Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Loving Bake Off 2026? Indeedarooney!

635 replies

GetSetFake · 09/10/2026 11:51

Three weeks in, we've reached Thread Two and so far, mostly agreed to disagree on all things baking and non baking related including:

Diversity casting
Throuples
Nigella's Big Bites
A clutch of dead nans and a couple of live ones
Several dead pets
And...the first ever - maybe last ever?- Audience Choice week.

Join us to sail through the rest of the series on a soothing cloud of icing sugar, hoping for cosy Tuesday nights curled up on the sofa with a packet of (not just an old people thing) biscuits and the ever dwindling ranks of (maybe) Britain's Best Amateur Bakers.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
C8H10N4O2 · 13/10/2026 21:58

AlwaysRightISwear · 13/10/2026 21:53

I was warming to Gabe this week until he thought the summer solstice was about the light coming back. It's actually the opposite....

I'm glad it wasn't just me noticing he had missed the point! However it did look nice.

FairViewRosie25 · 13/10/2026 21:59

This was in answer to the comment about Alison’s dress tbf

C8H10N4O2 · 13/10/2026 22:02

Newgirls · 13/10/2026 21:50

Dried fruit makes more sense. I agree Nigella is excellent. She’s made it watchable again for me.

It could have been interesting to say "you can pick one cheese and two herbs (with garlic being a herb)". or "one dried fruit, one nut and one or two spices" which would have been achievable and also tested their ability to combine flavours. Using grapes and giving a really tight time was setting them all up to fail.

ChaosandCwtches · 13/10/2026 22:07

FairViewRosie25 · 13/10/2026 21:59

This was in answer to the comment about Alison’s dress tbf

I think it’s Never Fully Dressed!

Butteredtoast55 · 13/10/2026 22:48

LaMarschallin · 13/10/2026 21:35

This is the first ever Bake Off I've watched and I only did it because my DD does and it's nice to talk to her about things.
Is it always this bad?
I'm used to Masterchef and people who know about food not people tittering "Ooh, well! I saw it on TikTok!".
Honestly, does it get better and was this just a particularly awful episode?

This is not representative. There's always a few disasters because people are nervous, the weather is freezing cold or red hot, the recipe is a challenge or they don't have the basic knowledge, but this year's lot seem woeful.
Watch series 5 if you can...it's a belter!

B9waiting · 13/10/2026 22:49

Thegirlwhowent · 13/10/2026 21:53

It was ridiculous to expect than to be able to roast the grapes for long enough to dry them sufficiently, then cool them down before cooking the flatbread. Nobody wants to see everybody fail!

Completely agree with this! Also loving Nigella. Was sad to see Mollie go!

TallagallaPenguin · 13/10/2026 23:05

They were generally pretty rubbish this week though weren’t they. I was 😮 at Mo saying he’d never made any bread, on the back of never having made any biscuits the other week. Seriously he’s missing two major baking food groups there!

Would be great if they rerun bread week later in the series in the manner of an entire class having to repeat the exam. Actually felt a bit sorry for Paul which I don’t think has ever happened before! Though wtf on roast grapes?! I also reckon they just started copying each others Eccles-cake shaped flatbreads and lost their collective minds. It wasn’t even that they were trying to get them thin and failing! Ho hum. Better luck next week!

Butteredtoast55 · 13/10/2026 23:09

I think Mo is very much underplaying how much he's prepared for Bake Off. Didn't his cousin say he's always baking and making stuff for her? He's clearly very good but I find his attitude very irritating at times.

Cookingdoesntgettougher · 13/10/2026 23:20

It would be great if one week all the bakers got together and told the producers when a technical was revealed that it is physically impossible in the time. They will do it, however they then want the person setting the task to do in the same conditions and time and it to be posted on website after the show has aired.

Wouldn’t happen of course due to all the agreements that they sign, and I suppose they have watched the show and as good bakers know when they apply that the times are due to it being entertainment not just a serious baking competition

LindorDoubleChoc · 14/10/2026 05:15

I must have missed the memo about this new thread starting 5 days ago. I was lonely checking in on thread 1 and wondering where everyone was!

Well ... should someone who has never made bread before really get through the vetting process for GBBO? I didn't get the feeling he was joking.

And ... I like grapes, I love flat breads (especially where they get slightly charred, like naan) and I'm a huge fan of blue cheese. But all together?? How horrible. What an utter waste of food that challenge was. Did any of them make a bread that was actually flat?

GetSetFake · 14/10/2026 08:13

So sorry, @LindorDoubleChoc. Last year the thread filled up mid episode, so I couldn't link the new thread and did literally "send the memo" and tag everyone from the old thread. This year, I did the new one in plenty of time but forgot that once a few messages have been added, the link to the new thread disappears. Glad you found us!

We have a hospital bedside waiting situation going on and I got called away for a family confab at 8.15 last night, so have just watched the rest on catch up this morning. Echo everything everyone else has said really:

The garlic bread challenge was a good one and did show who had some basic grasp of bread and who had - ahem - never baked bread before.

