Am I alone in wanting to decapitate melanie phillips!

[Heathcliffscathy]

uruughghghghhhhhh! she's frothing on question time...she is HORRIBLE!

I'm clearly alone!

no she's rough but not as babd as new statesman bloke

I haven't been paying attention to QT but I do like her hair .

Don't like her DM blatherings though.

No. She is quite awful.

she is mad!

She is full of hate. Have you ever heard her on The Moral Maze on Radio 4?

She is outrageous - AND she's married to Joshua Rosenberg - the thinking woman"s beefcake. Missed questiontime - will have to catch it on iplayer!

off to google image joshua thingumy...is he thinking woman's because he isn't fit? or is he fit?

he's not fit AT ALL

oooo, not very fit... must be his brain that's attractive, i'm assuming he isn't a rabid daily mail hack?

She's always been horrible, almost pantomime horrible. But, strangely, coquettish as well Urgh.

yes, not fit.

Although IMO he still looks exactly the same as he did years ago, wasn't he a BBC reporter once?

Wasn't he their legal correspondent? Can you imagine their pillow talk?

She is vile, what a crap one to have on such an important QT. She is such a clever twat isnt she.

I like her.

She's clear-sighted, articulate and extremely intelligent. And wrong about almost every issue she discusses.

I disagree with almost every single thing she ever says. But this evening, re the parliamentary stitch-up, I agree with her. For the first time in years.

i like that you like her despite hating what she says.

she is frothing tonight tho

I loathe her. Why are certain people (like her) on QT all the time? People should not be allowed to be on QT more than once in a series.

They're good value though. Ann Leslie is another good QT panellist

She was awful this evening.

What - did I miss Mad Mel in full flow?

She is vile.

she is rather evil - I thought the new statesman bloke Medhi was funny though - I think he'll be on a lot

I find her views odious, but like beatitude, I admire her conviction. I thought she was great last night sticking the knife in, in all directions. She is so right wing, she too has something of the night about her.

Didn't she - many, many years ago - used to write for the Grauniad or Nobserver?

New Statesmen bloke forgot that Heseltine is a national treasure tho. Don't mess with Tarzan. Wish they'd ask Carol Vorderman back..

She's vile. I can't read anything about her because it raises my blood pressure. Actually I don't think she's admirable at all. If she weren't Jewish, she'd be a member of the BNP

I always find it hugely disturbing that she's married to Joshua Rosenberg who I think is eminently sane and delightful.