Please or to access all these features

The royal family

PR and the Palace; are the mists clearing?

1000 replies

Whentherainsetin101 · 27/09/2026 23:39

For those of us interested in the PR aspects of how the institution of the monarchy presents itself to us, the unsuspecting public, and given that Charles Spencer’s book has prompted a re-examination of events which took place over twenty-nine years ago, I thought this might be a good time to examine what Andrew Lownie calls;

“that gap between the curated narrative and the reality”.

We now know lots of things that weren’t obvious thirty years ago, for example;

We know that BP sometimes issues statements that question the credibility of the “accuser” rather than addressing an accusation directly.

We know that the relationship between the press and the palace is largely self serving on both sides.

We know that the royal rota tow the line in exchange for access.

We know that certain tabloids favour certain royals eg Fergie and The Sun.

We know that BP leaks and briefs certain stories to deflect from other more damaging ones.

We know that BP uses “safe” public figures to broadcast their spin for them eg it used to be Nicolas Soames but now appears to be Rory Stewart.

We know that many things presented to us in one way are in reality very different, eg the late Queen Elizabeth’s marriage, AMW being “banished” to Sandringham.

Given all of the above, do you think the Palace are losing the PR battle, simply because people are now much more switched on about ‘spin’ and because they favour a much more authentic approach?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
38
OctoberMists · 05/11/2026 13:48

I think Yorks are a huge problem for the crown.

Andrew is dodgy as fuck and hopefully does get held to account - Sarah Ferguson not much better TBH finacially at least and company she kept.

They've tried very hard to put clear blue water between the palace and Andrew.

TBH I do think the vauge plan we hear being suggested that only working royals have titles going forward is one way to deal with any future events.

They clearly want him to stay quiet in country and avoid court cases and police investiagtions and that's not happening. An actual prosecution might be better as palace could then condem and completely wash their hands of him though perhaps they would still need to provide a place to live for security reasons.

The insitution does have time on it's side - it may just have to keep on keeping on till the people involved are all dead - like Windsors who not only colabroated with Nazi but also may have helped cover up a murder while Duke Governor of the Bahamas.

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 13:55

OctoberMists · 05/11/2026 13:48

I think Yorks are a huge problem for the crown.

Andrew is dodgy as fuck and hopefully does get held to account - Sarah Ferguson not much better TBH finacially at least and company she kept.

They've tried very hard to put clear blue water between the palace and Andrew.

TBH I do think the vauge plan we hear being suggested that only working royals have titles going forward is one way to deal with any future events.

They clearly want him to stay quiet in country and avoid court cases and police investiagtions and that's not happening. An actual prosecution might be better as palace could then condem and completely wash their hands of him though perhaps they would still need to provide a place to live for security reasons.

The insitution does have time on it's side - it may just have to keep on keeping on till the people involved are all dead - like Windsors who not only colabroated with Nazi but also may have helped cover up a murder while Duke Governor of the Bahamas.

It will be interesting in the future that’s for sure.

Now that the Democrats have had such a success in the mid-terms, I think there may be moves to impeach Trump, and that may mean the rest of the Epstein files being published unredacted?

OP posts:
SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 14:03

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 12:37

I very much disagree about it having no connection to the Palace and no PR interest.

I take it that you haven’t read the updated paperback version of Entitled by Andrew Lownie, or you would understand the broader ramifications of this case?

As I understand it as a non lawyer, it involves a major fraud lawsuit brought by wealthy Turkish national Nebahat İşbilen against her former financial adviser , Selman Turk, who she alleges misappropriated tens of millions of pounds of her money.

AMW has been summoned as a witness and the trial is scheduled to begin on 23 November.

Lownie sets out in Entitled, the circumstances and significance of the case, and points out that the High Court case in 2022 revealed in discovery, documents relating to approximately £1.3 million flowing from or through Turk to the York family that nobody could explain. This included £750,000 allegedly paid to Andrew, £225,000-£250,000 allegedly paid to Sarah Ferguson, and allegedly separate amounts to one or both of his daughters.

