I've always gone with Petplan - pricey maybe but never had a problem with claims and they've never quibbled paying out.
So went to insure Sam the Stray with them today and was asked if he had any medical treatment that I knew about. Of course he was at the vets last week and came out with antibiotics because of ear inflammation. On the grounds of that PP offered cover but have excluded him for two years for skin conditions and ear disorders (note disorders, they will cover injuries)
Arse. Do you ever think you've been too honest? Trouble is I work in the insurance industry and know how it can go wrong if you "don't mention something you really should."
Not a cheap policy as well. I could go elsewhere but have good experience with Petplan.