Mo is the ultimate youth market hire, isn't he? As you know, I am a passionate defender of the show's right to cast widely and diversely, but was shouting at the telly when he admitted to not having made bread, having previously admitted not making biscuits. It does make a mockery of the claim to represent Britain's best bakers - but they know exactly what they are doing. Him laconically dissing bread and biscuits as boring makes much better viewing than 12 proficient bakers making excellent flatbreads. Especially for the youth market they know they have to capture if they are to have any chance of surviving. But....grrrrrr.

Flat bread challenge - if all the bakers fail, it was a shit challenge. I bake along and will report back on how it goes, but I'm not optimistic. The last time this happened was the brownie challenge when Paul said "they're supposed to be Britain's best bakers and they can't even make a brownie - but they had 1.5 hours, which is not long enough to bake and cool a decent squidgy brownie. Definitely a judge fail. Same judge too... @TallagallaPenguin, do not feel sorry for that man, he deserves none of your tears!

Final challenge was a good one, especially with the extra hour and being able to use dead dough to make it beautiful.

Was sorry to see Mollie go, in the end they do often come down to flavour but I really liked her. Hope Nikki is back but unlikely, you'd just want to be with your family, not going through major stress on television.

And finally (sorry, it's an essay, I'd rather be thinking about cake than the other stuff at the moment!) Gabe and Noel discussed the frontrunners and it was a list of the men. Which has also happened on one of the podcasts- can't remember if it was Bake Down or Sticky Bun Boys - and really pisses me off. Obviously Tom is front runner at the moment, but both Connie and Clara are as good as any of the other men. Another grrrrrr.

Looking forward to next week's dessert trolley very much!

OP posts:
Tiredofitallagain · 14/10/2026 09:03

GetSetFake · 14/10/2026 08:13

So sorry, @LindorDoubleChoc. Last year the thread filled up mid episode, so I couldn't link the new thread and did literally "send the memo" and tag everyone from the old thread. This year, I did the new one in plenty of time but forgot that once a few messages have been added, the link to the new thread disappears. Glad you found us!

We have a hospital bedside waiting situation going on and I got called away for a family confab at 8.15 last night, so have just watched the rest on catch up this morning. Echo everything everyone else has said really:

The garlic bread challenge was a good one and did show who had some basic grasp of bread and who had - ahem - never baked bread before.

Mo is the ultimate youth market hire, isn't he? As you know, I am a passionate defender of the show's right to cast widely and diversely, but was shouting at the telly when he admitted to not having made bread, having previously admitted not making biscuits. It does make a mockery of the claim to represent Britain's best bakers - but they know exactly what they are doing. Him laconically dissing bread and biscuits as boring makes much better viewing than 12 proficient bakers making excellent flatbreads. Especially for the youth market they know they have to capture if they are to have any chance of surviving. But....grrrrrr.

Flat bread challenge - if all the bakers fail, it was a shit challenge. I bake along and will report back on how it goes, but I'm not optimistic. The last time this happened was the brownie challenge when Paul said "they're supposed to be Britain's best bakers and they can't even make a brownie - but they had 1.5 hours, which is not long enough to bake and cool a decent squidgy brownie. Definitely a judge fail. Same judge too... @TallagallaPenguin, do not feel sorry for that man, he deserves none of your tears!

Final challenge was a good one, especially with the extra hour and being able to use dead dough to make it beautiful.

Was sorry to see Mollie go, in the end they do often come down to flavour but I really liked her. Hope Nikki is back but unlikely, you'd just want to be with your family, not going through major stress on television.

And finally (sorry, it's an essay, I'd rather be thinking about cake than the other stuff at the moment!) Gabe and Noel discussed the frontrunners and it was a list of the men. Which has also happened on one of the podcasts- can't remember if it was Bake Down or Sticky Bun Boys - and really pisses me off. Obviously Tom is front runner at the moment, but both Connie and Clara are as good as any of the other men. Another grrrrrr.

Looking forward to next week's dessert trolley very much!

Edited

I agree with a pp that Mo is underplaying. I'd much rather have someone like Nadiya or Rahul who admit how hard they have studied to get there!!

Sticky bum boys have have Connie and Clara as top though...

ItalianChineseIndianMexican · 14/10/2026 09:35

Checking in to the new thread (thanks OP).

Agree that someone who hasn't baked bread before shouldn't be on GBBO. I thought these were meant to be some of Britain's Best Amateur Bakers..

C8H10N4O2 · 14/10/2026 10:00

@GetSetFake Will be interested to hear how you get on with those flatbreads in an hour. I've been making them since I was small and I could not do that challenge. I noticed in Paul's video to show how easy it was he did not address the issues of timing and drying out the fruit enough to put into the breads.

Its absolutely a failure of the judges when the entire cohort fails the challenge.

My head knows there are rounds and auditions but the cohort do not seem as good as last year and I'm not sure if its unrealistic challenges or too much focus on the "personality" over the baking. Mo must have done well in auditions so either he is on a wind up or the programme makers are trying to present him as a non baker coming through as a star (for the yoof market, as you say). I would rather hear about how they learned and practiced than nonsense about entering the tent never having tried bread and biscuits. In general its all been a bit underwhelming.

