging bowl. Your family split, sundered to the point where the British Isles were now home to two competitive royal houses, Windsor and Sussex. Your reign a soon-to-be-forgotten fag end between the glorious rule of your mother and the uncertain future promised by your son. In this moment, underneath his titles, Charles seemed very human. The head of the Commonwealth alone in the rain in a half-empty stadium. His kingdom for an umbrella.”

Thank you so much for posting this righteye

What refreshingly brilliant clear-eyed journalism.

Will Lloyd should be applauded. He has quite the turn of phrase 😄

And what a great exposition and stark reminder of how the new world order is busy establishing itself as the UK bumbles on about hypotheticals with one foot stuck in the past.

Meanwhile, China has already invested the billions, built the universities, and the hospitals, and the airports.

The Commonwealth has, in other words, and in many ways, been bypassed.

But of course we still want a slice of that pie. Plus ca change! T’was ever thus!

OP posts:
Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 00:36

Circumspection · 16/11/2026 23:23

It seems like Serenster is the adult in the room, actually.
(That is, the person that brings facts and measure, rather than hopes and emotion.)

Edited

Oooh missus! Shall I stand in the corner? 😬

Forgive me if I prefer to discuss posts rather than posters.

I am sure that Serenster is more than capable of defending her own.

OP posts:
Circumspection · 17/11/2026 01:35

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 00:36

Oooh missus! Shall I stand in the corner? 😬

Forgive me if I prefer to discuss posts rather than posters.

I am sure that Serenster is more than capable of defending her own.

“Forgive me if I prefer to discuss posts rather than posters.”

Yet…

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 02:02

righteye · 16/11/2026 21:57

The OW is generally despised and reviled on MN and with good reason - but not here obviously. Some sins can be forgiven just not Harry's. Sisterhood at it's best !

But it was 2011. 🤷‍♀️

And Harry has no sins according to .. Harry and apparently a few others.

righteye · 17/11/2026 06:03

BeLemonMoose · 16/11/2026 23:47

Thanks for posting this article. I have just read it all and it's an excellent read. Interesting to read how few local people turned out, contrary to the impression given by the British media.

Yes the excellent FT reporter placed themselves deliberately out the "pack" so they could be objective and critical in their reporting to an educated and well informed readership. It really is an excellent newspaper have read it for years. Here and I quote in full is his view of the "pack"

These sorts of thoughts do not preoccupy a certain section of the British media: the “Royal Pack”, a collection of veteran broadcasters, laconic cameramen, tabloid footsoldiers and flimflammers who follow the monarch and his relatives from photo call to photo call. Earlier that afternoon, I had visited them in their Palace-appointed billet at the Royalton Hotel just outside St John’s, the Antiguan capital.

With the exception of the crews from ITV and Sky, who asked tricky questions about reparations, the pack tended to report trivia, speculative fantasy, mawkish gossip and the menus of state dinners. They were the official narrators of every Royal progress, the organisers of the silence around the King. Wherever he went, they went too.

In the pack’s version of the Carolean era, each overseas tour had the same soap-operatic narrative structure: the King lands in a country Britain had ruled a long time ago, but which is now filled with truculent elected politicians. Questions are raised about whether his appearances, and therefore the Crown, and therefore Britain itself, will be derailed by protests or diplomatic spats. Then, at the end of the tour, regardless of what has occurred, the adulatory message rings out: the King was stoicism personified, success embodied. All is well.

On this afternoon, however, the pack was irritable. The evening before, The Guardian had published an op-ed by Prime Minister Andy Burnham about reparations that had ruined all the “stories” Buckingham Palace had “given” them for the Sunday newspapers. Meanwhile, their accommodation appeared to have been set up for a different sort of clientele. Strange messages were stitched on to the pillows in the rooms (“A party never killed anyone”). Poolside, I watched a foam cannon operated by a trio of athletic women in hot pink T-shirts spray drifts of bubbles over nearly nude holidaymakers. Guests in the water started twerking to Beenie Man’s classic “I’m Drinking/ Rum & Red Bull”.

Fighting to be heard, one of the younger correspondents claimed, with some exhaustion, that CHOGM was notorious for being badly organised, for its last-minute changes and for bad news that never made it into reports. They were depressed because everyone back in miserable London could see that their job in Antigua seemed to be standing on a ludicrously paradisal beach saying the same thing every other member of the pack said, just into a different camera.
Cheer up, I said. At least you might be able to ask the King some questions. My own interactions with Commonwealth officials that morning had not made me confident that they liked having reporters hanging around. But the correspondent shot me a look, as if I were deranged. The Royal Pack weren’t in Antigua to find anything out.