Accorfing to Lownie, “Apart from the £750,000 that the duke repaid, a further £350,000 was paid under the reference ‘TK Wedding’, which was not repaid. TK are the initials of Tarek Kaitu, the Libyan gun smuggler who had previously brokered meetings between the duke and the dictator Colonel Gaddafi and who had attended the duchess’s 60th birthday party – held at Royal Lodge for 100 and funded by Turk – and Eugenie’s wedding. Turk and Kaituni had held meetings with Andrew at least twice, including a dinner for the Duke with potential investors at Mr Turk’s apartment in South Kensington on December 5th 2019 and at St James’s Palace. Turk had also shared images with friends of him and Kaituni inside what is believed to be Frogmore House in February 2020.”

Lownie goes on to say;
“A payment of £10,000 made by Alphabet Capital Ltd, which the court heard was a ‘fraudulent’ entity, to Eugenie of York was under the payment reference ‘TK008’. She claimed not to know Mr Turk or Mrs Isbilen and the money was from “a long-standing family friend to assist with the cost of a surprise party for my mother.” The next day a further payment of £15,066.05 was made to Eugenie York under the payment reference ‘Birthday Gift’ – some five months before her March birthday.”

Fergie also allegedly received payments from the Alphabet account but has allegedly declined to explain what for exactly.

Nebahat İşbilen alleged that Turk misled her, claiming the £750,000 was paid to Andrew in return for help with a UK passport application.

But Turk (who was jailed for fraud) claimed it was a wedding gift for Princess Beatrice.

Lownie argues that the justifications given for these payouts-such as birthday presents, wedding gifts, or helping with a passport never added up because they claimed these were gifts from people they didn't really even know.

Andrew later repaid the £750,000 roughly 16 months later, though questions remain over whether he knew the source or true purpose of the funds.

Allegations also surfaced regarding other funds, including a £350,000 payment and money tied to Turk's fintech firm Heyman AI, which won a People's Choice Award at Andrew's Pitch@Palace event shortly before the £750,000 transfer. Because the pitch was said to be so poor, questions were asked as to why it was favoured in this way?

Judge Mr Justice Adam Johnson has granted Selman Turk permission to rely on a late witness summary, meaning Andrew is a targeted witness whose evidence Turk hopes will help rebut serious allegations of fraud.

While Andrew is not on trial for wrongdoing himself, and he subsequently paid the money back, he is obliged to give oral evidence under oath, and face cross-examination.

As Andrew Lownie highlights, the case brings renewed attention to the lack of transparency surrounding the financial dealings, commercial associations, and public roles of senior members of the royal family. He is also questioning whether it points to a pattern?

I think there is also interest in the case because it may reveal more information about AMW’s ski chalet sale, the funds of which, may or may not have been used in part to pay off to Virginia Giuffre?

I suspect that the palace will be taking a keen interest in proceedings. And I’m surprised you are so keen to repeatedly minimise public interest in it SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie,
particularly as the last time a royal was served a witness summons to give evidence was in 1870, when the future King Edward VII was called to testify as a witness in a high-profile divorce case.

I’m glad that AMW is literally being called to account.

I don’t see where I have minimised public interest? I think the public will be keenly interested. It’s hard to talk about the rest when you are so ready to go meta and insult.

simpsonthecat · 05/11/2026 14:07

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 13:55

It will be interesting in the future that’s for sure.

Now that the Democrats have had such a success in the mid-terms, I think there may be moves to impeach Trump, and that may mean the rest of the Epstein files being published unredacted?

I posted this earlier on another thread ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Following the midterms Democratic Rep Robert Garcia takes over the House Oversight committee as of January.
He has spoken out about four areas he will be focusing on. (footage of him speaking available via NBC)
One of those four is the Epstein files. He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.
Watch this space

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 14:19

“He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.”

One can only hope.

But I won’t hold my breath.

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 14:28

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 14:03

I don’t see where I have minimised public interest? I think the public will be keenly interested. It’s hard to talk about the rest when you are so ready to go meta and insult.

As is often the case I feel.

I wish people would read what is written rather than go with their own, often skewed, interpretation.

It kills discussion.

And it makes me inclined to disregard verbose posts - whether or not they are deemed great explanations - because I question the intent behind it.

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 14:33

simpsonthecat · 05/11/2026 14:07

I posted this earlier on another thread ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Following the midterms Democratic Rep Robert Garcia takes over the House Oversight committee as of January.
He has spoken out about four areas he will be focusing on. (footage of him speaking available via NBC)
One of those four is the Epstein files. He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.
Watch this space

Oh fantastic! I wasn’t aware, and you are ahead of me with the news simpsonthecat,
that is really excellent to know… .👍

I hope AMW doesn’t rush off to live somewhere where he is safe from extradition? Bahrain, Abu Dhabi, somewhere else in the Gulf States; Qatar?

I think he was “released under investigation” by TVP wasn’t he but that doesn’t involve any travel restrictions.

OP posts:
iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 14:41

I also hope that others involved (and those apparently not under the same scrutiny as amw) don’t think similarly.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 14:47

simpsonthecat · 05/11/2026 14:07

I posted this earlier on another thread ⬇️⬇️⬇️

Following the midterms Democratic Rep Robert Garcia takes over the House Oversight committee as of January.
He has spoken out about four areas he will be focusing on. (footage of him speaking available via NBC)
One of those four is the Epstein files. He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.
Watch this space

I am hopeful they will pursue everyone involved but not holding my breath. They would have done it under Biden if they wanted it to happen.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 14:48

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 14:28

As is often the case I feel.

I wish people would read what is written rather than go with their own, often skewed, interpretation.

It kills discussion.

And it makes me inclined to disregard verbose posts - whether or not they are deemed great explanations - because I question the intent behind it.

I often wonder if that is the intent. Insult someone so they focus on the insult rather than the discussion.

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 14:53

I agree.

I’d love to see all guilty parties held to account.

As you say, there has been plenty of opportunity for files to be released.

I don’t think it would be unreasonable to assume that they aren’t being kept in the dark because it incriminates amw.

OctoberMists · 05/11/2026 15:12

Following the midterms Democratic Rep Robert Garcia takes over the House Oversight committee as of January.
He has spoken out about four areas he will be focusing on. (footage of him speaking available via NBC)
One of those four is the Epstein files. He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.

I really hope they start looking at US people and anyone else left.

I know there are many senior/older democrats with stuff to hide as well- the guy collected people - but hopefully the new incumbents will be happy to see justice for the victims.

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 15:16

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 14:48

I often wonder if that is the intent. Insult someone so they focus on the insult rather than the discussion.

Wasn’t it you who posted an unnecessarily sarcastic response to LipglossAndLies last night when she linked an interesting and perfectly legitimate Observer article about William’s alleged murky management of the Duchy of Cornwall?

And you posted about five photos of Charles and Camilla in the rain in an attempt to derail when one would have been fine to make your point?

All quite rude posting and hypocritical given your post above.

OP posts:
iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 15:23

Interesting is subjective.

I can’t recall the post you refer to but I have been known on occasion to be dismissive of a post.

I didn’t realise we were only allowed to make one reference (or photo) to impress a point either.

I would think that your post is all a bit hypocritical also if you reply in the manner that you did to that poster. I found it rude.

And unnecessary. Perhaps not sarcastic but patronising.

I’m assuming that you perhaps did not intend it to be like that but that is how it read.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 15:25

Whentherainsetin101 · 05/11/2026 15:16

Wasn’t it you who posted an unnecessarily sarcastic response to LipglossAndLies last night when she linked an interesting and perfectly legitimate Observer article about William’s alleged murky management of the Duchy of Cornwall?

And you posted about five photos of Charles and Camilla in the rain in an attempt to derail when one would have been fine to make your point?

All quite rude posting and hypocritical given your post above.

Lipgloss has been quite insulting to me. Telling me not to use words I don’t understand. Which was quite humorous given her propensity to use words she cannot spell. (Well, perhaps can’t be bothered.)

I posted the photos for Simpson who was admittedly unaware of Charles’ long and storied history with respect to conservation.

Why are you attacking me? Can these posters not speak for themselves?

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 15:26

OctoberMists · 05/11/2026 15:12

Following the midterms Democratic Rep Robert Garcia takes over the House Oversight committee as of January.
He has spoken out about four areas he will be focusing on. (footage of him speaking available via NBC)
One of those four is the Epstein files. He says over 1000 survivors have come forward and he will be concentrating on bringing justice.

I really hope they start looking at US people and anyone else left.

I know there are many senior/older democrats with stuff to hide as well- the guy collected people - but hopefully the new incumbents will be happy to see justice for the victims.

I agree.

It bothers me that others involved round the world seem to be content with the British patsy taking all the heat.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 15:27

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 15:23

Interesting is subjective.

I can’t recall the post you refer to but I have been known on occasion to be dismissive of a post.

I didn’t realise we were only allowed to make one reference (or photo) to impress a point either.

I would think that your post is all a bit hypocritical also if you reply in the manner that you did to that poster. I found it rude.

And unnecessary. Perhaps not sarcastic but patronising.

I’m assuming that you perhaps did not intend it to be like that but that is how it read.

Kind of you to give benefit of doubt. Others are unable or unwilling to do that and happy to tilt at windmills.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 15:30

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 15:26

I agree.

It bothers me that others involved round the world seem to be content with the British patsy taking all the heat.

100% to this. The democrats had every chance and tried to prevent the release for ages.

I despise almost all of them on both sides and would throw them all out and start fresh.

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 15:37

simpsonthecat · 04/11/2026 21:27

Interesting article

It seems like Charles is not too happy with the way William is handling the duchy which of course he was handling himself up until qe2's death

I wonder about that and as it relates to Palace PR I found this:

PR and the Palace; are the mists clearing?
SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 15:39

Link to article about their relationship.

Puffy. But good PR for them.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/royal-family/2020/06/23/prince-charles-william-became-closer-ever/

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 15:42

More misty-eyed PR than clearing mists PR maybe?

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 16:38

LipglossAndLies · 04/11/2026 21:02

Came across this today, looks like those mists are not clearing just yet, I think its a fair question to asking about the Duchy snd time its addressed

observer.co.uk/news/national/article/extraordinarily-murky-william-accused-of-double-standards-over-duchys-tax

I archived this for the more serious posters who are truly interested and not just in search of sound bites.

https://archive.ph/wpSDv

SlowMoJoJoLouAnnMarie · 05/11/2026 16:38

https://archive.ph/wpSDv

A objective summary: The most important part of this story is the distinction between voluntarily paying personal taxes and the tax treatment of the institution generating that income.
Those are two different questions, and conflating them obscures the real issue.

There is also an important distinction between something being legally permitted under a longstanding arrangement and that arrangement being fair or appropriate.

The Observer's reporting raises a legitimate question about the legal foundation of the Duchy's privileges. But Neidle's interpretation still needs to be tested against the relevant legislation and legal arrangements.

iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 16:39

Not 5?

PR and the Palace; are the mists clearing?
iwouldntliketoknowyou123 · 05/11/2026 16:39

As per the rules.

Just the one photo.

One observation.

And one prize which they actually may have deserved to have ‘won’.

To keep it relevant to the thread title?

I wonder if the aviation legends still wished they had Palace PR instead of cosplaying a deceased MIL for clicks.

All a bit obsessive. Clearly.

Like Play MMisty For MMe.

PR and the Palace; are the mists clearing?
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.