Please or to access all these features

The doghouse

If you're worried about your pet's health, please speak to a vet or qualified professional.

Staffy v Parsons puppy

48 replies

Peggy21 · 04/11/2026 13:16

We are looking to get a female puppy and have narrowed it down to a parsons / staffy and two available pups have come up.
We are a family (two boys, 9 and 12) and have a garden.
The dog wouldn’t be alone much. We are looking for a loving, family dog. First time dog owners.
Any advice in these two breeds?
Many thanks.

OP posts:
wavingfuriously · 05/11/2026 09:45

I just lost my parson (from a rescue) lovely dog, high energy, intelligent and affectionate. Ran miles during the day, lapdog in the evening 😍

SpidersAreShitheads · 05/11/2026 13:33

There are loads of good things about owning a Staffy, but they’re not an “easy” dog for a novice owner.

I also don’t think setting your heart on a Staffy because you’ve heard them described as a “nanny dog” is a good reason to pick the breed. There are plenty of other breeds that are also great with kids without the same difficult terrier streak and potential for dog aggression.

Maybe tell us a bit more about your circumstances - how much time do you have for walks every day? How long do you anticipate each walk being? Who will do the walks? Do you have a good-sized garden? Space inside for play? I think you said you WFH but typically, will the dog be alone much throughout the week?

I’m not saying absolutely don’t get a Staffy - I just think you need to get the breed that’s best for your situation, which may or may not be a Staffy.

Unluckycat1 · 07/11/2026 07:23

I understand that staffies can be very loving to their people. My only real experience of them is when i see them out and about on walks. They are either on a lead, and will strain on it and show aggression when they see another dog. Or they are exceptionally trained and walking to heel looking up at their owner every other second. What I never see is a staffie running around, having a sniff, exploring, being a dog. I imagine this is because of their dog unfriendliness? For me, walks are the highlight of having a dog so I'd never get a breed where they would be so lacking doggy joy. When we go on family walks at the weekend to dog popular destinations the families with staffies and frenchies pulled tight on a lead when we pass do stand out to me for this reason compared to pretty much every other breed having a great time.

Voltaroldemort · 07/11/2026 07:48

I too notice that staffies are very often on a lead, but I have a very different experience of them than yours, @Unluckycat1 .

The staffies I see are generally friendly and relaxed. There is just one staffy I meet whose owner says he's not great with other dogs. But after all, they are terriers. I'd expect a certain level of risk of that, just as I would with a PRT.

It's interesting that the off-lead staffies you see are staying close by their owners. Perhaps that says something about their nature - perhaps staffies are very owner-focused and less interested in roaming about? So perhaps have less need to be off-lead?

Voltaroldemort · 07/11/2026 07:52

... and of course they aren't really built for speed and agility! Perhaps pottering alongside their human suits their physique

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 07/11/2026 08:46

Dogs don't need to be running around off the lead to be "having a great time" @Unluckycat1
They are just like us, they all have different needs and preferences. "Being a dog" isn't the same thing for every breed.
I agree with @Voltaroldemort , that all the Staffies I come across are totally devoted to their family. Much like my giant guarding breed that doesn't run off lead in public for its own safety.

Unluckycat1 · 07/11/2026 08:47

Yeah that's a good point, it might be that staffies have their needs met just pottering along besides an owner. Again, I'd not get a lot out of owning a dog like that, but there are no doubt people who would find my dog nightmarish (she absolutely needs to run!)

HoraceCope · 07/11/2026 08:51

i would have a parsons because i have had jack russells
although staffies have an adorable look their faces

Mistachio · 07/11/2026 08:59

TheHungryHungryLandsharks · 04/11/2026 14:32

I agree with PP. Both are lovely breeds, neither are breeds I think are suitable for first time owners with young children.

A Parson will rung rings around a relatively experienced owner, let alone a novice, and are high drive and high intellect.

Staffies are incredibly strong and can be boisterous. That combination is just too risky for a novice owner.

They are incredibly different dog breeds. Breeding is everything, and a poorly bred staffie (in particular) in the hands of a novice owner with children is a recipe for disaster. I love staffies, but they’re are lots of bad breeders out there breeding unhealthy and unsuitable dogs. You can fuck up a well bred dog, you can’t easily un-fuck a badly bred one. If you go with a staffie, you best be certain that breeder is beyond reproach.

This.

zobalina77 · 07/11/2026 13:48

My staff is generally on a long line out on walks. One, because he is too friendly and wants to be friends with everyone and everything and im trying to train that out of him.at the moment, and two because he has been nipped a few times by other (small) dogs even when he's just walking nicely next to me. Probably because he's intact and hes black so dogs can't see his features very well. I worry that if there is an altercation he will get the blame because of his breed so I don't let him off unless certain no one is around.