They didn’t ask the King questions.

righteye · 17/11/2026 06:20

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 00:21

Thank you so much for posting this righteye

What refreshingly brilliant clear-eyed journalism.

Will Lloyd should be applauded. He has quite the turn of phrase 😄

And what a great exposition and stark reminder of how the new world order is busy establishing itself as the UK bumbles on about hypotheticals with one foot stuck in the past.

Meanwhile, China has already invested the billions, built the universities, and the hospitals, and the airports.

The Commonwealth has, in other words, and in many ways, been bypassed.

But of course we still want a slice of that pie. Plus ca change! T’was ever thus!

Thanks I hadn't come across Will Lloyd before he writes brilliantly and he won't be part of the Royal Rota anytime soon I guess and I guess King Charles' office won't have included this clipping in his press digest.

Will Lloyd
Follow @Will_lloyd
Will Lloyd is senior writer at the FT Weekend and a former deputy editor of the New Statesman. He was previously a reporter at the Sunday Times and a pet insurance salesman in Sydney, Australia. The two jobs had nothing in common. He lives in Brixton, with a framed photograph of Saki.

BeLemonMoose · 17/11/2026 07:51

I wish there was more serious royal journalism. It's sadly lacking.

I have read other small articles saying the foreign office and most prime ministers haven't really know what to do with the commonwealth and have largely paid it lip service. And certainly that article backs up it's lack of real role. Especially eye opening that the members who actually are more powerful countries did not send their prime minister.

Also eye opening that the public turnout at events was very low. I hadn't realised that from other coverage. So even the public aren't interested in spite of Charles being there.

I can see why countries send a representative though even if it's not the prime minister. No need to piss off the UK by not attending even if you think it's a waste of time.

righteye · 17/11/2026 08:02

BeLemonMoose · 17/11/2026 07:51

I wish there was more serious royal journalism. It's sadly lacking.

I have read other small articles saying the foreign office and most prime ministers haven't really know what to do with the commonwealth and have largely paid it lip service. And certainly that article backs up it's lack of real role. Especially eye opening that the members who actually are more powerful countries did not send their prime minister.

Also eye opening that the public turnout at events was very low. I hadn't realised that from other coverage. So even the public aren't interested in spite of Charles being there.

I can see why countries send a representative though even if it's not the prime minister. No need to piss off the UK by not attending even if you think it's a waste of time.

There have been kites flying that William might wind it up and others that it would be a suitable vehicle for a returned Harry to play with. As that article makes starkly clear it's actual output and purpose now is very vague and was untouchable until after QE2 passed. If all it becomes is a forum for the ex empire to beat post Imperial Britain then it's probably time to wind it up.

Before Antigua, British officials had started to talk darkly again about the Commonwealth. Queen Elizabeth had been gone long enough for questions to be asked. At the last CHOGM in Samoa in 2024, where climate change was earnestly discussed in the shadow of an expanded airport built for attendees, the British were ambushed by other members of the “family” over reparations. After a 28-hour flight, a shocked Keir Starmer found himself surrounded by hostile Commonwealth leaders. It played terribly back home. The meeting, billed by the Foreign Office as the UK’s chance to convene the world on good terms without the interfering presence of China, Russia or the US, had made Britain look weak.

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 09:23

righteye · 17/11/2026 06:03

Yes the excellent FT reporter placed themselves deliberately out the "pack" so they could be objective and critical in their reporting to an educated and well informed readership. It really is an excellent newspaper have read it for years. Here and I quote in full is his view of the "pack"

These sorts of thoughts do not preoccupy a certain section of the British media: the “Royal Pack”, a collection of veteran broadcasters, laconic cameramen, tabloid footsoldiers and flimflammers who follow the monarch and his relatives from photo call to photo call. Earlier that afternoon, I had visited them in their Palace-appointed billet at the Royalton Hotel just outside St John’s, the Antiguan capital.

With the exception of the crews from ITV and Sky, who asked tricky questions about reparations, the pack tended to report trivia, speculative fantasy, mawkish gossip and the menus of state dinners. They were the official narrators of every Royal progress, the organisers of the silence around the King. Wherever he went, they went too.

