notalone, yes, a little bit more open happyness would be nice...but must admit, I would be ratehr overwhelmed by such an "open show" as you can see in the american idol shows....but it certainly is a great personality trait
My favourite contestants over the years
season one- didn't really watch it, so no favourites there...but have heard Kelly Clarkson, and love her voice
season 2- don't thin I watched it much neither, lol!
season 3- watched, but had no favourites then!
Season 4 : liked both Bo Bice and Carrie Underwood
Season 5 : Most disliked Gedeon McKinney (shudder), Never knew why Kevin Covais even got through and then stayed quite long, liked Mandisa, Kellie Pickler, Paris Bennett and Katharine McPhee, absolutely adored Chris Daughtry (in my eyes he was the winner) and also really liked Elliot Yamin (who was my 2. favourit to win), didn't really get Taylor Hicks that much and didn't think he should have won
Season 6 : continouing to wonder what Sanjaya Malakar was doing there, lol; Lakisha Jones-absolutely fabulous Melinda- super, too, and so quirky to me either Lakisha or Melinda should have won!