x-factor - the new thread!

[NosfeRaahhTu]

if it's not been done already...

well she's no nina simone (or muse) but she sang it well..

That was so not the best performance of the night Simon.

She's got no light and shade in her voice whatsoever.

What, Naoimi, violence to PAs?

and i love her personality

I think Rachel was well rubbish

screeeeechy

Laura was the best. Why don't they try out something new as a theme. and if I hear one more version of Mac the Knife sung by a 13 year old spotty kid...

It's actually quite hard to tell who Simon is shagging this year isn't it?

Alexandra was the best by far

Serious question - is it my imagination or in the old days of this show were the judges not much more critical, and therefore MUCH more interesting?

I am so tired of all the 'best ever' comments. Surely these so called experts can find faults in all the performances if they look. As much as I normally like these shows, I can feel my attention waning. Just so saccharin.

i like rachel. i think. some weeks i dont. some weeks i do. she can be hit and miss.

loved austin. and ruth as well this week.

daniel to go home please

oh yes, Alex was v.good as well

moomin, i have been wanting a death metal week for years...[grin ]

Is Simon shagging one of the contestents then? (Naive emoticon).

did every single girl get a standing ovation tonight? strange when big band is usually suited to men

alexandra's been the best so far.

Nah, Daniel and Scott to go if there's any justice.

ooo yes, new suggestions

ABBA night, get the MammaMenopause dollar
One Hit Wonder night
Try to Break America night
Regional stereotype night
"Tribute" night ( in Tonight Matthew I'm gunna be stylee)
Own choice night

Diana should sing a Cranberries song. 'Linger' or one of hte other memorable ones....

isnt laura dating one of the producers or something?

alexandra was v v v good.

I really like Rachel (she is REAL)! She needs to look a bit more street and not like she's in fancy dress.

That blinkin' Diana, sooooo affected! She seems like a sweet girl though.

I would like to see the battle of all battles with Rachel, Alexandra and JLS in the final.

Simon must be shagging Ruth? I thought i saw him wink at her

I find it hard to like Rachel TBH, I dont go for sob storys but especially not those that are self inflicked (sp?)

Right, off for a break now, see you guys later- darkpunk, I am still standing!

I dunno JP but I always think he boffs at least two from each series at some stage in their career. He just screams Casting Couch at me. JMO tho!

I think Rachel, Alexandra and Laura would be the mother of all finals.