We do go to freedom fields so he can run, and he does run exceptionally fast even though he's built like a barrel. Just struggles to stop in time before he collides with something 😂

Wetcappuccino · 07/11/2026 14:25

survivingunderarock · 05/11/2026 09:42

Rescues are not often suitable for homes with children unless the background is known so often rescues err on the side of caution.

Our Staffy cross came to us via Dog’s Trust at age 1 due to the previous owner’s health. We had a full history - she had lived with kids over the age of 10 and another dog. We met her beforehand and she was lovely with our 9.5 year old. She is friendly with people and other dogs. Great on the lead. Velcro dog with separation anxiety, but because we went to DT we knew all that going in. My vote is for a rescue Staffy.

Lemonfrost · 07/11/2026 14:47

Staffies are the best breed in the world ❤️ absolutely gorgeous

redboxer321 · 07/11/2026 15:02

Wetcappuccino · 07/11/2026 14:25

Our Staffy cross came to us via Dog’s Trust at age 1 due to the previous owner’s health. We had a full history - she had lived with kids over the age of 10 and another dog. We met her beforehand and she was lovely with our 9.5 year old. She is friendly with people and other dogs. Great on the lead. Velcro dog with separation anxiety, but because we went to DT we knew all that going in. My vote is for a rescue Staffy.

Edited

Thanks for posting. So much rubbish talked about dogs in shelters on MN.
Not all are suitable to live with children obviously and not all rescue centres are great but many are and many of their dogs do not have extreme and insurmountable issues as is the way they are often portrayed on here.

Munchyseeds2 · 16/11/2026 09:31

Have had 2 Staffies.
Best dogs ever

Thewonderfuldollypartonsbra · 16/11/2026 10:06

zobalina77 · 07/11/2026 13:48

My staff is generally on a long line out on walks. One, because he is too friendly and wants to be friends with everyone and everything and im trying to train that out of him.at the moment, and two because he has been nipped a few times by other (small) dogs even when he's just walking nicely next to me. Probably because he's intact and hes black so dogs can't see his features very well. I worry that if there is an altercation he will get the blame because of his breed so I don't let him off unless certain no one is around.

We do go to freedom fields so he can run, and he does run exceptionally fast even though he's built like a barrel. Just struggles to stop in time before he collides with something 😂

Thank god it's not just 'my' dog (staffie)

Ds has one and we have him when he goes away

Every other day or so,he gets a message 'I'm really sorry,your dogs just gone head first into this' (message with a picture of whatever dopey has ran into)

Hes a great first dog,isn't bothered by other dogs/cats,loves all humans (adores his human sister) and a 20 minute walk can take 3 hours as he's always sniffing something

Thinks food is better than anything else in the world (would sell us for a bit of cheese) but can pull in the first 5 minutes on a walk (ds is training him but he feels he can take the piss with anyone new)

That is his only flaw-he utterly adore him

barrel on legs is very true about a staffie

Staffy v Parsons puppy
Munchyseeds2 · 16/11/2026 10:10

House hippo is another good description!

redboxer321 · 16/11/2026 11:27

A well bred staffie should be a long way from a barrel on legs or a house hippo. We have just got used to them looking like that because of bad breeding practices.

Munchyseeds2 · 16/11/2026 12:47

Said with love...neither of ours were over weight

zobalina77 · 16/11/2026 13:08

Mines not overweight. Can feel his ribs, waist is tapered, he has a defined abdominal tuck. Hes shiny and has well defined muscles rather than chunk. I'm very careful to not get him overweight as he is at the top end of the average staffy weight (17kg) Our vet says he is in excellent condition. I just call him a little barrel/house hippo/land seal affectionately.

similarminimer · 16/11/2026 14:09

What is the ideal first dog? Is it a lap dog only?

CoubousAndTourmaIet · 16/11/2026 14:20

similarminimer · 16/11/2026 14:09

What is the ideal first dog? Is it a lap dog only?

My family's first dog was a giant guarding breed. So the answer is no. The ideal first dog is the one that best suits your lifestyle and it doesn't have to be a tiny one.

HoppityBun · 16/11/2026 14:23

redboxer321 · 16/11/2026 11:27

A well bred staffie should be a long way from a barrel on legs or a house hippo. We have just got used to them looking like that because of bad breeding practices.

I don’t completely agree because the conformation of some staffies is definitely barrel like with short legs. Other staffies have longer legs and are more agile. So it’s not just weight, it’s shape, as well.

Personally, I love staffies, but I really don’t like seeing the short, hippo like ones.

Ncrecently · 16/11/2026 14:31

I must own a very unusual Parsons JRT . She is the an absolute beauty with a very gentle temperament. She has never caught any wildlife but does yell at cat’s and the postman. She can be walked for 2 hours or 20 mins as long as she has been out and had a good sniff everywhere! The only reservation is that she is very easily spooked and can be quite shivery …she really is gorgeous and loves a zoomie and my bed .
She is great with the grandchildren.

Staffy v Parsons puppy
New posts on this thread. Refresh page