The editing also seem to be predetermining Tom as top which may be misleading. I still think Connie was robbed in biscuit week when Tom's disaster still won star baker and she and Clara should both be up there with him as front runners.

ChaosandCwtches · 14/10/2026 14:20

Flatbreads shouldn’t take anywhere near an hour to cook unless I’m missing something special about them? Few minutes to mix, few minutes to prove (maybe up to ten?) and few minutes to cook? The time is taken by waiting for the grapes but even that would be done while you’re getting everything ready

Their mistake was that they weren’t flat!

harriethoyle · 14/10/2026 14:28

The fact that not one bake was actually edible does suggest a fail in the setting of the challenge. And of course, loads of them then over baked the showstopper because they were terrified it would be raw again 🤣

murasaki · 14/10/2026 14:34

Flat breads are easy, it was the grapes that were a stupid idea. I bet they didn't chop them small enough and there definitely wasn't enough time to roast them. Unfair of Paul there. Its a bit like Jamie's 15 minute meals, only 15 minutes if you spend half an hour before hand chopping everything into every item of crockery you own.

Maggiethecat · 14/10/2026 15:03

murasaki · 14/10/2026 14:34

Flat breads are easy, it was the grapes that were a stupid idea. I bet they didn't chop them small enough and there definitely wasn't enough time to roast them. Unfair of Paul there. Its a bit like Jamie's 15 minute meals, only 15 minutes if you spend half an hour before hand chopping everything into every item of crockery you own.

😂

Mooselove · 14/10/2026 15:36

harriethoyle · 14/10/2026 14:28

The fact that not one bake was actually edible does suggest a fail in the setting of the challenge. And of course, loads of them then over baked the showstopper because they were terrified it would be raw again 🤣

Surely the main reason the bakes were no edible was because they did not cook as they were all far too thick.

I cannot believe that none of them knew what a flatbread is. Surely the name should give it away? Maybe none of them had ever made one but never eaten or seen one!

I do think they are a pretty poor bunch this year

murasaki · 14/10/2026 15:45

Even Yannis, who said he made naan a lot. It made no sense

ChannelLightVessel · 14/10/2026 15:59

I think it was the grapes that threw them: if they rolled the bread flat enough, there would be juice etc everywhere. From what Paul said to Nigella, that’s supposed to happen, but I can see why the bakers were wary.

ChaosandCwtches · 14/10/2026 16:00

Honestly cannot see how anyone but the bakers could be blamed for this. I’m usually the one defending them because silly things always go wrong with me too! But come on, flatbreads! Just checked Paul’s recipe online and it is indeed as straightforward as it sounds and is rated a difficulty of “easy”.

It’s really put a dampener on my enjoyment this year, they can’t do the technicals, the signatures are meh and the showstoppers aren’t showstopping.

Mooselove · 14/10/2026 16:09

ChaosandCwtches · 14/10/2026 16:00

Honestly cannot see how anyone but the bakers could be blamed for this. I’m usually the one defending them because silly things always go wrong with me too! But come on, flatbreads! Just checked Paul’s recipe online and it is indeed as straightforward as it sounds and is rated a difficulty of “easy”.

It’s really put a dampener on my enjoyment this year, they can’t do the technicals, the signatures are meh and the showstoppers aren’t showstopping.

I agree. I usually really enjoy the show but this year I am not. Are we really meant to believe that they are some of the best bakes in the country? Only an idiot would believe that

GetSetFake · 14/10/2026 16:10

ChaosandCwtches · 14/10/2026 16:00

Honestly cannot see how anyone but the bakers could be blamed for this. I’m usually the one defending them because silly things always go wrong with me too! But come on, flatbreads! Just checked Paul’s recipe online and it is indeed as straightforward as it sounds and is rated a difficulty of “easy”.

It’s really put a dampener on my enjoyment this year, they can’t do the technicals, the signatures are meh and the showstoppers aren’t showstopping.

What would your timings be, though? I guess roast the grapes at a very hot temperature, then squish the juices out. While they roast, make and prove the dough. Let the grapes cool a bit form and fill your flatbreads. If you make a 10" flatbread, you can only cook one in a pan at a time. Did they have two pans? What do you reckon - 2 minutes a side? It's going to be phenomenally tight even if you know what you're doing.

I'll give it a go and report back!

OP posts:
ChaosandCwtches · 14/10/2026 16:18

GetSetFake · 14/10/2026 16:10

What would your timings be, though? I guess roast the grapes at a very hot temperature, then squish the juices out. While they roast, make and prove the dough. Let the grapes cool a bit form and fill your flatbreads. If you make a 10" flatbread, you can only cook one in a pan at a time. Did they have two pans? What do you reckon - 2 minutes a side? It's going to be phenomenally tight even if you know what you're doing.

I'll give it a go and report back!

20 minutes to roast grapes which should be enough time to mix and prove the flatbreads.
90 second per side for the flatbread so maximum of 24 minutes if using one pan (but surely they can use 2 or 3 or 4??) That would still leave 16 minutes of extra time for fussing.

But it’s all a “moo” point anyway, they didn’t make one decent one!