Masked Singer 2023 Thread 2: It's a game of Cat and Mouse and our guesses are all Rubbish!

[Piggywaspushed]

Thread Two for jovial discussions and guesses!

As per previous thread, and guesses or I told you sos (I am preparing myself for Rubbish demasking!!) are welcome.

Please avoid sharing any heavy hints garnered from social media. A few identities have been leaked that way , especially on the US version.

Once the show has finished airing on ITV, discussion of demasked 'celebrity' is allowed and this does not constitute a spoiler.

We all (ahem, nearly) guessed Lulu. Let's hope we have heard of the rest!!

Nope, it's Charlie from Busted, promise!

James Arthur

Little horse joke

I said James Arthur for rhino and sticking with it. I'm not watching when they sing and he's all I can see when I listen.

Just like him isn't it

Yes, James Arthur's voice for sure

It does actually sound like Charlie to me now.

No because I thought it wasn't written correctly. The comma was in the wrong place

I didn’t know who Charlie was until you guys suggested him. But after looking him up, I’m sure it must him. Mainly because he sounded like James Arthur before James Arthur sounded like James Arthur.

It sounds very very very like him - but what is the New York connection?

Yep!

Absolutely Charlie from Busted rather than James Arthur. Only one (apart from Amber Davies for Jellyfish) I am 100% on

Is James Arthur tall?

Oh yes Davina it's definitely him

Charlie for me, 100%

19,990 just rewound. Doesn't seem to mean anything.

I thought it might just be a long way. But that doesn't help.

Wasnt Lulu the big name though?

GrandTheftWalrus first time I have watched this and caught rhino and immediately said James Arthur

Blimey, Jonathan agrees

No it's just four letters

James Arthur was on American Idol and had a number 1 in America.

Not for me. At all.

It almost sounds like James Arthur but the tone just isn't quite right. Definitely Charlie for me.

It's got to be Charlie and after Johnathon suggested James there is no way it will be him

Oh I don’t know. I can’t make sense of pretty much any of the clues on this show so his voice is all I have to go on!