In the pack’s version of the Carolean era, each overseas tour had the same soap-operatic narrative structure: the King lands in a country Britain had ruled a long time ago, but which is now filled with truculent elected politicians. Questions are raised about whether his appearances, and therefore the Crown, and therefore Britain itself, will be derailed by protests or diplomatic spats. Then, at the end of the tour, regardless of what has occurred, the adulatory message rings out: the King was stoicism personified, success embodied. All is well.

On this afternoon, however, the pack was irritable. The evening before, The Guardian had published an op-ed by Prime Minister Andy Burnham about reparations that had ruined all the “stories” Buckingham Palace had “given” them for the Sunday newspapers. Meanwhile, their accommodation appeared to have been set up for a different sort of clientele. Strange messages were stitched on to the pillows in the rooms (“A party never killed anyone”). Poolside, I watched a foam cannon operated by a trio of athletic women in hot pink T-shirts spray drifts of bubbles over nearly nude holidaymakers. Guests in the water started twerking to Beenie Man’s classic “I’m Drinking/ Rum & Red Bull”.

Fighting to be heard, one of the younger correspondents claimed, with some exhaustion, that CHOGM was notorious for being badly organised, for its last-minute changes and for bad news that never made it into reports. They were depressed because everyone back in miserable London could see that their job in Antigua seemed to be standing on a ludicrously paradisal beach saying the same thing every other member of the pack said, just into a different camera.
Cheer up, I said. At least you might be able to ask the King some questions. My own interactions with Commonwealth officials that morning had not made me confident that they liked having reporters hanging around. But the correspondent shot me a look, as if I were deranged. The Royal Pack weren’t in Antigua to find anything out.

They didn’t ask the King questions.

I have to say that this part of the article made me laugh out loud! Hilarious, revealing, excoriating at the same time.

I hope Rebecca English enjoys it! 😆

But joking aside, as *BeLemonMoose says, *

“I wish there was more serious royal journalism. It's sadly lacking.”

Such a simple plea and straightforward observation but goodness, one that hit me between the eyes, it’s so true.

The UK is supposedly a modern democracy, Why is this Royal rota nonsense tolerated? Why such deference still?

Why do so few serious journalists choose to put pen to paper in this way?

I hope Will Lloyd has broken the mould and started a trend. We desperately need more intelligent, clear eyed, commentary such as his.

Reading that article is like stumbling out of a dark cave after a lifetime of captivity… 😆

And I am going to enjoy reading it all over again with my elevenses.

OP posts:
Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 09:29

Totally agree about the FT being an excellent newspaper overall btw righteye.

One of the few.

OP posts:
Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 09:34

Meanwhile, back at the ranch, the Daily Mail is leading with;

“Prince of Wheels! William drives rickshaw with Kate as couple cruise round on day two of India tour”

😆😆😆

OP posts:
CathyorClaire · 17/11/2026 10:40

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 09:34

Meanwhile, back at the ranch, the Daily Mail is leading with;

“Prince of Wheels! William drives rickshaw with Kate as couple cruise round on day two of India tour”

😆😆😆

I suppose it's a start in off-setting all those helicopter trips between forever homes.

I wonder what the ordinary commuters and workers of Mumbai think of the disruption to their schedules this enormous puff effort is causing?

smilesy · 17/11/2026 11:13

CathyorClaire · 17/11/2026 10:40

I suppose it's a start in off-setting all those helicopter trips between forever homes.

I wonder what the ordinary commuters and workers of Mumbai think of the disruption to their schedules this enormous puff effort is causing?

Have you ever been to Mumbai? There are far
more things likely to disrupt a daily commute than closing a part of the metro 😆. And not all of it is open yet so they may have been travelling on a new bit that isn’t open to the public 🤷‍♀️

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 11:24

smilesy · 17/11/2026 11:13

Have you ever been to Mumbai? There are far
more things likely to disrupt a daily commute than closing a part of the metro 😆. And not all of it is open yet so they may have been travelling on a new bit that isn’t open to the public 🤷‍♀️

A lovely woman I worked with years ago told me this.

”There is something you should understand about India. On the way to work, there might be a cow in the road, but we do not move it and we do not go around. We wait. It could take minutes or much longer. It could make us late for work.

But that is not what you need to know. What you need to know is that we don’t mind.”

