BUT the producers don't want either of them to go. So I have a terrible terrible feeling they will have told Jamie to pick Demi, then Luke is left with Shaughna and Natalia - and will obviously pick Shaughna.
I think you might be right here. It would be pointless Jamie picking Shaughna given that she’s already spoken to him and taken herself out of the picture. But it might not be a bad thing if Connagh comes back. Then maybe him and Shaughna can get to know each other and that will leave Luke & Demi back together? And Jamie our?