Soft cat carriers - any recommendations?

[OlennasWimple]

I'm trying to decide between two carriers: the Sherpa deluxe, which gets great reviews but is a dog carrier that also fits cats IYSWIM; and the Sherpa cat tote, which has fewer reviews that I can find but is cat specific and a little taller (good for one of ours).

Any thoughts? It's for taking on a plane, so dimensions are really important!

Thanks

Some airlines are super super picky about carriers. I've never taken my cat on a plane but when I was looking at carrier reviews so many carriers had poor reviews from people who had been told by an airline that it wasn't suitable even though other reviewers had flown with them without a problem. Whatever you go for I'd check with your airline that it will be ok.