I have never been but have had the pleasure of working with many people from India and also in India. This above was very helpful to me in seeing how the culture and thinking is so very different from my own.

bluegreygreen · 17/11/2026 11:57

Some relevant information about the rickshaw ride

Earthshot finalist: Mahindra Last Mile Mobility

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:36

bluegreygreen · 17/11/2026 11:57

Some relevant information about the rickshaw ride

Earthshot finalist: Mahindra Last Mile Mobility

This is inspired. I hope everyone posting here will read it. Here’s one bright bit of a large picture. So it’s not just the environmental, but a holistic impact on communities.

”Mahindra Last Mile Mobility has also trained 500 women to drive and repair electric three-wheelers, moving some into independent, income-generating work.”

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 12:42

bluegreygreen · 17/11/2026 11:57

Some relevant information about the rickshaw ride

Earthshot finalist: Mahindra Last Mile Mobility

Thank you bluegreygreen

I wasn’t trying to make any deep point, I was just laughing at the DM headline!

It’s good to know the background.

On a serious note, as a declared Republican, I do think that even the good things the RF do are very ill-served by such a deferential, obsequious press.

I really don’t think the royal rota are serving them very well at all.

OP posts:
Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:47

@smilesy a bit more about Mahindra Last Mile

“The company has now sold more than 400,000 electric last-mile vehicles, including over 100,000 in a single year, making it the first commercial vehicle manufacturer in India to reach that scale. Mahindra Last Mile Mobility reports the sales have avoided more than 180,000 metric tonnes of CO₂. Its electric three-wheelers have helped push the category past 50% of new sales in India, the country’s first vehicle segment to get there.

Behind the vehicles sits a wider network: more than 900 sales and service outlets, financing partnerships, and access to over 10,000 public charging points, plus plans for responsible battery recycling. Lower running costs mean drivers’ take-home income can rise by 25-30%.”

righteye · 17/11/2026 12:48

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:36

This is inspired. I hope everyone posting here will read it. Here’s one bright bit of a large picture. So it’s not just the environmental, but a holistic impact on communities.

”Mahindra Last Mile Mobility has also trained 500 women to drive and repair electric three-wheelers, moving some into independent, income-generating work.”

Well, let's hope some of this fairy dust manages to sprinkle on the Palace, and that the endless holidays, private yachts and helicopter rides might acquire a rather more sustainable character. And while he's at it, perhaps he could turn his attention to his Duchy properties, transforming those environmentally questionable dwellings in some of the country's poorest communities into decent, energy-efficient modern accommodation and stop the evictions. I'll wait.

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 12:51

I agree there is definitely a credibility issue looming for William when he accedes to the throne if he doesn’t instigate serious changes.

OP posts:
Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:55

righteye · 17/11/2026 12:48

Well, let's hope some of this fairy dust manages to sprinkle on the Palace, and that the endless holidays, private yachts and helicopter rides might acquire a rather more sustainable character. And while he's at it, perhaps he could turn his attention to his Duchy properties, transforming those environmentally questionable dwellings in some of the country's poorest communities into decent, energy-efficient modern accommodation and stop the evictions. I'll wait.

I think it’s really sad to wholly dismiss this great work with a post like this. I don’t know what else to say about it. If one can’t ever say anything positive it really makes their commentary irrelevant for me.

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:57

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 12:51

I agree there is definitely a credibility issue looming for William when he accedes to the throne if he doesn’t instigate serious changes.

Back home, we have a credibility issue as well. Lacking any form or balance or subjectivity. That’s why I really appreciate @Serensters posts and perspectives. Always full of facts and balance.

Whentherainsetin101 · 17/11/2026 13:26

Circumspection · 17/11/2026 12:57

Back home, we have a credibility issue as well. Lacking any form or balance or subjectivity. That’s why I really appreciate @Serensters posts and perspectives. Always full of facts and balance.

Fhs Circumspection
Sorry but are you intent on trying to derail?

I’ve already thanked Bluegreygreen for the background information which I am genuinely interested to read.

I’ve said that some of the better initiatives the RF are involved in are not particularly well served by the current royal rota.

I was hoping we could all enjoy a less snippy thread about PR.which is my main focus of interest when it comes to the royals.

That “gap between the curated narrative and the reality” as Lownie puts it.

Of course all sound environmental issues are to be welcomed but one cannot deny the credibility issue of one of Eathshott’s leading proponents who is about to inherit sixteen estates or whatever it is, and large swathes of land, urging others to cut their consumption and outgoings.

On the other hand, there are far worse things he could be using his platform for, I am sure we all agree!

OP posts: