I think that's part of their problem here.
If you know someone who typically lies, misrepresents situations to put themselves in a better light etc then you start second guessing their motives.
But because of past experience with them, you immediately start wondering what's in it for them, and you don't really give benefit of the doubt when things don't add up.
A bit like for my dc, one is very accurate - might misinterpret a situation, but wouldn't add extra details. They also tended to sit on things and think it over before speaking up. They could need a lot of reassurance over a few days. Another is very dramatic and imagination comes into play when things are happening and you get an immediate reaction. They'd have forgotten all about it by the next morning and moved on to the next thing even though apparently they were far more visibly upset at the time.
So a similar thing would have different reactions from me.
First one: I listen, reassure, check when it happened (might well be several months ago) and react if necesary.
Second one: I listen, calm down and then go and phone my friend who had an equally dramatic child and we'd compare stories and work out what the middle story was and which bits of it were correct.